Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ban on May 15, 2010, 11:13:58 PM

Title: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: Ban on May 15, 2010, 11:13:58 PM
I've taken some photos of brand new Hohner Erica Double Ray I got yesterday. I've opened it up, taped up the thirds on the bass side and checked for any obvious faults. Here are the pics with some comments:

http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=63436

To my untrained eye (first time I ever played or opened one of this instruments) everything looks OK as it can be on a Chinese machine. If any of you guys can see something I should worry about please point it out, I need all the help I can get because this is only B/C box in radius of 400km, and one of only two in my country. No one here has any experience with these instruments.

By ear I can hear two problems:

1. Loud clacking on the bass side, although there is felt + "something like leather" on the pallets.

    This is known issue as I understand, but will some more felt or thinner springs help or am I stuck with it? How thick felt could help?

2. On changing from draw to press on same button on low treble notes  (from D and below) I get this awful rasping sound from the reeds, so shrill and annoying that I just must lift my finger off the button for a moment when switching direction to not get that sound.

   Is this something that I can check or fix somehow? Maybe after some more playing time it will disappear?  ???



Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: diatonix on May 16, 2010, 11:24:07 AM
Obviously, felt would solve the problem, at least to a certain degree. But you shouldn't do that without readjusting the pallets, as the angle will change. I wouldn't mess with the springs. You would have to dismantle everything in order to change or modify the springs (and that can be tricky if you are not experienced). You may end up with slow buttons, airleaks and probably very little effect on the clacking.
The other issue you mention is probably a valve problem. Not much you can do other than replace the faulty ones (which, again, is not as easy as it sounds if you are not an expert).
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: Theo on May 16, 2010, 11:55:27 AM
I've taken some photos .....

http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=63436

This link won't work for me.

Quote

1. Loud clacking on the bass side, although there is felt + "something like leather" on the pallets.

    This is known issue as I understand, but will some more felt or thinner springs help or am I stuck with it? How thick felt could help?

2. On changing from draw to press on same button on low treble notes  (from D and below) I get this awful rasping sound from the reeds, so shrill and annoying that I just must lift my finger off the button for a moment when switching direction to not get that sound.

1 sounds like normal Hohner.   The pallet issue is indeed well known.     To fix it you must remove all the pallets from the arms, remove all the existing leather then replace with felt with a layer of soft leather on top,  the re-attach pallets and adjust action to allow for the thicker facing material.

For 2 the noise you hear is from the valves and you will get it on all instruments to a greater or lesser extent.  The longer the reed, the worse it is, and plastic valves are noisier than leather.  This is really more a question of playing technique. It's nearly always a bad idea musically speaking to keep a button depressed while changing bellows, it is almost always better to leave at least a tiny gap between notes when changing bellows.
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: LDbosca on May 16, 2010, 01:16:03 PM

1 sounds like normal Hohner.   The pallet issue is indeed well known.     To fix it you must remove all the pallets from the arms, remove all the existing leather then replace with felt with a layer of soft leather on top,  the re-attach pallets and adjust action to allow for the thicker facing material.

For 2 the noise you hear is from the valves and you will get it on all instruments to a greater or lesser extent.  The longer the reed, the worse it is, and plastic valves are noisier than leather.  This is really more a question of playing technique. It's nearly always a bad idea musically speaking to keep a button depressed while changing bellows, it is almost always better to leave at least a tiny gap between notes when changing bellows.

Maybe it depends on what style you play but I'd always recommend to students that they keep a button depressed if the are changing bellows, it's efficient and it can get a nice snappy sound too. *thread drift alert!*
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: melodeon on May 16, 2010, 02:57:58 PM
You ordered a Gaillard with the optional "baited breath" ?

Part of the charm of a Hohner Erica or Pokerwork is the clacking and the reed slush.
I suspect the slush may diminish.

I have taken Hohners, removed the pallets made new thinner ones and felted and leathered them so they have the same original thickness. I do not recommend it. Not really worth the effort.
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: LDbosca on May 16, 2010, 03:24:16 PM
You ordered a Gaillard with the optional "baited breath" ?

Part of the charm of a Hohner Erica or Pokerwork is the clacking and the reed slush.
I suspect the slush may diminish.

I have taken Hohners, removed the pallets made new thinner ones and felted and leathered them so they have the same original thickness. I do not recommend it. Not really worth the effort.

I thought it was mandatory when you order a Gaillard! ;D
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: Stiamh on May 16, 2010, 03:40:51 PM
You ordered a Gaillard with the optional "baited breath" ?

I thought it was mandatory when you order a Gaillard! ;D

What are you hoping to catch?

I'm also puzzled by the idea that it's "almost always" a bad idea musically not to lift a finger when changing bellows. I would have thought that it's sometimes a good idea musically to do so...
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: Owen Woods on May 16, 2010, 05:50:19 PM
I generally lift a finger. Mainly because my finger agility >> my bellows control. Unless you are really sharp it can sound really very sloppy if you use the bellows solely to change note. However, there are times where doing that (with decent control) is a desired musical effect.
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: Theo on May 16, 2010, 06:07:43 PM

I'm also puzzled by the idea that it's "almost always" a bad idea musically not to lift a finger when changing bellows. I would have thought that it's sometimes a good idea musically to do so...

I think I overstated with "almost always" but I still go with "usually" its best to lift a finger when changing bellows, which leaves the option that its "sometimes" not!   I hope we can agree on that.

I think for a new player its probably best to get into the habit of lifting the finger when changing bellows, then later (s)he can make a choice to keep the finger down.  I think that it could be harder to learn to lift the finger after getting into the way of not doing so.
Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: Ban on May 16, 2010, 07:00:06 PM
Thanks guys!

I somehow suspected I should lift a finger on changing direction, but from looking at some video tutorials the guys were not doing that, so I followed. Will try that from now on.

And yes, it's definitely plastic valve sound now that you mentioned it, lovely he he he.

I'll leave the thing as it is for now, 3rds are out, button travel limited, tuned good enough for practicing first tunes and scales.

I guess any piano accordion expert could do the tuning work or should I point to them that we always have 2 different reeds paired (or what's the term)

@Theo: Thanks for the photos you made on limiting button travel, took me some time to get the heights more or less the same, but it's great now. Regarding my photo album, try this

http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=63436&id=1343220427&l=3ae19744dd

@LDBosca: When could we get on with the lessons we arranged? As you can see the box is finally here (123 days from placing an order and it should be 30, arghhhh). You can get me on e-mail.

BTW, this is amazing forum and community, A+




Title: Re: New Hohner Erica - photos/questions
Post by: LDbosca on May 17, 2010, 01:06:29 PM
Thanks guys!

I somehow suspected I should lift a finger on changing direction, but from looking at some video tutorials the guys were not doing that, so I followed. Will try that from now on.

And yes, it's definitely plastic valve sound now that you mentioned it, lovely he he he.

I'll leave the thing as it is for now, 3rds are out, button travel limited, tuned good enough for practicing first tunes and scales.

I guess any piano accordion expert could do the tuning work or should I point to them that we always have 2 different reeds paired (or what's the term)

@Theo: Thanks for the photos you made on limiting button travel, took me some time to get the heights more or less the same, but it's great now. Regarding my photo album, try this

http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=63436&id=1343220427&l=3ae19744dd

@LDBosca: When could we get on with the lessons we arranged? As you can see the box is finally here (123 days from placing an order and it should be 30, arghhhh). You can get me on e-mail.

BTW, this is amazing forum and community, A+






I've emailed you, I'll be free some time next week. And I wouldn't start lifting fingers for different notes on one button or I'll be at you to stop once we get a lesson going! :o
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal