Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ellie on April 28, 2010, 10:14:37 PM

Title: Broken foot
Post by: Ellie on April 28, 2010, 10:14:37 PM
I've just noticed that one of the feet has broken off my Saltarelle - along with the bit of wood it was attached it. Luckily it seems to have happened in it's bag, and the missing piece was still in the bag *phew*. Any suggestions as to the best was to reattach it please?

Missing foot: (http://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c146/firebird082/Missingfoot.gif)

Missing piece: (http://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c146/firebird082/Missingpiece.gif)
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 28, 2010, 10:22:28 PM
Ellie,

It should be OK to glue it back with an epoxy glue - especially as it looks like it has a jagged edge to the break which will increase the surface area of the join and help locate it nicely in the correct position.  With any luck it won't need a piece glued across the back to support it, although that would remain an option if you feel it would strengthen it.  But, of course, any extra might interfere with the fit onto the box.

Rob.
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: LJC on April 28, 2010, 10:26:22 PM
Oh, don't use epoxy please! I would go the more natural route and use a good quality specifically made wood glue. As Rob says, looks like a large surface sheer (is it laminate?) which should take the glue well. Wipe off any excess and clamp overnight. Once its dry you could glue a small wooden cleat behind to support the weight. It looks like the bottom corner of the box where there is no mechanism so you shouldn't have any problems with the cleat touching moving parts.
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Ellie on April 28, 2010, 10:31:29 PM
Ok, wood glue. It is the bottom corner, so no problem with air button etc. It's not laminate - looks more like mdf to my (untrained) eye! Rather thin cheap stuff - the foot is definitely the heavy bit. It'll have to wait until after the weekend now though, especially if it needs clamping. Ta!
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 28, 2010, 11:02:33 PM
Enlarging the pics, it looks like 3-ply.  I like epoxy its strong, but any wood glue will most likely hold. 

Rob.
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Andy Simpson on April 29, 2010, 12:22:49 AM
There's no need to clamp that, tape will do and it'll be a lot easier to keep the two pieces where you want them. Just don't use too much glue or the two pieces will slide against eachother. If you do it properly there shouldn't be any further problems or need for reinforcement, it's not under tension.

Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: emrock on April 29, 2010, 12:24:44 AM
best wood glue in my experience is evostick, that would fix it and should be pretty strong
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Theo on April 29, 2010, 12:27:29 AM
..., it's not under tension.

It must be under some sort of excess load or it would not have snapped in the first place!  I'll second LJCs suggestion of some reinforcement on the inside.   If it breaks again you may need to consider replacing the whole flat plate that covers the bass end, preferably with some good quality plywood.
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Andy Simpson on April 29, 2010, 12:44:38 AM
That looks like an impact, which if repeated will just break it again regardless of reinforcement.

The infamous "Gibson headstock repair" that provides guitar repairers the world over with a semi-reliable income where the headstock has sheared off during a fall simply entails gluing and clamping the head back on and then touching up the finish. They hold up fine with the enormous tension of six steel strings, more than any box will ever see, across an area already rendered weak by design and when the same accident happens again it always breaks next to the repair, never in the same place.

Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: theSmoiler on April 29, 2010, 01:08:28 AM
Frankly, I am surprised this has happened at all - particularly if no obvious, very significant trauma has happened to the box, such as it being dropped heavily and knowingly on this side of the bag, on the foot. I'm not aware of having seen it happen in a box before - neither old nor modern (and I've dismantled and cleaned up rather a lot of old Hohner bass endplates in the past). Is this a new box? if so, I would consider the quality of the materials used, and whether they are fit for purpose - having considered, if you think not, then what about taking it back to the shop and questioning whether it's of merchantable quality?

Just my thoughts....

Diane
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on April 29, 2010, 04:12:33 AM
I don't want to worry you, Ellie, but at the recent National Folk Festival in Canberra, Australia, I was shown not one, but two larger Saltarelle models with similar damage.    :o

Upon closer inspection, and after removing the end cover completely, I found further damage to the ledge upon which the end cover sits and is secured to. I think the problem is that the pressure placed upon the feet by the weight of the instrument puts undue strain on that supporting edge which is not well supported itself. I feel that the design of this area is quite poor, and will not withstand much of an impact, or even being put down heavily after use.    >:(

Because of the newness of these instruments I recommended these Australian owners to contact Saltarelle or their supplying retailer. If you find the same has happened to your Saltarelle, Ellie, and I sincerely hope is hasn't, then I would suggest the same course of action.    >:(

Maybe part of the problem is a pet hate of mine, namely gigbags. Very useful as dust covers, but give little protection to the melodeon from impact damage. I use one myself for my "floor" instrument when travelling, but any instrument that I value is transported in a decent and well-padded hard case. My 10c worth....

Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: ganderbox on April 29, 2010, 09:30:44 AM
The Pastourelle II seems very light for a 2.5 row (3.1kg according to the figures I found on the web).
Could it be that they achieve this lightness by using very thin wood?
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: LJC on April 29, 2010, 10:00:53 AM
More to do with the fact its a 2 voice not 3 I would imagine but I've not looked inside one before.
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Ellie on April 29, 2010, 10:20:00 AM
Frankly, I am surprised this has happened at all - particularly if no obvious, very significant trauma has happened to the box, such as it being dropped heavily and knowingly on this side of the bag, on the foot.

This is my issue - I'm not sure when it happened, as I've hardly played in the last week or so, so it's just been sitting around the house, but I'm sure that either I or my housemate would have recalled any impact great enough to cause such damage....

Malcolm - you might be right on the gigbag score - I always use one in preference because it's just SO much easier to carry, but perhaps not so great when it comes to storing it in the house. Lesson learnt, the hard way  :( I'll be taking the hard case to Rochester I think!

I bought it secondhand, so it's about 2 years old now. I've not had any other problems with it in the year I've had it so far, and it regularly gets taken all over the place.
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: Owen Woods on April 29, 2010, 10:25:45 AM
I "saw" the same thing happen in Sidmouth... or rather I saw the results of it. I found a Saltarelle foot from a black finish box in the Ship during a session. We put it on a table in a conspicuous place and hoped that whoever it was thought to come back and look...
Title: Re: Broken foot
Post by: pete /acorn on April 29, 2010, 06:18:06 PM
Hi,
Looking at the damage I wouldnt try to repair it,if you want to send the plate I can make a new one for you,if you contact me and let me know size I will give you a quote,I would also ,if there is room fix a  small block in each corner with a recess for the screw holding the foot,
01347 824831

Pete
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal