Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: mber on March 19, 2008, 11:27:59 PM
-
Hi guys.
I'm teaching my mom, who is 82 (and kicking), to play 2 row accordion.
She is doing OK, I guess the main problem is me, who must find time to come to her appartment regularly and dedicate one hour to teaching, and minor problem of her having trouble with fast push-pulling.
I gave her Hohner Pokerwork in A/D, which has beautiful sound and rather fast action. I fixed some shoes to the buttons, so they don't travel in much, and repadded all palletts, so it's quiet. However, it became a bit slowish and still, a Hohner is not your fastest.
So I was thinking to give her some light and fast good quality one.
The Button Box had some selection and I ordered Lilly. To my surprize the Lilly had very stiff bellows, so it went back to the shop. Next one was Guerrini with 3 voices. We called it "Elvis" for it's kitchy appearance. Great sound, super easy bellows, but very tough action, esp. on the "peggy" basses. So it too, went back.
Now I have a choice: either to keep looking, or to order my A/D overhauled. I would really want her to have some top notch instrument, but she said she better likes the lever action on Hohner air valve.
Are there fast, light and easy ones with Hohner type lever for air valve?
Help me out.
Thanks.
-
Why not get a secondhand Lily? Is it possible the bellows were quite stiff because the instrument was new? They are small, light, powerful, open keyboard, fast action, and the bellows shold be easier with age.
Dino Baffetti Black pearl boxes have a fast right hand and bellows, though the left hand can sometimes be slower so it's worth checking.
You could get a smaller Hohner, like a Liliput or Preciosa, but if the size isn't the problem, then you may as well get the pokerwork overhauled.
Just a few ideas.
James
-
Hohner Morgane. Small, lightweight, easy to play. Rather inexpensive compared to comparable italian boxes.
-
Why not try a reconditioned Lilliput or Presciosa. Small, lightweight and fun to play. Bellows would be well played in too ;D
-
I'd Agree with Daryl, the little boxes are great: light, fast, bright . . . . and so on. A couple of years ago I met a 85 year old German guy at a sausage festival who was happily banging away on an old Corona. He said he preferred the Hohner three-row because it was so light, and he could cross rows a lot of the time, and so didn't have to do a lot of bellows reversals. He'd only been playing for a couple of years, but was doing pretty well, and obviously having a lot of fun.
And three cheers to your mum for having a go!
-
Thank you all. All great suggestions.
Let's see:
Morgana and all the family are looking great, but are made in China, so probably a bit slow and quiet.
Liliputs and Preciosa are new to me. I have never tried them and am very curious. My mom has biggish hands, so smallish keyboard of Lilly, Liliput and Preciosa may not do. The size is not a problem, Pokerwork is small enough. So I guess your suggestion of overhaul is a good one.
Any recommendations of where I can order this to be done sooner than in 6 weeks?
Thanks.
Oh yes, my mom sends quadrupple cheers back.
Three row would be too bulky. I know Coronas well enough. They are great instruments, a but ugly perhaps, but very well made (old ones). I'm teaching her to do cross row fingering on a two row to avoid push/pulling. But a three row will add too much patterns to remember, I think. But I'll think about it some more.
I even thought of getting her a uni-sonoric one, like Russian Tula accordions or German Router or Rounter.
But couldn't locate any.
-
Thank you all. All great suggestions.
Let's see:
Morgana and all the family are looking great, but are made in China, so probably a bit slow and quiet.
The Morgane is not made in China, and is not quiet! It is actually louder than my Corona II!
-
The Morgane is not made in China, and is not quiet! It is actually louder than my Corona II!
I've looked on the Hohner website and failed to find any clear statement of where the Morgane is made. They do state clearly on the US website that the Corona II Supreme and the Gola PA are made in Germany, but the description of the Morgane is silent on its origin. Inconclusive I know, but I'm surprised they don't publicise the origin if it is indeed made in Germany.
Based on a detailed examination of a Morgane compared to a Chinese built Pokerwork I observed that many of the components, such as reeds, reedblocks and mechanical parts look identical. The reeds I saw were Hohner 'T' reeds which are now made in China. My guess is that the Morgane has been developed in Europe using Chinese components where these are suitable, and who knows they may still be assembled in Europe.
The one example I tried had a good volume of sound, but I'd not have described it as loud.
-
Morgana and all the family are looking great, but are made in China, so probably a bit slow and quiet.
Hmm, is that a general characteristic of things made in China? I'm under the impression that Chinese factories are quite capable of building anything the client specifies. Don't underestimate them. Like the Japanese they will probably end up showing us the way.
Just a comment on stiff Lilly bellows. They do free up with playing.
Roy (Lilly, Tommy and Max in the household).
-
My first two row was Chinese made Parrot, replica or Erica. Actually a good instrument (after some tweaking and tuning). But real old Hohner is unbeatable so far, even by today's Weltmeister.
Chinese made Panther was an embodiment of sorrow in comparison to it's rivals from Erica and Weltmeister's Monica (not sure). Since Hohner's move to China was to cut costs, not to fetch professionals, I doubt they will show anything except more or less successful replications, but I'd be not against been wrong.
But I'm tired of cheap instruments, I have a handfull at home. They are good to work on and practice repair skills, but I'd like to lay my hands on something more valualble. And besides Morgane, there are the whole spectrum, nobody is talking about. Have you seen the whole family?
-
And besides Morgane, there are the whole spectrum, nobody is talking about. Have you seen the whole family?
Do you mean the Hohner family? Most of their boxes are now Chinese-made! But the quality is usually better than other Chinese-made boxes bearing imitations of Italian brand names.
Remember the old adage: you get what you pay for!
Your best best bet might be to locate a German-made or Italian-made second-hand box. Some are for sale on this forum!
-
They do state clearly on the US website that the Corona II Supreme and the Gola PA are made in Germany, but the description of the Morgane is silent on its origin.
Someone should ask Hohner to stop the speculation. But now that I still have the chance to speculate :) my wild guess is that parts - or most of them - are made somewhere else but in Germany. However, old, even prewar Erika design concepts are used, starting from the reed blocks. Here's little more to the speculation, how does this tag connect the manufacturing with Trossingen, if at all? This is the Morgane tag:
http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Tag.jpg (http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Tag.jpg)
PS. Manufactured in Hohner factory outside Germany, final quality control done in Trossingen, Germany???
EDIT: typos etc...
-
Funny that you bring this up, because I also retrieved the tag that came with my Morgane to check this out. It has the exact same handwriting than yours, so it was the same person who did the quality control in the same factory.
-
... It has the exact same handwriting than yours, so it was the same person who did the quality control in the same factory.
At first glance the text on the first row looks suspicious, but it actually reads F06435, same number is printed under the grille. There is no mention of China anywhere, not in the instrument or the case or the cardboard box it was shipped in. I have products of known western brands with an honest made in china label. I wonder if they could use a tag like that with the German address if the quality control was done somewhere else ...
-
Well, as we say in French: "Dans le doute, abstiens-toi", loosely translated as "when in doubt, don't speculate"...
No matter where the fabrication and assembly takes place, the Morgane is still an excellent box for the price, easy to play, with a stunning looks, sturdy construction despite a few disappointing details like the aluminium keyboard plate with sticky-back plastic. We can now get it in Canada for less than CAD 800, which beats any other box of that style.