Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Banjo Ray on May 12, 2010, 12:45:58 AM
-
Greetings all,
Brand new newbie here. Just putting me toe in the melodeon water so to speak.
I am a morris man from years back and a fairly competent banjo and guitar player. I have recently had a hankering to play the melodeon after tinkering around with one many, many years ago. I'm hoping that eventually I can play along with my daughter on fiddle. My interests are English folk dances mostly. My question is this - I know from banjo playing that the favoured keys for a fiddle are A and D, I think because of the ability to play double-stops. So which tuning for a melodeon is best for a beginner, into English morris and wanting to play with a fiddle? Should I get a typical D/G and should the fiddle player learn to play in different keys?
I hope that question isnt too complicated.
Ta
Ray
-
The ubiquitous melodeon for morris/English sessions is in D/G with heavy bias towards the G row. So looks like a bit of work for your daughter ;)
-
With current prices the A/D/G Hohner Compadre offers lots of possibilities ... I just happen to have one surplus to requirements ;D
-
The
UK English standard box is certainly the D/G and you'll cut yourself out of sessions if you take alternative keys. Playing in A on it is certainly possible. You just practice up a different pattern of pull/push up the keyboard, and cross row a bit.
The problem is its G# note. This is usually supplied as an 'accidental' at the head end of the instument. Depending on the tune you may find the one available is in the wrong octave. You can fudge through or simply miss it out - but sometimes that matters to the melody. If you play a brazen G pull on the outside row, that's a minor 7 and sounds 'Cajun'. Not always what morris dancers prefer!
Left hand chords in A are useful, particularly if you can take the middle G note out of your Em - same reason as above. So a lever or pull rod to do this might be worth the extra ££. Or you could 'customise' and tape out the G reed - at the expense of a weaker E minor when playing in that key.
You might also consider an A/D/G three row. More money, but a lot less cumbersome than two separate boxes.
Finally there is the 'half tone' box. Others will give better advice but a B/C or C/C# will play all the keys you need - IMHO at the expense of a weaker chord structure. Again a 3 row eg B/C/C# overcomes this aspect.
Coming from the instruments you mention, I suspect your brain might tend to think of music 'in chords' and so you might move most easily in the D/G (or A/D/G) direction. Get to a good dealer and mess about a bit. You'll get good advice, and comfort with your chosen instrument is important.
[edit] I see xgx just beat me in! An big advantage of getting a second hand box is that if it doesn't work - you can generally sell on at minimal loss. But I think the advice to get to a dealer and 'experiment' still stands (and they may make you an offer you can't refuse)!
-
The UK standard box is certainly the D/G . . .
I think you mean "English" (and possibly Welsh, but who's counting?). I know there are a few in Scotland, but relatively rare (I've yet to encounter one), and I'd be surprised if they're all that prevalent in Northern Ireland.
-
The D/G melodeon was introduced and popularised in the 1950's precisely because it was compatible with fiddles.
Fiddles are perfectly happy in G, which is a much a natural key for the fiddle as any. There's no 3rd finger stretches in that key, for example.
Playing in A suits certain fiddle styles, like American with lots of open string drones, and a lot of Scottish music in in A but that may be due to the influence of pipes.
-
No stats to hand, but common session and dance tunes in England? I'd reckon something like 80%+ are D & G.
-
The UK standard box is certainly the D/G . . .
I think you mean "English" (and possibly Welsh, but who's counting?). I know there are a few in Scotland, but relatively rare (I've yet to encounter one), and I'd be surprised if they're all that prevalent in Northern Ireland.
Opps! sorry!
-
I think the reason so many are in D or G now days is because of the melodeon. Chicken or the egg syndrome!
-
In my experience of irish fiddle music the most common scales are D G A, in that order. There are many historical reasons but I don't think conforming to melodeons/accordions is one of them.
-
I ;think its more a case of Dg being popular in England rather than Dg being popular for Englich music( which it probably also is!) I have lead sesssions of over 150 players without straying from D & G and have never had a complaint about choice of keys. Tunes 'normallyu' written in A work quite well in G although I readily admit that they sound a bit nicer in A. - however D &g suites the DG boxes! & doesn't trouble the fiddlers, although the one rowists in C may be somewhat buggered.
george
-
Should I get a typical D/G and should the fiddle player learn to play in different keys?
My nine year-old daughter plays fiddle (currently just taking her grade two so not that far advanced yet) -and her favourite keys are D major, Gmajor, E minor, & A major in that order of preference. We've just had an 'after tea and before homework' practice session where she played 'Lord Lovat's Lament' (G), 'Oyster Girl' (G), and 'Finlay is his father's darling' (D) and 'Rakes of Mallow' (G). The reason most fiddlers prefer playing in D,A &G is that they are easy keys for fingering purposes - nothing really to do with double stops. So you'll have no probs with a D/G box. Hope this helps. AL
-
The reason most fiddlers prefer playing in D,A &G is that they are easy keys for fingering purposes - nothing really to do with double stops.
Ray referred to double-stops as being a reason why fiddlers like the key of A and D. I would say that, as far as fiddlers (American, Scots and Irish to a lesser extent) are concerned (rather than violinists), he's right, except that the effects he are talking about aren't double stops at all, but merely open strings used as drones or pedals.
There is a bit less opportunity for this kind of thing in the key of G. But Al is right too, G is a nice easy key on the fiddle, don't worry about that.
Double-stopping (which by definition cannot involve open strings) is another kettle of fish altogether. (Most fiddlers will play the odd double-stopped chord, or hold down fingers on two strings for "rocking pedal" figures, but practically nobody in the traditions I mentioned makes any greater use of true double-stopping, except in the upper echelons of bluegrass fiddling.)
-
As a relative newcomer to fiddle playing I think Steve has hit the nail on the head. And it goes further, it's not just playing drones etc on the open strings it's the resonance effects that the open strings give that help to create the big ringing sound that is a feature of many trad styles of fiddle. It is possible to get resonance with stopped strings, but it's much harder to do and much less dramatic in sound.
-
I've been fiddling for a few years now. The D/G choice is simple - you only need to use one fingering shape and just use different strings. C can also be played in the same shape, though this is possibly only helpful in East Anglia! :|glug
-
I've been fiddling for a few years now. The D/G choice is simple - you only need to use one fingering shape and just use different strings. C can also be played in the same shape, though this is possibly only helpful in East Anglia! :|glug
One note drone with melodeone (i.e. pete coe hiding below the droner) on Broghton patented method a done.
Remember this example of how to produce so much from so little? Play it in Realtek Arena setting for full depth effect of drone :||: :|||:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKALZC3FXOc
-
Thanks for all the replies - what a helpful and knowledgeable bunch you are.
Steve is right, its not "double-stops" but the open-string drones and the sympathetic ringing of the open strings that particularly flavours old-time US fiddle music (which is derived from Irish/Scots/English music of course - many of the tunes are the same), and although a fair number of tunes are in G or even C, I thinks its fair to say most are in A or D and for this reason many old-time banjo players like me, capo-up to A almost permanently or play a short-scale banjo.
Anyways it looks like D/G is the way to go- thanks again for your help.
Ray
-
A number of old-time fiddlers retune the fiddle to give more open-string opportunities - the guy I play with has fiddles tuned GDGD and ADAD as well as GDAE. We play a fair mix of G, D and A as keys (I play backup guitar and PA).
-
I think the reason so many are in D or G now days is because of the melodeon. Chicken or the egg syndrome!
Indeed. Tunes in F or Bb do seem to crop up in old tunebooks... and there's a fair deal of lush stuff I've come across in G or D minor for that matter. 8)
Which is kind of why I sometimes regard the ol' D/G as a bit of a musical truss... and why I developed a penchant for mutant contraptions...
But a 'straight' D/G's good enough for most things. Good and light too.
Get one... work out what works... what doesn't... and go from there...
Ed J
-
I think the reason so many are in D or G now days is because of the melodeon. Chicken or the egg syndrome!
>:E Can't resist repeating here the joke someone told at a Sunday session in Upton. Seems he found a chicken "making passionate love" to an egg! Afterwards the bird stood up and said "well that settles that one" ;D .. but I digress
-
With current prices the A/D/G Hohner Compadre offers lots of possibilities ... I just happen to have one surplus to requirements ;D
Well if its at a bargain price and can be shipped to Australia, I may be interested.
Ray
-
Oz !!!!
Good luck with the search ray ;D
(this is one of those times when some indication of location (country at least, displayed in the left hand box) would have been useful ...)
-
I've just got my hands on one of these
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/SP_A0008.jpg)
I'm sure my siblings will be begging me to practice the melodeon instead soon enough. lol!
-
I've just got my hands on one of these
Nice one. 8)
Takes a bit of time getting past the cat strangling phase, but stick with it...
I'd reccommend fiddleforum (http://www.fiddleforum.com/fiddleforum/index.php?action=forum) for advice/ideas/etc...
Ed J
-
So far ive managed to make sounds by plucking strings as i can't get any noise using the bow. And the rosin isnt sticky and wont go onto the bow.:-(
-
If you thought melodeon was a difficult instrument to master, try the fiddle! It requires to master two techniques at the same time, the bow and the fingerings. I studied violin for a few years, I can tell you it's not easy!
-
So far ive managed to make sounds by plucking strings as i can't get any noise using the bow. And the rosin isnt sticky and wont go onto the bow.:-(
If its new rosin you need to use sandpaper to roughen up the surface to start, (I use the things you get to file your nails). If its a new bow you wont get any sound until you get it rosined. Fiddlehangout is a very useful resource.
Good luck.
Ray
-
If you thought melodeon was a difficult instrument to master, try the fiddle! It requires to master two techniques at the same time, the bow and the fingerings. I studied violin for a few years, I can tell you it's not easy!
Too true! With a melodeon, you pick it up, press a button, and a reasonably nice sound comes out, and you can then start thinking about playing tunes. It takes a long, long time to get to this stage with a fiddle!
Many people can manage to teach themselves to play melodeon, but this is rarely true of the fiddle. I'd definitely recommend finding a teacher, ideally one who teaches folk fiddle rather than violin.
-
As already mentioned the rosin needs scratching to produce the rosin dust that will go onto the bow. But yes, get a teacher is an absolute must,I agree with Pauline. Most violin teachers will be accepting if you say that you want to play folk music - regardless of whether they're 'classical' teachers or not. But it is an instrument that one needs to get the basics right on first - where you take it from there is then entirely up to you - best of luck with it.
BTW I've just finished reading about the history of the Art of Funerary Violin (http://www.rohan-k.co.uk/guildbooks.html) - it's an absolute hoot! I thoroughly recommend it! The book cover is pictured below. It is -despite appearences -a very funny book written by an exceptionally talented violinist and humourist.
AL
-
I'd be happy to just learn some scales and work on that for a year. I find it slightly wierd the instrument is so light. lol
-
the nail file trick worked. thank you. just managed half of twinkle little star. lol! It might be my play by ear instrument.
-
just managed half of twinkle little star. lol! It might be my play by ear instrument.
Good stuff! The melodeon's my play by ear instrument - which is such a release for me as I've been note-bound by all my other instruments!
AL
-
the nail file trick worked. thank you. just managed half of twinkle little star. lol! It might be my play by ear instrument.
Fiddle is a great play by ear instrument, all the notes are exactly where you expect them to be! Unlike melodeon.
-
I've just got my hands on one of these
Nice one. 8)
Takes a bit of time getting past the cat strangling phase, but stick with it...
I'd reccommend fiddleforum (http://www.fiddleforum.com/fiddleforum/index.php?action=forum) for advice/ideas/etc...
Ed J
looks useful. I'll go have a nose round.
the nail file trick worked. thank you. just managed half of twinkle little star. lol! It might be my play by ear instrument.
Fiddle is a great play by ear instrument, all the notes are exactly where you expect them to be! Unlike melodeon.
I know..that surprised me at first. I thought logically the note must be the next string along....and there it was. lol! A novel experience.
-
As a relative newcomer to fiddle playing I think Steve has hit the nail on the head. And it goes further, it's not just playing drones etc on the open strings it's the resonance effects that the open strings give that help to create the big ringing sound that is a feature of many trad styles of fiddle. It is possible to get resonance with stopped strings, but it's much harder to do and much less dramatic in sound.
Resonance: (click on video at bottom. This would be immeasurably better with a squeezbox of any sort behind them, but even so, rather nice... (:) (:)
http://hardangers.com/?page_id=37
-
A much clearer video featuring the Hardanger fiddle (Hardingfela). Lovely playing.....
Annbjørg Lien on Hardanger fiddle (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ioX9-UGboc)
-
A much clearer video featuring the Hardanger fiddle (Hardingfela). Lovely playing.....
Annbjørg Lien on Hardanger fiddle (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ioX9-UGboc)
yes - great fiddle and great performerette! but is the instrument male or female ;) ;) hardingfela or hardingfele? I think it's a man in Devil's clothing - 'fele >:E
-
In my experience of irish fiddle music the most common scales are D G A, in that order. There are many historical reasons but I don't think conforming to melodeons/accordions is one of them.
Interesting to note that in your neck of the woods (Newfoundland) the key of choice seems to be A/D!
-
A much clearer video featuring the Hardanger fiddle (Hardingfela). lovely playing.....
Interestiing instrument - I was introduced to it via Colin Ross in the 70's. I recall he said that most fiddles are strung with gut, but for the Hardanger they use the whole cat!
-
A much clearer video featuring the Hardanger fiddle (Hardingfela). lovely playing.....
Interestiing instrument - I was introduced to it via Colin Ross in the 70's. I recall he said that most fiddles are strung with gut, but for the Hardanger they use the whole cat!
A friend of mine, who is doing the violin making course at Newark, told me that gut strings were actually made of sheep or goat (I think) guts. The makers told everyone that they used cat guts as they didn't think people would want to kill a pwoor wickle pwussy cat to try and copy their string making methods!
-
Yes, sheep and goats but I think that story's actually apocryphal. Cats entered the equation either with a corruption of "kitgut", (kit = fiddle), or from early bass strings made from smaller strings twisted together called catlins or catlines that derived their name from a type of nautical rope.
Hardingfele sympathetic strings are actually steel anyway so any Norwegian cats that were reading this thread and getting worried can now breathe a sigh of relief. ;D
-
Nice explanation - but 'catgut' is quite definitely an English term too. And haven't we separated sheep from goats already in the present Hermeto Pascoal thread? ;) I personally feel Colin may have been experimenting with a little joke :|glug