Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Graham W on April 27, 2010, 11:40:36 AM
-
Hello All,
Another question . . . . The Loffet Graet e Breizh boxes seem to have a two voice bass, I've never seen or played one but I assume the bass is going to seem a bit harsh or thin compared to the bass end of my Rik? ???
Any comments much appreciated. I understand these questions are all a bit subjective but as it looks like initially I'll be taking a gamble and buying a GC box unseen any opinions are welcome.
Thanks,
Graham
-
I have a G e B in G/C, and it's possibly the best-sounding of all my boxes. I don't know whether that's down to the construction of the box, the tuning, or just the fact that it's in G/C (which always seems to sound good).
I've never even seen a Rik, so I can't really compare, but I just had a look at one on the Castagnari website and see it has 4 registers on the basses. The bass end of the G e B is certainly a lot more basic than that. I don't know how many bass reeds it has (two?) but the main feature is that it has no thirds in the chords. So, if you like the full sound of the thirds, then it's not for you. If however you think that everything generally sounds better without the thirds (which I do) and never use them , why bother having them in the first place?
-
That's great, thank you,
Graham
-
Hello All,
Another question . . . . The Loffet Graet e Breizh boxes seem to have a two voice bass, I've never seen or played one but I assume the bass is going to seem a bit harsh or thin compared to the bass end of my Rik? ???
Any comments much appreciated. I understand these questions are all a bit subjective but as it looks like initially I'll be taking a gamble and buying a GC box unseen any opinions are welcome.
Thanks,
Graham
My G e B is in D/G, and it has thirds in the basses with a stop to take them out if wanted, and it sounds great! A very full sound. I use it both with and without the thirds, depending on the tune (or how I'm feeling, or if I've forgotten to to pull the stop up...). I bought it from another member of this forum who ordered it from Bernard, so I've no idea if they come like this as standard, but you can certainly specify this when ordering...
Cheers,
Guy
-
Details of the G e Bs are here
http://diato.org/loffet_accordions.htm#pro
Seems the 2 row models do have thirds in the basses, with a stop.
The G e B models are all the same size (28x16x31cms), presumably made to the same specification by his local carpenter. The features which can be incorporated in each model thus depend on what he feels he can fit in the box. The 2.5 and 3 row models do not have thirds, presumably to accommodate the 12 basses.
There's no harm in asking him if he could do a 12 bass model with thirds and a stop, but I suspect he would say it wasn't possible.
-
There's no harm in asking him if he could do a 12 bass model with thirds and a stop, but I suspect he would say it wasn't possible.
You are exactly right. Here is Mr. Loffet's response to my query about two months ago:
"I already considered to add thirds to the 21+5 - 2 voice Graet e Breizh...
But sorry, it is not possible to add thirds to this model as there is not enough space inside."
-
If he cant fit the thirds in the 12 bass model, how does he fit all the reeds for the 18 bass model?
-
A very good question, Mike!
-
I have to say that this puzzled me too when I bought a GeB from Bernard (now sold on). The 2.5 row, 12 bass GeB is actually larger (28 x 16cms) than, say, a Saltarelle Connemara II (28 x 14cms) and this has 12 basses with thirds and a stop.
I know Bernard did a prototype (or at least a feasibility study) when I pestered him for thirds but was adamant that there was no space.
They are good melodeons though.
Martin
-
I read somewhere that he uses a specially designed bass mechanism. Perhaps that is the explantion.