What sort of meloden is it? It sounds interesting, and maybe a shame to change it. I assume that's a long G and C row, and the 6 buttons are accidentals.
There are a few layouts here .... Two and a half row (http://info.melodeon.net/info/layouts/club)
They all have longer rows that yours, I would suggest losing the top buttons from these layouts rather than the low notes.
| ------------------C/D-----E/F---Bb/G#---C/D-----E/F----Bb/G#--------------- -----B/C-----D/F#----G/A-----B/C----D/E----G/F#-----B/A----D/C---G/E------ F#/G----A/C#----D/E----F#/G----A/B----D/C#----F#/E----A/G----D/B----F#/C# |
| ----(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)---- ----(B+/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)---- ---(F#-/F+)----(F#/F)----(Bb/G)----(Bb/G)---- |
I would get a Bm chord on the push. Way more useful for English or French tunes, unless you have a 3rds stop.
I would replace the push B major chord with B minor. Even if you do have a stop to remove the thirds, a full chord of B minor is generally much more useful than a full chord of B major.I would get a Bm chord on the push. Way more useful for English or French tunes, unless you have a 3rds stop.
Which chord would you replace with the Bm?
The instrument does have a 3rds stop.
As Steve says - replace the B major push chord on the other side of the Em chord. Far more useful than a B major, or the B neutral you get with the 3rds out.
Depending on how you play, I would also be tempted to get an A push reversal on the inner two buttons which had the Bb. I really like the A's in both directions for playing in Am and A dorian which very common (and sound jolly good). A Bb chord would give you more scope for tunes in F or Gm, but on the balance of my playing/repertoire I would opt for the A's.
Something like this:
----(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)----
----(B-/E-)-----(B/E)----(C+/C+)----(C/C)----
---(F#-/F+)----(F#/F)----(A/G)----(A/G)----
Flanna - this does sound like an interesting box. I don't think I've seen a 12 bass box with the basses laid out in 3 short rows - normally it's 2 long rows.
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.
me too, I'd also have the Bb/G# the other way round, but it is personal.
And I'd want an Eb, too, but I'd keep the Bb/G# as it is.
The thing is that it is personal, and we've all got our own ideas based on what suits ourselves. Many of us are still experimenting with different layouts, even if we have one that works, because nothing is perfect. Whatever you go for, chances are that at some point in the future you will want to change something.
I do think, though, it would be a shame to have a box like yours that didn't have all 12 notes somewhere on the keyboard, and I'd be reluctant not to include the Eb (but that's personal!).
Its such a personal choice, but I'd want an Eb.
me too, I'd also have the Bb/G# the other way round, but it is personal.
The music I will play on it, when it has new reeds, will be in the keys of mainly D and G, with some in C, F and A.