Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Fungusface on March 31, 2010, 04:10:06 PM
-
In antique world an item sells for a better price if you have providence on it, Cars sell better if less owners,
in Ref to melodeons or accordions wouldnt it be better if your box had similar history to it who and how many owned it before you.I like to know such things the rare Paolo Soprani I had belonged to Clinksdale originally,then a guy called Alan Clark both had for many years,then me,now somewhere in England.
My Hohner 3 voice I have, only had 4 previous owners first was Forbes of Dundee, then Jimmy Shand, then a guy in Glasgow who played in the White Heather Club and then Raffles444 in Dundee, I was asking him about me researching old boxes Derek informed me what he knew about this old Hohner, would show pic but dont know how to make file smaller,not a PC whiz kid.
What about yours has it providence,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,apoligies is the latter word spelt wrong.
-
well i know that my tommy was owned by two melnetters before me. ;)
-
I agree that God does providentially work in all actions to his own glory, the pedigree or lineage or heritage of boxes included of course --
Every box has a story to tell - some interesting, some dull, some sad. I'm curious to learn what will happen to my Dancemaster - I know it's getting upgraded reeds, so I'm sure it's going to sound great.
I believe my new box is an old new stock box - other than the original instrument seller who had it in their inventory, I don't believe it had a previous owner.
I'm sure my little Hohner G/C presswood has quite a past - I got it from a guy out in New York city - I'd love to know where it was used and what kind of music it was used for.
-
What about yours has it providence,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,apoligies is the latter word spelt wrong.
John, I think the word you are meaning is provenance
-
I'm fairly confident as there was a superb documentary only last night about the Bolton art forger (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amarna_Princess) Shaun Greenhalgh. It was all about "provenance" - the other word usually refers to God.
My kits all rather boring - though my Mori is now "much happier" being played by Julian Sutton, and my old concertina "ditto" by Chas Marshall
-
My Hohner belonged to a fellow who sold it after buying a Saltarelle, a C#/D I think, don't know about before that. Amateur player I think.
My Saltarelle was brand new when I got it...I think having me as one of its owners will significantly reduce it's value, it's been played and gigged a lot and has all the dings to prove it. Never broke a reed or anything tho, I'd say you'd have to really tear at your instrument to do that.
-
A melodeon is always rare item in the States, especially in the western US. Accordions are rare enough, not to mention diatonic ones. Having lived in a remote mountain valley for 20 years, I was probably the only person learning this instrument within a 100 miles in any direction. Until internet auctions came along, I had searched for years to find an instrument. I had collected a couple(http://) during the 90's, and was able to progress to a degree.
I received a call one day from a neighbor (10 miles away was still the neighborhood) who said she had an old 'accordion', and would I look at it for her? So off I went, and having arrived and navigated the pleasantries, she produced from a closet a quite lovely old Hohner 3-row (see photo).
She then directed me to play it for her, which I did. Surprisingly it was in lovely condition, and was in decent tune as well. After enjoying that for a bit, the woman then asked me if I would be interested in buying it. Of course I said yes. As it turns out, the instrument had been the prized posession of her father, who was a piano tuner and musician. Her Dad had always wished that she would learn to play, but the box got put away, and finally, at 90 years of age, she was not about to begin. So she was grateful that she could pass it on to someone who understood it, as it baffled her relatives on how to work it.
Fortunately it did not become the plaything of small children who can demolish such a thing in short order, nor did it get shoved into a damp basement or broiling attic. So it was practically 'handed' to me. For a while I considered selling it, as it is in rather less popular keys (F#/B/E). I am enjoying it quite a bit now, and you can hear it on my postings for March Totm's.
-
I recently came across an old Anglo concertina on Ebay. I'm always interested in the Provenance of these things as to me it adds intrinsic value. The concertina was nothing special, not a Lachenal not a Wheatstone but it had lovely silver inlay and was beat all to h*ll. The woman told me it was found under the bed of an elderly woman in Dublin who's father busked on the docks with this same Concertina. That sold me! Yeah I'm a bit sentimental but most people are. I now have the Concertina sitting at home, I might someday restore it but I wrote that story down and put it away for when I might someday sell the thing. I don't know the provenance of the current boxes I own. Wish I did on the newly acquired Globe melodeon, I only know it was found at the local flea market and I traded for it with an old Paolo wood box I found on Ebay. If you have ever watched the Antiques Road Show you will know that a story has the power to make something more valuable, whether it's true or not.
-
A melodeon is always rare item in the States, especially in the western US. Accordions are rare enough, not to mention diatonic ones. Having lived in a remote mountain valley for 20 years, I was probably the only person learning this instrument within a 100 miles in any direction. Until internet auctions came along, I had searched for years to find an instrument. I had collected a couple(http://) during the 90's, and was able to progress to a degree.
I received a call one day from a neighbor (10 miles away was still the neighborhood) who said she had an old 'accordion', and would I look at it for her? So off I went, and having arrived and navigated the pleasantries, she produced from a closet a quite lovely old Hohner 3-row (see photo).
She then directed me to play it for her, which I did. Surprisingly it was in lovely condition, and was in decent tune as well. After enjoying that for a bit, the woman then asked me if I would be interested in buying it. Of course I said yes. As it turns out, the instrument had been the prized posession of her father, who was a piano tuner and musician. Her Dad had always wished that she would learn to play, but the box got put away, and finally, at 90 years of age, she was not about to begin. So she was grateful that she could pass it on to someone who understood it, as it baffled her relatives on how to work it.
Fortunately it did not become the plaything of small children who can demolish such a thing in short order, nor did it get shoved into a damp basement or broiling attic. So it was practically 'handed' to me. For a while I considered selling it, as it is in rather less popular keys (F#/B/E). I am enjoying it quite a bit now, and you can hear it on my postings for March Totm's.
j. w.,
I wouldn't want to tempt you to part with that lovely accordion and its associations for you. I have a few instruments that came from places near my home or otherwise significant to me.
But if it would interest you, I would be able to trade you a set of G/C/F steel reeds from a Hohner of similar style, quality and vintage, for your F#/B/E reeds (if yours are in excellent condition, whether or not they have been overhauled). Mine would need cleaning, valves, tuning, and waxing on to your blocks but they are in great shape with no rust. This trade might not make sense for you if you have already invested in having your F#/B/E reeds overhauled. But on the other hand the keys of G/C/F are so much more generally useful if you play with others that it might possibly be worth your while to make the trade and then get the G/C/F reeds overhauled too. Unfortunately, these days I don't have time to do that kind of work for you, so you would have to find another tech. I am sitting on lots of old accordion projects and parts, but for future plans I will have need of F#/B/E melody and bass reeds from a box like yours.
PM me if that would help you out. If not, it won't be too hard for you to find another similar G/C/F (and for me to find another F#/B/E).
Paul Groff
-
I have always been interested in the history of instruments and who owned them before I did. To that end, there is a company called "Case Notes" that makes a kind of instrument diary that fits in the case of most stringed instruments (although it could fit in the case of any instrument, really). I decided to get one for my custom made mandolin so that successive owners could know where it came from and what kind of music was played on it etc.
It is a well made leather bound booklet with places to put your information and information about the instrument. You could also just write a letter that would stay in the case to accomplish the same thing. I have no financial interest in the company and I do not know if Case Notes is made any more. But I liked the idea enough to purchase one, fill it out and keep it in my case for the next owner.
http://www.mandolincafe.com/news/publish/mandolins_00984.shtml
-
I have taken to writing my name and date of acquisition inside my boxes for two reasons, a bit of history for any one who gets one after I have got rid of it and for security identification purposes.
This will undoubtly increase their value in years to come ;D
-
I know nothing about who might have owned or played any of the various accordions I have bought secondhand. However I was recently given an English concertina by some cousins of mine. It belonged to their father, my uncle, who died in the 1960s and had been lying unused since then. Enquiring about it on concertina.net I was amazed and delighted to be pointed (by Steve Chambers) in the direction of the Wheatstone ledgers showing the name of the person who bought it in 1845: no. 1008 on this page (http://www.horniman.info/WNCMARC/C104A/PAGES/C1P0520S.HTM). I wonder how many hands it passed through between then and when my uncle bought it in the 1930s.
(Note to self: must gently harass Colin Dipper to complete the restoration.)
It would be nice if records kept by accordion makers found their way online, but it seems improbable.
-
I have a Wheatstone Triumph duet that has a lovely Salvation Army pedigree. My Cairdin is a bit more basic. A Canadian who wanted to learn the instrument had Paddy Clancy make it for him but never got around to learning. He had nameplates made with his name and "Handmade by Paddy Clancy, Limerick, Ireland". He stuck them on the instrument but I have the nameplates in my case as a memento. Perhaps the box is happier with me as it certainly gets played a lot more. It now knows a lot of tunes. So that is the "providence" of the box.
But by the by, I love "providence." "Provenance" always sounds a bit stuffy, no matter what the thing discussed, but "providence" has a wonderful serendipitous ring to it. I shall use it in future.
-
I got my Club IV from a guy who played in sessions with Tony Hall in Norwich a long time ago (decades). He bought the box off Tony. I spoke to Tony about it last year and he said he'd never had anything to do with Clubs. I guess he might have had it for spares. Still its nice to have a connection to a great player. The box is for sale but I've resisted the temptation of "as played by Tony Hall" in advertising it.
-
My current squeeze I've had from new. I swapped my last box - which I also had from new - for this one. Of the three before that - a five row Continental chromatic C system, Saltarelle Bouebe & Dino Bafetti Black Pearl II, only the Dino was second-hand. Bit boring really. The 'old & knackered GDR GCF' came to me from someone in the same morris side via a very convoluted route. I wish I still had the Dino Bafetti.
-
I bought a C/F Hohner Club III from the East Anglian Traditional Music Trust that had belonged to the late Barry Callaghan and have recently had it restored by Theo. It's a lovely box.
I've always wondered whether any Sheffield Melodeonista's had any memories of Barry having played this box.
-
I bought a C/F Hohner Club III from the East Anglian Traditional Music Trust that had belonged to the late Barry Callaghan and have recently had it restored by Theo. It's a lovely box.
I've always wondered whether any Sheffield Melodeonista's had any memories of Barry having played this box.
You're lucky to have Barry's melodeon. I don't remember that particular box, but I did play alongside Barry on many an occasion in the 1980s and1990s, mainly as co-musician for the womens' dance side Lizzie Dripping. We played D/G boxes then, mine was an Erica, Barry's was a Pokerwork. He taught me a great deal about playing for dancing. A lovely man and a fine musician. Much missed, as ever.
-
I'd love to know the story behind my C/F Hohner Club - all I know is that it came from Canada, swapped for a banjo apparently. Go figure! Supposedly, and we're into the land of urban legend here, my A/D Lilly was once Roger Watson's box, and my D/G pokerwork which I've had from new has in its time been played by Andy Cutting of this parish, and Marc Perrone. You wouldn't think Spaghetti Panic can be played on a standard 8 bass pokerwork, but yes it can, and it sounds bl**dy amazing.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Some of my current melodeons have been bought from new, but my Castagnari Mory came second hand from Hobgoblin in Crawley about 8 years ago, and the Giordy 2nd hand from the London branch last year. I've no idea who owned them before, which is a bit sad. The G/D Loffet and the Udo Schneeberg Steirishe were both purchased through the auspices this very site, and both had the provenance and servicing/tweaking history from new, which is great and shows that many of us care about this-thank you both (you know who you are). My organetto was bought from one of the volunteers who staff the Accordeon Museum in Castelfidardo (no, it wasn't one of the exhibits, although he did open up some of the display cabinets and let me try some of the instruments!). He was a brilliant player of this style of box, and became extremely animated (as in crimson with rage)whilst trying to get me to play it smoothly across the rows rather than in-and-out like a one-row....the photos are stored in the case to prove it.
Cheers,
Guy
-
Well, my three row 'El Rey' was bought from some crazed bearded bloke from the Welsh borders claiming to be a maker of melodeons. He swore blind that the box had the very best Welsh pedigree and that the words 'Made in China' is actually an obscure Welsh language phrase meaning 'there's one born every minute'. I didn't believe him mind you - it plays like a dream. How providential is that?
;D
-
Well my Tommy was second hand but I've no idea who owned it before me.
My first box, a Pokerwork, was pretty cheap and though working fine appeared to have got too close to some Child who had scribbled all over the bellows folds. Only when I got it home did I realise they were actually autographs. Including one "Martin Carthy" whoever he is (Child, Carthy, see what I did there?).
I've no idea who had the box before and whether the signatures are genuine.
-
provenance of mine (two old Hohners and a Weltmeister) - ebay!
-
I bought my Pokerwork from Dave Jolly around Christmas 2007, who told me it had one previous owner, but had not been played much. My Club was bought from a car boot and I assume it came from a house clearance. Wish I knew more about that box.
-
My Erika came from Bremen in a tatty ancient case. I've always wondered what it got up to in the 70 odd years between when it was new and when it came into my hands, would it have many stories to tell or did someone play it for a few years and then stick it in the back of cupboard and forget about it until someone doing a house clearance thought, "Hmm, I could sell that on eBay". I also have a Club II of similar age and all I know about its history is that it was originally sold by a German music shop that put a little metal plate with their name on it and that I bought it from Tom B-R.
I once had an Excelsior that I bought from and later sold through Theo that had obviously seen a lot playing and I sometimes wonder about where that came from and where it is now but I'm most intrigued though by the Jorgina I used to have. I bought it from Pip Ives, who bought it from Rees and I don't know anything else beyond that but I'm guessing it was imported by Roger Watson in the mid 80s and with 12 basses and lots of wooden inlay compared to the other plainer Jorginas I've seen, which are quite rare anyway, today it's a rarity among rarities and at a time when nearly all good D/G melodeons in the UK were Hohners it must have been quite a prestigious and expensive instrument. I sold it to John Spiers and as far as I know he still has it.
My current box is brand new but it's the first of its kind and I quite like that.
-
A used box played by Al or Alex Meixner is probably worn out. These guys really give an accordion a workout. Father and son are truly amazing musicians.