Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Don Roberts on June 02, 2010, 04:28:05 PM
-
I am curious if there are CBA players on this forum that have chosen one system over the other and why.
I have been playing the C griff and am doing ok with it but still would like to give the B griff a try to better understand the difference.
I'm attracted to the three row bayan style as I think it fits the upper body more naturally somewhat like a PA.
Any comments are appreciated
-
I don't understand what any of this means, and would like to.
G
-
I am curious if there are CBA players on this forum that have chosen one system over the other and why.
....
Me too.
Seems as if many of us just start playing the system which is dominant in the area you live in. For instance, with my Roland I could have chosen any system but I started to use the Finnish C-griff (because these instrument are available here on the market). Still, I know of a couple of prominent players in our country (contest winners etc.) who first used the C-system but then later moved to B-griff and stayed there. For us mortals it is not a minor task to relearn all tunes you've taken the time to learn, if switching to another system.
-
I don't understand what any of this means, and would like to.
G
Believe it or not, This Wikipedia article (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromatic_button_accordion) has a pair of good diagrams that show the difference in a nutshell.
Then if you want to get into the intricacies of playing chords, scales etc. on B vs. C system and loads of other detail try http://www.thecipher.com/chromatic-accordion-cipher.html (http://www.thecipher.com/chromatic-accordion-cipher.html)
-
You know I have checked out those resources and I can see the difference but it is not like actually playing and experiencing the difference.
The finnish system looks almost like a hybrid between the c and b griff system.
There was a nice Hagstrom accordion on Craigslist for some time, I studied the photo on several occasions and finally determined that it was the finnish layout.
-
in the Uk the C system is the most common and the B system relatively rare in comparison. Probably bnecause of this B system boxes are often much cheaper and dtherefore there are bargains to be had!. For anyubody starting from scratch I don't think it makes any difference which of the two systems is chosen as , not unlike the national/regional preferences for melodeon layouts/tuning the choice between the 2 continental systems seems to be very much regional. for what itsw worth I know a number of professional continental players who swear by the B system although to me the C system is more preferable - but this is probably because I can play C system & can't play B system
george
-
Don - if you are able to visit, I've got a three row B-griff and you could have a try on it - although I guess from the time shown on your posts that we may be on different continents! B-griff is the only system I've ever handled (couldn't resist a bargain) and it was so intuitive that I had a couple of tunes within a day, I guess C-griff would be just as easy; it's the CBA idea rather than the system that counts. Having said all that, I haven't touched it for a few weeks now as I didn't find it as satisfying to play as a melodeon or a BCC#. Regards BLT.
-
Thanks Tony, if I'm ever in your neck of the woods I'll take you up on the offer.
-
as I didn't find it as satisfying to play as a melodeon or a BCC#. Regards BLT.
[/quote]
this is very much my experience. In theory the continental chromatic ( either system) is the most sensible box of the lot- it just doesn't provide the same level of 'job satisfaction' as the British Chromatic.
george
-
George, regarding the BCC#/stradella, I notice that Castiglione accordions lists two used Hibernian brand accordions. One is said to have 45 bass from E to Ab. Is this a common setup on the bass ? They also list a 60 bass. I'm wondering what is the most useful of the two ?
Thank you
Tony your comments are welcome as well
-
the continental chromatic ( either system) is the most sensible box of the lot- it just doesn't provide the same level of 'job satisfaction' as the British Chromatic.
I play both button diatonic and button chromatic, buttons are very important to me; but I simply cannot decide which I love best, I play them all and I choose the button box that I think is the "most traditional" for the region the tune comes from:
- gleichtoned boxes for Bavarian, Austrian tunes
- D/G or A/D/G for English
- button chromatic for Hungarian
- B/C or button chromatic (learning tunes from a Karen Tweed tutor CD-ROM) for Irish
- C one-row (Cajun tuned) for Cajun
- Liliiputs for anything
I am happy that I can play a couple of tunes on each of my button boxes.
-
George, regarding the BCC#/stradella, I notice that Castiglione accordions lists two used Hibernian brand accordions. One is said to have 45 bass from E to Ab. Is this a common setup on the bass ? They also list a 60 bass. I'm wondering what is the most useful of the two ?
Thank you
Tony your comments are welcome as well
assuming the number of treble buttons & voices & size & weight are the same on both boxes and the price is the same I would poersonally go for the 60 bass as you get 7th chords. 45 is a very unusual for stradella bass - could it be a misprint for 48 (12x4)or is it 9x5 in which case it would also have 7ths.
george
-
You know I have checked out those resources and I can see the difference but it is not like actually playing and experiencing the difference.
The finnish system looks almost like a hybrid between the c and b griff system.
There was a nice Hagstrom accordion on Craigslist for some time, I studied the photo on several occasions and finally determined that it was the finnish layout.
The only difference between the Continental and Finnish C-griff systems is that the three outer rows of the continental system are the three middle rows in finnish system. If one is able to transpose then one can use both systems.
Interestingly, research has shown that the Finnish system actually is the older and original Stradella treble layout by the inventor (Italy). The current C-griff layout was developed later by his rivals, perhaps to avoid patent issues, as some have said, but I that is just a rumor. The Finns sticked with the original system while the new system spread in other parts of the Europe, still so though it would be very easy to get continental layouts from Sweden today.
EDIT: With the finnish system you mostly play with the three middle rows. Is it so that with the continental system you mostly play with the three outer rows? If that is the case then I can understand why some prominent players prefer the Finnish layout as you may have a little better hand position, I might think.
-
in the Uk the C system is the most common and the B system relatively rare in comparison. Probably bnecause of this B system boxes are often much cheaper and dtherefore there are bargains to be had!. ...
george
Applies here as well. Even the C-griff accordions are fairly cheap here.
-
Finland?
Cheap?? ???
-
There seems to be quite a number of mostly C griff instruments and fewer B griff that show up on Ebay here in the US. Most Often, they are priced too high and few people ever bid so they just go off. There just isn't much of a market for them apparently.
-
Its interesting that the CBA which I think nearly everyone would agree is a logical, consitent, sensible and highly capable system has made so little headway in so may musics whereas the illogical, limited, inconsistent and idiosyncratic diatonic accordion is so popular!
-
I agree - but I think that where the CBA has made the greatest headway is of course in the realm of classical & Jazz music where it's now overtaken the PA in most parts of the world and certainly here in the Uk is doing a good job of catching up. The demands are different - both musically and technically - and the level of study and commitment needed to succeed in the classical arena is immense. To that extent, no matter how logical the system, the overall perception I think that many folk have is that the big box with loads of buttons is complicated - whereas the little, lightweight, diatonic box with much fewer buttons is easier. The facts couldn't be more different. To play either well demands a high level of study, practise and commitment - but I do think that size, weight and perceptions have a part to play in the success of the humble melodeon within the contemporary music scene - as well as tradition, of course.
AL
-
[[[I didn't find it as satisfying to play as a melodeon or a BCC#. Regards BLT.
[/quote]
couldn't be less true for me.....i am in the process of ditching b/c box but for the occasional workout so as not to forget how to play it.......with cba, i feel like a bird released from a musical cage. the pre-decided directional changes and concomitant pre-set phrasing forced on you by the diatonic two-row system, the way the box mechanism fights the pulse of the tune if that pulse doesn't fall within the mechanism's push/pull emphasis biases, along with the harmonic limitations on right-hand chording or double stops, not to even begin to talk about the limitations of those stupid basses, began to infuriate me. the cba or any unisonoric box won't really do that one-row push-pull sound, though it can come close....but that is the only limit i perceive.....and the added value in what you can do with it is mind-boggling.
now, if only the makers would start producing compact eight-or-nine-pound two-voice, three-row, thirty-noters with thirty-six basses (12 counter-basses, 12 tonic basses, and twelve major chords, with a stop to remove the thirds)......i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
-
I take it you like em ? ;D
Well so do I. So much so that I can't seem to find time to practice my c#/d. I do however still love the PA for some things.
-
now, if only the makers would start producing compact eight-or-nine-pound two-voice, three-row, thirty-noters with thirty-six basses (12 counter-basses, 12 tonic basses, and twelve major chords, with a stop to remove the thirds)......i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
I think that you may be right there. But then if makers made anything that is light, compact, with three rows and stradella bass it would be successful I think.
-
i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
Is it a chromatic or a BCC# box?
-
if makers made anything that is light, compact, with three rows and stradella bass it would be successful I think.
Agree - except that most makrs actually see their CBA market much more in terms of classical and jazz markets I think, where big heavy boxes that can do it all are much more likely to sell. The folk market is already pretty much saturated with all sorts of variant small boxes as it is I guess?
AL
-
now, if only the makers would start producing compact eight-or-nine-pound two-voice, three-row, thirty-noters with thirty-six basses (12 counter-basses, 12 tonic basses, and twelve major chords, with a stop to remove the thirds)......i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
Isn't that the sort of instrument that Dom Riviere plays?
-
[[[I didn't find it as satisfying to play as a melodeon or a BCC#. Regards BLT.
couldn't be less true for me.....i am in the process of ditching b/c box but for the occasional workout so as not to forget how to play it.......with cba, i feel like a bird released from a musical cage. the pre-decided directional changes and concomitant pre-set phrasing forced on you by the diatonic two-row system, the way the box mechanism fights the pulse of the tune if that pulse doesn't fall within the mechanism's push/pull emphasis biases, along with the harmonic limitations on right-hand chording or double stops, not to even begin to talk about the limitations of those stupid basses, began to infuriate me. the cba or any unisonoric box won't really do that one-row push-pull sound, though it can come close....but that is the only limit i perceive.....and the added value in what you can do with it is mind-boggling.
now, if only the makers would start producing compact eight-or-nine-pound two-voice, three-row, thirty-noters with thirty-six basses (12 counter-basses, 12 tonic basses, and twelve major chords, with a stop to remove the thirds)......i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
[/quote]
I once had a roayal standard 3 row con;tinental with 24 bass, poweerfull little bugger & same size & weight as an erica.phrasing on a sook an blaw box is entirely down to the player & in particular the degree of fine bellows control. As far as right hanad chords the BCC# offers far greater possibilities than the 2 row although not as many as the continental. I do agree about the useless bass on semitone 2 row boxes
george
-
now, if only the makers would start producing compact eight-or-nine-pound two-voice, three-row, thirty-noters with thirty-six basses (12 counter-basses, 12 tonic basses, and twelve major chords, with a stop to remove the thirds)......i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
Something a bit like this? http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/1315 (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/1315)
Steve
-
[something a bit like this?] yes, but at eleven pounds, it's still too heavy. and the limited bass tonic notes are silly. the full twelve in three rows---counter-basses, basses, plus a chordal row with removable thirds so you can play minor, diminished, whatever, would be lighter and more chromatically versatile....plus, if they put their minds to it, they could get another pound and a half or so out just by doing some structural re-engineering.....actually, something looking like this, but with MM rather than the single M.....that is a skeletal freebass, which actually would work fine for irish or other world folk music. or, just three rows of basses, counter-basses, and chords with stoopper for the third.....
http://www.akkordeoncentrum.de/english/shop/001432,details_Borsini_Prelude_Mini___K%3Eauch_in_K%C3%B6ln_erh%C3%A4ltlich.html
-
Is it even possible to have a stop for the thirds on a stradella bass accordion without having extra reeds? I can't offhand think of a way of doing it.
-
Is it even possible to have a stop for the thirds on a stradella bass accordion without having extra reeds?
Maybe by mechanical linkage...
-
pesumably the 6 or so bass couplers on some larger boxes enable virtually any comb;ination of reeds.
george
-
I think that I need to find a massive box and take it to pieces. I honestly can't work out how to do it :|bl
-
The linkage for converter (Stradella <-> free bass) boxes must be mind-boggling :o
-
i have an 11.5 pounder sixty-bass, but there is still plenty of scope to get a good three pounds off that and still create a brilliantly versatile yet portable box for world folk music.....those things would take over the world....
Is it a chromatic or a BCC# box?
a BCC# is a chromatic box! and is officialy known as a Bitish Chromatic Accordion
george ;D
-
is officialy known as a Bitish Chromatic Accordion
Which 'Bit' Bites? ;D
-
The linkage for converter (Stradella <-> free bass) boxes must be mind-boggling :o
the normal stradella 120 bass linkage is a mine field of wire rods & linkages so the converter must be even more so - but the bloke who invented the stradella system must be a bit of a genius
george
-
pesumably the 6 or so bass couplers on some larger boxes enable virtually any comb;ination of reeds.
george
Not really. The couplers switch in different 'footages' of reeds, e.g. 16', 8', 8-4'(don't ask), 4', 2'. The Roland 7 bass couplers give the following combinations: 2', 4', 8-4', 16'/8'/8-4'/4'/2', 8'/4'/2', 16'/8'/8-4', 16'/2'. No matter what coupler you're on, you'll still get a 3-note major chord. You could make it very squeaky (only 2' reeds), but you can't switch out the thirds with the bass couplers.
-
The linkage for converter (Stradella <-> free bass) boxes must be mind-boggling :o
Its really two mechanisms in one box, the converter switch just connect the buttons to one or other part of the mechanism. In the only one I've looked inside that part of it was pretty simple. Actually three mechanisms in one box because a standard stradella has two more or less separate machines one of the basses, and one for the chords.
-
[a BCC# is a chromatic box! and is officially known as a British Chromatic Accordion]
ha, i guess it's "define your terms" time.....i was using "chromatic" in the sloppy, technically incorrect usage that has evolved where people say "chromatic'" when they really mean, unisonoric.
yes, the BCC# is "chromatic," but then so are other boxes often sloppily called "diatonic," such as the two-row semitone systems, b/c, c#/d. all are "fully chromatic." when people call those boxes "diatonic," they are really meaning to say, "bisonoric."
so more accurately, i guess i'm saying, i find it vastly more satisfying from an expressive and phrasing standpoint to play on a unisonoric box.....but i will say that i didn't feel this with PA. it's that it is unisonoric, with buttons, and with the pattern layout, of cba. after years of bisonoric playing, it's like getting out of jail.
-
i was using "chromatic" in the sloppy, technically incorrect usage that has evolved where people say "chromatic'" when they really mean, unisonoric.
yes, the BCC# is "chromatic," but then so are other boxes often sloppily called "diatonic," such as the two-row semitone systems,
We're certainly on thin ice if we head in that direction.
A Russian two-row Garmoshka is diatonic (notes of one major scale only) AND unisonoric.
-
i find it vastly more satisfying from an expressive and phrasing standpoint to play on a unisonoric box.....but i will say that i didn't feel this with PA. it's that it is unisonoric, with buttons, and with the pattern layout, of cba. after years of bisonoric playing, it's like getting out of jail.
I am very much interested in your story in details, please.
I love both systems, I feel in jail a little bit when playing either one of my bisonosics or my unisonoric for a longer period of time. When I start feeling "in-jail" after a couple/number of days of playing one system, I switch to to the other one to "get out of jail". Then, after a couple/number of days of playing the "in-jail" feeling starts again, and I have to switch back to the other system. Or, back to my pipes.
-
[a BCC# is a chromatic box! and is officially known as a British Chromatic Accordion]
ha, i guess it's "define your terms" time.....i was using "chromatic" in the sloppy, technically incorrect usage that has evolved where people say "chromatic'" when they really mean, unisonoric.
yes, the BCC# is "chromatic," but then so are other boxes often sloppily called "diatonic," such as the two-row semitone systems, b/c, c#/d. all are "fully chromatic." when people call those boxes "diatonic," they are really meaning to say, "bisonoric."
I think the only sensible starting point is that they are all 'accordions'. The most common chromatic box being the piano accordion followed by the continental chromatic B & C systems, both of which have one note per key or button. Thge BCC# is also chromatic whilst having 2 notes per button and the 2 row semi;tone boxes eg BC, Cc# etc or chromatic but difficult to play in some keys. The true diatonic boxes only have the notes ,whether one or two notes per button, to play in a limited number of keys and are therefore not chromatic.
I ;thought this would be easy to define but having tried I'm not sure
george :-\
-
well....the bisonoric button accordion started with the diatonic one-row, which was not "chromatic" because it did not have all tones and semi-tones. the point of the two-row bisonorics was to have a "fully chromatic" box. but people often still call two-rows "diatonic" despite the fact that they are as "chromatic" in the tone sense as the unisonoric "chromatic accordion" or "CBA." and the bisonoric b/c/c# is known as the "british chromatic" even though it's bisonoric like the two-rows which technically speaking are also "chromatic" but never get called "chromatic." and i'm as loosey-goosey about those odd distinctions as anybody.
-
I failed to win another 3 row griff on eBay :(
-
Try getting tutor books or dvd's for either of these systems and you will find it pretty frustrating. C giif has the advantage because there are a couple of poor books for it There seem to be none available for the B system. I find it unbelievable that there is so little out there for the learner.
-
Not really, if you read French there are excellent tutor books.
-
Yes. And there are probably some excellent ones in Russian. Have you missed my point?
-
Try getting tutor books or dvd's for either of these systems and you will find it pretty frustrating. C giif has the advantage because there are a couple of poor books for it
What are the two poor books you've identified for the C system?
-
C giif has the advantage because there are a couple of poor books for it
The following tutors are excellent for C system:
COMPLETE METHOD FOR ACCORDION by L. O. Anzaghi
(text in English)
and
METODO PER FISARMONICA by Cambieri – Fugazza – Melocchi
(text is in English)
I use the Anzaghi edition myself everyday as it covers both the PA & CBA.
Also available and an excellent book is L’ACCORDEON BOUTONS PAR L’IMAGE by Michel Lorin
It's easy to understand, starting straight off with treble and bass clef together. Text is in French but it is still relatively easy to follow.
All of which are readily available, at least here in the UK anyway - I tend to get my accordion music from Trevani.
AL
-
C giif has the advantage because there are a couple of poor books for it
The following tutors are excellent for C system:
COMPLETE METHOD FOR ACCORDION by L. O. Anzaghi
(text in English)
I tried to learn PA from this one, too. It's very well put together, although a lot of work if you hope to get anywhere near the end (I didn't...). There are also two companion books of graded music that go with it, mostly of a classical nature, but accessible enough all the same.
-
Regarding the original topic, when looking for something else bumped into this site:
http://home.swipnet.se/nydana/accordion.html
Scroll downwards to 'B-system features'.
-
thanks risto, a good comparison between the two systems. I am feeling more and more confident with the C system, altho I have been tempted to try the B griff I think I will stick with the C
I have located a 5 row model, Serenelli, of Italian manufacture, LMM, more swing tuned than musette, will probably make a deal on it tomarrow.
-
I chose "B" system because the hand position seemed more natural, and the thumb was poised over the keyboard ready to drop in lower harmony notes or share the playing with the fingers. On smaller accordions where the right hand is higher up (nearer to the chin), this may not work quite as well. But for me, it seemed natural at the time (22years ago) and I am happy with the decision!. I play a 5-row 120bass Vignoni, which is quite compact! but I understand that many players prefer smaller accordions.
John
-
I play a 5-row 120bass Vignoni,
Sounds great any chance of a clip or a pic?
AL
-
.... altho I have been tempted to try the B griff ...
We have been discussing this same thing on a Finnish board and I decided to try the B-system, at least to learn one tune with it. For my Roland I changed the button colours like in the pic attached. In the Finnish C-griff and Bayan B-system the note C is in the same place, found only in the middle row and that I left white. The first impression is that the hand position is better with the B-sys, didn't take long to find the scales either.
-
well that's interesting, keep us informed as you progress. maybe you will prefer the b system after all?
-
Sounds great any chance of a clip or a pic?
AL
Does this work?- sorry, I'm experimenting here- not done this before
-
beautiful instrument !
-
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4169.0;attach=3389;image)
Yep - echo the sentiment - a real beauty! Although not so compact - just looking at all the couplers - how many voices does it have on each side?
AL
-
It's 4 reeds in the RH LMMM, and I think 5 in the LH so yes, it's quite heavy - but it speaks easily and can be played in/out/in/out as fast as most melodions. I think perhaps we've digressed a little from the thread title?
John
-
This is my follow-up post. I bought a small traditional bayan (3-row B-system chromatic button accordion) from Ukraine to learn a couple of tunes on the bayan using the traditional way: four fingers and thumb behind the keyboard.
The first thing you should notice is that the keyboard of traditional bayan is not aligned with the back of the accordion body, instead, it is placed towards the middle. This is perfectly devised to support the traditional "four fingers and thumb behind the keyboard" style of playing. And here comes the meaning of the B-system layout: for this style of playing my experience showed that the B system is (much) better and meaningful.
On the other hand, playing with 5 finger hand hovering over the this protruded positioned keyboard is terribly inconvenient. For 5-finger playing style the back-aligned keyboard.
My guess is that a 5-row bayan (B-system) with back-aligned keyboard was invented to support 5-finger playing: the conservatory style. I think that for 5-finger style there is no really difference and preference for the C or B button layout.
I tried to play my C-system box with thumb behind the keyboard, and it did not work at all: only 5-finger style or "thumb on the edge" worked.