Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Bish on June 07, 2010, 04:39:47 PM
-
I just thought I'd poke my head above the ramparts and say "Hi".
I've been lurking for a while, and joined the board a few weeks ago with a mind to finding out as much as possible before jumping in to this wonderful world of melodeons. First of all, I've got to say what a friendly and well-run board this seems to be... the membership reaches out to the newest of players and makes them welcome.
I'm an ex-pat Brit living in the melodeon wasteland of Long Island, New York, and after a life of dabbling with electronica, I feel an overwhelming desire to get back to something more "traditional". The melodeon seems to fit the bill perfectly... hopefully serving my (very) eclectic tastes. One of my greatest problems is that I over-analyse any major purchase decision and end up like a deer in the headlights, overwhelmed by the details!
So, if my conclusions aren't completely skewed, I've whittled the list of prospective candidates down as follows...
1. Discount anything with a celluloid finish... it's me... I just don't like it. I like the natural finish, so even the ubiquitous Pokerwork has limited appeal.
2. Avoid ebay if possible... again, just me... I've been bitten a couple of times.
3. Stick with a D/G box... although a G/C has it's appeal (being in isolation, there's no chance of me playing where a D/G is absolutely needed, but the learning materials seem to be skewed that way).
4. Bass stop the remove thirds would be nice, but not essential.
5. Listening to posted songs, I prefer my tuning on the drier side... maybe a little damp, but not wet.
So for new melodeons, it's come down to the Hohner Morgane or the Weltmeister 86W (wood finish), both of which are available in the States. Both of these would bust my budget completely, but isn't that what budgets are for?
A used melodeon from a reputable/known source leads me to an older Le Bouebe or the Sandpiper (looks interesting). Getting one of these used in the States is well-nigh impossible, so there may be some logistical issues with sourcing one in the UK.
Anyway, I've prattled enough for a first post (:)
Cheers
Peter
-
Welcome Peter. I echo your comments about the friendliness of this forum, and I find it continually inspiring and useful.
Oh, and amusing in all the right places!
I've just entered "year 2" of melodeon playing and it's a blast. Looking at your conclusions you'll be on the right track for you, and I wish you much fun, pleasure and I'll-get-this-if-it-kills-me moments!!
All the best
Chris
-
Forget about buying from the UK, there are too many pitfalls, especially for a first purchase. Get along to the Button Box (http://www.buttonbox.com/), they say its 3 1/2 hour from NY. Spend a couple of hours there and play everything in sight, but keep tight hold of your plastic!
-
I'd second Theo's suggestion of a trip to the Button Box: in the past they've also been willing to mail out instruments on a trial basis. I'm not sure if they still do this, but if they do, it's a good way to test out likely candidates for a purchase. You have to be pretty sure about what you're interested in, however, as the postage adds up pretty fast. Also, if you get down to Manhattan, drop in and see Walter at The Main Squeeze http://www.mainsqueeze-nyc.com/html/menu.html (http://www.mainsqueeze-nyc.com/html/menu.html). He's a nice guy, and he carries some decent diatonics, although they are not his speciality.
Good luck!
-
It's worth the trip to the Button Box. You sound like you feel a bit isolated and just immersing yourself in their world will give you enormous energy.
I personally have had better luck with ebay and a friend of mine buys and sells old boxes constantly on ebay and says he has been stung only once. However, you MIGHT get stung and in any case ebay is very isolating. The Button Box will give you the beginnings of a community. After that, they communicate very well by email and ship things very quickly.
-
The Button Box is certainly within striking distance if the traffic gods are smiling that day. I've heard good reports and may well check them out. On the other hand, Manhattan is only an hour or so from me, so a visit to The Main Squeeze may be in order... they have their own badged G/C (or C/F) diatonic which looks OK, but I'm always wary of web sites that give no pricing information. Nothing that can't be solved with a phone call though. Does anyone have any experience with the Main Squeeze 2-Row diatonic? I guess there's also Alex's on 48th St. as well... they seem to have a range of melodeons, but again, no pricing.
Thanks for the comments & advice.
-
The Main Squeeze instruments are, I think, made in the Czech republic, and they're solid workhorses. There are usually some second-hand Hohners for sale there as well, and often other instruments -- I saw a lovely Savoy one-row there once, that I was too poor to buy. It's worth calling in advance, to find out what they have on the shelves. Quite a few of the Dominican music shops in the neighbourhood used to to have Ericas and Coronas in the windows as well, but I've not been down there for a while, so I don't know if that's still the case.
-
The Main Squeeze instruments are, I think, made in the Czech republic, and they're solid workhorses.
Yes, they look like the acccordeons from http://www.harmoniky.cz/en/
-
Check out this link, they are also in New York and I was in contact with them about a box a couple years ago when I first started playing. I also was looking at Weltmeister and Hohner models at that time. http://www.alexmusical.com/diatonic.html
-
Alexmusical in NYC are on my list of people to talk to. From what I read, the Weltmeister 86W is comparable (cost-wise) to a Pokerwork (and is available in the natural wood finish). Some reports here indicate that the Welty is a little better made than the current crop of Pokerworks. It may be interesting to compare the 86W with the Morgane, bearing in mind their price difference. I'm still on the fence about pushing my budget out to $1000 though :) ... so, despite my concerns, I'm still keeping a close eye on ebay.
-
Alexmusical in NYC are on my list of people to talk to. From what I read, the Weltmeister 86W is comparable (cost-wise) to a Pokerwork (and is available in the natural wood finish). Some reports here indicate that the Welty is a little better made than the current crop of Pokerworks. It may be interesting to compare the 86W with the Morgane, bearing in mind their price difference. I'm still on the fence about pushing my budget out to $1000 though :) ... so, despite my concerns, I'm still keeping a close eye on ebay.
Be careful on eBay...
The 86w has its roots in similar looking models made during the DDR period. I know Theo could comment more on this, but there are known issues with the treble pivot rod/springs on the older models, which makes changing broken springs a pain in the posterior. I know someone who had one of these, and he had terrible time of it when a spring broke.
I'm sure this doesn't apply to the newer boxes... but be aware...
If you can push the boat out, take a serious look at the next tier of Weltmeisters... in particular what they called for a while the 'James Keane' model (with the flat keyboard). These are good, and a low voice and stopper adds a bit of colour when you want it.
Anyhow, go out and try stuff... it's the best way... (:)
Ed J
-
You may also consider the "Verde Derby" for €820 ...
http://www.verdepro.com/articolo.php?a=715
It has even a third's stop
I had the chance to play on such a box several times, it is a quite nice box.