Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: folkman on June 03, 2010, 09:09:51 PM

Title: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 03, 2010, 09:09:51 PM
Will be getting my first melodeon next month...at long last. As a complete beginner who has never really played an instrument before, I am totally reliant upon the expertise and experience of others.
The music shop folk were very helpful and have suggested a GR4205 Scarlatti Nero as a good 'starter', bearing in mind that available funds are a factor here.
Would very much appreciate your thoughts/comments/suggestions. I am only interested in learning to play English traditional folk, especially morris tunes.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Anahata on June 03, 2010, 09:20:26 PM
Look for a good second hand Hohner pokerwork, Erica or similar. They go on eBay for similar prices to the new Scarlatti and if you decide to upgrade in the future your old box will still have some resale value, while the Scarlatti will have fallen to bits.

Plus it's a perfectly respectable morris and session box to have, whereas the Scarlatti will scream "newbie!" at anyone who knows the difference.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Christopher K. on June 03, 2010, 09:21:22 PM
Welcome to the world of melodeon playing!  :||:  :||:

Having only played older, dodgy Scarlatti boxes, I can't vouch for the new ones. But several posters in this forum have indicated that their quality is improving, and the price is certainly right. Given that you won't know what you'd like to be different or improved in a particular box until you've had experiences with several, a Nero or something comparable might not be a bad investment as a first box. If you like it then go for it! Nothing beats getting started in a hurry when you're eager to learn.

Having come to the box a few years ago with only limited experience in boxes and much experience in strings, I'd say get a Pokerwork or Erica in D/G tuning and you cannot go wrong. If you stick with the instrument then you've got an instrument for life. If you give it up, then you've got its strong resale value. On the other hand, buying the Nero now and in person will be far less of a hassle than finding a used Hohner and paying and waiting while its tuning and action are fettled up to snuff. I think with no musical experience, a Nero is a good "step one" and a used, quality Hohner is a good "step two" once you know what you're into and feeling up to it.

Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 03, 2010, 09:26:54 PM
This has given me something to think about already! Also, do you think the weight of the instrument has any bearing (as my wife seems to think) ie are some noticeably heavier than others?
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 03, 2010, 09:36:10 PM
I think that cpsmart has it about right. I've recently purchased a Scarlatti 'Rosso' which is the B/C tuned version of the D/G 'Nero'. It has the thirds stop available in the bass end to enable you to take out the thirds of each chord - hence giving you more accompaniment options - which is something that you have to pay a LOT more for in most other makes of box. I love the feel and play of it - the box is very light (weight no problem) and in fact I prefer it to most of the Pokerwork's that I've played - (although an Erica is a different matter). I would say go for it - it's a very good box - much improved on the earlier Scarlati's which were not very good. The Nero/Rosso range is very good value for money in my opinion and it is an eminently playable box worthy of sitting in any session. And as for Anahata's comment about it screaming 'newbie' - well, that's what you are aren't you? I thoroughly recommend the box. And then think about a used Hohner that may need a bit of fettling etc further on down the road - or maybe even pushing the boat out out for a more expensive box if circumstances allow at some other point. Hope this helps? Oh - welcome to melodeonworld by the way  ;D
AL
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Anahata on June 03, 2010, 09:39:03 PM
do you think the weight of the instrument has any bearing (as my wife seems to think) ie are some noticeably heavier than others?
They aren't all the same weight, but for a cheap 2 voice two-row weight isn't really an issue because they are all quite light.

When you get to 4-row Steirische boxes (described somewhere around here as like strapping a wardrobe on your chest) 120 bass piano accordions etc. you can start worrying about weight.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 03, 2010, 09:50:38 PM
In view of what has been said so far, I'm inclined, at least at the moment, to go for the Nero. Another important factor is that I probably haven't got the patience to keep looking on ebay as I am 'raring to go'. As long as the Nero is suitable for a novice like me, and it seems that way by the response so far, then at least I can go to the shop at the designated hour and come away with one and start learning....
The weight would not appear to be a problem which is a bit of a relief.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 03, 2010, 10:00:05 PM
The Pokerwork is THE classic English trad and Morris box and there seems to be a big movement back towards Hohners underway at the moment so you'll be in good company with one. I think Anahata's spot on, you'll see many accomplished players, even some of the very best, playing Hohners in sessions or for Morris and even a restored Made in Germany one in tip top condition isn't going to be too expensive and will hold its value if you fall into the clutches of Melodeon Acquisition Disease and want to sell it to fund a posh box.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 03, 2010, 10:10:57 PM
I think that Andy has a very valid point - however I would say that your best bet for a used Hohner would NOt be to buy off eBay. Get it from someone trusted and reliable - like our own Theo on this forum - or have a chat with him first about it if buying a used box and build in the price of a basic fettle into what you'd be spending just getting it.

Finally - the 'Nero' will not let you down. It's a basic box with a couple of extras that all but the most expensive of other boxes won't offer. The thing to do is go to the shop and sit down and try the Nero and compare it with a new hohner pokerwork - then compare the price. I think you'll find it's a no-brainer!
Regards
AL
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: GbH on June 03, 2010, 10:59:34 PM
This might be an obvious point, but for the sort of music you're wanting to play, you should make sure you get a 'D/G' instrument.  That is, with the rows tuned in D and G, with the D row being on the outside. 
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: melodeon on June 04, 2010, 05:19:36 AM
Another vote for a used Hohner Pokerwork or Erica.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: tim54 on June 04, 2010, 07:13:18 AM
Hiya

My vote also goes to the D/G Erica or Pokerwork. I use my 25 year old Erica for morris because they are loud enough to cut the mustard outside.

The old german models appear robust enough to take years of rain, spilled beer and general abuse and still come back for more. Mine's had a new set of bellows (Chinese) and one new spring during all those years......and it's got a shiny chrome grille :-)

Tim
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 04, 2010, 07:25:14 AM
D/G basic box as everyone says.

Many of us started there. Although a better box may be slightly easier to play - the pokerwork 'works' and if you buy second hand you'll not lose much should you later bottle out.

Or "more likely" ;) you'll love the instrument and move on to Costalotti and co as I did. I've had about 10 instruments over 24 years though I've tried to keep to 5 or less at any time.  The steady 'MAD' drift to better kit spins off a steady stream of good quality used entry level boxes- so with a bit of shopping round at festivals or here you won't be ripped off or disappointed.  :|glug  Chris
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Bananayogi on June 04, 2010, 09:06:20 AM
The Nero is £350 at Hobgoblin.
The Pokerwork is £500 on special offer at the Music Room.

They are, I think, both Chinese made boxes nowadays, but I would still stump up the extra £150 for the Hohner. You'll get the extra back if and when you sell it.

Personally I would buy an Erica - my favourite variety of Hohner (in D/G as others have said). The bass end is way more comfortable to play, apart from the fact that it looks nicer   :D

Edit - A few weeks ago, the Music Room had an even specialer :) offer - Pokerworks were £399. It might be worth a cheeky phone call to see if they'll be repeating the offer? At a difference of £50 between the Nero and the Pokerwork it would be a total no-brainer as they say!
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: nemethmik on June 04, 2010, 09:17:40 AM
I would not buy a new instrument in any way; it was a big mistake of mine when I bough new accordions. Used instruments retuned and revalved are the way to go, IMHO. I'd never buy a new accordion again.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: OwenG on June 04, 2010, 09:59:36 AM
There's a Sandpiper for sale over in the Buy and Sell . . .  ;)
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 10:07:38 AM
This is exactly why I joined the site....to get advice like this from people who know what they are talking about and who are genuinely interested in helping beginners like myself. I am going to sit down and evaluate all the points made over the weekend and see what I come up with. The good news is that I may be able to stretch my funds a bit more to get something more worthwhile!
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Theo on June 04, 2010, 10:09:00 AM
When you have thought it through you can post a 'wanted' in the buy and sell section.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 04, 2010, 10:20:59 AM
Quote
The good news is that I may be able to stretch my funds a bit more to get something more worthwhile!

Aah! It's so rewarding to be able to detect such early signs of MAD ;D
Well done!
AL  ;D
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 11:18:14 AM
If I consider a Pokerwork or an Erica, which seem to be very popular choices, is there much of a difference between the new ones and older used models? I am now starting to think that I should be considering a used one as you appear to get more for your money but, for example, is a S/H Pokerwork that is only 2 years old as good as one that is say 10 years old? If not, is there some sort of cut-off point where you would say only consider ones made before that date?
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 04, 2010, 11:21:27 AM
Generally speaking the older German made models (preferably with the wooden treble button board rather than plastic) are deemed to be better than the more recent chinese made ones.
AL
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Bananayogi on June 04, 2010, 12:48:15 PM
I wouldn't worry about it too much.

I have a couple of plastic treble ended German made boxes. One has been recently tuned, the other hasn't been touched since I bought it new about 25 years ago. Probably I'm just used to it, but it still sounds OK to me.

The 'ideal' thing would be for you to find an older model Erica or Pokerwork that has been fettled by Theo or Rees (other fettlers are also available!).  As a newbie, buying a used box off Ebay or elsewhere is probably not recomended - you'll need to get it looked at anyway which will add to the cost.

If I were you I would:
a) drop Rees and Theo an email to see if they know of any boxes that might be available
b) pop a wanted note on the forum here (I recently bought a nice D/G Erica for my son by doing that) - people here are honest in their descriptions of their instruments
c) Keep your eye on the for sale forum here (that Sandpiper proto looks like good value if you want low notes rather than accidentals)
d) If none of those bear fruit, buy a new Pokerwork or Erica wherever you can get it cheapest.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 04, 2010, 12:48:53 PM
Actually the Sandpiper would probably be a good bet.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: nemethmik on June 04, 2010, 12:50:29 PM
the older German made models (preferably with the wooden treble button board rather than plastic) are deemed to be better
My Hohner Victoria Bb/Eb that I bought off ebay and had retuned/revalved is the best (excellent mechanics with powerful sound) of all my accordions including expensive posh Italian boxes.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 01:15:54 PM
One decision I have made is not to buy from ebay! As a 'Newbie' it is obvious that, at the moment, I know very little about what is good and what is bad so, if I am going to go for a used box, and I'm really starting to think that this is the best option, I will hopefully buy it from someone connected to this site by way of the Buy/Sell section or direct from someone like Theo.
Every reply I get to my original post is helpful in it's own way and are much appreciated.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Gandy on June 04, 2010, 01:24:11 PM
Generally speaking the older German made models (preferably with the wooden treble button board rather than plastic) are deemed to be better than the more recent chinese made ones.
AL

Mine is 30 years old, with plastic keyboard.  Wooden keyboard is going to mean what, 40 or 50 years old? 
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Bananayogi on June 04, 2010, 01:32:08 PM
Mine is 30 years old, with plastic keyboard.  Wooden keyboard is going to mean what, 40 or 50 years old? 

I'd guess so. And unless it has already been tuned/restored you'd have to factor in the possible/probable extra cost of having that done. As a group of MAD-affected buyers I guess we all know that can turn a 'bargain' into something else entirely!
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Anahata on June 04, 2010, 01:54:00 PM
If I consider a Pokerwork or an Erica, which seem to be very popular choices, is there much of a difference between the new ones and older used models? I am now starting to think that I should be considering a used one as you appear to get more for your money but, for example, is a S/H Pokerwork that is only 2 years old as good as one that is say 10 years old? If not, is there some sort of cut-off point where you would say only consider ones made before that date?

Ideally you need to be able to try the boxes out. If you're a complete beginner this won't help much, but the trick even with new pokerworks (and other makes to some extent) is to go to a shop or more where there are several in stock,  try them all out and pick the best. New boxes vary!

When it comes to second hand there are many more variables: how well it's been looked after (extremes of temperature, damp etc) how much and how hard it's been played etc. Even so, an old box that's basically well made but needs reedwork can be refurbed by someone like Theo and be worth the money spent - and if it's playable when you buy it you don't have to spend that money straight away.

I've recently acquired a 1930's C/F Club from another melnetter for a price you could just about afford. Theo has done a full service on the reedwork and it's in fantastic condition for a box of its age. Probably not loud enough for a morris box and in the wrong keys, but it's a lovely box and possibly 70 years old.

Returning to your question: if your S/H Hohner is old enough it will be German made. Some years ago they moved manufacturing to China and the quality dropped, but (please let somebody else confirm or deny this) I hear a rumour that they have improved recently - still Chinese manufacture but sharper quality control being exercised (this is the way to get stuff made in China - you have to exert pressure and maybe pay a little more else they will cut all the corners they can)
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 04, 2010, 02:02:50 PM
The general consensus seems to be that the Chinese ones are now at least on a par with the later German made instruments, my first box was a new 2006 Chinese Erica and it was as well made as you could expect for the price. John Kirkpatrick certainly believes they're good boxes and Ollie's contributions in the Tune of the Month threads demonstrate that a Chinese Pokerwork is no barrier to playing well.

Bought "as is", a very desireable old Made in Germany box with a wooden keyboard could well have a leaky bellows gasket, damage and wear on the bellows, noisy hard pallet facings, curled up reed valves, crumbling wax holding the reeds to the blocks, rust on the reeds themselves and be seriously out of tune, requiring hundreds of pounds worth of work whereas a 3 year old Chinese one could have no major issues and be perfectly playable to a beginner so you can't really make a decision based on when and where it was made.

I concur that the safest bet is to get one that's been seen to by someone who knows what they're doing and will stand by their work, you'll know that the box is performing the best it can and a well set up Hohner is the weapon of choice for the likes of John Kirkpatrick, Tony Hall, Pete Coe and Simon Ritchie so there's no question about whether or not it's good enough. As has been mentioned, Theo sometimes has restored Hohners for sale and several people here have one of Mike Rowbotham's, (sometimes seen here as Microbot), restorations and are very pleased with them.

....but....don't be too daunted by any of that, any box sold by a reputable shop or in a private sale here shouldn't have any big problems with it and if it does it'll be clearly stated. You should be able to get stuck in straight away and before long you'll be nitpicking with the rest of us. ;D
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 04:11:26 PM
Theo has just let me know that he has a German made Pokerwork in good condition that may suit me. I am just waiting to see a picture but am very hopeful that this could be the one. If for any reason it is not, I have been given so much great advice from everyone here that I'm sure I can come to a satisfactory decision on what to get.
Sincere thanks to everyone!
My next post will obviously be...what is the best way to learn?
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 04, 2010, 04:17:17 PM
Theo has just let me know that he has a German made Pokerwork in good condition that may suit me. I am just waiting to see a picture but am very hopeful that this could be the one. If for any reason it is not, I have been given so much great advice from everyone here that I'm sure I can come to a satisfactory decision on what to get.
Sincere thanks to everyone!
My next post will obviously be...what is the best way to learn?
I think you should go for that one. It is such a bargain that I'm surprised you are not trampled in the rush. I already have a lovely Erica (from Theo) so I do not need a Pokerwork myself, otherwise I would be first in the queue for this one. Theo does not sell duff instruments. This is the one to go for. Don't miss it.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 04:19:49 PM
Thanks Steve, it does sound good! Just waiting to hear back from Theo and hoping no-one nips in quick before me.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Theo on June 04, 2010, 04:26:16 PM
Thanks Steve, it does sound good! Just waiting to hear back from Theo and hoping no-one nips in quick before me.

You have first refusal Peter.  My website shop has decided not to display new items correctly, so that means that nobody else can see the picture.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 04:29:21 PM
Thanks Theo!
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 04:55:15 PM
Just to let everyone know, I'm pleased to say that I'll be buying the Pokerwork that Theo offered me. It sounds just the box for me! Now comes the learning... :|glug
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Christopher K. on June 04, 2010, 05:24:04 PM
Just to let everyone know, I'm pleased to say that I'll be buying the Pokerwork that Theo offered me. It sounds just the box for me! Now comes the learning... :|glug

Score! Welcome to the club! You'll do well to clear your schedule for the upcoming weeks until you're familiar with the new affliction.  (:)
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 05:43:23 PM
I've pre-warned the family....although I may be banished to the garden shed when practising as my wife is one of those strange souls who doesn't like folk music (with the exception of Kate Rusby) and has an especial aversion to morris dance music.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Anahata on June 04, 2010, 06:29:38 PM
Just to let everyone know, I'm pleased to say that I'll be buying the Pokerwork that Theo offered me. It sounds just the box for me! Now comes the learning... :|glug

It couldn't have come from a better source. Welcome to the club :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :|glug :|glug :|glug

As for learning: what musical experience do you have? Play another instrument? Read music? Sing?
In any case, watch and listen to as many other players as you can - we all learn a lot from each other.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 06:55:12 PM
Unfortunately, I've never played another instrument (at least not seriously), cannot read music, sing all the time, albeit quite badly, but I do love going to festivals and morris rings whenever I can to watch the dancing and especially the morris musicians.
I'm off to the Thaxted Morris Ring tomorrow where I can watch the players all day long although it's too early for me to learn anything from them yet.
Very much looking forward to the day when I can accompany myself on the melodeon while singing the many folk songs I love.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Anahata on June 04, 2010, 07:05:39 PM
I'm off to the Thaxted Morris Ring tomorrow where I can watch the players all day long although it's too early for me to learn anything from them yet.
Very much looking forward to the day when I can accompany myself on the melodeon while singing the many folk songs I love.
:( Forgotten Thaxted was on... we have a gig in the evening - I wonder if we might catch up on one of the tours earlier in the day (living only about 1/2hr away from Thaxted it's possibe)

I hope your voice has enough range to sing lots of songs in D or G, or you'll be getting MAD* very soon as you find songs that must be done in C or F or B flat... a lot of singers like those Hohner 1950s C/F melodeons - often good keys to sing in and mellow-toned instruments that don't drown your voice.

*as you're new here: MAD = Melodeon Acquisition Disease  :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||: :||:
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 04, 2010, 07:44:18 PM
I think I've got it! :||: :||:
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 05, 2010, 02:24:26 AM
I am not going to Thaxted *grumble grumble*

However, congratulations on your purchase folkmann! ;D
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: juker on June 05, 2010, 03:52:57 AM
Welcome Folkman, let the fun and learning begin. Just a warning - this is very addictive stuff!
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 05, 2010, 09:27:31 AM
Thanks for all your help folks, I can't wait to start. Sitting here reading Mally's Beginners Instruction Book...it looks pretty daunting but I'm up for the challenge. :||:
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: JimJ on June 05, 2010, 09:05:08 PM
I'm waiting for delivery of my copy any day now.
So, you are one step ahead of me.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 08, 2010, 06:31:14 PM
I'm now the proud owner of a Pokerwork....and it is GREAT! The good ladywife has relented and let me have what was officially my birthday present two months early and I've just had an hour on it. Marvellous!
My debut tune? Johnny Todd! I don't know why, it just came into my head so I gave it a go and was fairly happy with my first effort on a box.
I then started to get cocky and managed a fairly decent version (to my ears anyway) of Princess Royal...copying the version from the Morris On album. All on the one row (G) and obviously no bass notes but it sounded alright to me...for a newbie.
My initial problem is that I have found it very hard to sit down and play. In fact I couldn't! But standing up is a different matter as I walked around, and on odd occasions slightly jigged around, and found it quite comfortable and very conducive to the music I was attempting to play. Have I made a rod for my own back already, I wonder? :||: :||: :||:
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2010, 06:44:20 PM
I'm now the proud owner of a Pokerwork....and it is GREAT!...I then started to get cocky and managed a fairly decent version (to my ears anyway) of Princess Royal...copying the version from the Morris On album. All on the one row (G) and obviously no bass notes but it sounded alright to me...for a newbie.

Congratulations on your acquisition. :||:

An impressive start, playing Princess Royal by ear within an hour! I doubt whether there are many (if any) on this forum who could match that.

My initial problem is that I have found it very hard to sit down and play. In fact I couldn't! But standing up is a different matter as I walked around, and on odd occasions slightly jigged around, and found it quite comfortable and very conducive to the music I was attempting to play. Have I made a rod for my own back already, I wonder? :||: :||: :||:

Standing up to play is a decided advantage if you intend to play for a Morris side and there are many people who prefer to stand up when playing in sessions as well. However, you will probably find a comfortable way to sit down and play before long.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 08, 2010, 07:52:50 PM
I don't deserve too much praise really because I have been listening and whistling along to that tune since the Morris On album first came out in the early 70's so it has been in my head ever since. And, of course, there were plenty of mistakes but I was still fairly pleased with myself.
I'll continue to practice standing up but when I start flagging then, hopefully, I will be able to find a sitting position that suits. Still very early days I guess!
As a footnote, I bought that album because the Chingford morris men were dancing on it and they were formed at my school by our new biology teacher, Peter Boyce. They were all classmates of mine and some went on to better things like John Watcham, the concertina player, playing for the Albion morris and Geoff Hughes becoming an influential figure in the world of the morris apparently. Good times!
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Ollie on June 08, 2010, 07:59:41 PM
Hope you enjoyed Thaxted, folkman, it's a great weekend (when Winstering down that hill... that's what it's all about  :M). Congrats on your purchace, there's no going back now!  >:E  :||:
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 08, 2010, 08:07:37 PM
Wasn't there for as long as I'd hoped but had a couple of pints of decent ale and got a fair amount of decent photos and really enjoyed the music and dancing. As you say, the procession down the hill was just magic... :|glug :|glug
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Anahata on June 08, 2010, 10:11:08 PM
Hope you enjoyed Thaxted, folkman
We saw you at the Debden Plough - don't know if you saw us  (:)
Had to go long before the evening's fun and games started. I hope it wasn't too wet.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Ollie on June 09, 2010, 05:21:04 PM
Hope you enjoyed Thaxted, folkman
We saw you at the Debden Plough - don't know if you saw us  (:)
Had to go long before the evening's fun and games started. I hope it wasn't too wet.


I did! I meant to come over and say hello, but I was a bit busy trying to sort out how many we had for each dance and which dance to do. It rained a bit in the first massed show, but was clear and fine for the rest of the time.
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on June 09, 2010, 11:01:48 PM
Geoff Hughes becoming an influential figure in the world of the morris apparently. Good times!

FYI - Geoff is still clogging and dancing with The Rumworth Morris of Bolton. And of course, he was the creator of what is commonly called the Upton-upon-Severn (or Chingford) Stick Dance.

Andy
Title: Re: Best bet for a beginner?
Post by: folkman on June 10, 2010, 09:16:02 AM
Geoff Hughes becoming an influential figure in the world of the morris apparently. Good times!

FYI - Geoff is still clogging and dancing with The Rumworth Morris of Bolton. And of course, he was the creator of what is commonly called the Upton-upon-Severn (or Chingford) Stick Dance.

Andy
Would be good to catch up with him again! I've read his article about how he wrote the Chingford Stick Dance and, although I didn't really understand the technical side, it was very interesting.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal