Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: tedrick on May 08, 2010, 12:45:27 PM

Title: watch the buttons?
Post by: tedrick on May 08, 2010, 12:45:27 PM
Curious to see the groups response here - I almost never look at my fingers or the buttons - it usually causes me to goof up -

Recently though, I've noticed if I watch what I'm doing I can do ornaments a little better if I look at the buttons instead of trying to do it by feel --

What is the groups experience/opinion?

Thanks,
Reed
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 08, 2010, 01:59:09 PM
I've learned to play main rows by touch.   Fancy scales, or fingering say an F natural in a G tune I tend to look. Of recent years I've tried to do it 'proprioceptively' but if I'm not on one of the mainline scales that can be a bit dangerous! On balance I think I look, unless I feel I'm on very solid ground. Not sure it makes any difference for ornaments though. Are they in any way different from tune and variation?

.. do use all 4 fingers both hand though!
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Owen Woods on May 08, 2010, 02:04:04 PM
Never. Or at least, sometimes I do just to look, as I tend to think "what the hell is my hand doing?". I know all the buttons by touch, if I do look at my hand I don't actually know what it's doing, so there is no real point.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Theo on May 08, 2010, 02:34:18 PM
Never,  I want to be in eye contact with my fellow players, or the audience/dancers.   

A secondary reason is that if I lean forward, and tilt the box back so that I can see the buttons, then my left hand and arm are in awkward position for playing, its not great for the right either.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: ganderbox on May 08, 2010, 02:53:04 PM
Playing a tune I know well at home, never look. Playing a tricky tune out in public, often look.
Also look when there are difficult bits, big jumps up or down the keyboard (in case I miss!) or playing in odd keys etc.
Playing for dancing, ceilidhs etc, I look as little as possible as it's more important to watch what's going on around me and, as Theo says, you tend to get a better playing position when you aren't hunched over your box looking at the keyboard.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Rob2Hook on May 08, 2010, 03:09:01 PM
Why look?  They all look the same!

Rob.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Howard Jones on May 08, 2010, 03:10:11 PM
Hardly ever.  I'll sometimes look if I'm making an awkward leap to one of the top accidental buttons, but otherwise not.  I don't find looking helps that much anyway - unlike a piano keyboard, the buttons all look the same so it's not easy to pick out a particular button. Much better to practice the move and rely on muscle memory.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Andrel on May 08, 2010, 03:41:14 PM
  I never look. Question of vanity. My fingers look fat on the buttons  :D
  Seriously, one thing that has really helped me is the little screw on my Gaillard, near the A on the outside row. It's my anchor. I feel it and I can go anywhere from there... I works very well with my system. (D/C#).
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on May 08, 2010, 04:11:15 PM
Sometimes when I'm learning a tune but then I get a very nasty crick in my neck that won't go away so I try not to do it.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: forrest on May 08, 2010, 04:19:04 PM
Only when learning, or working out a difficult passage. Performing, never.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 08, 2010, 04:19:17 PM
 Seriously, one thing that has really helped me is the little screw on my Gaillard, near the A on the outside row. It's my anchor. I feel it and I can go anywhere from there... I works very well with my system. (D/C#).

I know it well. The adjacent key pulls a G on my Gaillard, and  D on the Oakwood. I like the tininess of the screw head in both cases - appearently the uninitiated think we  pull the notes out of a sea of little identical black buttons.

Well, how wrong they are  ;)
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: NeilA on May 08, 2010, 04:38:16 PM
I'm just not used to looking at them when I'm playing but does help sometimes when starting a tune. I'm also trying to listen more to bass end while I'm playing Watching treble end while listening to basses would totally mess me up.

Neil
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Marje on May 08, 2010, 04:49:15 PM
I never watch the buttons. Now and again if I'm trying something new and keep getting to wrong, I have a look at what my fingers are doing (or failing to do) and I'm generally quite surprised to see where the buttons are in relation to each other. I play by feeling for the distance and postion of the buttons, and what I see doesn't always correspond with where I feel the notes to be, it just confuses me. Same applies to the fingering - if I stop to think about which finger is doing what, it just makes me go wrong.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 08, 2010, 05:06:22 PM
Tend to watch the fingers when working through a new tune which requires some specific fingering, particularly cross-row stuff. After that, they are on their own!

Andy
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: LJC on May 08, 2010, 05:49:59 PM
I never look, but I ALWAYS listen!
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 09, 2010, 04:22:16 PM
Well, I NEED to see where my fingers are to go (but I intend to do something about this problem.)  :|bl
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 09, 2010, 04:45:58 PM
.
If proof were needed - here's Yours Truly (another Chris) playing with Christophe (another Chris) somewhere in central France.  As you can see - deep contemplation of my manicure is in progress  :-\  

Though to be fair - from somewhat vague memory and the position of my hands - I think Christophe was improvising in F

[edit] Thanks JB!  This is a trimmed down version for the Web. The original B/W on my wall is an absolutely beautifully composed image - of course not taken by me! 
  (http://www.chrisryall.net/chris-chris.jpg) (http://www.chrisryall.net/chris-chris.jpg)

Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Bill Young on May 09, 2010, 07:44:33 PM
Why does this poll remind me of "H.M.S. Pinafore"?

"What, never?"
"No, never!"
"What, never?"
"Well, hardly ever!"
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: brianread on May 09, 2010, 08:45:35 PM
Just about never. 

A (good) piano player once looked at quizzically and said - "How can you play if you can't see where the notes are?".

As Theo says, looking at the other players, the dancers, the television on the other side of the pub, the audience (especially the pretty ones), anything but the fingers - I suspect if i did I'd think too hard and go even more wrong!
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Theo on May 09, 2010, 11:49:29 PM
When I'm practicing at home I like to look out of the window and watch the birds as I play.  If they all fly off I know I need more practice.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: GbH on May 10, 2010, 12:40:37 AM
Why look?  They all look the same!

Rob.

Not necessarily!  I admit that getting the moustache pattern put on my buttons was really just a bit of sillyness, but having different coloured buttons does come in useful if I need to quickly locate a starting button.  This is particularly so if I'm starting a tune higher up the keyboard.  It's probably true that my fingers would most likely find the right place anyway, but the visual double-check can be very welcome if I'm playing to someone else.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Anahata on May 10, 2010, 08:42:27 AM
A (good) piano player once looked at quizzically and said - "How can you play if you can't see where the notes are?".
A good piano player who reads music can't be looking at the keys much, but you need to look once at the beginning to get your bearings, as it were. I wonder if that's the reason why melodeon players often stab at random notes before starting a tune, in order to find the first note. Coming from a classical background (where you *never* do that) I particularly noticed this in my early days of observing folk music.
Quote
As Theo says, looking at the other players, the dancers, the television on the other side of the pub, the audience (especially the pretty ones), anything but the fingers - I suspect if i did I'd think too hard and go even more wrong!
Most of the above in a session or a ceilidh (good looking dancers can be a dangerous distraction from hand signals from the caller), but If I'm performing in front of a listening audience I stare into some neutral point on the floor - people's faces can be too distracting and I don't want to lose concentration.

But never at the buttons, except occasionally to find the first note without audible faff referred to above.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Howard Jones on May 10, 2010, 10:34:34 AM
I wonder if that's the reason why melodeon players often stab at random notes before starting a tune, in order to find the first note. Coming from a classical background (where you *never* do that) I particularly noticed this in my early days of observing folk music.

A classical player will know what note they're starting with, because it's on the score in front of them, and they'll know where to find that note on the instrument, because they've learned it that way.  For folk musicians, neither of these may apply.  As an ear player, I don't always know which named note a tune starts on, and I probably couldn't find it on the keyboard anyway, but I know what it sounds like.  A quick noodle  - preferably with the sound muted - helps me to check I'm starting in the right place.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Howard Jones on May 10, 2010, 10:42:07 AM
Slightly off-topic, but related - I once worked with a blind secretary, who would take dictation using a stenography machine which produced a paper tape with braille, and he would then touch-type it (this in the days before word-processors).

One lunchtime we'd all been in the pub  :|glug, and that afternoon he lost his "home position" on the typewriter keyboard, with some interesting but incomprehensible results.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: george garside on May 10, 2010, 10:56:25 AM
[quote  .  As an ear player, I don't always know which named note a tune starts on, and I probably couldn't find it on the keyboard anyway, but I know what it sounds like.  A quick noodle  - preferably with the sound muted - helps me to check I'm starting in the right place.
[/quot

on some of Jimmy Shands  78rpm recordings (i.e. not digitally arsed about with)  you can just about hear him play a quick 3 notes which I have always assumed  was to ckeck that he was starting in the right place.  On the 3 row I often check for general finger location by playing a quick  cde across the 3 rows - this establishes that 2nd finger is on D from where it is easy to locate other notes.
on 3rd button doh DG box I sometimes locate doh by putting fingers 123 on ist 3 buttons then swapping fingr 1 with finger 3 so finger 1 is on doh whereafter all is apparent!
george
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on May 10, 2010, 11:45:33 AM
Me too George  :D . My Trichord used to have three black "locator" buttons (BCC#) half way down the board - like on a Black Dot, 'cept one per row. I recently got Theo to replace them with white ones, to match the rest. Once you've got your start position, they're not going to move, are they? Those black buttons were cross-hatched  :( and felt nasty anyway. BLT.
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Owen Woods on May 10, 2010, 12:08:46 PM
A good piano player who reads music can't be looking at the keys much, but you need to look once at the beginning to get your bearings, as it were. I wonder if that's the reason why melodeon players often stab at random notes before starting a tune, in order to find the first note. Coming from a classical background (where you *never* do that) I particularly noticed this in my early days of observing folk music.

That's why I do it :D
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: seinegydd on May 10, 2010, 03:38:29 PM
I've just checked by watching a video of myself playing. No, I don't look at the buttons at all! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4iKbdSmras
Title: Re: watch the buttons?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 11, 2010, 12:18:55 AM
When I first started, I put red dots on all the octaves of D & G, the dots are still there, but I just don't look at them as much now I am an Improver.  :||:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal