Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: waltzman on April 03, 2010, 10:10:03 PM
-
Does anyone know what type and key instrument Stephane is playing here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnAB3sCm7Bg The instrument has a beautiful tone and this is a beautifuly played mazurka.
Thanks,
Michael
-
Does anyone know what type and key instrument Stephane is playing here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnAB3sCm7Bg The instrument has a beautiful tone and this is a beautifuly played mazurka.
Thanks,
Michael
Yes - isn't it gorgeous!
The key of the tune is G minor and although it's difficult to see, I get the impression that the home row for the piece is on the inside row. That suggests a C/F box. Make - no idea, but possibly Bernard Loffet?
-
It's not clear enough to really see, but from the general appearance of the box, especially the colour of the case and bellows, I'd agree that it is very probably a Loffet. Sounds right for a Loffet, too.
-
Does anyone know what type and key instrument Stephane is playing here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnAB3sCm7Bg The instrument has a beautiful tone and this is a beautifuly played mazurka.
Thanks,
Michael
Yes - isn't it gorgeous!
The key of the tune is G minor and although it's difficult to see, I get the impression that the home row for the piece is on the inside row. That suggests a C/F box. Make - no idea, but possibly Bernard Loffet?
I have learned this piece on a G/C box in Am and I assumed that was the key he was playing it in but it isn't. When I tried it on a C/F box it didn't sound right either. The box has has me puzzled.
-
If it's in Gm then could it be a Bb/Eb box?
-
The key of the tune is G minor and although it's difficult to see, I get the impression that the home row for the piece is on the inside row. That suggests a C/F box. Make - no idea, but possibly Bernard Loffet?
I have learned this piece on a G/C box in Am and I assumed that was the key he was playing it in but it isn't. When I tried it on a C/F box it didn't sound right either. The box has has me puzzled.
I don't know this tune, but I just tried playing along with it my C/F, playing in G minor on the inside row, and it seems to work fine.
I'm going to try to learn it
-
G minor on the inside row and the lovely rich tone makes me think it's an F/Bb box and I'm sure there's another recent thread that mentions him playing an F/Bb Castagnari Casta, which would further explain the mellow sound, but that box doesn't look like a Casta to me. The picture quality isn't too good though so a definite ID is going to be very hard.
-
G minor on the inside row and the lovely rich tone makes me think it's an F/Bb box and I'm sure there's another recent thread that mentions him playing an F/Bb Castagnari Casta, which would further explain the mellow sound, but that box doesn't look like a Casta to me. The picture quality isn't too good though so a definite ID is going to be very hard.
Yes. That would make sense, except it would be played on the outside row (mostly). I believe it was written in Am on the G/C which would put it in Gm on an F/Bb. I've not come across that tuning before. Thanks.
-
Looking at it again, I think he's playing on the outside rather than the inside row, in which case it will be an F/Bb.
I've just spent a while playing it in A minor on a G/C and a D/G, and in G minor on a C/F (but not as well as him! :( ), and it does seem to sit better on the outside row. Sounds better in Gm, though.
It's quite good on the inside row with a 12 bass box, and I think the one he is playing here is quite big, although I can't see the buttons clearly. It has a metal grille, and could be a Loffet 3 ranges.
Sounds wonderful, whatever it is.
-
Here's another Youtube video of this tune. This time it's much clearer to see the fingering and the buttons, although the performance doesn't have that velvety quality of the one we first started discussing. I haven't had the chance to check, but I would guess this is being played in Am on a G/C box. It's interesting that the poster has mentioned that the original key on Stephane Delicq's original recording ('Accordeon diatonique') was Em.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5xgKuzrHyA
-
The version I play is this one (http://www.diatonia.net/pdf/64-Nadiejda.pdf), in Am on a G/C box. Fingering looks similar to the youtube video. The cd-recording by Delicq is indeed in Em. So the youtube version is either played on an F/Bb or it somehow got slowed down a bit from G/C.
-
Excellent! Many thanks, Simon, for posting the PDF file of the tablature.
Something to work at now....
-
There are also two other similar versions on the Accademia del Mantice website.
Its a simple tune, but if you listen to Stephane playing it he puts in some lovely variations and plays it with so much feeling that you could listen to it (or better still dance to it) for hours.
All his tunes on the website are for G/C, but I saw that one of them had a note at the bottom to say it was originally written for an F/Bb box. I also read through a recent thread
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2889.0.html
from which it seems he generally played Castagnaris, so it probably isn't a Loffet on the video.
-
I am pretty sure that it's an F/Bb, you can hear that he is using push Bb's as harmony from time to time.