Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: hatman on March 23, 2008, 09:57:39 PM
-
Apologies if this has been covered before but i am having basses trauma!
I have been playing a little over a month and have reached the dizzy heights of page 18 of Dave Mallinson's book and am trying to use all the bass buttons.
Am i being daft ( or have skipped a relevant bit of info.) because i find it hard to go from C chord to A chord when using first two fingers but much easier if i use my third and pinkie for C and first and second for A.
Is using four fingers for basses a melodeon heresy that will mean trouble later on. I have played guitar and bass guitar for many years so my fingers are fairly strong and can sound the chords reasonably well.
Should i stop now and carry on trying to shift my two fingers effectively ( mmm didn't mean that how it looks!)?
Thanks
Hatman
-
Nope, there's nothing wrong with using 4 fingers for the bass - it's a perfectly reasonable technique, and many professionals do it, so I'd say keep doing it. The truth is there's no right or wrong way to do this - most players use 2, because it's easiest for them, and after a bit (a lot) of playing some migrate to using 3 or 4. It sounds like your guitar background is giving you a headstart here, so make the most of it!
Cheers,
Clive.
-
I would even say it's a desirable technique! Why use only 2 fingers when you have 4 available. Takes practice, but it's very rewarding. It's even more useful when using a 12-bass box.
-
Personally I use fingers one and two exclusively on the the left hand. I have, however, at least one friend (who is a fabulous player) who uses all four fingers, and at least one friend (who is a fabulous player) who uses fingers one and two on the top four buttons and fingers two and three on the bottom four. The moral therefore is; do what works for you.
-
Thanks for the input and encouragement. Funnily enough i was thinking of experimenting with using 3 fingers as the weakest of my fingers is the pinkie which does let the overall quality drop. I will get back with my progress.
Hatman
-
It's also easier to "cross-row" and play melodies on the basses if you use all four fingers -- take a look at the thread on bass combinations and play around a bit.