Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on March 28, 2010, 07:00:01 PM
-
is it me or are most irish tunes in d? if so , why dont alot of irish players play d/g and play straight up and down the ropw , surely it would be alot easier?
-
There are also a lot in A. But then A is difficult on the BC as well. It is also true that Irish tunes when played fast are difficult up and down the row, as you have lots of bellows changes. Although you have lots of bellows changes on the BC as well... Not sure :P
-
There are also a lot in A. But then A is difficult on the BC as well.
no more difficult than g or d! or e for that matter
george ;)
-
Well, I remember someone talking about when the most common box in Eire was the four stop in D...
I guess some habits die hard.
Rob.
-
Tim Edey's DVD shows you how on the D/G. An hour or so in front of the screen and you're away.... Mally has three books of Irish tunes arranged for D/G.
-
The C#/D tuning is very popular amongst ITM players -giving one D up & down the row with A,G and any other key across, diagonal, whatever.
-
tbh i just wandered why bc players played in d when it seems to me that it would be alot easier to play strait up and down on a dg, and cross rows when you need too
-
The BC gives you a lot of chance at ornaments within the flow of the music in D. As is clear from great one row players, you can achieve quite a smooth sound but IMHO it is easier on the BC. On the surface the BC is not logical but once you recognize how an Irish tune in D fits, it seems perfect, the best way of following music originally meant for pipes or fiddle.
Now for all the C#D responses.
-
For Irish music up and down the rows, check out Johnny Connolly....plays amazing irish music on one row 4 stop melodeons :-)
-
Apart from the question of ornaments, C#/D (or B/C) of course opens up a whole world of Irish tunes (essential ones, to me) that are not available on a D/G.
Many of them would be playable on a 2½-row D/G of course, but not all. The thing about a semitone box is that you are _never_ stuck for an accidental, right through the entire range of the box, and the accidental is always right where it should be - next to the uninflected note.
Before taking up C#/D I thought very seriously about D/G but couldn't face the thought of being basically stuck in easy keys on the tin whistle. Now in the position of teaching a student with a D/G so having to learn more about the system. You can do neat things on it all right but I'm very glad I chose a semitone box.
-
my limited experience with just doing it all on one row was that it was a lot of work -- as in lots of push/pull -- the nice thing about b/c is you have your f# and c# on the outer row so you can play the notes all in one bellow direction - push in the case of b/c - ie D (pull) E, F#, G (pull) B, C#, D (push)
-
You can do it like two one row meldeons on a D/G but cross rowing makes for smoother playing and ornaments and saves the bellows. And you have the basses which a lot of Irish players on B/C don't use very well if at all.
I agree the Tim Edey DVD is a cracker
I just noticed that Johnny Connolly(sr) is doing one row Connemara style melodeon workshops at Willie Clancey week in Clare this year. First time ever. What goes round comes round (:)
-
good point - the basses make a lot more sense and are a lot easier to do on the D/G setup - great D/G player out on youtube - cathycook1 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zb9QbQODEB8 - check her out!
-
i havent ordered my tim edey dvd yet, il get round to it soon!
-
Re: Cathy Cook
This is NOT true of Tim Edey but at least on this the DG sounds a lot like a D melodeon.
-
They quick answer is of course - they're Irish >:E
I think however there is a musical reason why B/C and its cousins sound good - and I agree that they do. To me music is about setting up tension and then resolving that. You'll hear it in Blues, or a Jazz II-V-I progression for that matter. You'll feel it when someone ostensibly playing in G voices an A7 rather than Am - (or simply harmonises something with a C#) ... the melody 'resolves' onto the D row.
That's standard chord theory, but there's also 'rhythm' and 'attack'. Playing across the C/B rows in this way somehow gets a tension that the up and down the row rarely achieves (OK, Quebecoise gets there). More generally that tension seems present in any music played in a scale 'across' the natural keys of a box.
I don't play B/C - but I think that might contribute something to its undoubted energy. And some cracking musicianship of course. There may be a parallel in Tex Mex - again rows crossed - again "energetic" Doc 1-row
-
is it me or are most irish tunes in d? if so , why dont alot of irish players play d/g and play straight up and down the ropw , surely it would be alot easier?
Why don't the Irish play D/G? Don't forget the D/G wasn't invented until, what was it, the 1950s, by which time the B/C was becoming very firmly established in Ireland. The B/C worked well, so why would you expect the Irish to suddenly jump on this English invention with a stratospheric G row? ;D
As for playing up and down the rows, more and more of them are starting to: on C#/D yes, but the one-row "melodeon" is making a strong comeback with exponents like Johnny Connolly and Brendan Begley. Because it's easier, though? I doubt that's the reason.
I'm mulling over what Chris said about tension being created by playing against a box's natural scale, and this explaining why the Irish favour the B/C. I don't think I buy it at all - my idea is that the B/C was supposed to dissipate the tension of playing _on_ the row, by dividing the D scale into three uni-directional chunks. Will give the matter some further reflection though.
-
I'd be shade dubious about the tension thing myself...do you mean that the tension is due to the way the scales used fall with bellows movements gives a sort of tension?
Regarding the whole bass issue, while it seems a bit awkward at first playing bass on B/C, if you have the Joe Burke layout there's actually plenty of room for maneuver. I spent years (like, until I was 22...I'm 23 now) barely ever playing basses but I decided that if I was gonna order a nice new instrument I'd want to be able to play both sides of it, so I sat down and forced myself to play it with every tune until I figured out what worked. Given that oom-pah on every bar is a bit much in ITM the B/C limits the player a little bit in a good way sometimes.
To go slightly more off-topic, 12 basses with B/C's probably ideal for ITM, add an Fsharp minor and a Bminor on push/pull and you've got first inversion of D and G major, plus a bunch of other fun tricks.
-
I think that tension/relaxation is fundamental to music in general, but there are many ways of making it. Tunes that play on notes that aren't in the current chord, swing, syncopation, little lead notes, holding a drone while the music goes in and out of harmony then magically resolves ...
OK - I don't play either Irish (very very little) or half tone. But they are very good (:) I was speculating as to why, but will defer to other's experience. I've have actually played in sessions with Connolly (if it's the Galway fella) a couple of times and he does absolute wonders on one row.
So did Andy Cutting at the EATMT weekend - but there was definitely a tension/resolution in his music (for all he said about relaxing his body). It's not about the body - if that is tense it affects your music by destroying that quintessential timing that better musicians than I can do.
Am I way off thread? Probably - apologies in that case.
-
When Rose Murphy ( Galway and Maltby), Peter Conlon's sister came back to record in her 70s she had a B/C Double Ray , and played in B on a number of tracks so she played up and down as she would when younger on a D/C# or D/D#.
If the B/C hadn't come in I wonder if the Joe Derrane style and D based related boxes would have stayed the fashion as they were in America?
I think the B/C was to get a box that allowed a lot of keys cross row and smooth for fiddle style ornaments
Did Paolo Soprani respond to a demand or was it the available chromatic box and then played around with?
-
I think that tension/relaxation is fundamental to music in general, but there are many ways of making it. Tunes that play on notes that aren't in the current chord, swing, syncopation, little lead notes, holding a drone while the music goes in and out of harmony then magically resolves ...
OK - I don't play either Irish (very very little) or half tone. But they are very good (:) I was speculating as to why, but will defer to other's experience. I've have actually played in sessions with Connolly (if it's the Galway fella) a couple of times and he does absolute wonders on one row.
So did Andy Cutting at the EATMT weekend - but there was definitely a tension/resolution in his music (for all he said about relaxing his body). It's not about the body - if that is tense it affects your music by destroying that quintessential timing that better musicians than I can do.
Am I way off thread? Probably - apologies in that case.
I meant more that I was off thread! Maybe not tho!
You're right about tension and resolution in music alright, but I don't think that's really affected by the system in this case, the same notes are used regardless of the tuning of the instrument, there's not a whole lot of chord work done on the right hand usually in Irish so that aspect doesn't come in either. The change in character between Csharp/D and B/C (and presumably D/G, this is where my knowledge runs out) is due to the different bellows combinations and available grace notes - I always find all those cuts in thirds on the Csharp/D gives quite a bright sound.
Regarding the B/C coming in, I don't really know for sure but since the concept of semitone tuned boxes was thought of relatively early on with tunings like C/Csharp I imagine that the B/C was a permutation of this that caught on when its potential was realised. I'm very much open to correction on this, there's people on this forum that have a bit of knowledge on the older boxes.
-
Regarding the B/C coming in, I don't really know for sure but since the concept of semitone tuned boxes was thought of relatively early on with tunings like C/Csharp I imagine that the B/C was a permutation of this that caught on when its potential was realised. I'm very much open to correction on this, there's people on this forum that have a bit of knowledge on the older boxes.
I'm pretty sure that the earliest two row boxes were mostly C/C#, certainly the ones I've seen are. The B/C system seems to have popularised and promoted first by Jimmy Shand and Forbes Music Shop in Dundee. Don't know if they 'invented' it, but there was collaboration with Hohner which led to the production of the Double Ray and a tuition system to go with it.
-
I heard Peter Wyper may have played B/C, that'd be pretty early, anyone hear this?
-
I heard Peter Wyper may have played B/C, that'd be pretty early, anyone hear this?
Yes that has been amply documented by Steve Chambers aka Triskel. Apparently Wyper started playing a C/C# inside-out, from which it was a small step to getting a box a semitone lower to fit in with the rest of the world pitch-wise.
Read all about it here: http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2347
-
If the B/C hadn't come in I wonder if the Joe Derrane style and D based related boxes would have stayed the fashion as they were in America?
Well the odd thing about Derrane's system - D/C# - is that it's a semitone box with the inner row lower than the outer one. Now where on earth did that come from? Who knows, but on a previous discussion on here or the previous forum, someone, maybe Steve C or Eejay or Paul G, revealed that in the 1920s, on the continent somewhere, people were playing C/B [sic] systems.
-
I thought the reason Irish B/C players didn't play chords was that the Hohner B/C bass layout would not allow them to play related chords.
-
I thought the reason Irish B/C players didn't play chords was that the Hohner B/C bass layout would not allow them to play related chords.
Only the v. old layout, which seems to be geared towards the outer row as the home row and as you say won't allow many related chords in conventional keys. Other layouts pose problems too, such as when a D on the push is needed. In reality however, people usually have something like this:
http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/BC23modernbass.gif
or the sensible option (IMHO) which is also very popular, the Joe Burke layout, which is this
(chin) push/pull
(bellows) E/A D/D
(bellows) C/F G/G
Take the thirds out of that and there's nothing stopping B/C players doing a nice bit of accompaniment.
I think more Irish players are using basses than people realise, they're often done pretty quietly compared to some English players.
-
There's more detail just been announced on the one row workshops at Willie Clancey week on another thread on mel net
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3705.0.html
-
The B/C worked well, so why would you expect the Irish to suddenly jump on this English invention with a stratospheric G row? ;D
Amen to that - main reason why I packed in playing a D/G Lilly. That's why (of all the fourth apart tunings) I prefer Bb/Eb or A/D. It just seems to sit there much better...
... previous discussion on here or the previous forum, someone, maybe Steve C or Eejay or Paul G, revealed that in the 1920s, on the continent somewhere, people were playing C/B [sic] systems.
Indeed... from what I recall, I think C/B was initiated by Maugein Freres. And a few months back I had a try on an old wooden Paolo in G/C/B.
This subsequently evolved (with more basses) into the Accordéon Mixte (http://denecheau.free.fr/spip.php?article28)... and the French Bal Musette was born... 8)
As for the evolution of the D/C#... who knows? The idea is the same, but the logic and development seem to come half a century later... pretty much like Mr Shand and his B/C/C# idea happened along... right when the Accordéon Mixte systems were on the wane...
Ed J
-
IIRC correctly a small number of D/G and a fair few A/D/G boxes were knocking about in Vienna long before Peter Kennedy got on the blower to Hohner. I can't recall what the original tuning was but I also seem to remember Triskel mentioning that the semitone system was first invented in England by the concertina maker George Jones and in its early years was called English System accordion.
So the Irish are playing an English system and the English are playing a German one, whodathunkit.