Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: pete /acorn on April 28, 2010, 07:17:53 PM
-
Hi,
Just an idea,why not use skype to help each other other with tune learning or instrument problems.I use it a lot to keep in touch with Manfrini in Italy .
Pete
-
The only reason I don't use skype is because nobody else I know has ever told me that they are on it. Sounds a good idea Pete.
Chris.
-
I use skype loads - you get me at: glory-hallelujahal
Looking forward to chats & squeezing etc.
AL
-
There are three of us on there now - me , Al and Brian Read.....
Im on as 'ukfolkmusic' would be happy to see any melnetter..
Almo
-
There are three of us on there now - me , Al and Brian Read.....
Im on as 'ukfolkmusic' would be happy to see any melnetter..
Almo
There are still only the three of us...come on folk, don't be shy.
Almo
-
I have no working mic, but I do have a functional webcam, so even if you can't hear me, you can see me. I'm happy for people to add me though. meet_mr_noodle
-
I have no working mic, but I do have a functional webcam, so even if you can't hear me, you can see me. I'm happy for people to add me though. meet_mr_noodle
Added :D
Almo
-
Skype will stop working soon now Microsoft has bought it. :o
-
Skype will stop working soon now Microsoft has bought it. :o
So you're not joining us then Lester ::)
-
Skype will stop working soon now Microsoft has bought it. :o
I don't think they'll keep supporting the linux version of skype. :-\
-
there are, apparently, web chat extensions to this forum available.
https://blueimp.net/ajax/
one example.
Any interest from the mods on this?
-
Any interest from the mods on this?
More to the point, any interest from members?
-
Any interest from the mods on this?
Not from me, to be honest. I use it occasionally for video chats with my folks in Aberdeen so they can see the kids, but that's it.
I would think latency issues would mean it's not suitable for playing in virtual sessions, unless someone knows different.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Live chat boxes on forums do have a tendancy to make the forum threads quiet. IMO
-
Well, I thought it might provide a sort of instant session, which might be quite fun, and I applaud Almo for his enthusiasm. However I'm not yet sure this would work very well, because I suspect there are time delays in the system, so I was waiting to see whether anyone had got the idea going. In terms of general communication, Skype really works best on a 1 to 1 level, I think, so I wouldn't have thought it would compete with melnet much, where the main concept seems to be that of a wider forum - people can dip in and out as they please, but they can find there's usually something going on.
-
Any interest from the mods on this?
Not from me, to be honest. I use it occasionally for video chats with my folks in Aberdeen so they can see the kids, but that's it.
I would think latency issues would mean it's not suitable for playing in virtual sessions, unless someone knows different.
Cheers,
Clive
No, I saw it only as text chat I must admit, I am not sure "live" sessions will work at all unless we are all on 20mbps lines.
-
Well, I thought it might provide a sort of instant session, which might be quite fun, and I applaud Almo for his enthusiasm.
Chris, not so much a session as connection speeds could be an issue, I'm on 20meg Broadband but........
Where I think it's useful, would be for one to one chat and perhaps help with tunes and ideas about playing, and chat is a lot easier that posting notes on a forum as you can easily get a conversation going. Those of us with webcams/ mics would be able to demonstrate and hear what others are doing - I'd love some discussion / demonstration about bass technique to give me a nudge in the right direction. It's ok looking at video or reading dots but it's not as good as being able to question whats being shown.
In addition it's more sociable if you can have a chinwag with someone..
Oh well just a thought...my ideas usually run sideways to everyone else's anyway..
Alan
-
Well, I thought it might provide a sort of instant session, which might be quite fun, and I applaud Almo for his enthusiasm. However I'm not yet sure this would work very well, because I suspect there are time delays in the system, so I was waiting to see whether anyone had got the idea going. In terms of general communication, Skype really works best on a 1 to 1 level, I think, so I wouldn't have thought it would compete with melnet much, where the main concept seems to be that of a wider forum - people can dip in and out as they please, but they can find there's usually something going on.
It would "just" give you someone to text chat to if the moment takes you... :-\ :-\
-
Any interest from the mods on this?
Not from me, to be honest. I use it occasionally for video chats with my folks in Aberdeen so they can see the kids, but that's it.
I would think latency issues would mean it's not suitable for playing in virtual sessions, unless someone knows different.
Cheers,
Clive
No, I saw it only as text chat I must admit, I am not sure "live" sessions will work at all unless we are all on 20mbps lines.
Yes, sorry for the confusion. I meant Skype, not chatboxes. Even with fast broadband, I'm pretty sure the lag would render Skype sessions impractical; I've been doing some recording (with Mixcraft) while listening to what I'm playing in realtime recently; even a lag of 20 milliseconds is too much to my ear. And there's no way Skype sends a video/audio feed across the internet that quick.
Cheers,
Clive
-
No interest in Skype from me, it's rather restrictive software that does nothing unique but comes with asll sorts of issues.
-
No interest in Skype from me, it's rather restrictive software that does nothing unique but comes with asll sorts of issues.
I would prefer an open source alternative. The problem is that the rest of the world doesn't.
-
I've been doing some recording (with Mixcraft) while listening to what I'm playing in realtime recently; even a lag of 20 milliseconds is too much to my ear. And there's no way Skype sends a video/audio feed across the internet that quick.
Cheers,
Clive
Mixcraft - you need to check your settings Clive -Preferences - Sound Device - Sample Rate and Bit Depth. Or if you can select Wave RT - but that might only be an option in Windows 7 :-\
Alan
-
Mixcraft - you need to check your settings Clive -Preferences - Sound Device - Sample Rate and Bit Depth. Or if you can select Wave RT - but that might only be an option in Windows 7 :-\
Alan
[DRIFT]
Yep, I'm running Windows 7, so I can use Wave RT, and with exclusive mode on, I can take the lag all the way down to 10ms (and probably beyond) which sounds great to me. I'm still very impressed with Mixcraft!
Cheers,
Clive
[/DRIFT]
-
Just as a point of interest, I used Skype to give lessons to a Croatian man called Damir who was looking for lessons here a while ago. Speed means you can't play together but it went reasonably well.
-
Yes, I agree. I think that skype could be an excellent tool for sharing and teaching purposes--though a full blown session would be out of the question. It's used by a lot of instrument teachers...
-
My first thought a skype session would be great but then I remembered how slow my internet was.
What if the session was not in real time but a "colab" such as on you tube. For example one of the tune of the month recordings is selected as "leader". Folks then listen and play along using headphones and record their contribution. Recordings are uploaded to a common location and combined. I think I could do this with audio only files but adding video would exceed my computer equipment's abilities.
-
Skype will stop working soon now Microsoft has bought it. :o
I don't think they'll keep supporting the linux version of skype. :-\
And there we go.. just two weeks after the Microsoft takeover we've had major Skype problems with lots of users unable to log in. They released a fix for windows and plan to release one for mac. Linux users will have to fix the problem themselves. No more skype for me I guess.
-
Skype will stop working soon now Microsoft has bought it. :o
I don't think they'll keep supporting the linux version of skype. :-\
And there we go.. just two weeks after the Microsoft takeover we've had major Skype problems with lots of users unable to log in. They released a fix for windows and plan to release one for mac. Linux users will have to fix the problem themselves. No more skype for me I guess.
>:(
-
I was chatting on Skype last night using a webcam/mic and had no problems..
-
Skype will stop working soon now Microsoft has bought it. :o
I don't think they'll keep supporting the linux version of skype. :-\
I've been running the latest version of Ubuntu (Linux) for the past couple of months as an alternative to Windows 7. I won't be using it for much longer, Windows 7 was more stable and more user friendly IMHO. It also goes without saying that there's far more out there for Windows. My parents and both brothers use Macs, they're not for me either although they do look very nice!