Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: juker on June 05, 2010, 11:39:50 PM
-
I assume that H stamped on the reeds of a Hohner box means that they are Hohner reeds. So what does T mean?
-
I'm not sure anyone is 100% absolutely sure what either the T or H on Hohner reeds mean, there's certainly a lot of debate.
I seem to remember several sources saying the T stands for Tropisch but others think Trossingen is more likely if it stands for anything at all.
-
Thanks for that (:)
-
An accordionist that I played with for many years always called them Tango reeds, any ideas about that anyone ??
Lovely looking melodeon Juker.
Ian
-
Hohner describe them as "T Mensure" reeds. Lord only knows what that means.
-
Mensur is the German word for scale length. Is there any difference in scale between H and T reeds?.
-
Not as far as I know, but Theo would know best.
-
Off the top of my head I would say that T reeds mostly have consistent scale lengths, but H reeds vary. The ones in Liliput and Preciosa models are much shorter. There is also a variety of different reed tongue shapes on H reeds, some are almost parallel sided, some are more trapezoidal like T reeds.
-
"T" for "tipo a macchina"
-
"tipo a cheap steel" more like
-
Trossingen?
-
The town in southern Germany where Hohner is based.
-
Uh, of course, thanks! Still wee bit slow after yesterday's gig ;D
-
"tipo a cheap steel" more like
(:)
Haha! Probably, but it doesn't matter to me, I am never likely to be musician enough to notice the difference, and it only cost $150 (Australian) (:)
-
I seem to remember several sources saying the T stands for Tropisch
My husband (who has an uncanny skill for finding things on the internet) said he came across a Hohner manual which indicated that the T did indeed stand for Tropisch. They were specially designed to cope with tropical conditions.
If he ever finds it again I'll post a link!
-
I read somewhere (I think it was on this board) that T reeds were more frequent on boxes made before WWII and the H somehow replaced them thereafter.
-
I have original boxes with a mix of "H" and "T" reeds. Presumed to be late 40's early 50's.
An example would be a "pre" Corona.
-
Check this thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1134.0.html
-
No it is the other way round. H reeds are older.
-
I have been told that Hohners built in the late 40's and early 50's used a mixture of pre war parts and new parts, and anything goes
As an example, a Honey presswood in A/D with an original black wood keyboard.
Also, common to see T treble reeds and a mixture of H and T reeds on the bass side.
-
The H reeds on my new box are indeed the older ones, and they are on zinc plates, whereas the T are a different steel. It has two T reeds which clearly appear to have been retrofitted (and one of them is horribly out of tune! Soon going to Malcolm Clapp though (:))
This one for anyone who hasn't admired it yet ;D
-
I have been told that Hohners built in the late 40's and early 50's used a mixture of pre war parts and new parts, and anything goes
As an example, a Honey presswood in A/D with an original black wood keyboard.
Also, common to see T treble reeds and a mixture of H and T reeds on the bass side.
Yes I've seen a lot of that. And H treble reeds and T bass. Also mixtures of zinc and aluminium reeds on treble reedblocks for example on early 4-stop. But it is even more complicated, H reeds can be on zinc or Al plates. Some reeds marked T have reeds with the shape and other characteristics of H reeds.
-
I have Hohners with individual zinc plates and some very old ones with long plates
It is my opinion the individual zinc plates/reeds have a more responsive and mellow/rounded sound compared to aluminum plates, whether T or H. And I believe the T reeds are more responsive than H reeds.
But, I also believe tuning is paramount in getting a good sound from a Hohner.
-
But, I also believe tuning is paramount in getting a good sound from a Hohner.
Yes, but then it will not sound like a Hohner anymore, will it :o