Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Kautilya on June 01, 2010, 04:08:08 PM
-
[Somehow this lost the little iintro note to Theo kindly to shift this to learning if he feels it better there or kill it off when it has run its course; and also saying it's also posted over on cnet but applies both to melodeon and tina probs which I have because of various layouts and keys and my generally addled brain].
Lots of useful tips coming in I must say! Tku.
Practise, practise, practise - yes, I know, so let's get that out of the way first.
The problem:
Even the masters hit bum notes. Watching John Kirkpatrick (and other Meister/Mätressen) at Swaledale during a work-session, he masterfully zipped on with his Anglo with no more than a grunt when he produced a falsie, as he demoed a piece for the class. This raises an important issue for a beginner. He and others have a real skill in bypassing the mistake - an art in itself. How to develop that?
Can the expertini suggest a trick/tactic/psychomove which they have developed and use to ignore the mistake and forge ahead? This is not to do with playing something different from the dots in front of you -- indeed, John made the point that he rarely plays the way he wrote (his own) dots anyway! It is about the bum note brainblocker.
For the illiteratini the bad note is like a hole in the road, hit by the front wheel of your bike - it not only throws you, it panics you, you grab the brakes or u just come off and everything falls apart....
Part of the problem after the bum note is hitting the correct subsequent note of course, so holding the tune in the head has its part to play... but that is not enough methinks...
any advice welcome! Tks
-
I used to get really thrown by any wrong note....but now I'm finding it easier to play through it. Can't figure out why. Although I think going to sessions has helped a lot. Coz when I practice at home I can stop every time I make a mistake and start again. Can't stop a room full of people and say "do you mind awfully starting again I got a wrong note" ;)
-
I try to keep the rhythm going with a laugh at the same time. :|||:
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
As long as the gap between beats is the same you can get away with an awful lot! Just keep a steady pulse in your head and don't let it falter, even if you go wrong.
-
Just keep playing and smile!
Most of the time you will be the only one noticing the mistake... if you don't make a big deal of it nothing bad will happen! Besides, there are worse things that can happen, like running out of air. Same approach, keep going and smile!
-
Playing along with others (e.g. at a session) or better still, playing for dancing, are ways of making sure you learn to keep in time and ignore the wrong notes. Even if you miss the rest of the bar, or even the line, you need to be able to jump back in at the right time and find your place. I find that keeping the bass going is a big help.
But your question raises an interesting issue: when we practise, this isn't normally what we do, is it? If I'm practising and I get something consistently wrong, I slow it down and keep going over that part until it comes right. If we don't do that, and just ignore a mistake, our fingers/brains will never learn the correct pattern, and we'll just reinforce the wrong one.
So when we're playing "out", a completely different response is required from what happens during a private practice session. Maybe that needs a different sort of practice? I suppose playing with a metronome or even with a recording would provide the right opportunity.
But now that you've raised this, I can see it's no wonder our brains get confused, if on some occasions we stop and replay until we get it right, and on others we simply bash ahead and concentrate on keeping time. On one hand there's the sort of practice that aims to get every note right, and on the other hand there's the "Strictly Cotswold" practice in which the main thing is not to miss a beat. Tricky, isn't it?
-
One of the nice things about a melodeon is that quite often a bum note doesn't sound too bad, as there's a good chance it will be part of the right chord, or at least in the right key, and anyway it's surprising how often nobody notices, Main thing to do is keep the rhythm going until you can get back into the tune.
Sometimes, though, if you're doing a lot of cross-rowing, (and especially if it involves a row of accidentals!) the results can be quite spectacularly wrong.
The worst problem that arises is when you play the tune through again, and when you approach the bit where you went wrong you begin to panic. You start to doubt yourself, your automatic pilot fails, and you get a complete mental block about how to play a particular phrase, so you get it wrong again. If stopping at the end of the next time through the tune is not an option (say if you're playing for a dance) then you just have to do the best you can to cover the blank in your brain by playing something else that fits and doesn't upset the rhythm or chord structure. Ad lib, and call it a variation!
-
It is just down to practice, and that takes time, so be patient with yourself.
One technique that I find useful is playing along with the tune, either played by another person, or on a recording. If you do this with a familiar tune you can try deliberately stopping, and then rejoining the tune.
-
I used to get really thrown by any wrong note....but now I'm finding it easier to play through it. Can't figure out why. Although I think going to sessions has helped a lot. Coz when I practice at home I can stop every time I make a mistake and start again.
I think you've nailed it.
I'd only add (as Marje also has) that as well as sessions, playing for dancing is another situation where you simply can't stop, which is why playing (preferably solo) for dancing is essential training for any folk musician.
Learning to improvise your way round mistakes is a separate skill from learning to play the right notes and has to be practised. It is also is one of the things that distinguishes a professional performer from an amateur. Some singers and actors have an amazing knack for making stuff up when they forget the words.
-
Ad lib, and call it a variation!
And at the same time, give a dirty look to the musician next to you, perhaps.... >:E >:E >:E
(...coat...etc)
MC
-
Another similar skill learnt from playing for dancing is to change quickly from the A to the B or vice versa without losing your place when you realise you got it wrong (again!).
-
Another similar skill learnt from playing for dancing is to change quickly from the A to the B or vice versa without losing your place when you realise you got it wrong (again!).
Yes, I nearly posted an anecdote about switching from bar 4 of the A music to bar 5 of the B music of Princess Royal without losing a beat >:E
-
Another similar skill learnt from playing for dancing is to change quickly from the A to the B or vice versa without losing your place when you realise you got it wrong (again!).
Not so easy if its "slows" for a Morris dance ... (so I'm told)
-
Another similar skill learnt from playing for dancing is to change quickly from the A to the B or vice versa without losing your place when you realise you got it wrong (again!).
Ah yes, I can do that, I've had plenty of practice :P
-
I always work to a rule that if a make a bum note in a piece of music I repeat it next time round so that people think I meant to do it!
-
Who was it said "if you play a wrong note once it's a mistake, play it twice it's a variation, play it three times it's an arrangement"?
-
......If you play it wrong four times, it's Jazz! ;-)
-
......If you play it wrong four times, it's Jazz! ;-)
Only if you play it differently wrong each time ;)
-
I'll forego cheap jibes about there being no bum notes. You can get away with just about anything that's within the diatonic scale your tune is on - don't worry about it. I do actually then tend to repeat it and it becomes 'arrangement' or even 'inprovisation'.
Should you leave your scale you may be more at sea. Flat 9ths (eg Ab in G) and 5ths (eg Db in G) and 7ths (F natural in G) are part of the Blues tradition and so it's a matter of whether the tune you're playing can take that. Some of the more Morissy stuff really won't - but soldier on - you probably picked out that 'accidental' on purpose anyway?
Rather deeper water should you confuse C from C# taking you from from natural minor to Dorian. That can sound horrid, although flattening the C# to C when playing on D row seems to be tollerated rather better. (A lot of Irish types now seem routinely to use their C chord playing in Irish/Dorian E minor)
There is a real bummer - that is to play a major third (eg C# in A minor = uggh) when you are supposed to be on a minor scale tune. It can really jar and may lead to you being eaten by a passing shark.
In general - just keep playing. Most errant notes can be absorbed, but your rhythm is all. The worst thing you can do is to stop (all right - playing the bit again is even worse)!
-
I didn't realise how many bum notes I played untl the the older members of the band started to retire! Sometimes i completely c##k up the intro, which reduces me to fits of giggles. Best to wait 'til the dancers have stopped taking the p#ss befrore restarting. I've also hit a wall in the middle of a tune and had to rejoin at the start of the next phrase - so keep the tune going in your head...
All in all, after a while you stop worrying about it , so it becomes less frequent anyway.
Rob.
-
......If you play it wrong four times, it's Jazz! ;-)
Jazz is never having to say "oops!"
Ray
-
......If you play it wrong four times, it's Jazz! ;-)
Jazz is never having to say "oops!"
Ray
"Jazz isn't dead, it just smells funny." ~ Frank Zappa
:|glug
-
But more seriously, I've found that most of my mistakes are functions of familiarity and frequency. The tunes I make the most mistakes with are tunes that I am least familiar with or don't often play (seems obvious, right?). This includes tunes that are totally fresh and still in the learning process, tunes that I have recently learned, and tunes which I play exclusively on the box and do not play often on other instruments. If I play the tune on other instruments, I'm less likely to make mistakes when I take it over to the box. So taking those "box only tunes" over to other instruments helps me to "know" the melody as opposed to "remembering" the melody.
When I play a bum note, I try to play through it instead of stopping and restarting only to make the same mistake again. I also try to work out a practice routine that avoids practicing the mistakes, so they won't be cemented in muscle memory. Learn the tough bit correctly and then practice the whole tune. Also being familiar with playing across both rows is helpful - fingering the same phrase in different ways is helpful (and fun).
-
Top tip from the professionals:
When John Kirkpatrick plays a bum note he usually shouts "Aaaargh!"
-
That's presuming you can vocalise and play at the same time...Could end in a vicious circle of bums and arrghs.
-
one of the first things I learnt when playing in public was the ability to go "aaaaarrrrgggggghhhhhhhhhhhh" and keep on playing to which I quickly attained the reputation of playing tunes with lyrics ;D
-
Perhaps you could get the audiance to do some complementary Ooooohs?
-
one of the first things I learnt when playing in public was the ability to go "aaaaarrrrgggggghhhhhhhhhhhh" and keep on playing to which I quickly attained the reputation of playing tunes with lyrics ;D
or take to emo-grunge music or 'screamo' as someone told it was called once.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aD6ewQnbEPE
-
I would recommend learning a good collection of both cross row and on the row ornaments. Any time you hit a wrong note you can probably turn it into a quick turn to get you back to the button you meant to press or the next one in the tune. Practice deliberately playing the wrong button mid tune and bringing it back.
If all else fails you could always just mash the main home key push buttons on the row to get the tonic chord in a rhythmic fashion until you work out where you are supposed to be going.
Also, practice making small 1 or 2 bar chunks of tune up on the fly, and then try incorporating these 'variations' into the tune. Once you get away from the fact that the notes are only a suggestion of how to play the tune, you will find mistakes can become natural variation.
-
I would recommend learning a good collection of both cross row and on the row ornaments. Any time you hit a wrong note you can probably turn it into a quick turn to get you back to the button you meant to press or the next one in the tune. Practice deliberately playing the wrong button mid tune and bringing it back.
If all else fails you could always just mash the main home key push buttons on the row to get the tonic chord in a rhythmic fashion until you work out where you are supposed to be going.
Also, practice making small 1 or 2 bar chunks of tune up on the fly, and then try incorporating these 'variations' into the tune. Once you get away from the fact that the notes are only a suggestion of how to play the tune, you will find mistakes can become natural variation.
This is extremely good advice.
-
Even if you don't make a mistake, mashing the home key push buttons is still a good idea!
-
Indeed.
When playing for a ceilidh, perhaps third or fourth time through the tune I might play once through the whole tune just using right hand chords. It breaks things up and gives the dance a new dynamic.
Watching Roger Watson a few weeks back calling a dance, just him and his melodeon. The first couple of times through the dance he was mostly playing chords with a strong rhythm and just hinting at the tune.
As the dancers got the hang of it, the calling became less complicated allowing Roger to concentrate on playing the tune.
-
I practice with a drum machine, if I lose it then I have to get back onto beat and it also negates the option of slowing down for the hard bits.
Steve
-
I'm a novice on the melodeon, but from my experience, playing punk-rock to jazz, you should just carry on and try NOT to grimace... no-one will notice if the rhythm stays steady.
As mentioned, I usually repeat the "bad" note again as soon as possible, while looking confident. If nothing else, people in the know will get a laugh from it.
Talking about this once with a really great Be-Bop sax player, he said "Yes, but if you get completely lost and play five awful notes in a row, frown down at your instrument and clatter some keys, as if they have got stuck."
-
Er, while not known for box playing, jazz trumpet legend Miles Davis is quoted as saying "There's no such thing as a bad note - it's the one you play next that matters". Something I've found does work!
I also like his riposte to then sideman John Coltrane who, when Miles asked him why his sax solos were so long, said "I just don't know how to stop" to which Miles replied: "Just take the horn out of your mouth!" >:E
-
I also like his riposte to then sideman John Coltrane who, when Miles asked him why his sax solos were so long, said "I just don't know how to stop" to which Miles replied: "Just take the horn out of your mouth!" >:E
This is the censored version of the quote, he used other words between "Just take the" and "off your mouth" !!!
-
Even if you don't make a mistake, mashing the home key push buttons is still a good idea!
How do you 'mash the home key push buttons'?
-
'mash the home key push buttons' = press several adjacent keys on the G row (for a tune in G) and push the bellows. You'll get some sort of G major chord.
-
Get better. I'm not trying to be snide here, although it might sound like it. ::)
-
Steve is right in that the more you play the less this will be a problem. Just keep at it!
-
......If you play it wrong four times, it's Jazz! ;-)
Jazz is never having to say "oops!"
Ray
Otherwise known as Ralph Jordan's First Principle of Improvisation...
Ian