Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on April 14, 2010, 09:32:14 PM

Title: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Andrew Culwell on April 14, 2010, 09:32:14 PM
So I'm going to ask a Piano Accordion Question here on behalf of my sister.  She is quite an accomplished pianist and is fascinated by the free reed sound since I have taken up the B/C system.  She would prefer to take on the the Piano Accordion rather than go diatonic.  Yes I tried to get her to go Diatonic but she is terrified of all those buttons.  However she is a slip of a girl and has borrowed a friends Silvio Soprani 120 bass which is massive and overwhelming to her.  She wants to purchase an accordion but I think she should stick to something more manageable than the monster she currently has on loan.  I'm scanning ebay but have no idea which direction to take her in as I'm totally not a Piano Accordion person.  Al or anyone else that has PA experience want to weigh in on this.  She is a pianist and also plays with her church Band and Worship team so she is eager to use it in this way also. 
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: george garside on April 14, 2010, 10:04:41 PM
for 'folk' or church  or just jolly tunes music  the smallest box that you like the sound of & that has enough keys on the keyboard to cope with the particular music you want to play makes sense. 48 basss is often enough & there is little or no point in going above 72. 9 60 BASS IS AA GOOD SIZE IF YOU CAN FIND ONE - SAME EVERYTHING AS A 72 BUT WITHOUT DIMINISHED  CHORDS/(You get a longer treble keyboard with 72 bass).  lightweight & portability are very important.  whether its 2,3 or 4 voice is entirely to prsonalo choice & some 2 voice boxes can be pretty powerful.

As always the best thing by far is to go to one of the big dealrs , or a festival where several have stands, and try as many as you can both new & secondhand.

george
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: ganderbox on April 14, 2010, 10:11:50 PM
I know little about PA's, but I have to confess (somewhat ashamedly) that my husband has decided he wants to play one, and is currently awaiting delivery of a Hohner Student which he bought on eBay Germany.
I think it's a 48 bass and weighs in at about 4kg.
I used to play in a band with someone who played a hohner Student, and because of its size it was a much livelier instrument than most PAs I've met....almost as good as a melodeon!  >:E

BTW...shouldn't this thread be in the "other accordions" section?
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Andrew Culwell on April 14, 2010, 10:14:28 PM
Oh didn't know about the other accordions section.  My mistake!
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: pete /acorn on April 14, 2010, 10:33:26 PM
Hi,
The main question before getting carried away is how much do you want to spend,a good starter box but fairly rare would be a 48 bass,30 key Guerrini 2 voice,much more scope on right hand than more normal 25 key,a very good 25 key a Hohner Student V,very reliable and well made.
Hope this helps


Pete
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Kautilya on April 14, 2010, 10:35:52 PM
So I'm going to ask a Piano Accordion Question here on behalf of my sister.  She is quite an accomplished pianist and is fascinated by the free reed sound since I have taken up the B/C system.  She would prefer to take on the the Piano Accordion rather than go diatonic.  Yes I tried to get her to go Diatonic but she is terrified of all those buttons.  However she is a slip of a girl and has borrowed a friends Silvio Soprani 120 bass which is massive and overwhelming to her.  She wants to purchase an accordion but I think she should stick to something more manageable than the monster she currently has on loan.  I'm scanning ebay but have no idea which direction to take her in as I'm totally not a Piano Accordion person.  Al or anyone else that has PA experience want to weigh in on this.  She is a pianist and also plays with her church Band and Worship team so she is eager to use it in this way also. 
There must be an accordion group in N Carolina (like the UK leyland accordion club www.accordionclub.co.uk- because she could then try out different sizes and ask advice and at Leylnd they also sell good, low cost accordions within the group to beginners.....
Buying unseen off ebay is really difficult and sometimes the reeds fall out  of the wax in the post and the bass buttons drop inside.... etc etc
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Larry Anthony on April 14, 2010, 11:02:33 PM
An important consideration, in my opinion, is to be sure the treble keyboard goes down to G below middle C.
It may not mean much at this stage but I suspect she will find not having the lower notes, as she becomes more accomplished, could be something of a drawback.
 
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Andrew Culwell on April 14, 2010, 11:31:52 PM
Cost is the tricky part as She is actually more curious than absolutely in the grip of Piano Accordion Disorder.  I was the one that got her interested in Free Reed intruments.  I'm thinking of something that is used, not a piece of junk, but something that will be a good experience for her and won't make her shy away.  This is experimental so in no way are we ready to go and spend thousands of dollars.
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: RGF on April 15, 2010, 05:15:04 AM
I will echo George's comment here, that there's really not much reason to go beyond a 72 bass instrument. (Or a 60 bass, which is basically the same, minus the diminished chord row.) The PA I play most often is my 34 key/72bass 3-reed Serenellini, which I consider to be kind of my "smallest instrument that will do everything I might want to do".  And for most folk music, I think a 26 or 30 key, 48 bass would do nicely.....especially for a beginner.

The older Hohner Student 48 bass has really achieved something of a cult status, and you can see and hear it being played by Charles Giordano in Bruce Springsteen's  Seeger Sesisons band. The Hohner Concerto III is also a nice instrument, a 34 key/72 bass/3 reed, set up LMM. Some of the later versions are recent enough that they can be in quite nice original condition, reed-wise, etc. The usual caveats about shopping for older instruments, of course. Here in the states, you might want to have a look at Liberty Bellows. Although I have never done business with them, I browse their website from time-to time, and am usually impressed with their offerings and their prices. They seem to have instruments other than the run-of-the-mill 41/120 things that seem to always show up on Craig'sList. I see that there is currently a nice sounding, 2-reed Hohner Arietta offered for $395. You can hear it, and others, here: http://www.libertybellows.com/Sales-Small.html

For a new instrument in the lower price ranges, you might want to look at Weltmeister. When I got back into playing again, the first instrument I picked up was a 30/60 Welsmeister Rubin. I have since replaced that with their 30/72 Juwel (a three reed, LMM), and they also have a 26/48 2-reed.

Bob
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: RGF on April 15, 2010, 05:23:11 AM
I should add that there are two configurations of 48-bass instruments. One is 4x12, so it will play in all keys, but the chord rows are just major and minor. The other is 6x8, offering 7th and diminished chord rows, but which doesn't lend itself to playing in each and every key.

Bob
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 15, 2010, 08:00:16 AM
If she is an accomplished keyboard player she would really begin to get frustrated with a 48 bass PA pretty soon. Bearing in mind that a lot of contemporary worship music is in guitar friendly keys (E major & D, A etc) I would suggest a 72 bass PA as that would give the left hand accompaniment buttons. Anything smaller like a 48 bass would be probably be too limiting - especially in a worship band situation.

AL
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Earbrass on April 15, 2010, 11:20:30 AM
Hi there,

I've only been playing PA for a year (after 40-odd years on the piano amongst other instruments) so I don't have Al's experience, but I'm not sure I'd agree that a 48 bass would be too limiting; I think the length of the treble keyboard is more important, and I'd definitely recommend no less than 30 keys. I play a cheap 12x4 48 bass with 30 treble keys (low G - high C). This gives, as RGF points out, root, third, maj and min chords for all 12 keys in the bass - I don't miss the 7th/diminished chords; not much call for dim chords in folk (and I would have thought the same applies to hymns??) and you can augment the lh chords with rh notes to give a 7th when required. Even a 6x8 would give basses in the keys Al mentions, so I am a little puzzled by his remarks. Care to expand, Al? (I expect I'm missing something!)

Regards,

E
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 15, 2010, 12:01:03 PM
Well, it's just that the chord of B major (& 7ths) for example would be missing from a 6 x 8 48 bass - and I play loads of contemporary worship music where I simply couldn't manage with B & F# rows for the bass end which are missing from my standard 48 bass but are there on my 72 bass. Similarly on a 6 x 8 48 bass the buttons only go down to Eb - no good if you're playing a load of hymns as I do which are frequently written in three and four flats - you really need the bass buttons to go down to include Ab & Db. I agree that for folk anything more than a 48 bass is not really necessary - if the majority of tunes being played are in D,G,A, C or F. However, a lot of church music often written in at least three flats or 4 sharps - a classic example is 'Slane' which on the face of it is a traditional popular 'Irish' melody - but in a lot hymnals is in E major - and you really need the B row on the bass side of things to provide a full and proper accompaniment.

Funnily I do also think that a 26 note keyboard (mainly what you get on 48 bass models) is too short as well. 34 keys minimum (which is more usually to be found with 72 bass accordions) is better. However, as least with the keyboard if the G below middle C isn't there at least you have the option/possibility of transposing the note up an octave etc. So it's not like the note isn't there - it's just in a different place. But the problem with a 48 bass is that so many really important accompaniment rows just aren't there. A 72 bass isn't perefct but if you'll pardon the pun, it covers all the bases!  ;D

Hope this explains my perspective better?

AL
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Earbrass on April 15, 2010, 12:03:21 PM
Yes, perfectly, thanks!  (:)
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: jonm on April 15, 2010, 12:19:37 PM
When playing my 40 bass (48 without the diminished row) I use the B note (major third off the G row) and Dmaj chord for Bm7 and the F# (major third off the D row) and Amaj chord for F#m7, which I find are adequate for most folk-ish applications in C, G, D and A. For jazzy stuff, I use the two rows of bass notes to provide more of a melodic / harmonic bass line accompaniment in funny keys where I run out of chords.

Personally, I'd recommend a 60- or 72-bass for a pianist, simply more versatile. There are some really good lightweight (ladies'?) models made in Italy but they can be expensive. My better half has a Fantini 72 which weighs nearly nothing considering it's four voice, it has a real bellow, however, it cost more than my last car! Pigini three-voices are better value, I think the Music Room stocks them.
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: pete /acorn on April 15, 2010, 01:00:33 PM
Hi,
I'me waiting delivery of a new model in Manfrini range,72 bass 34 key 3 voice,tipo a mano reeds as standard,A mano as option.

Pete
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 15, 2010, 01:36:19 PM
Hi Pete - what sort of price are we talking about for the Manfrini 72b TAM?
AL
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: pete /acorn on April 15, 2010, 02:40:33 PM
Hi Al,
Price will be £2695 with 5 year warranty subject to conditions,A Mano reeds + £300,this is specialy spec instrument to rival Pigini with A Mano Reeds and at £3895,I am having 2 made.one 3 voice musette {3 x  8' reeds}and one 16' reed + 2 x 8',tune to customers spec.
colour   Black

Pete
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: MandoC on April 15, 2010, 06:09:29 PM
Ajay:  My wife's main concern when buying a piano accordion was as little weight as possible.  She bought a Weltmeister Rubin which I believe has 60 bass.  This is a very popular folk model in the US.  It has a decent (but a little brash) tone and only two voices. It weighs in at around 11 pounds.  At the high end of the folk piano accordions is the Saltarelle Clifden (also 60 bass I believe) which my wife has considered buying.  However she has much better resistance to the Aquisition Syndrome than I have for musical instruments. Both instruments are carried by the Button Box in the US if you want to have a look at them.  Weltmeister also makes a wide range of accordions including the Achat which is 72 bass I believe and somewhat heavier than the Rublin, but still out of the Schwarzeneger range of weight lifiting. Good luck with the search. All the best Charlie
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 15, 2010, 06:40:14 PM
Quote
She bought a Weltmeister Rubin which I believe has 60 bass

A lovely little box! The only problem I have with it is that it doesn't have full-size keys. That's not a problem for some - though not ideal. The Achat is very good - and you can get some excellent prices on Weltmeister PAs from www.thomann.de (http://www.thomann.de)
AL
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: george garside on April 15, 2010, 07:55:47 PM
Al,have just looked at the website you mention some very interesting 4 row diatonics (steiriche) with tunings in gcfbflat, gcfb, f/b/es/as whatever that is & with 12 to 15 bass plus horns! Petty they dont have some branches here where they can be tried.  prices seem good dtoo



george
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Tony Gibbons on April 15, 2010, 11:52:40 PM
I've played a 120 bass Sonola for over 40 years and wish I had a 72 bass PA. I love my 120 bass but am being realistic on size and weight. 72 bass everytime but I think there are less of those on the second hand market than 120 bass PA's. I haven't researched price but I feel that they hold their price better. Supply and demand no doubt. 120 bass can be bought cheaper.
Don't buy cheap, go for quality. Consider it an investment. Buy Italian. Try as many as you can. Consider action/touch. Look out for the balance between left hand and right hand. Some PA's tend to have louder basses and run out of air quickly to the detrement of the right hand particularly when trying to play softly.
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: squeezenplease on April 16, 2010, 12:41:01 AM
Older PAs tend to have overpowering bass ends...most Italian boxes are now well ballanced...up here in the ash clad north we have 48 bass size (6x8,6x10,5x12)...72 base size (6x12,6x14,6x16)...2 3 or 4 voice...standard,hand type or hand made...yep...lightweight is the future...TC
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 16, 2010, 09:19:18 AM
Quote
Al,have just looked at the website you mention some very interesting 4 row diatonics (steiriche) with tunings in gcfbflat, gcfb, f/b/es/as whatever that is & with 12 to 15 bass plus horns! Petty they dont have some branches here where they can be tried.  prices seem good dtoo



george

Hi George - I agree - the prices are pretty good - especially considering they are offering free UK delivery if you spend over £200 (pretty easy to achieve when buying an accordion heh?). I've purchased a couple of accordions from them - excellent delivery - stonkin' prices and they operate an excellent returns service as well, though I've never needed to use it! I particularly like this (http://www.thomann.de/gb/kaerntnerland_edelweiss_mini_knopfakkordeon.htm) particular box - indeed I created a thread about it a long time ago now!

Another thing to consider - given that we're actually talking about PAs here is that Thomann did also have an economy range of PAs (48, 72 & 120 bass) which come with Cagnoni (Italian) reeds. Don't know if they still have it - but it's the kind of thing to look out for i.e. a 72 bass instrument with Italian reeds for around £300 -£400 BARGAIN!
Title: Re: A PA question ...no rotten tomatoes please!
Post by: Andrew Culwell on April 18, 2010, 07:31:03 PM
If she is an accomplished keyboard player she would really begin to get frustrated with a 48 bass PA pretty soon. Bearing in mind that a lot of contemporary worship music is in guitar friendly keys (E major & D, A etc) I would suggest a 72 bass PA as that would give the left hand accompaniment buttons. Anything smaller like a 48 bass would be probably be too limiting - especially in a worship band situation.

AL
Al
She is in a worship band that is guitar driven but currently plays Keyboards.  She is looking to branch out and thus the search for a decent not overly huge PA.  She is quite a competent, talented keyboard player so you may have hit on something. I'm probably going to point her to some of the websited you and others have posted above.  Seems like they have some inexpensive yet well maintained boxes.  Thanks all for your input.  

(we now return you to your regularly scheduled Button box discussions)

--Drew
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal