Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: JimJ on June 02, 2010, 01:38:46 PM

Title: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: JimJ on June 02, 2010, 01:38:46 PM
Hi all,

I am just starting out on my road to learning the melodeon.
I have a Hohner D/G "Pokerwork" and a bunch of learning
material on order. The impression I got was that if you wanted
to learn, you were on a budget, or at least didn't want to spend
too much getting started, and you were not focused on a particular
style of music, that this was a reasonable choice for a first instrument.

I also get the impression that the D/G system is not the current
choice for traditional Irish music. Although one of the sites that I
read claims that the popularity of the B/C system is a more recent
trend. And, that if you wanted to sound like the original Irish box
players rather than the modern one, that a D/G system would do this.

I was wondering who some of the classic Irish box players are, so that
I might get to hear their recordings to see the differnece in the sound
from the modern players.  Thanks ---- JimJ
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: LDbosca on June 02, 2010, 03:19:01 PM
Hi all,

I am just starting out on my road to learning the melodeon.
I have a Hohner D/G "Pokerwork" and a bunch of learning
material on order. The impression I got was that if you wanted
to learn, you were on a budget, or at least didn't want to spend
too much getting started, and you were not focused on a particular
style of music, that this was a reasonable choice for a first instrument.

I also get the impression that the D/G system is not the current
choice for traditional Irish music. Although one of the sites that I
read claims that the popularity of the B/C system is a more recent
trend. And, that if you wanted to sound like the original Irish box
players rather than the modern one, that a D/G system would do this.

I was wondering who some of the classic Irish box players are, so that
I might get to hear their recordings to see the differnece in the sound
from the modern players.  Thanks ---- JimJ


The D/G melodeon was never really popular for Irish music, it's been single row, then C#/D (or similar configurations) and more recently (50s/60s on) B/C. Although there's one or two people doing it, I'd say it's more or less the wrong instrument for Irish music. It might be worth looking up Tim Edey tho, he plays D/G and I think does some Irish stuff on it, that might be helpful.

Apart from that, someone like Tony McMahon or Joe Cooley might give you an idea of the older style. McMahon plays C#/D and Cooley plays D/D#, which is similar to C#/D. Although their boxes are different to your D/G, they do some playing on one row (B/C involves playing across rows), which might transfer to the D/G better than B/C playing.

Other people on this forum know a lot more about D/G boxes than I do, they might be able to help more.

Luke.
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: tedrick on June 02, 2010, 04:27:45 PM
If you'd like to get an idea of what the D/G is capable of, there's a great D/G player out on youtube - Cathy Cook - http://www.youtube.com/user/cathycook1

the benefit of D/G is the basses are a lot more easy to use

Tim Edey has some youtube vids out there on the D/G as well - check him out

You are going to have a blast learning Irish tunes on the D/G - just jump in and start learning and playing tunes you enjoy.
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: juker on June 02, 2010, 08:55:28 PM
Thanks for this link - Cathy's playing is excellent.
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: mikesamwild on June 03, 2010, 06:50:33 PM
D/G is a good allround box and Dave Mallinson does good on one for irish music as does Tim Edey
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: NeilA on June 03, 2010, 08:23:01 PM
If you'd like to get an idea of what the D/G is capable of, there's a great D/G player out on youtube - Cathy Cook - http://www.youtube.com/user/cathycook1

Yes indeed - listening to this got me interested in learning the melodeon.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKrulqVhN_M&playnext_from=TL&videos=Uzu7-1tZdwY (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKrulqVhN_M&playnext_from=TL&videos=Uzu7-1tZdwY)
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: EeeJay on June 03, 2010, 10:14:36 PM
Another D/G player worth a mention (before Steve J mentions it) is the late Simon Melia from down under - thankfully, some of his playing made it to CD... (http://www.acrosstheborders.com.au/cdshop-melia.htm) 8)

It's one of those recordings that goes to prove how darn right a Pokerwork can sound when it's played good... :|glug

Ed J
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 03, 2010, 10:20:07 PM
This is my favourite Tim Edey Clip (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ) of him playing Irish tunes on D/G - and of course he's now produced a DVD  (http://www.melbay.com/product.asp?ProductID=FA005) about playing Irish on D/G melodeon.
AL
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: Tony Gibbons on June 03, 2010, 10:45:44 PM
I agree, AL, lovely bit of playing. Just shows there is nothing wrong in playing Irish on a D/G. I've done it all my playing life and I guess I won't change now but I will say, "watch the basses". Nothing wrong in playing them but with irish music it does not want to sound as if it's a morris dance tune. Keep the basses very light and in some cases fairly sparse. I vary what I do in the bass end, sometimes using only a bass note and no chord, other times just using a chord. I have no rules, it's purely down to intuition, knowledge of the tune and general feel for what goes best.
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: Owen Woods on June 03, 2010, 10:52:20 PM
Agreed. I've found that virtually the only think I can do is stick in the odd chord (no bass) on the offbeat. Apparently it works, I've had some compliments from Irish players, but if I'm honest I'd rather be playing Morris ;)
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: JimJ on June 03, 2010, 11:02:24 PM
Thanks for all the links and names. I just want to clear up.
I am a toltal newbie. I have not made any musical style
choices yet. That is part of the reason I chose the D/G box.
It is my understanding that it is very versitle when it comes
to being useful in many different styles. Some day I may
decide to specialize, although at my age I probably won't
get good enough for it to matter.

I did find the quote that got me thinking about all of this. It
is on the Eagle Music sight in their FAQ for accordions. Here
it is in part.

Irish music, what type of box do I need?
Traditional Irish music... As a point of interest, it is a commonly held belief that it is easier to play Irish music on a diatonic than it is English style on a chromatic. It is perfectly possible to play Irish Traditional Music to a very high standard on the D/G diatonic melodeon; in fact until the 1940’s and early 1950’s the D/G and 1-rows were highly favoured. If you want to sound like one of the older traditionalists, a diatonic is the one to choose. It wasn’t until players like Paddy O’Brien came along that the modern Irish accordion style developed. They realised that switching to the B/C system had several advantages. Firstly, the fact that the C row comprises of all natural notes and the B row is all sharps and flats.

Thanks again for all the responses --- JimJ
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: EeeJay on June 04, 2010, 11:04:17 AM
Quote from: Eagle Music Website
It is perfectly possible to play Irish Traditional Music to a very high standard on the D/G diatonic melodeon; in fact until the 1940's and early 1950's the D/G and 1-rows were highly favoured.

Not 100% accurate... D boxes yes indeed... but from what I gather, D/G was far less widespread at this time than what is implied here (and only really came into wider manufacture/vogue from the 1950s). Various other semitone combinations C/C#, D/D# or G/G# were in use though... sometimes played 'outside-in' style...

Quote from: Eagle Music Website
It wasn't until players like Paddy O'Brien came along that the modern Irish accordion style developed. They realised that switching to the B/C system had several advantages. Firstly, the fact that the C row comprises of all natural notes and the B row is all sharps and flats.

Well yes - but the same could be said of C/C#. This supposed logic is not the key reason why B/C became so dominant... it's more so to do with how other keys, such as D and A, sit on the 'draw of the box'. This sound came to be more 'accepted' as 'traditional' (despite the whole newness of the concept) and the demand for big red Paolos took off...

Besides... Paddy O'Brien pinched the B/C idea from the Scots... ;)

Ed J
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: nfldbox on June 04, 2010, 05:27:12 PM
A good source, mentioned a few times on "the session" is Graeme Smith's "Modern-style Irish Accordion Playing" in Ethnomusicology 41:3 (1997)
Title: Re: Newbie question on classic players
Post by: Gromit on June 04, 2010, 11:42:07 PM
You were asking about classic Irish box players - this guy Darren Breslin plays in an older (ish) style and not too fast, I think his music has a real swing to it. I believe he plays a B/C.

Video clip here

http://comhaltas.ie/music/detail/comhaltaslive_319_1_darren_breslin_and_david_phelan/
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal