Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Flanna on May 31, 2010, 12:54:41 PM

Title: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on May 31, 2010, 12:54:41 PM
Hello to all you good melodeon people. I'm new to the forum and new to melodeons too.
The instruments that I normally play are English concertina and various flutes.
Recently I decided to try the melodeon as I want to have some bass/chords.
A friend has given me a melodeon that needs new reeds to play properly. The instrument is in the keys of G/C, and has 12 bass buttons. As it needs new reeds anyway I will change it to D/G.
I've had a look at the keyboard layouts section of melodeon.net but didn't find any layout that I can use as the instrument has rows of 10/9/6.
The music I will play on it, when it has new reeds, will be in the keys of mainly D and G, with some in C, F and A. So I don't need any D#/Eb buttons.
Can anyone suggest possible keyboard layouts that I might use?
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Gandy on May 31, 2010, 01:18:40 PM
What sort of meloden is it?   It sounds interesting, and maybe a shame to change it.   I assume that's a long G and C row, and the 6 buttons are accidentals.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Theo on May 31, 2010, 01:58:51 PM
Are you sure it needs new reeds?   It is very unusual for a complete set of reeds to need replacement.  usually thge reeds are the most durable part of the whole instrument.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on May 31, 2010, 02:14:11 PM
What sort of meloden is it?   It sounds interesting, and maybe a shame to change it.   I assume that's a long G and C row, and the 6 buttons are accidentals.

I don't know what make it is. Unfortunately it has been neglected and the reeds are beyond a re-tune, some bodger has been at it and some of the reeds are bent and broken. I know a chap who re-tunes accordions and he can fit new reeds easily if I can tell him the layout.

It is indeed a long G (10), short C (9) and 6 accidentals. I would like it to be long D, short G and accidentals.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Gandy on May 31, 2010, 05:07:58 PM
There are a few layouts here .... Two and a half row (http://info.melodeon.net/info/layouts/club)
They all have longer rows that yours, I would suggest losing the top buttons from these layouts rather than the low notes.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on May 31, 2010, 05:41:33 PM
There are a few layouts here .... Two and a half row (http://info.melodeon.net/info/layouts/club)
They all have longer rows that yours, I would suggest losing the top buttons from these layouts rather than the low notes.

Thanks Tony. I had a look at the club layouts but they all have far more buttons than my instrument.

I've made a possible layout. Would this seem sensible?
------------------C/D-----E/F---Bb/G#---C/D-----E/F----Bb/G#---------------
-----B/C-----D/F#----G/A-----B/C----D/E----G/F#-----B/A----D/C---G/E------
F#/G----A/C#----D/E----F#/G----A/B----D/C#----F#/E----A/G----D/B----F#/C#
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: rees on May 31, 2010, 06:16:47 PM
For my particular playing style, that layout would be ideal.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: ganderbox on May 31, 2010, 10:32:35 PM
This is very similar to the layout that I use, except that on the accidental row I have E flats rather than Cs on the push. If you are happy not having any E flats, then I'd say it's very useful.
Now you need to think about the basses......
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 01, 2010, 06:15:14 AM
Thanks for the feedback Rees and Pauline. It sounds like my layout idea will work fine.
Now for the basses... The instrument has 12 basses in 3 rows of 4 buttons. Here's what I was thinking of doing (remember that I play mainly D and G with some use of C, F and A).
----(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)----
----(B+/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)----
---(F#-/F+)----(F#/F)----(Bb/G)----(Bb/G)----
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: LJC on June 01, 2010, 08:32:08 AM
I would get a Bm chord on the push. Way more useful for English or French tunes, unless you have a 3rds stop.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 01, 2010, 09:08:07 AM
I would get a Bm chord on the push. Way more useful for English or French tunes, unless you have a 3rds stop.

Which chord would you replace with the Bm?

The instrument does have a 3rds stop.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 01, 2010, 09:13:22 AM
I would get a Bm chord on the push. Way more useful for English or French tunes, unless you have a 3rds stop.

Which chord would you replace with the Bm?

The instrument does have a 3rds stop.
I would replace the push B major chord with B minor. Even if you do have a stop to remove the thirds, a full chord of B minor is generally much more useful than a full chord of B major.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: LJC on June 01, 2010, 10:22:31 AM
As Steve says - replace the B major push chord on the other side of the Em chord. Far more useful than a B major, or the B neutral you get with the 3rds out.

Depending on how you play, I would also be tempted to get an A push reversal on the inner two buttons which had the Bb. I really like the A's in both directions for playing in Am and A dorian which very common (and sound jolly good). A Bb chord would give you more scope for tunes in F or Gm, but on the balance of my playing/repertoire I would opt for the A's.

Something like this:

----(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)----
----(B-/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)----
---(F#-/F+)----(F#/F)----(A/G)----(A/G)----
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 02, 2010, 09:23:55 AM
As Steve says - replace the B major push chord on the other side of the Em chord. Far more useful than a B major, or the B neutral you get with the 3rds out.

Depending on how you play, I would also be tempted to get an A push reversal on the inner two buttons which had the Bb. I really like the A's in both directions for playing in Am and A dorian which very common (and sound jolly good). A Bb chord would give you more scope for tunes in F or Gm, but on the balance of my playing/repertoire I would opt for the A's.

Something like this:

----(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)----
----(B-/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)----
---(F#-/F+)----(F#/F)----(A/G)----(A/G)----

Thanks for this useful advise. I'm going to check through my favorite music books (there's lots of them) and see if I play more in A etc or in F. I suspect that I use F more, but as I play mainly in D and G, I'm not really sure  :-\
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: ganderbox on June 02, 2010, 09:54:24 AM
Flanna - this does sound like an interesting box. I don't think I've seen a 12 bass box with the basses laid out in 3 short rows - normally it's 2 long rows.

As for the bass layout, I'd agree with LJC, except I'd swap the positions of the A/G and F#/F buttons. This would put the basses you need in their particular keys (F,C,D,A) closer together.
If you want the Bb, you could put one with the F bass (instead of having the F#). This is what I've got on my Dony. 
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Prestidigitator on June 02, 2010, 02:45:28 PM
Flanna - this does sound like an interesting box. I don't think I've seen a 12 bass box with the basses laid out in 3 short rows - normally it's 2 long rows.


The Yvus Pyrenees model is available with 12 basses configured in 3 rows

http://yvusaccordeons.free.fr/anglais/models-yvus-accordions.html#pyrenees

I've a feeling that I've seen this on another instrument but, for the life of me I can't remember which!
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: LJC on June 02, 2010, 02:49:11 PM
I love having F#m on the push as it's the 3rd chord in the key of D and fits really nicely in almost every D tune! I wouldn't give that up for a Bb. It sounds like I have a vendetta against Bb chords and playing in F, but for a D/G box I just think it's far more useful to maximise the chords for the home keys rather than go for out and out chromaticism.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 02, 2010, 03:10:34 PM
Well, now I have had a day or two to ponder over the options. The advise from forum members has been very useful, thanks.
Here is the complete layout for my 10/9/6 12 bass that I am thinking of asking the accordion repairer to fit in the melodion.
Would anyone find this awkward to use for playing mainly D and G and also in C, F and A ?
I am not trying to make the melodion fully chromatic (there are no Eb/D# notes). I would like it to be as convenient as possible to play in the 5 keys that I use most.
Any music with more than 1 flat or 3 sharps is a candidate for my English concertina.


--------------------------(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)--------------------------
--------------------------(B-/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)--------------------------
--------------------------(A+/G+)----(A/G)---(Bb+/F+)----(Bb/F)-------------------------

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

---------------------(C/D)---(E/F)--(Bb/G#)---(C/D)-----(E/F)---(Bb/G#)------------------
------(B/C)----(D/F#)---(G/A)---(B/C)----(D/E)----(G/F#)----(B/A)----(D/C)---(G/E)-------
(F#/G)---(A/C#)----(D/E)---(F#/G)---(A/B)---(D/C#)----(F#/E)---(A/G)----(D/B)---(F#/C#)

Any suggestions for revision will be most welcome. I am really not too sure whether the bass note Bb is right or if it should be an F#minor.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Gandy on June 04, 2010, 09:24:48 AM
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Theo on June 04, 2010, 09:43:09 AM
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.

me too,  I'd also have the Bb/G# the other way round,  but it is personal.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: ganderbox on June 04, 2010, 01:18:18 PM
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.

me too,  I'd also have the Bb/G# the other way round,  but it is personal.

And I'd want an Eb, too, but I'd keep the Bb/G# as it is.
The thing is that it is personal, and we've all got our own ideas based on what suits ourselves. Many of us are still experimenting with different layouts, even if we have one that works, because nothing is perfect. Whatever you go for, chances are that at some point in the future you will want to change something.
I do think, though, it would be a shame to have a box like yours that didn't have all 12 notes somewhere on the keyboard, and I'd be reluctant not to include the Eb (but that's personal!).
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Gandy on June 04, 2010, 01:44:23 PM
Maybe it would be no big deal to change one or more of the buttons at a later date if you change your mind.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 04, 2010, 02:12:38 PM
And I'd want an Eb, too, but I'd keep the Bb/G# as it is.
The thing is that it is personal, and we've all got our own ideas based on what suits ourselves. Many of us are still experimenting with different layouts, even if we have one that works, because nothing is perfect. Whatever you go for, chances are that at some point in the future you will want to change something.
I do think, though, it would be a shame to have a box like yours that didn't have all 12 notes somewhere on the keyboard, and I'd be reluctant not to include the Eb (but that's personal!).

I do agree with this. It would be nice to have all 12 notes but I can't easily fit them all in.
So, I went through the books of music that I am likely to play on the melodeon, looking for instances of Eb. I concentrated on keys of D, G, C, F and A. After looking through more than 500 tunes, I hadn't found any occurrence of Eb. That is why I decided to leave it out and make room for more reversed common notes such as C, D and E which I think will be very handy.
Of course this means that the box will not be fully chromatic, but then a D/G box is not meant to be chromatic anyway.
This makes me unsure whether the bass side would be better off with the Bb+ or an F#-, or with nether of them, but another chord instead.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 10, 2010, 06:15:52 AM
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.

me too,  I'd also have the Bb/G# the other way round,  but it is personal.

Theo, as an expert on melodeons, could you tell me why the Eb is so useful. Is it really more useful than one of the reversed notes (C, D, E) on a D/G box?

If you were going to swap one of the reversed notes for an Eb, which note would it be?
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Theo on June 10, 2010, 08:21:00 AM
It's nothing to do with being an expert!   It all depends on what you play.  I have a very small number of tunes in my repertoire where the Eb is used, mainly as a passing note or ornament.  The instrument is limited so you must make some compromises in choosing your note layout.  Which compromises you can live with depends on your repertoire and playing style.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: LJC on June 10, 2010, 08:33:15 AM
Getting one or two reeds replaced or re tuned isn't a big deal - I would go with the layout YOU think you will be happy with and then make changes as and when you decide they are necessary.

For playing in D, G and A, having an F# bass would be better than Bb as it gives you the iii chord in the key of D and the vi chord in the key of A, rather than Bb which only occurs in F (unless your messing around chromatically with other keys). 
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 10, 2010, 11:18:13 AM
Thanks Theo and LJC. It all helps me to get the box setup in the most usable way for the music that I will play on it.

Having had another scan through some favorite music books, I see that; Bb chord is indeed only used in tunes in key F and, I don't play much in F anyway. The F tunes can be reserved for my English concertina. So I agree with you that the Bb bass/chord should be changed to F#m. Now that I will not be using the melodeon for key F, is there any point in keeping the Bb accidental notes? Is there another note that would be more useful for D/G/A/C that could be put in the 1/2 row instead of Bb?

Here is what the treble side would look like with the Bb...

------------------C/D-----E/F---Bb/G#---C/D-----E/F----Bb/G#---------------
-----B/C-----D/F#----G/A-----B/C----D/E----G/F#-----B/A----D/C---G/E------
F#/G----A/C#----D/E----F#/G----A/B----D/C#----F#/E----A/G----D/B----F#/C#
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: LJC on June 10, 2010, 11:47:04 AM
The Bb is useful as an accidental in lots of Em tunes, I would keep it.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: ganderbox on June 10, 2010, 12:59:18 PM

The music I will play on it, when it has new reeds, will be in the keys of mainly D and G, with some in C, F and A.


No minor keys?  
Eb and/or Bb are needed if you want to play in Gm or Dm (and Cm, but that's less common).

They also crop up as accidentals quite often, even if they don't appear much in your current prospective repertoire. Ones that immediately come to mind are Jump at the Sun (Bb in Em), and a lovely tune I've recently learned in Em called Waltz Harry Lane, which wouldn't be the same without the Eb. Not forgetting the session favourite Horse's Braul, in G, for which a Bb is essential.  

You may not want these notes now, but chances are that one day you will!

P.S.    I put in a suggestion here about converting to ADG instead....then remembered we're talking about a 6 button 3rd row, so I've edited it out!  :|bl
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 10, 2010, 01:29:40 PM
These are very good points, Pauline and JLC. The Bb, I already have. If I wanted to add Eb for octaves 1 and 2 (the full octaves) where would be the bast place to put them?

For octave 1 I think the low F# could be changed for Eb but what about the next octave up? Which note around the middle of the keyboard could be most usefully changed for an Eb?
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: ganderbox on June 10, 2010, 03:12:52 PM
Two of my boxes have an Eb in the low F# spot, and it works really well.
Unfortunately, the Eb in the upper octave is in the spot where you have a C on the push (paired with the D), which, given the way you've arranged it to play in C, you probably don't want to lose.
You could always just have the Eb in just one octave (as 2 row players have).

Other than that, maybe you would be best to go with it as it is, and see how you get on with playing in the different keys with its current layout. As we've said, you might find something you want to change anyway, at which time you can rethink, if necessary.
Title: Re: Converting from G/C to D/G on 10/9/6 instrument
Post by: Flanna on June 14, 2010, 11:37:05 AM
Having read all your useful replies, I now agree that it would be best to include the Eb notes.

I've updated this as I was thinking of altering the melodeon to 10/9/8 by adding 2 more treble buttons. Now I think that it is best to keep the box as original looking as possible.

So, having read the comments in this thread, here is the layout that I think will be most suitable:

--------------------------(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)--------------------------
--------------------------(B-/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)--------------------------
--------------------------(A+/G+)----(A/G)---(A#-/F+)---(A#-/F)-------------------------

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

---------------------(E/Eb)---(F/G#)--(Bb/D)---(C/F)----(E/Eb)---(G#/Bb)-------------------
------(B/C)----(D/F#)---(G/A)---(B/C)----(D/E)----(G/F#)----(B/A)----(D/C)---(G/E)-------
(G/B)---(A/C#)----(D/E)---(F#/G)---(A/B)---(D/C#)----(F#/E)---(A/G)----(D/B)---(F#/C#)

There are 3 main ideas behind this layout:


Can anyone suggest any improvements this layout?

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal