Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on April 11, 2010, 06:28:39 PM

Title: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 11, 2010, 06:28:39 PM
Ok - this is a post I've long wanted to make - and recent comments on the thread started by miklos concerning CBA accordion forums have prompted me to finally get round to posting (you know how usually reticent I am  :|bl).

As a PA player as well as Button Accordion, I've naturally shopped around looking for a decent, lively and active forum for my instruments, and believe me they just don't exist. In my opinion there is no other accordion forum that can get anywhere near the regular, lively informative and fun debate that we get here on melnet.

So howsabout having a board where forum members can legitimately discuss their various other types/varieties of accordions. Nothing complex - just a place for 'Other Accordion Talk'?

Well, that's it. I'm going to duck down back into my bunker now.
God Bless!
AL
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: ladydetemps on April 11, 2010, 06:42:33 PM
what a no PA joke zone? ;)
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Pete Dunk on April 11, 2010, 06:59:10 PM
There's always the Reyes Accordions Forums (http://www.reyesforum.com/) Al, they cater for all accordion types and have sub forums of interest to many players.  (:)

Conversations on here often wander into the realms of different accordion types but this after all melodeon.net and that sounds pretty specific, even if the expression 'melodeon' is open to interpretation. bisonoric-diatonic-accordion.net doesn't have the same ring somehow.  :Ph
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 11, 2010, 07:08:12 PM
not suggesting a name change - just a board within the forum where other accordion stuff can legitimately be discussed. Reyes forum I find dificult and challenging just to get into let alone understand 80% of what people there are banging on about.

There's always accordionist.org which is based in the UK but frankly there's more activity in a morgue at midnight than goes on there - so I've directed a few disgruntled members of that forum over to this place, as one can usually get an answer to a question or issue within the same lifetime here. Although this is melodeon.net a lot of us here play other types of accordion too - in fact a lot of us here don't even play melodeons.

Back into me shelter!
 ;D
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 11, 2010, 07:23:41 PM
I'd support the idea of a discussion section for other accordions on this forum. It would not get in the way of the current topics, and folks could visit it if and when they wished. I already read the posts to do with CBAs; they are amazing instruments and if I were 20 years younger, I would definitely take it up.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Owen Woods on April 11, 2010, 07:27:44 PM
Steve - Whereas if I were 20 years older I might be able to afford one ;D

I think this is a good idea. Reach out the hand of brotherhood to our poor cousins from across the intellectual gulf, etc.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 11, 2010, 07:36:40 PM
Quote
I'd support the idea of a discussion section for other accordions on this forum. It would not get in the way of the current topics, and folks could visit it if and when they wished. I already read the posts to do with CBAs; they are amazing instruments and if I were 20 years younger, I would definitely take it up.

I agree - I too think CBAs are brilliant - and I've noticed an increase in their popularity recently - especially amongst members of this forum.

Quote
I think this is a good idea. Reach out the hand of brotherhood to our poor cousins from across the intellectual gulf, etc.
LOL! It's good to appreciate difference as well as similarity sin't it?
 ;D
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: arty on April 11, 2010, 09:33:02 PM
Quote
I'd support the idea of a discussion section for other accordions on this forum. It would not get in the way of the current topics, and folks could visit it if and when they wished. I already read the posts to do with CBAs; they are amazing instruments and if I were 20 years younger, I would definitely take it up.

I agree - I too think CBAs are brilliant - and I've noticed an increase in their popularity recently - especially amongst members of this forum.

Quote
I think this is a good idea. Reach out the hand of brotherhood to our poor cousins from across the intellectual gulf, etc.
LOL! It's good to appreciate difference as well as similarity sin't it?
 ;D

I am a CBA player and I would welcome this idea. I love Melodeon. net - it is quite simply the best forum I have come across. I love the music usually played on the melodeon and I enjoy learning some of it on my CBA. I have learnt an awful lot from your site since I started looking in. I don't see why it matters what one plays, CBA or Diatonic - surely it's the music and the fun that counts.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Pete Dunk on April 11, 2010, 11:45:35 PM
I don't see why it matters what one plays, CBA or Diatonic - surely it's the music and the fun that counts.

This in itself is true. Music, the love of music, and the joy it brings to us is all that really matters. Whatever instrument we choose to play and to whatever standard we play it at is also irrelevant. Whatever style we cleave to is a matter of choice or personal taste, so musicians everywhere are indeed brethren.

There's probably room for all systems here and I find the CBA very interesting but it's sad that players of such instruments don't have a lively forum of their own where I can lurk in fascination and learn a lot without commiting myself to something I don't really understand.

Welcome to the forum though arty, I look forward to being educated.  :D
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: juker on April 12, 2010, 07:22:02 AM
I think an 'other accordions' posting spot sounds like a good idea. I have an old PA myself and am, anyway, curious about other 'boxes'. The friendliness and intelligent exchange of info (sometimes more or less intelligent than at others  ;D) found here on mel.net is surely not just because we only talk about melodeons?
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 12, 2010, 09:04:29 AM
Quote
The friendliness and intelligent exchange of info (sometimes more or less intelligent than at others  ) found here on mel.net is surely not just because we only talk about melodeons?

AMEN!


Welcome arty! What's your box and what system do you play?
AL
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 12, 2010, 10:05:20 AM
Seeing as Theo is otherwise occupied at the moment in another place, we need to ask Clive very nicely if he will please set up a new space on the forum for 'other accordions'.
 (:)
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: george garside on April 12, 2010, 11:02:09 AM
I also am in favour of the idea

george
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: nemethmik on April 12, 2010, 11:04:13 AM
CBAs; they are amazing instruments and if I were 20 years younger, I would definitely take it up.
Steve - Whereas if I were 20 years older I might be able to afford one ;D
Brilliant!  (:)
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 12, 2010, 11:41:06 AM
Quote
Seeing as Theo is otherwise occupied at the moment in another place, we need to ask Clive very nicely if he will please set up a new space on the forum for 'other accordions'.

Good point! I shall draw this thread to his attention and ask for his assistance.
AL
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Clive Williams on April 12, 2010, 12:49:23 PM
Quote
Seeing as Theo is otherwise occupied at the moment in another place, we need to ask Clive very nicely if he will please set up a new space on the forum for 'other accordions'.

Good point! I shall draw this thread to his attention and ask for his assistance.
AL

All done - enjoy!

Clive
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Owen Woods on April 12, 2010, 03:07:34 PM
Wahey :P
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 12, 2010, 04:52:59 PM
Quote
All done - enjoy!

Clive

Oh, for he's a jolly good fellow!
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: ladydetemps on April 12, 2010, 04:57:34 PM
so...what's a Pan-accordion?
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: LDbosca on April 12, 2010, 05:05:55 PM
so...what's a Pan-accordion?

It's related to the pan-pipes.

Luke.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: nfldbox on April 12, 2010, 05:40:38 PM
and one more cheer for melodeon.net, wonderful people and the technology is the most workable and satisfying of any forums I know.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: arty on April 12, 2010, 09:17:18 PM
Quote
The friendliness and intelligent exchange of info (sometimes more or less intelligent than at others  ) found here on mel.net is surely not just because we only talk about melodeons?

AMEN!


Welcome arty! What's your box and what system do you play?
AL


Thank you so much for the welcome!

I lived in France for a few years and one thing that I found myself really looking forward to, was hearing the sound of an accordion playing in the open air, often the saturday morning market or a fete maybe. For the  first year there, I was helping a friend to restore an old house. I went on and on about my love for the music, and when the house was finished I was presented with a 25 year old Cavagnolo Button Accordion as a very generous thankyou for the help I had given.

I started to teach myself, trying different tutor books until I found a method with which I felt comfortable and I loved it! However, as I am no longer a spring chicken, I did find the Cavagnolo very heavy and decided to treat myself to a smaller, lighter one. Then, all sorts of questions came to my mind, like, what would be the best instrument to buy? I have always had a passion for folk music (I have played guitar for years), and thought long and hard about starting all over again but on a diatonic accordion. However, I decided that I didn't want to 'waste' the time that I had put into the CBA by starting all over again on a diatonic. So, when I heard someone playing a beautiful little Saltarelle Chaville CBA, I decided to treat myself to one. And I haven't regretted it for one second. I absolutely love it!

Please don't change Melodeon.net, it is brilliant as it is! But a place within it, where people like me could take part now and again, would be nice.
Thankyou
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Theo on April 12, 2010, 11:44:04 PM
I may be away from base, but I'm still Reading the forum.  I think this one needs a bit more time and discussion before making any changes.  My first thought is that the present format copes quite happily withe the occasional post about other systems.  Having a separate forum for non-diatonics risks creating a ghetto where fewer regular members will read the chromatic posts to everyones detriment.  I think this thread should run for a week or two to see what consensus emerges. 

Fwiw I have talked to several other people here on the melodeon building course and all were opposed to the idea.  I'm not opposed in principle,  but I think we need time for a bit more debate first.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Theo on April 12, 2010, 11:46:46 PM
Oh I see I have been gazumped.

I'll just crawl back into my hole and keep quiet.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Owen Woods on April 12, 2010, 11:50:34 PM
Gazumped?
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Accordion Dave on April 13, 2010, 01:43:09 AM
Is segregation really necessary?

I am interested in all varieties of accordion.... piano accordion, button accordion, accordeon, acordeon, bayan, melodeon, concertina, bandoneon, Steirsche Harmonika, chromatic, chromatic with fake piano keys, etc.

Any style of musik that uses an instrument with a bellows and reeds hits a chord with me, so to speak.

Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: RGF on April 13, 2010, 01:51:03 AM
I'm with Theo on this one........sounds perhaps workable, but a bit unsure if this is the place. MELODEON.net, after all, and this is coming from the owner of three piano accordions.

The PA was the instrument of my youth, and -- after a 40-year lapse -- I returned to it about six years ago. (Though much more into folk and dance music this time around.) I was delighted to find a PA newsgroup where I then spent WAY too much time. A few years later, I picked up the two-row, and was then most happy to discover mel.net....one of the most congenial and helpful online resources, where I've also spent way too much time! And while I would like to say that I "play" both instruments, I'm using the term very loosely here. In any event, I do have something of a foot in each camp.

A while back, that particular PA group was hijacked by trolls and cranks, sad to say, and the last time I looked there, it was full of ads for time-share holiday homes, fake Rolex watches, and porn. (And some accordion stuff, but it's a sad shadow of its former self.) I have not been back, nor have I found any site to take its place.

So while I would really like to find some forum for PA, chromatic, etc., with all of the friendly, helpful, give & take of information as mel.net, I guess I would first hope for it to be a separate entity entirely. I mean, the PA has been in a kind of ghetto for most of its life......time to break out!

Bob
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: RGF on April 13, 2010, 04:55:49 AM
On The Other Hand..........

Since my last post, I have had a first look at a little book that I was given just yesterday: HOW TO BE AN ACCORDION PLAYER, by Geoff Berner. (Kolakovsky Press of Canada)  I will transcribe chapter three in its entirety.

Chapter Three
Different Kinds of Accordions


"There are many different names for types of accordions, such as concertinas, harmonicas, and squeezeboxes. What are the distinctions? I don't care, and neither should you."

This is followed by:
Figure 2: "Different kinds of accordions. This diagram should be ignored. It just doesn't matter."

HA!
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on April 13, 2010, 12:49:13 PM
A very healthy and typically Canadian attitude! The reason I don't play the PA is because of all those buttons - I just don't have 150 fingers! (or indeed the skill to use them if I did)  ::)
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Accordion Dave on April 13, 2010, 01:12:39 PM
You do not use all 120 buttons at the same time. You have any key available. No need to say, "Sorry my box is not in that key. Can you transpose?" You do not need to carry a one row melodeon for each key signature.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: george garside on April 13, 2010, 03:18:53 PM
better still a continental chromatic 5 row  - more or less self transposing or a british chromatic  12 keys for the price of 5 makes transposing on the hoof relatively easy
george
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on April 13, 2010, 05:28:30 PM
Now then, now then - do I have to post on two threads about this?
The reason I can't play PA (or piano, for that matter - despite mother having been a whiz on it) is that I never got my head sorted with every key having a different fingering, although I can play tunes on the basses! Buttons seem to overcome this affliction to a great extent - I can play BCC# in G, D and A without too much trouble, but the CBA has always intrigued me in the way the keys are set out so you can play any key with the same fingering (or at least one of three on the lighter 3 row). Tone.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: george garside on April 13, 2010, 07:03:45 PM
Now then, now then - do I have to post on two threads about this?
The reason I can't play PA (or piano, for that matter - despite mother having been a whiz on it) is that I never got my head sorted with every key having a different fingering, although I can play tunes on the basses! Buttons seem to overcome this affliction to a great extent - I can play BCC# in G, D and A without too much trouble, but the CBA has always intrigued me in the way the keys are set out so you can play any key with the same fingering (or at least one of three on the lighter 3 row). Tone.

that should mean you can also play it in Aflat, Eflat & Bflat without too much trouble!

george
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on April 13, 2010, 07:17:43 PM
Absolutely George, but nobody I know wants to join me in those keys! What'd they know, eh!
Bless all (and Al), Black Sheep Tone  ::).
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: Nick Hudis on April 14, 2010, 05:21:26 PM
Just to say that I whole heatedly agree with the comments about this forum.  Its the besty I've ever come across.  I think thats down to the people involved.  One of the great things here is also how international we are and eclectic in the styles of music we play.

I still lust after that Castagnari PA that Rees had or has for sale.
Title: Re: Pan-Accordion Board?
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 14, 2010, 05:47:01 PM
 
Quote
still lust after that Castagnari PA that Rees had or has for sale.

Me too - but I think it's gone  :'(
AL
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal