Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Broadland Boy on May 12, 2010, 03:22:01 PM

Title: Clacking
Post by: Broadland Boy on May 12, 2010, 03:22:01 PM
I was indulging in my own version of a 'white knuckle ride' last night (cutting the rough grass in the orchard with one of my ancient Allen scythes - think hairdressers electric clippers but with a reciprocating blade a yard wide and able to cut effortlessly through shrub / tree stems an inch or more thick) when it encountered a chunk of wire mesh - a relic of this years wassailing (our annual ritual of spreading the bonfire heap remains under fruit trees without free reed accompanyment - that's reserved for the playing of Gathering Peascods prior to gathering the Peascod Nonsuch - finest apples ever IMHO) , this it ate and disgorged quite happily but it nicked a couple of blades so the sound became more audible over the exhaust and other mechanical noises.

The resultant sound was just like the continual and rapid clacking of a loose Honer action.   >:E

I wondered if anyone else had a domestic / garden appliance which could outclack a Honer ?    ???

Incidentally, the shredded, squashed and fermented product of last years Peascod and Bramley harvest is due to be racked off and bottled soon, any thirsty melodeonists holidaying on the Bure, North of Wroxham would be welcome to sample, no guarantees you would be able to navigate a straight course for a while thereafter........

Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 12, 2010, 10:14:39 PM
No, but I know an old Hohner that can play 'Click goes the shears'!
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 13, 2010, 12:20:02 AM
I thought Terry Pratchett invented the clacks!  ;D
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Broadland Boy on May 13, 2010, 11:18:47 AM
Click goes the shears, hadn't thought of that Andy - lovely match  (:)

As for TP and the clacks, I'm not looking forward to the day he is unable to complete another book or maintain the complexity we have come to love  :(

On a more serious note I find a periodic gentle nipping of the turned over lever arm either side of the wire reduces the noise from sideplay in my DG PW and have been sorely tempted to try a dab of silicone grease to damp further.

I presume people do not lubricate such joints as the dust pickup must inevitably lead to a nice abrasive lapping paste which wears faster rather than lubes ?? - have replaced the original Hohner fitted mull from the endplates with some nylon honey straining cloth which hopefully will ought not discolour and has a finer mesh, not that there was much dust inside to start with.....
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 13, 2010, 12:05:03 PM
On a more serious note I find a periodic gentle nipping of the turned over lever arm either side of the wire reduces the noise from sideplay in my DG PW and have been sorely tempted to try a dab of silicone grease to damp further.

I presume people do not lubricate such joints as the dust pickup must inevitably lead to a nice abrasive lapping paste which wears faster rather than lubes ??
No - don't use oil or grease anywhere on a melodeon, ever, for the reasons you state. Also the dust/oil mixture would eventually lead to clogging and binding of the pivots/joints, etc.

The only lubricant which is permissible is graphite powder (available from locksmiths, good hardware shops, etc.). It is possible to mix the graphite powder with a little methylated spirit or ethanol (vodka?) which acts as a carrier to get it into awkward spots. The alcohol then evaporates, leaving the graphite behind.
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Theo on May 13, 2010, 01:25:17 PM
Steve's advice is spot on.

Also worth noting that much Hohner noise comes from other places:  on older models the pallet facings are usually quite hard and close with a loud slap, and on the treble side and Pokerwork bass there can be a lot of noise from the buttons coming into contact with the sides of the holes.  This can be slightly less on those with a wooden fingerboard.
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Broadland Boy on May 14, 2010, 04:14:12 PM
Thanks Steve & Theo,

Yes, I thought the practice of not lubing would apply and I've used Graphite in Cellulose thinners or lighter fluid 'paint' to dry lubricate amongst other things one of our local church tower clocks where some idiot of a 'pro' clock maintainer had oiled all the wheels including the escape, to very good effect (i.e. it stopped withing a fortnight of dosing and had picked up an unbelievable amount of dust / grit in that time). Were you aware that there is also an aerosol available from woodworking outlets like Axminster Power Tools (no connection) which has PTFE powder suspended in an evaporating  solvent solution? not easy to manage the spray even with a needle on the thin tube but great if applied by needle / brush from a puddle sprayed into the tin lid or a bottle top.

Both my boxes have a little wear but the noise is no where near as prominent as some of Tony Hall's recordings and I don't dislike the sound.

Should I play them enough to seriously wear the holes - or find a cheap basket case to renovate, I might be tempted to experiment with some bushes in one of the bearing plastics such as PTFE, Ertalyte, Peek or HMW Nylon - I'll have to check some UHF radio co - ax cable as the insulating tube betwixt shield braid and conductor is often of PTFE nowadays and may be somewhere near the right size for instant use - will advise if I have some in the workshop to test as reaming the holes and pushing in a snipped off bit of tube might be a quick / practical and cheap repair method. I'm not fast enough yet but I can't see this slowing the action down for a pro - or would it ??

Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Mike Gott on May 17, 2010, 12:56:00 PM
 
...I wondered if anyone else had a domestic / garden appliance which could outclack a Honer ? ....


Not in the house as such, but a loom in a cotton mill does a pretty good Hohner impression (if you can find one still working, of course). I did have a manager back in my engineering days with badly fitting false teeth who could also take a pokerwork on......................

Mike
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: george garside on May 17, 2010, 01:06:40 PM
Triumph tiger cub tappets!

george ;D
Title: Re: Clacking
Post by: Steve C. on July 03, 2010, 10:09:34 PM
Irish Dancemaster does a very nice, very reasonable pallet facing that, along with the keyboard pad (almost) eliminates the Hohner Clack.  (I do, almost, miss it).
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal