Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: boscaceoil on June 01, 2010, 04:18:24 PM
-
Just got my new hand made Kincora melodeon yesterday from Martin Connolly in Ennis, Co. Clare. Absolutely fabulous instrument. Binchy reeds, reed blocks set 2-up 2-down. In D 4 stops. Fantastic sound. Martin is the only person making one-row melodeons in Ireland. He is also well known for his 2-row boxes. Will post a picture when I can. :)
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4109.0.html
-
Kincora photos
-
Surely there are more subtle ways to attach the thumbstrap...
-
Surely there are more subtle ways to attach the thumbstrap...
Obviously intended to be adjustable for size, but what an abortion of a design!
-
Surely there are more subtle ways to attach the thumbstrap...
Obviously intended to be adjustable for size, but what an abortion of a design!
Had I the money to considering buying a new 1-row, that would be enough to put me off buying this particular box.
-
Surely there are more subtle ways to attach the thumbstrap...
Am I missing a picture? I only see 3, nothing of a thumbstrap, and all these comments have me intrigued to see whats going on! ::)
-
Eh? I don't see anything. It's the horrible logo things that would put me off. However, what really matters is how it plays (:)
-
I am sure if you requested not to have an adjustable thumbstrap then Martin would replace with the ordinary one. I think asthetically the melodeon is really attractive and the workmanship is second to none.
Just put the thumbstrap photo back. It may not be the best picture angle. I have no problem with it. The sound is fantastic and the action really smooth.
Regarding the logo. The color of this actually matches the green bellows when playing.
Tom.
-
"Regarding the logo. The color of this actualy matches the green bellows when playing."
Swell. Color coordinated offense.
I am supposing that the inner folds of the bellows have an advert for the Kincora boxes.
The thumbstrap knob might have a dual purpose. Such as a coat rack...
-
I think it's a passable looking box. Not sure how it's any more garishly labeled than a Jr Martin or a standard Cajun box as for the coloring I'm inclined to prefer solid black with no garish branding at all. I play a garish red Hohner so if this box plays as nicely as claimed I think color is hardly a disqualifying factor. As for the offending thumb strap I think an adjustable thumb strap is rather cool. It may not be engineered as unobtrusively as some may want it's the function that is important. Form over function is not a good philosphy in design of melodeons.
-
That's probably a lovely box to play and very well made but I think the responses demonstrate that the first things everyone notices are those awful logos and that hideous thumbstrap thingy that looks like a coat hanger nicked off the back of an airport toilet door.
I would seriously advise Mr Connolly to rethink those, you never get a second chance to make a first impression.
-
I have to say that many of the responses in this thread seem to lack the usuall courtesy found on melnet. Here is someone who wishes to share his joy in a wonderful new instrument with the melnet community and has received mostly very rough criticism about its appearance....which is entirely a matter of personal taste. What value is that sort of critique? Silence would be much preferable.
-
Point taken and I usually hate the negative comments when they come out. However, presumably this is one of the best places for a critique of such a new instrument, by likely purchasers, and the general reaction is not good. And I must admit I agree with the others. Anyone who is selling something of which the primary attribute is performance must still recognize the importance of appearance. In this case, that is clearly an issue. It would be very sad if a good instrument doesn't sell because of the way it looks.
-
If you went to a garden party at Buckingham Palace dressed in an elegantly tailored Saville Row suit, perfectly groomed and socialising with the utmost grace, wit and charm then people would remark on that after you left...if you went to a garden party at Buckingham Palace in an elegantly tailored Saville Row suit, perfectly groomed and socialising with the utmost grace wit and charm but with your flies deliberately undone to allow your genitalia to hang out in full view then they'd say something else...
I think that looks to be an otherwise very nice box but without being able to hear how it sounds or feel how well it's made and plays all there is to go on is visuals and the logos and thumbstrap adjuster really stick out. It's the first time I've seen one of those boxes as well, those things just hit me straight away and without a reputation it's quite hard to get past them. I'd expect something a bit more subtle on a handmade instrument.
-
It looks a lovely instrument to me, and if I came across one in a shop I'd certainly want to have a go on it. Are there likely to be any sound files coming?
... but yes, and this is more for Martin Connolly's feedback if he ever reads this forum than anything else, if I were him I'd tone down the green badges to something much more understated*** because the first thing I'd do (personal taste alert) when I got that instrument home is find some way of taking that off or covering it up. Then I'd take the adjustable thumb strap off... so that's not a problem at all really, is it? And then I would have an instrument that looks absolutely gorgeous. I guess what's annoying to me is it is *so* close to looking perfect - I love the look of the rest of it.
Enjoy your new box - any idea how many he is making of them? What do they cost?
Cheers,
Clive
*** but now I think about it, he's not alone, is he? Castagnari and Saltarelle have both had some truly, truly, horrible logos all over their instruments in their recent history... in fact I hate, with a passion, the logo on my Mory.
-
Congratulations on your new purchase. I certainly hope it sounds and performs well.
I do not think it is discourteous to make honest comments on the accordeon.
This is not the first thread on the Kincora melodeon. Considering that the
same observations were made in the first, and there for all to view, the
person who started this thread had the opportunity to read them.
An expectation of any thing different would be unrealistic.
There are three basic elements to product; design , materials and workmanship.
Where this accordeon seems to "fail" is in the design. The design of the box itself is
somewhat traditional, except for the design "affectation" of the massive logo banners
on the front of the box. This deters from its appearance and its purpose seems to
be to satisfy the self interest of the builder, not the buyer. It is also "hideous.
The thumb strap is odd, large and could be toned down. I own a 2 row made in Austria
around 1880, it has a very clever, simple and small feature for its adjustable strap.
This needs attention.
So when do facts and honesty become discourteous. Have the PC police invaded the
world of melodeons.
Were I too make a product that was critiqued, and critiqued honestly, I would appreciate the
response and effect changes.
Cajun accordeons. While not "cajun" in origin, these boxes have a life and tradition of their own
as evolved from a near 50 year tradition. of Cajun construction. .
I do not care for the metal corner bits, the chrome foil on the pallets, the arte nouveau scrolls on
the face plates, the massive bolted on hardware etc. but that's what they are.
I ordered one from a Cajun builder. The second in fact. I asked for no chrome foil,
no red anywhere on the box, leather bits without the white piping, no arte nouveau scrolling. Plain
maple.
What did I get:
Red lined bellows, red tipped chrome foiled pallets, white piping on black leather.
and not only did I get the scrolling but it too was red
and to top it off the box was maple with walnut end panels.
Hideous. I owned it one day and offed it at a minor loss.
Hohners... here again is a tradition, born of its origin where color is king.
As garrish as the HA114 is.. it is a charming bit of kit. I like them for exactly
that. I mean where else can you justify gold, silver, black, red and loud.
Maybe on a good motorbike. It just works.
The Kincora melodeon did not work.
Some time ago I made some honest comments about a book , DVD combination
that was at best a self indulgent work that was a production mess. I was blasted.
Not because of my honest and factual observations but because I was rude to
the author by stating same. Sorry, the baby was ugly. The author had the opportunity
to contact me, per my invitiation, but chose not to.. instead posted an infantile response.
I had gone to great lenghts to edit the work, rewrite a major portion of it with an intent
to do the rest. I was going to forward it to the author. But based on his insulting, to me)
response, I kept my rewrite and sold the offending material. My intent on being helpful
backfired. I lost nothing except half the price of the book and DVD.
Was that discourteous. Not to me. Like the comments on the Kincora box, they were honest
and could be used to benefit the maker into making changes that would improve its appeal.
I don't believe the intent by anyone was to be mean, but to voice an opinion. The opinions were near
universal and honest. How the comments are taken is a matter of choice.
-
Hi all,
I don't know Mr. Connolly but I have met him and heard him play. He has been around traditional music all his life and I remember he had some interesting ideas on the tone qualities of different soundboard materials. I'm sure he has put a lot of thought and effort into making his new melodeon sound and work great. If this is his first try at a one-row box, and if he keeps making them, sure we can expect him to keep improving them. From that point of view some feedback from potential buyers is helpful..... but let's not "prune the seedling" (as we used to say about overly harsh criticism of a first draft of a paper). I would like to encourage Mr. Connolly to make these. I agree with the priorities of some here, that the sound and playability of a musical instrument are more important than looks, but it is also true that a very eye-catching (or at least not eye-offending) appearance can really help sales of a model of instrument.
I would like to know how the new owner(s) describe the tone quality, tuning, and action of the Kincora melodeon and if they can tell us how it compares with a Castagnari, an old Globe, a modern cajun accordion, etc.
PG
edited to add: sorry, cross-posted. Of course everyone is entitled to his opinion and these instruments are not cheap, so a potential buyer has to be tempted, not discouraged! My perspective is to identify with the guys who dedicate so much time and effort doing their best to add new musical instruments to the world. I want to thank and encourage them, and recognize that they may have ideas of their own (not necessarily their customers') that they want expressed in their work.
-
Interesting perspective. Like you , Paul,
I admire anyone who goes to great length to create a product.
But to attach a banner that appears to say
"look at me, look at me" does detract from an otherwise
admirable effort. So much so it seems to be an affront.
That seems to be the focus of the comments.
Back to pruning the root ball.
-
It looks a lovely instrument to me, and if I came across one in a shop I'd certainly want to have a go on it. Are there likely to be any sound files coming?
... but yes, and this is more for Martin Connolly's feedback if he ever reads this forum than anything else, if I were him I'd tone down the green badges to something much more understated*** because the first thing I'd do (personal taste alert) when I got that instrument home is find some way of taking that off or covering it up. Then I'd take the adjustable thumb strap off... so that's not a problem at all really, is it? And then I would have an instrument that looks absolutely gorgeous. I guess what's annoying to me is it is *so* close to looking perfect - I love the look of the rest of it.
Enjoy your new box - any idea how many he is making of them? What do they cost?
Cheers,
Clive
*** but now I think about it, he's not alone, is he? Castagnari and Saltarelle have both had some truly, truly, horrible logos all over their instruments in their recent history... in fact I hate, with a passion, the logo on my Mory.
I like the design...maybe a slightly lighter blue would have contrasted with the black better. And the logo could do with tweaking - from a graphic design point of view - smaller and more stylised. But on the whole looks nice.
-
I like the way it looks. The sparkly bits, labels, signature and so on are quite jolly. If I'm not mistaken, it's only quite recently that instrument builders have taken to building understated and elegant instruments, all matt varnish, natural grain, and gentle curves. There is a long and fine tradition of melodeon building in which the builder decorates the instrument with shiny metal plates, pictures of girls peeping through little windows, silver trumpets, patents, paint, multi-coloured celluloid, national flags, medals proclaiming prizes won at international trade fairs, mirrors, and the owner's name picked out in precious stones.
Brilliant.
How does it sound?
-
The problem is that in accordion and melodeon/ button box manufactuing circles the norm is to brand your product. Wouldn't it be nice to have a very simple beautifully minimalist Melodeon tastefully branded (Rees Melodeons come to mind). Instead the maker is (maybe rightfully or not) interested in marketing a brand not just a work of art. In my opinion a small trademark done artfully and tastefully w/ superb workmanship would be a huge improvement over what we see in the market today. To simply say that because Hohner has done it for years makes it acceptable while Mr Connelly's rather new product is unacceptable is a double standard, garish is garish and doing it for 100 years does not make it any less garish than someone who is new to the scene. I do agree that the Kincora melodeon above is not what I would prefer in a first rate box. The real kicker is what it sounds like, if it sounded fantastic i wouldn't give a hoot as to what it looked like. If one is going to spend a great deal of money one should probably look to a Messervier or one of Rees very nice clippers. To each his own is my mantra!
-
Back to the Kincora. Disregarding the aesthetics, there are two things that I would really like to know:
1. How does it feel?
2. How much does it cost?
Agreed - how it looks is not so important - if it sounds and feels/plays great then who cares how pretty or otherwise it is. In fact, its perceived ugliness or otherwise could very well end being an attribute in the long run.
Personally I should love to hear from anyone who has actually played it. I'm contemplating getting a 1 row box in the near future and would love to know how various models/makers compare. I've a gut feeling that I'll end up asking Rees to make me one anyway given both Steve's excellent review of the Clipper etc.
AL
-
Looking forward to hearing your new box boscaceoil. It looks great to me, but then I am the proud owner of a bunch of old Hohners that don't exactly have the world's prettiest emblem on them - but that isn't what I bought them for (:)
Oh, and one of them has green bellows :|||:
-
I like the way it looks. The sparkly bits, labels, signature and so on are quite jolly. If I'm not mistaken, it's only quite recently that instrument builders have taken to building understated and elegant instruments, all matt varnish, natural grain, and gentle curves. There is a long and fine tradition of melodeon building in which the builder decorates the instrument with shiny metal plates, pictures of girls peeping through little windows, silver trumpets, patents, paint, multi-coloured celluloid, national flags, medals proclaiming prizes won at international trade fairs, mirrors, and the owner's name picked out in precious stones.
Brilliant.
How does it sound?
Hi Everyone,
I finally found some time to record a few phrases (in the kitchen). Note the playing is not John Kimmel, Bobby Gardiner, Martin Connolly, or Paul Brock. The new Kincora melodeon is a joy to play. I like the large chrome buttons on the keyboard and the bellows is not too stiff for a new instrument. I have been used to playing hohners (I have an old globe special also!) and this instrument is a new experience. I have kept the phrases short to keep the .mp3 quality as good as possible. Hope it gives some idea of the sound of this lovely Kincora melodeon. I'll post the mp3s in 2 posts due to file size.
By the way I'll have it with me at Eigse Eatharlai Summerschool in Tipperary at the end of July (www.eatharlai.ie).
Thanks again to Martin.
Thanks
Tom.
-
Looking forward to hearing your new box boscaceoil. It looks great to me, but then I am the proud owner of a bunch of old Hohners that don't exactly have the world's prettiest emblem on them - but that isn't what I bought them for (:)
Oh, and one of them has green bellows :|||:
-
Lovely sounds, especially Home ruler. That is just the type of tune for a nice one row
-
Excellent - I love the sound of those spoon basses.
-
Well done Tom it sounds lovely!
-
Very nice sound. I love that 4 voice sound almost like a pipe organ. Sweet sounding box and well played!
-
It sounds great - looking forward to hearing a longer clip (:)
-
Many of the comments are about the ugly, obtrusive logo.
Tom (boscaceoil) is not alone with this problem: before I placed my order for a Cooperfise Perla, I asked the (Italian) maker to apply a small logo, and they promised that they would. When I received the box I was shocked by the huge, terribly obtrusive COOPERFISA logo decorated with colored fake gem (glass) stones. The sound of the accordion is superb but the logo is terrible to my taste. What can be done to get rid of these ugly logos?
Fortunately, I do not see the logo when playing ;D
-
Hohners are tastefully garish.
-
love that sound, very sharp!
-
I would just like to say that a lot of the less-than-complimentry comments about this instrument's appearance are not the sort of thing that I have come to expect from this normally supportive and encouraging community. There are probably aesthetic issues with the vast majority of boxes that we all play - but that doesn't stop either our enthusiasm or prolific outbreaks of MAD. I think it's a wonderful box - and from the pictures I've seen it's an extremely well-crafted box by a real top-rate musician and master craftsman. And the sound clips that Tom has so kindly put up only serve to confirm my original impression. This is one quality box that I, for one anyway, would give my eye-teeth to possess! And do you know what?...I wouldn't give a monkey's about the blessed logo!
AL
-
Al, I agree, I've also been surprised at the criticism of the looks of this box. Especially when you consider that the squeezebox world in general is not noted for its restrained or understated designs.
Even the traditional one row is pretty garish to my eyes with all those bits of shiny fake gold on the corners, fake gold and red pallets and gold curlicues on the ends, and then there are the bellows with red crayfish emblazoned on them. Talk about crimes against good taste and the cajun box is right up there among the leaders. By comparison the Kincora seems to me to be relatively restrained - plain black bellows, slightly less bling than usual, and all the coloured parts in a matching muted green - very tasteful.
-
The crayfish bellows are amazing, I won't hear anything said against them!!
-
Perhaps we should have a vote. How many don't agree with Miklos that the Cooperfisa logo is decidedly ugly?
-
I just love the sound of that box - it really hit the target in terms of getting that old 1920's-30's sound!
- and btw, I myself play a pale green Baldoni with loads of rhinestones and engraved ornamentation - the one box to get the most positive comments of all my boxes when speaking of looks!