Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: melodeon on May 11, 2010, 04:38:23 PM

Title: New Box Tuning Tolerance.
Post by: melodeon on May 11, 2010, 04:38:23 PM
Lets say you just received a new Italian made box. Looks good and plays well.

Just how far off  of dead on tuning is acceptable.

I'll once again refer to a miserable Castagnari Mory I bought new many years ago. A total mess and no reed of reference owing to the
worst tuning job on a Castagnari I had ever heard. Far worse than Hohner's "almost tuning".
But let's say the box you got is not bad...   
but:
anywhere from 1 - 3 cents off dead on tuning..
an example would be two same octave A's on different rows.. one dead on the other at 3 cents high .
or a couple G's
Some notes off 2 cents.. some exact... others 1 cent and so on.
In only one case could I actually hear the difference.

Overall a rather nice sound but not really an exact tuning.

So what is tolerance for an expensive Italian accordeon ..and are these variances acceptable and of no consequence.

Again without checking it with a tuner only one note seemed a bit off.. not off to listeners, and not annoying to me.. but a tad off.

Jusr curious what your opinion might be.
Title: Re: New Box Tuning Tolerance.
Post by: HallelujahAl on May 11, 2010, 04:47:25 PM
Quote
Just how far off  of dead on tuning is acceptable.

Zero
Title: Re: New Box Tuning Tolerance.
Post by: pete /acorn on May 11, 2010, 06:19:52 PM
Hi,

Re tuning,when you order reeds from manufacturer you specify tuning required then after fitting into reed blocks they are fine tuned,or should be before packaging and dispatch,if for some reason this final adjustment is missed thenthis can cause that problem,also temperature will make a slight difference,also did you let box acclimatise before you checked the reeds,

Also you may not be aware that A Mano reeds require a bedding in period of say 8 - 10 months then tuning should be checked,during that time they alter a fair bit.

With regard to the accordions I sell a free service and tune after 2 years is available to allow for this,we allow 2 years because not everyone uses their boxes the same.

Pete
Acorn instruments
Title: Re: New Box Tuning Tolerance.
Post by: Mike Averill on May 11, 2010, 06:22:48 PM

In only one case could I actually hear the difference.

Overall a rather nice sound but not really an exact tuning.


I think you answered your own question. If you could only hear the one difference then the next smallest error defines an acceptable tolerance.

The most important aspects of tunings are octaves that dont beat if its single reed or dry tuned and a smooth progression in the beat on wet tunings as you progress up the scale.

Modern equal temperament tuning is a huge compromise any way so no need to get  hung up over the odd cent. Chords  will always have imperfections.
Title: Re: New Box Tuning Tolerance.
Post by: forrest on May 15, 2010, 10:55:22 PM
    An interesting thread. It also may show that tuning can shift, either subtly, or suddenly. When a brand-new box comes off the line and is bench tuned for shipping, it may leave the bench spot on, and arrive weeks later after much transport into entirely different climate(s), sit on a shelf, be tried out by customers, etc. I would not expect it to remain "spot-on". I also think that factory tuning is just that...it is good to work through a dealer who will sweeten or adjust tuning before final delivery.
     One thing I have experienced, is that my boxes never sound best when first played that day. Sometimes I used to think I needed to "touch up" a reed or two, but after playing for 15 minutes or more, the reeds seem to fall in with one another and the box "sweetens up". Of course, all of my instruments are old and cheap, not new or expensive. Now, whenever I decide to adjust the tuning of a reed, I only do so after the box has been played hard for at least a half hour or so, and still seems a bit off.    :||:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal