Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Quebecois on March 14, 2008, 10:03:35 PM
-
Just curious to know how many of us have experience with the mouth organ, affectionately called "musique à bouche" or "ruine-babines" in Québec!
-
There you are, then - 75% of us play gobiron! Yee peee !!
-
Hi
I played mouth organ from age about 9 and the blow suck method became ingrained so that simple melodeon and anglo concertina playing was quite natural.This served well for Morris and dance music
Over the years i wanted to get the ornamentations of Irish Traditional Music and played around with B/C but recently have come to Csharp/D melodeon/button accordion. It seems that a lot of players are playing the D row much like a mouthorgan. A lot of good one row melodeon players do the same and there are/were some very good D/G players
A lot of old style Anglo players in the Irish tradition play/played up and down the rows as did Scan Tester and William Kimber I think.
So what's the consensus on just playing diatonic boxes like a gob iron and using the bounce that attracted us to the instruments in the first place.
In the 60s and 70s I sometimes found myself the butt of patronising or even snide comments by B/C players who used 'melodeon' as a term of abuse like 'atrocious' as in 'that was melodeon!' I don't think it was my playing but the notion of press and draw techniques. I had no trouble in sessions with genuine trad players who welcomed the box.
Then Jackie daly, Mairtin O'Connor etc seemed to find a middle ground and Johnny Connolly showed us the single row's strength again.
I met Rose Murphy who lived in Maltby, Yorks, when she was recording for Topic and she had a Hohner B/C which she played quite a bit up and down the rows in C or B (She was P.J.Conlon's sister) I just think that was the box she got and played old style up and down the rows.
Any views?
I'm still making my mind up about the pros and cons of C sharp/D versus D/G plus a few extras on a half row. The basses have it on the D/G
Cheers
Mike in Sheffield
-
Just curious to know how many of us have experience with the mouth organ, affectionately called "musique à bouche" or "ruine-babines" in Québec!
I find these days, in my dotage, I much prefer carrying 4 gob irons round festivals to sessions. Much easier on the shoulders...and the session rarely needs another melodeon. I'm particularly fond of my Lee Oskar 10 Hole High G, which complements nicely. Oh Quebecois..."babines"? please?
And while we're on the subject, BBC 4's Friday Night "Tin Sandwich, Anyone?" is well worth catching if you have the facility. Some great playing, and I particularly liked the bit abiut the diatonic/chromatic "schism".
Not now Arthur
Baz
-
And while we're on the subject, BBC 4's Friday Night "Tin Sandwich, Anyone?" is well worth catching if you have the facility. Some great playing, and I particularly liked the bit abiut the diatonic/chromatic "schism".
See Lester's post elsewhere, which has a link...
Memo to self...check before posting
Baz
-
babines = lips
When I told a box-playing friend that I was thinking of taking up the instrument, he advised me to try the harmonica to see whether I could get my head around the in-out concept (or whether it would fry my brain). Luckily before I got the chance to ruine my babines, the same friend went on a long trip and left his one-row and B/C box with me and my fate was sealed.
-
Pronounced "bab-een"...
I find the harmonica a very enjoyable instrument to play, and as noted earlier, it's very easy to carry and there aren't many people playing them in trad music sessions, so it's usually a conversation piece and a fun thing to bring up. I have played a little Marine Band in G for many years, I just won a Super Chromonica on eBay for $20, so I'll get a go on a chromatic, for the kick...
-
Sad to learn that Quebeccois folklorist - and harmonica player - Gabriel Labbé passed away last Friday (14th)...
See here for more info... (http://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=109511)
And here for tunes... (http://www.jeanlouislabbe.com/Gabriel/musique_gabriel.htm)
Ed J
-
Yes, he was a monument in the realm of traditional music, and a major contributor to the preservation of the Québec musical heritage.
-
I have played harmonica (I own 7 Hohner "Blues Harps") longer than I have accordion. I also find myself playing very different music on each instrument.
-
Just to reactivate this I find the thread on how reeds work and bending notes on the forum on constructions etc and technical issues very useful. Leads you off into hyper-reed space. And that's
what it's all about innit musically?
Mike
-
I play at harmonica
I have 9 Special 20's, 1 Lee Oskar, 2 Delta Frost, 1 64 Chromatic and 1 8 hole Chromatic
-
One of our guys has just taken it up - he likes to wind the box players up with what he calls his "one row melodeon" that he can fit into his shirt pocket when they're hauling heavy boxes around!