Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Just4Fun on May 10, 2010, 12:57:19 PM

Title: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on May 10, 2010, 12:57:19 PM
I sold my sole to the devil four months ago and bought my first box. So now I've crawled out from under my rock and made a video. Won't be booking the Albert Hall just yet but any advice would be more than welcome. >:E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsS9RiT14e8
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: xgx on May 10, 2010, 01:23:59 PM
4 months !!  you've put a fair bit of work in to get that far in that time... cracking start ;)

Have you thought about the Button box course on the Isle of Skye in July ...quite a trek from your locale...
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on May 10, 2010, 01:40:27 PM
Thank you xgx for the encouragement. Unfortunately July won't be a good time for me but I would love to do something similar at another time. Worried that B/C might make me a bit of a Pariah at these courses!
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Owen Woods on May 10, 2010, 02:04:17 PM
4 months !!  you've put a fair bit of work in to get that far in that time... cracking start ;)

Have you thought about the Button box course on the Isle of Skye in July ...quite a trek from your locale...

I got all excited about that, but irritatingly it is the week after HebCelt, not before. I am sailing around the inner Hebrides that week :P
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: xgx on May 10, 2010, 02:14:06 PM
J4F ...the button box course is B/C

Watch out for Graeme Mackay's Aviemore course offerings!! 

Bert... thought about doing the hebcelt fest and then on to Skye but with a 7m motorhome and the current anti motohome views on the Islands decided against.  Shove and old melodeon on the mast head so that I can spot you and give you a wave ;D

Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: juker on May 10, 2010, 09:44:03 PM
Nice tune J4F, you are doing very well (:)
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: GbH on May 10, 2010, 10:15:48 PM
It's good to see a solo B/C vido posted, with basses used to.  It doesn't seem to happen here as often as I might have expected.  I don't know anything about playing that system, but it sounds as if you're well on you're way with it.  Thanks.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: zubz on May 10, 2010, 11:44:15 PM
J4F that's a lovely piece and very well played.
I look forward to hearing more over the months to come.
It's not only good for you, I would think it's good for everyone trying to improve their skills on this tricky instrument. Thanks for posting.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on May 11, 2010, 01:42:08 PM
Here's another attempt. Working on a bass.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCLD_4fTNm0
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on May 11, 2010, 10:12:10 PM
B/C is good, 2/3 of a BCC#  :D BLT.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on May 11, 2010, 10:30:20 PM
BC seems hard enough. Add another row and I'd start having nihjtmares >:E
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Pete Dunk on May 11, 2010, 11:36:32 PM
Won't be booking the Albert Hall just yet but any advice would be more than welcome. >:E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsS9RiT14e8

My best advice is to keep at it, you're doing fine, very well in fact. Has anyone mentioned yet that you may be subject to a serious malady known as MAD if you continue in this vein?

Pete  ;D
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on July 07, 2010, 03:09:40 PM
It's a few weeks further down the line and I thought I'd have a go at something a bit more English. I've got to admit that having bought 'Hardcore English' and various other English CD's I'm becoming totally hooked. Trouble is I play B/C and it's been a lot of work starting to learn this system. Can I persevere with B/C or if I'm going to plonk for English rather than Celtic should I bight the bullet and change. Words of wisdom (and encouragement) hugely appreciated.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntAzIHjSEp0
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 07, 2010, 04:58:50 PM
It's a few weeks further down the line and I thought I'd have a go at something a bit more English. I've got to admit that having bought 'Hardcore English' and various other English CD's I'm becoming totally hooked. Trouble is I play B/C and it's been a lot of work starting to learn this system. Can I persevere with B/C or if I'm going to plonk for English rather than Celtic should I bight the bullet and change. Words of wisdom (and encouragement) hugely appreciated.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntAzIHjSEp0
Nicely played!
However, a tune like that polka would work far better on a two-row quad-box (i.e. a D/G) as the basses and the bellows movement would give you much more automatic rhythmic drive. You could get a similar effect on your B/C by playing the tune in C on the C-row only and treating it as if it were a one-row. But if you want to play tunes in G or D - to fit in with other players perhaps - then maybe you should consider trying a D/G box. Any chance you could borrow one for a while to try out and see whether you can get used to it (I don't think you'd have much trouble)?
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on July 08, 2010, 01:38:41 PM
Thanks Steve,
That's rather the suggestion I was hoping not to get but exactly what I was expecting. Basically I've started learning on the wrong system so I'll just have to accept the fact and change. Anyone want to buy an Excelsior Shannon (B/C!!!!) almost new? Or for that matter a black dot with lowered action and other bits done to improve it (B/C!!!!!!!!!).
You mention D/G 'quad-box'. I apologise for my profound ignorance but what is a quad-box. I really do need to get my next investment right!
Your time and wisdom is much appreciated.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 08, 2010, 02:20:22 PM
You mention D/G 'quad-box'. I apologise for my profound ignorance but what is a quad-box.
I call it a quad-box, because I think that is the correct terminology, but many here will call it a quint-box. But we mean the same thing: A two-row instrument where the inner, higher, row is tuned a fourth (hence quad) above the outer, deeper, row.

Convention is to quote the key of the outer row before the inner row, so - D/G, C/F, G/C, etc.  And as musical intervals are normally described ascending from the lower note to the higher note, D to G is a fourth, not a fifth.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on July 08, 2010, 03:16:14 PM
Thanks for that Steve, I really do appreciate it. One final question and then I'll leave you in peace: Since so many English folk tunes seem to be in either D or G am I right in thinking that by buying a D/G my options would be widest and also that, having learnt on one quad, the fingering on any other would be the same albeit the outcome would be in a different key?
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Gandy on July 08, 2010, 03:24:19 PM
That's correct for both treble and bass.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 08, 2010, 04:25:42 PM
Thanks for that Steve, I really do appreciate it. One final question and then I'll leave you in peace: Since so many English folk tunes seem to be in either D or G am I right in thinking that by buying a D/G my options would be widest ...
Yes - a D/G box would give you the widest set of options to begin with, and many top-rate players use nothing else. However, in East Anglia, there is a lot of interest in playing in C, often on a one-row four-stop instrument or a two-row in C/F, and that appears to be spreading very slowly to some other parts of England. To some extent, this is a bit of a revival movement, as the D/G instrument didn't become popular until the 1950s, and the key of C is rather nice to play in, having a definite mellowness about it. But don't worry about that too much for now; a D/G box will do you very well indeed.

Quote
.... and also that, having learnt on one quad, the fingering on any other would be the same albeit the outcome would be in a different key?
Yes - as Tony said in the previous post.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Theo on July 08, 2010, 06:22:33 PM
Trouble is I play B/C and it's been a lot of work starting to learn this system. Can I persevere with B/C or if I'm going to plonk for English rather than Celtic should I bite the bullet and change.

I think it depends on how much of an individualist you are.   I can't see any reason to not learn English tunes on a B/C box,  though they will tend to have a different feel to them.  And there is a load of older English material that people are discovering in archives and they include many tunes in keys that would not sit easily on a D/G, or might even not be possible.  The ultimate English trad box player must be John Kirkpatrick who plays mostly on a B/C/C# which is just a B/C with one extra row. If you persevere with the B/C you will be in a good position to move on to B/C/C# in a year or two, and you won't have to discard the learning you have done so far.

You can also play East Anglian material in C on your C row.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 08, 2010, 08:40:22 PM
Quote
Can I persevere with B/C


Yup - stick with it - you've made a good start so it'd be a shame to junk it all and go back to square one again. And as Theo says - you'll find it very useful indeed when suddenly a fiddle player breaks out into a tune in F (btw loads of Morris Tunes in Bacon's 'Black Book' are in keys other than D,G, or A) and you'll be the only melodeon player able to jam along. Also, you'll be half-way to a BCC# box which the great JK plays - and Jimmy Shand didn't do a bad job on it either (and his recording of English Country Dance tunes is epic!). A B/C is a brilliant box - superb for all kinds of music - and finally: you qualify for graememackay's button box workshop at Aviemore & Inverness this year as well! Couldn't be better!
Regards
AL
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: GbH on July 08, 2010, 09:44:10 PM
When considering the sort of instrument you want to learn, shouldn't the main factor be the type and style of music you want to make?  To my ears, B/C box playing sounds fundamentally different from D/G playing, with a stradella B/C/C# being different again.  Different stilll are the 4-stop one-rows and, of course, the 2.5/3 row dependent continental style is not really going to happen on a 2-rwo Pokerwork. 

So, if you already know what sort of music and sound you want to achieve, I don't really see the reason why you'd want to be learning an instrument that does something different to that.
Title: Re: Newbie having a go
Post by: Just4Fun on July 08, 2010, 09:56:45 PM
GbH. Such words of wisdom. With all the kind words of advice that were being offered my head was starting to spin but your sound logic has helped put things very much in perspective. Many thanks. :Ph
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal