Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: ladydetemps on June 05, 2010, 11:18:11 PM
-
Ok. Maybe its coz im watching i'm in a rock n roll band, where they are discussing the best eva singer/guitarist/drummer. But heres my question: who is the best ever
-1 row
-2 row
-3 row
melodeon player. Dead or alive. I want reasons for your 'nominations'. No fistycuffs please.
-
Steve Dumpleton because he just gave me a fiver to say so.
-
Best 1 row player ever (IMHO) is Bobby Gardiner. Here is a reason why http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4&feature=fvw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4&feature=fvw) :Ph
-
Steve Dumpleton because he just gave me a fiver to say so.
Lester Bailey because I gave me £10 to say so!
-
Rees Wesson because I'm hoping he'll give me a discount on a Clipper if I say so.
-
Anyone who will give me a discount on anything if I say so :P
Seriously though, JK has got to be up there somewhere.
-
Over the last 35 years or so I've always quite liked Tony Hall's efforts.
-
One of the wonderful things about music in general, and particularly about folk/trad music is that it can be performed at all sorts of levels and while we all to a large extent agree who the 'greats' are, its still almost entirely non-competitive. Yet almost all players from the freshest beginners to seasoned players are striving to develop and enrich their music making. Contrast this with sport for example where most sports have clear winners and losers, or record holders, or league tables. So I'll agree that Tony Hall, John K, Julian Sutton, Nick Wiseman-Ellis (look out for him) and many others are great and inspiring players, I could never imagine myself saying that any one is the best. It's as silly as asking which is the best fruit - apples, raspberries or mango?
-
It's as silly as asking which is the best fruit - apples, raspberries or mango?
apple clearly ;)
-
Well, I can't stop listening to Andy Cutting's new CD lately, so for now I'd have to nominate him! However I love DTN's style of playing too.....wish I had one his CD's (:)
-
Like, you don't know who I'm going to suggest,
;D
but without a doubt it's the great man Sir Jimmy Shand OBE - who, as far as I'm aware is the only melodeon player in the history of the instrument to have had a Top of the Pops top ten hit with an instrumental tune played on the melodeon (Bluebell Polka) - and whose worldwide musical influence has left an amazing legacy that is still resonating today - inspiring so many of the current crop of great musicians. IMHO whereas all the others mentiond so far are all brilliant - Shand is THE MAN - in some ways the Daddy of them all!
AL
-
Like, you don't know who I'm going to suggest,
;D
but without a doubt it's the great man Sir Jimmy Shand OBE - who, as far as I'm aware is the only melodeon player in the history of the instrument to have had a Top of the Pops top ten hit with an instrumental tune played on the melodeon (Bluebell Polka) - and whose worldwide musical influence has left an amazing legacy that is still resonating today - inspiring so many of the current crop of great musicians. IMHO whereas all the others mentiond so far are all brilliant - Shand is THE MAN - in some ways the Daddy of them all!
AL
agreed! In the blurb on the EMI Shand CD 'King of the melodeon men ' (1994) John Kirkpatrick says 'Shands early playing knocks me sideways, the playing is so exiting, quite manic.. he's a real virtuoso'
His ear;y stuff was on a 2 row and he also recorded some beautifuol slow airs in relatively recent times on a hohner erica CC# . His technical & musical expertise on a wide range of music including continental stuff on the button box is without equal and the effortless & minimalist way he played somne extremely tricky stuff is inspiring to say the least. Who else on a sook an blaw box ever achieved recordsales of over 50,000 on some of his singles and sales of Lps of over a million. Much of his early stuff is now available on Cd aand those issued by the Shand family are the best as they have been extremely carefully remastered from the original recordings.
In the English folk world I think Tony Hall is in a class of his own!
george
-
I'd agree with Theo, in that it seems a somewhat silly discussion, given the variety of instruments and music styles covered. However, if I was had to take only one box CD to a desert island, it would most likely be one of Máirtín O'Connor's. So, I guess that would be my choice.
-
Rather predictably I totally agree with Al and George about Shand, just listen to a bit of one of his early recordings, track 2, the Wonder Hornpipe, recorded on a 2 row in the 1930s
http://www.emusic.com/album/Jimmy-Shand-Beltona-Recordings-Vol-3-MP3-Download/11252944.html
and tracks 3 and 4 on this CD
http://www.emusic.com/album/Jimmy-Shand-Parlophone-Sessions-Vol-1-MP3-Download/11252947.html
Ian
-
This man, William Hannah, was highly thought of in Scotland [still is, a lot of his tunes are still played]
Interesting article here about him and if you scroll down there is a sound sample of his playing.
http://www.raretunes.org/performers/william-hannah
Plus here's a clip of me playing a Wilkinson's Excelsior which is mentioned in the article,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3XzUO-12n4
Ian
-
Hi folks 1st reply to the site, I never personally saw Will Hannah but he was a legend in his own lifetime.
My father used to take me when I was a boy to the Whitehall theatre in Dundee and I can remember listening to Will Starr who played with such speed it was breath taking.
Every time he appeared on stage to do his solo spot it was as if the heating had been turned up by 5 degrees - Absolutely astonishing the atmosphere he created.
Regards Alex
-
His style might not be everyone's cup of tea, but Norbert Pignol must be about the most virtuoso player about at the moment in terms of sheer technical mastery of the diatonic?
He or Stéphane Milleret . . . . . .
-
You guys are so "local", why isn't there any mention of great players who came from elsewhere on the planet? Like Québec or Louisiana? On the top of my list are Alfred Montmarquette and Philippe Bruneau.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HiA1WlxWc2w
How many obscure players are there who would qualify? Tons of them. Just an example.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=smooAKSBF4A
But as Theo said, it's not about being "the" best, it's about giving it our best.
-
Yes, so many approaches, styles, genres, types of boxes, might as well ask which is the best vehicle on the road?! But a few of my favourites are JK, Tony Hall, Phillipe Bruneau, but above all, Norbert Pignol, in a class by himself - and not just for his unbelievable box playing, but for his mastery of musical composition.
I'm aware that there will be hundreds of players I've never heard, or heard of, who have much to offer.
-
How many obscure players are there who would qualify? Tons of them. Just an example.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=smooAKSBF4A
Like the slightly curved button arrangement .
Was waiting for the pizzicato.
-
Stephane Landry.... :-)
-
Frederic Paris - wrote beautiful tunes too.
-
Like the slightly curved button arrangement .
Québécois craftsmanship! They make good instruments there too...
-
I like Quebecois's comment above. There is something about the way Kimmel and Montmarquette drove through those early recordings.
But given the topic, who but Joe Derrane?
-
Way, way too many and there's also the difference between those captured on tape and those who you've seen live. In the latter category I would nominate three from the States, Eddie LeJeune, Rockin Dopsie and Flaco Jimenez. Unfortunately only the latter is still with us :(.
It also says much about how badly paid/treated/undervalued great musicians can be that Eddie LeJeune died of a heart attack whilst working on a construction site not long after completing a UK tour.
Steve