Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: Clive Williams on April 24, 2010, 11:58:35 PM
-
Hi folks - here we go again! Happy voting!
-
hi clive can you put a list of the nominees in a reply post to this thread as i can't view poll options on my mobile?
-
I would suggest not voting for Dearest Dickie, considering the likelihood of the ThOTM being Morris tunes. I've plumped for Michael Turner's Waltz.
-
Here's the list LdT.
The Ash Grove
Cock of the North
Dearest Dickie
Fisher's Hornpipe
La Marianne
Michael Turner's Waltz
Mon Amant de Saint-Jean
Pterodactyl 2 Step
Twin Sisters
Woodland Revels
-
I know of at least two tunes with the title Twin Sisters - so which one is intended?
-
looks like theres three tunes to choose between for me
-
I know of at least two tunes with the title Twin Sisters - so which one is intended?
By the way the poll is going, I shouldn't worry :D BLT.
-
who's winning?
-
We all are.
G
-
Mon Amant de Saint-Jean
Is it this one?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tf6_Ep6jThY
/quote]
-
Probably so, this one is much nicer to watch (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqFHYcxxEfs&feature=related). Not a bad tune but I don't hear anything to lift it above the crowd.
-
I would suggest not voting for Dearest Dickie, considering the likelihood of the ThOTM being Morris tunes. I've plumped for Michael Turner's Waltz.
Heh, that's why I've stopped naming the ThOTM until the very last minute; the theme reflects and is influenced by the TOTM winner. If the TOTM winner is a relatively easy tune, the theme is a little more complex, and vice versa. I am considering Morris as a theme for this month, but it's by no means a certainty, especially if a relatively easy tune wins as seems highly likely at the moment!
Cheers,
Clive
-
Probably so, this one is much nicer to watch (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqFHYcxxEfs&feature=related). Not a bad tune but I don't hear anything to lift it above the crowd.
Yep, that's the puppy. It's actually IMHO *way* easier to play on a 2 row than you'd expect, although it's still not in all honesty an easy tune for those used to single row playing - it encourages, rewards, and indeed teaches across the rows playing and playing in the upper octave.
Cheers,
Clive
-
I know of at least two tunes with the title Twin Sisters - so which one is intended?
I had in mind the Upton on Severn morris version like this one:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ctYuGYwTqZg
... but rather like when we did 'Princess Royal', any even slightly related variant counts too.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Go Pterodactyls :P
-
Yep, that's the puppy. It's actually IMHO *way* easier to play on a 2 row than you'd expect, although it's still not in all honesty an easy tune for those used to single row playing - it encourages, rewards, and indeed teaches across the rows playing and playing in the upper octave.
Admirable sentiments and a 'classic French style' tune -- Cette adaptation, ainsi que les variations, peuvent se jouer sur tout accordéon diatonique 2 rangs. --- but it'll rather squeeky on a British Army issue D/G. I had the same problem arranging 'Flatworld' which is also played at the top end.
[edit] Hmm - it's a song! See bottom end of Steve's tab.
-
Here are the dots and tablature for Mon Amant de Saint Jean. It's written in A minor here, with the intention of being played on a G/C box, but if you use the same tablature on a D/G box it will sound in Em - maybe a bit squeaky at the top end, but if you've got a box with a low voice stop, that will help it to sound OK.
Mon Amant de Saint Jean tablature (http://diato.org/tablat/tab108.pdf)
Nice tune. As Clive says, rewarding to work at.
Probably so, this one is much nicer to watch (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqFHYcxxEfs&feature=related). Not a bad tune but I don't hear anything to lift it above the crowd.
Yep, that's the puppy. It's actually IMHO *way* easier to play on a 2 row than you'd expect, although it's still not in all honesty an easy tune for those used to single row playing - it encourages, rewards, and indeed teaches across the rows playing and playing in the upper octave.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Another vote on Cock of the north because it has the same kind of little twiddly things as a typical tarantella.
-
A bit like the 'Mon Amant de Saint-Jean' suggestion would be the lovely 'Valse d'Amélie' by Yann Tiersen, from the great film. I won't suggest it for ToTM because of possible copyright issues, but it's a lovely tune, for anyone who doesn't know it. eg: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1LPj9msobY&feature=related
-
Michael Turner's... Wow, brings back some memories of my early morris days!
-
A bit like the 'Mon Amant de Saint-Jean' suggestion would be the lovely 'Valse d'Amélie' by Yann Tiersen, from the great film. I won't suggest it for ToTM because of possible copyright issues, but it's a lovely tune, for anyone who doesn't know it. eg: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1LPj9msobY&feature=related
Yes, another lovely waltz. You may be right about the copyright issues, but the music and tablature are available on diatonia.net, and there are various Youtube versions of people playing it.
'Valse d'Amélie' music and tablature (http://www.diatonia.net/pdf/163-La%20Valse%20Amelie.pdf)
-
The thing is, have we got a fair voting system? I mean, if the exits polls are correct, does this mean we'll get a Michael Turner regime with no representation for the runners-up? Or can we have a redistribution of losing votes to our second choices? Or might the Cock of the North and Mon Amant de St Jean be prepared to form a coalition to create one new tune with the best aspects of both?
At the very least, I expect a three-way public debate between Michael, the Cock, and Mon Amant on subjects such as musicians' pay, law and order in this Forum, and Moderators' expenses claims.
-
The tunes that lost the vote get another chance next month.
Though it's funny how the tune that came 2nd doesn't often win the following month's vote either...
-
It doesn't look better than that Michael Turner's waltz is winning 8) I'd better start looking for a simple recording of it!
-
It doesn't look better than that Michael Turner's waltz is winning 8) I'd better start looking for a simple recording of it!
Looks like all a girl could wish for, manuscript, button numbers, chords, video instructional etc
http://bellowsandstrings.blogspot.com/2010/01/michael-turners-waltz.html (http://bellowsandstrings.blogspot.com/2010/01/michael-turners-waltz.html)
-
It doesn't look better than that Michael Turner's waltz is winning 8) I'd better start looking for a simple recording of it!
Looks like all a girl could wish for, manuscript, button numbers, chords, video instructional etc
http://bellowsandstrings.blogspot.com/2010/01/michael-turners-waltz.html (http://bellowsandstrings.blogspot.com/2010/01/michael-turners-waltz.html)
Wow, Lester, good find! Not bad! So there's hope even for this tune ;)
-
Michael Turner's Waltz
The original music by Mozart is the second of Six German Dances, KV 536 (the index number of Mozart's works), written in Vienna in 1788. No.2 is written for piccolo, two flutes, two bassoons, horn, two violins and double bass. The score is here:
http://imslp.info/files/imglnks/usimg/a/ab/IMSLP24787-PMLP55790-Mozart_6_Deutsche_Tanze__K.536.pdf
The section used as Michael Turner's Waltz is the trio (i.e. the second section) of No.2 which is on the 3rd page (scroll down to it) of the pdf file.
I haven't researched this further, but I wouldn't mind betting that Mozart got his inspiration for this from a traditional German or Austrian Landler, a country dance rather like a rustic waltz or mazurka.
If you can understand the music notation, you will see that it is not quite how it is 'traditionally' played as MTW, but that only goes to illustrate how tunes catch on in people's minds and get played and transmitted aurally down the years, evolving on the way. That's fine. If you want to play it as Mozart intended, go ahead and assemble your musicians and play from the written music. If you want to play it in the folky evolved form commonly played in English sessions, that's good too.
It's a nice tune but then, Mozart was good at those. (:)
-
Ah, thanks for that link, Steve. Took ages to lead but I have it now. Actually I'm surprised the tune has changed so little, given how much it's been played and passed on orally. Maybe some tunes are just right as they are, and hard to improve on.
I had known that it was a Mozart tune - indeed, one of my problems with it is that it's neither "Michael Turner's" nor a waltz (and Michael Turner never claimed that it was either). But I like to think that, as you suggest, he may have nicked or adapted it from a traditional source.
-
so what are you supposed to do with the LH on MTW? Try as I might I can't go 'um pa pah' I'm totally bamboozled by it!
-
so what are you supposed to do with the LH on MTW? Try as I might I can't go 'um pa pah' I'm totally bamboozled by it!
RTFM as recently posted here by Lester....
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3906.msg49355.html#msg49355
.... and written/played by our own Luca Celano.
http://bellowsandstrings.blogspot.com/2010/01/michael-turners-waltz.html
Scroll down to the video tutorial at the bottom. Basses/chords starts at approx 1' 45"
-
so what are you supposed to do with the LH on MTW? Try as I might I can't go 'um pa pah' I'm totally bamboozled by it!
Delighted to hear it! The tutorial has been a lot of work and is very sound. But I too look forward to the 'different' base line promised in the text. That one in the video seems to have been written for Nellie the 3 legged elephant. Playing "um-paaaaaa-silence" would sound nicer IMHO ... and is actually simpler. ;)
-
so what are you supposed to do with the LH on MTW? Try as I might I can't go 'um pa pah' I'm totally bamboozled by it!
In terms of rhythm, just hold the chords down! Honest, it works.
-
Playing "um-paaaaaa-silence" would sound nicer IMHO ...
...because it makes it more like a Mazurka?
There are lots of melodic possibilities in the bass too...
-
so what are you supposed to do with the LH on MTW? Try as I might I can't go 'um pa pah' I'm totally bamboozled by it!
RTFM as recently posted here by Lester....
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3906.msg49355.html#msg49355
.... and written/played by our own Luca Celano.
http://bellowsandstrings.blogspot.com/2010/01/michael-turners-waltz.html
Scroll down to the video tutorial at the bottom. Basses/chords starts at approx 1' 45"
From reading the text it sounds like just suggesting um pa pa! Which I CAN'T DO!
*bangs head against wall*
I think it will just be melody for me.....again
-
From reading the text it sounds like just suggesting um pa pa! Which I CAN'T DO!
Not even slowly, left hand by itself?
Of course you can!