Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: mikesamwild on March 27, 2010, 01:11:59 PM

Title: Best combo for box player
Post by: mikesamwild on March 27, 2010, 01:11:59 PM
What's your favourite group of instruments.

I like  box, fiddle, bouzouki (or sensitive non thrash guitar) and cello
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on March 27, 2010, 01:16:27 PM
four melodeons!
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 27, 2010, 04:42:29 PM
We play double D/G, fiddle, bouzouki and gob stopper - and I like it!  :|glug
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: nfldbox on March 27, 2010, 05:23:39 PM
fiddle and two row
banjo and one row
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: george garside on March 27, 2010, 05:54:45 PM
i sometimes play  (dg or bcc'#) with fiddle,bohran,banjo,washboard,guitar & trombone!  It makes a surprisingly effective ceilidh band, quite different from  the line up I would have chosen but non the worse for that- you just can't get the staff these days!

george ;)
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: uofdoboe on March 27, 2010, 10:28:07 PM
i sometimes play  (dg or bcc'#) with fiddle,bohran,banjo,washboard,guitar & trombone!  It makes a surprisingly effective ceilidh band, quite different from  the line up I would have chosen but non the worse for that- you just can't get the staff these days!

george ;)

What do you do with the T-bone?  Treat them like a bass or something?
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: george garside on March 27, 2010, 10:59:27 PM
  Indeed, very like a double bass  and it adds greatly to the proceedings now he's got the hang of it.  ( I had him listen carefully to the way the bass   sounded in the Shand band  to get some idea of   how it should come out.)   We sometimes use one or two  skiffle tunes eg sweet sixteen(puttin on the agony)  for dances like the circassian circle so our washboardist can  enjoy a good scrub! & the punters a sing -
.  Its very much a question of being a bit creative and making the best out of what  you've got!

george
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Anahata on March 28, 2010, 12:13:38 AM
I'm in a ceilidh band with an electric piano, fiddle and recorder.

And another with French horn, fiddle and piano again, where the horn player sometimes plays melodeon and then I switch to cello.

And another, newer one with an English concertina and a Sousaphone.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Stiamh on March 28, 2010, 12:51:21 AM
Bouzoukis are fine but there's nothing better in a dance band than a really good Quebec or Cape Breton piano player. Yep, fiddle, flute, box and piano does it for me.

With the proviso that how you gel with your fellow musicians is more important than what instrument they play. For example generally I'd much rather play with a fiddle than a banjo, but far rather a good banjo player than an indifferent fiddler. As a fiddler, better a good box player than a so-so flute!   :D
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Anahata on March 28, 2010, 02:04:25 AM
With the proviso that how you gel with your fellow musicians is more important than what instrument they play.

Yes, about time somebody made that point!
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: LDbosca on March 28, 2010, 02:40:04 AM
Box n fiddle, flute's fun but restricts keys if one is that way inclined. Good guitar playing for accompaniment would be my choice, bouzouki either.

Box and more boxes is hell to me, I really don't like playing with other boxes. Anyone else feel the same?
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: GbH on March 28, 2010, 03:08:37 AM
Our little 'band' (still nameless) now tends to be box, fiddle and one of banjo/bouzouki/harmonica, depending on the tune.  We're now starting to incorporate foot percussion, too, which makes a bigger difference than I'd expected.  I'm not sure which exact combination I like best - I think I tend to appreciate the variety. 

I've never played with another box player, so can't really comment on that first hand.  However, I've certainly enjoyed some of the duets that have been posted here in the past, so I'm not sure that multiple boxes is necessarily a problem.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Bryn Pinzgauer on March 28, 2010, 09:04:16 AM
My "fantasy folk band" line up, which I have never yet managed to get together is:

Fiddle
Fiddle/melodeon - me
Melodeon
Mandolin

Cheers

Bryn
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: ladydetemps on March 28, 2010, 09:09:12 AM
My "fantasy folk band" line up, which I have never yet managed to get together is:

Fiddle
Fiddle/melodeon - me
Melodeon
Mandolin

Cheers

Bryn
Did you fall out with yourself then? ;)
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Bryn Pinzgauer on March 28, 2010, 10:03:16 AM
 :D

I have actually got the first two together.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: mikesamwild on March 28, 2010, 11:23:20 AM
Nobody's mentioned Irish or other pipes, are they best solo?  I like Julian Sutton and Blowzabella with pipes though
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: george garside on March 28, 2010, 12:31:58 PM
a couple of interesting trends seem to be emerging from this thread

- a dislike of multiple boxes

- not much emphasis on rhythmic bass.

I tend to agree about the multiple boxes particularly if of similar tuning , however two differently tuned eg Lilly & erica can sound goodd together as can 1st box playing melody & 2nd box playing more or less chords on both ends, this works well with melodeon playing melodyonly & piano accordion (or continental) playing chaords etc on both ends.

for dance work I like the 1//3, 2/3 split between the number melody & rhythm instruments. A piano can be great  as can  a set of drums played skilfully but unobtrusively.

As to wind the Gallowglass ceilidh band made exellent use of a saaxaphone & of course clarinets are not  unknown.

I totally agree with the previous posting that  its the way the musicians work together that is more important than the actual combination of instruments.  This is surely the fundemental difference between a 'band' and a 'motlley collection of musicians'  as sometimes occurs in sessions.

george
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: LDbosca on March 28, 2010, 12:49:49 PM
Nobody's mentioned Irish or other pipes, are they best solo?  I like Julian Sutton and Blowzabella with pipes though

It works when Paudie O'Connor and John O'Brien do it alright, the different temperament of Uileann pipes plus the way some players use the regulators a bit differently than we'd use basses can make it a tricky one tho.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: LJC on March 28, 2010, 02:06:43 PM
Box and Gurdy  ;D

I have a real dislike of playing in sessions with hundreds of Melodeons - it just gets too soupy, and I think this has happened enough times for me to feel less inclined to play in bands with other box players. I think it can be done, the Sultans of Squeeze album is proof (more or less!).

Playing tunes with instruments providing different textures, eg Fiddle/Box/Pipes, Box/Gurdy, Box/Banjo is a good way to not have to worry about different parts. Play the tunes straight and the instruments take care of themselves. With similar sounds/textures going on, then you need to look at arraignments.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Anahata on March 28, 2010, 05:06:18 PM
a couple of interesting trends seem to be emerging from this thread

- a dislike of multiple boxes
- not much emphasis on rhythmic bass.

I don't see the point of having more than one of the same instrument in a band, except possibly fiddles which work well in numbers (look at any orchestra...) and especially not melodeons which is inclined to get a muddy sound. Surely the point of a band is to have the contrast between different instruments.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: nfldbox on March 28, 2010, 06:32:15 PM
I take your point about "a band" but I have always found it quite thrilling to hear one of these massed whatever. I really enjoyed one with 300 flutes. The largest I have been a part of was 1000 accordions. It sounds amazing on the recording but being in the middle it was hard to tell what was going on at the time.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: oggiesnr on March 28, 2010, 06:37:51 PM
In the days when I did the Country Show circuit we had an occassional "pick-up" band which met at various show grounds during the year.  I played melodeon and whistle, Jerry played sax, Tom played upright bass and Clive plyed 5-string banjo.  What made it even more fun is that we all came from different musical traditions (folk, jazz, rockabilly and country) and a fine time was had by all.  We played one memorable all-nighter in the Stockman's on the Suffolk Showground where we somehow conjured six hours of material out of somewhere.

Steve
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Stiamh on March 28, 2010, 11:43:49 PM
Nobody's mentioned Irish or other pipes, are they best solo?  I like Julian Sutton and Blowzabella with pipes though

It works when Paudie O'Connor and John O'Brien do it alright, the different temperament of Uileann pipes plus the way some players use the regulators a bit differently than we'd use basses can make it a tricky one tho.

I know a very good uilleann piper in New England whose partner plays B/C box. She has a Double Ray converted to A/A# (for playing with his C pipes) and tuned by a member of this forum and if I'm not mistaken the intonation of some notes is adjusted to accord with the corresponding notes on the chanter. The member in question might want to tell us more...
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Ollie on March 28, 2010, 11:57:03 PM
I suppose it depends on what music you're playing. In terms of English music, I've never liked acoustic melodeon where the bass is prominent and acoustic guitar together, just doesn't work for me. However, if the box is only playing right hand, guitar or bouzoki can sound good (Crucible are a good example of this) Melodeon and fiddle work amazingly well together. However, if I was playing box in a band, my dream line up would be melodeon, electric lead guitar, electric rhythm guitar, drums, bass, keyboard/synths and possibly an electric fiddle player. Yes, I am rather fond of the late 70s Albion Band stuff!  :D
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Theo on March 29, 2010, 12:08:10 AM
Box, fiddle and piano, my favourite line-up for playing with and dancing too.

Bring back the Bismarks!
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: LDbosca on March 29, 2010, 12:11:23 AM
Nobody's mentioned Irish or other pipes, are they best solo?  I like Julian Sutton and Blowzabella with pipes though

It works when Paudie O'Connor and John O'Brien do it alright, the different temperament of Uileann pipes plus the way some players use the regulators a bit differently than we'd use basses can make it a tricky one tho.

I know a very good uilleann piper in New England whose partner plays B/C box. She has a Double Ray converted to A/A# (for playing with his C pipes) and tuned by a member of this forum and if I'm not mistaken the intonation of some notes is adjusted to accord with the corresponding notes on the chanter. The member in question might want to tell us more...

I'd be interested to hear more alright, but even more interested to hear the box in question...a while ago I had the idea of single note two-voice basses laid out in an 18 bass fashion (6x3) that would effectively be used like regulators by holding a finger across 2 or 3 of them to give a chrod etc. but I didn't take the idea any further. Poor student and all of that. I can't wait to be a grown-up.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Earbrass on March 30, 2010, 10:57:39 AM
For me I think it would be:

Bass guitar (me)
Box (someone rather better than me)
Fiddle
and possibly a hand-drummer/percussionist of some sort.

(If anyone in the London area is looking for an experienced bass guitarist to add to an English/European folk-based ensemble, drop me a line!)
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 30, 2010, 11:46:17 AM
Like Theo:  For our purposes Fiddle, Box, and Piano - though we've added bass guitar to give more rhythmic oomph.  I've played with and without drums, and I think that might be the next instrument to add if you want to get bigger as a band.  Or perhaps mandolin?  Or even tenor banjo? I've come away from the idea of a rhythm guitar (which is a bit strange because it's my main instrument).  Country music players can deliver a clean 'boom, chink' sound on an acoustic guitar, flatpicking, but otherwise strumming seems rather to add to the general fog, IMO.

Horses for courses, though - a tuba makes a lovely sound, and so does a soprano sax or a hurdy-gurdy, depending on what you're trying to play for.  If you're going to add pipes, IMO you need to be careful to add strong rhythm to neutralise the drone.

In fact it really does all depend on what you want to play, and I think the only rules are that you should do what you think works best for the type of music.
Title: Re: Best combo for box player
Post by: mikesamwild on March 30, 2010, 02:36:52 PM
A good pianist ,like Beryl Marriott who had a big influence on Swarb, is great.

Too many old Irish 78s are ruined for me by heavy vamping.  They just had to have one in those days.

There are some great pianists aroud for Irish music still but they have to be very sensitive to trad music.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal