Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: folkman on June 09, 2010, 09:24:07 PM
-
I know the answer is 'how long is a piece of string' but what is the general view of experienced players as to the minimum a total beginner should practice every day.
I accept that there are numerous variables to take into account like time available, natural talent, structured practice etc etc but any sort of guidance would be appreciated.
I intend to practice as often as I can (assuming I can drag myself away from the forum) but it's hard to know whether I am putting in the required hours or not. ???
-
IMHO practice shouldn't be mesured in hours but in progress ;)
-
Don't beat yourself up about it. Practice when you can. If you set goals that you can't meet it becomes a chore, and that is an enemy to progress.
-
Every day if possible, even if its just a few minutes. But think of it as playing, not practice, and give yourself a pat on the back whenever you detect an improvement, even a small one.
-
A good tip associated with practice is - "Don't keep your melodeon in its case".
If you leave it somewhere visible and close, you are much more likely to give it a squeeze - even if its just a couple of times through a current favourite tune.
I also find I 'practice' more if I have a specific reason. For many of us, that tends to be visiting a local session and/or playing for morris team. And both will definitely help improve your playing.
Andy
-
don't thinkof it as practice, it makes it feel like hard work. Just play the bugger at every opportunity whether it be playing a few scales or simple tunes, or making simple tunes sound better or whatever. That way what was intended as a 10 minute 'go' on the box can easily become an hours worth!. The trouble with having 'set' practice times ,eg an hour on sunday aftrnoon, is that you can be too busy & leave it till the sunday after or after or after,, by which time the box has found a home on top of the wardrobe!
george ;)
-
I found that a little and often worked for me - ie 5-10 minutes whenever you can and at least once per day - leaving the box lying around worked well - as did methodically working my way through the early pages of Mally's book.
Also a contributory factor was "how much the neighbours can take in one go" - hearing "Baa Baa Black Sheep" played repetitively, and badly, can test most neighbourly relationships - however they do notice and comment when it improves
-
I play most days and, as has been suggested elsewhere, I keep the boxes in a convenient place. They have their own table in the kitchen area and I pick one of them up whenever I can. I would love to practise more though as I have noticed that phrases of tunes that I work really hard on (usually because I find them difficult to learn) really stick in my head and hands and end up being the best played bits of the tunes. But really the key for me is 'Love, love, love.....dadadadada!' - I just love playing!
-
All this advice is very much appreciated and it makes much sense. As from today, the box stays out of the case and remains somewhere very accessible and I will not be practising, I will be playing. My original idea of practising an hour every morning from 6-7am was very daunting and something I'm not sure I was looking forward to all that much. That is now a no-go! From now on I pick my box up at every opportunity and play, be it for 5 mins or 50 mins...and enjoy it! But I'm still not going to play Ba Ba Black Sheep or Polly Put The Bloody Kettle On...sorry, I just can't!
-
All this advice is very much appreciated and it makes much sense. As from today, the box stays out of the case and remains somewhere very accessible and I will not be practising, I will be playing. My original idea of practising an hour every morning from 6-7am was very daunting and something I'm not sure I was looking forward to all that much. That is now a no-go! From now on I pick my box up at every opportunity and play, be it for 5 mins or 50 mins...and enjoy it! But I'm still not going to play Ba Ba Black Sheep or Polly Put The Bloody Kettle On...sorry, I just can't!
There's nothing wrong with nursery rhymes. :P Although I can't stand twinkle little star. Prefer bobbie shaftoe.
I started by practicing 2-4 hours a day...but found it caused me to ache too much. So I reduced it to hour each day and 2 hours on a saturday/sunday. Now I can do 30mins of 'intense' practice and get more out of it than an hour of vague wandering.
I tend to do scales, boring stuff first and reward myself by if I do that I get to play a tune of my choice to finish.
btw. I have been known to play tunes while watching TV which according to my mum is a 'waste of electricity'. lol
-
All this advice is very much appreciated and it makes much sense. As from today, the box stays out of the case and remains somewhere very accessible and I will not be practising, I will be playing. My original idea of practising an hour every morning from 6-7am was very daunting and something I'm not sure I was looking forward to all that much. That is now a no-go! From now on I pick my box up at every opportunity and play, be it for 5 mins or 50 mins...and enjoy it! But I'm still not going to play Ba Ba Black Sheep or Polly Put The Bloody Kettle On...sorry, I just can't!
There's nothing wrong with nursery rhymes. :P Although I can't stand twinkle little star. Prefer bobbie shaftoe.
I started by practicing 2-4 hours a day...but found it caused me to ache too much. So I reduced it to hour each day and 2 hours on a saturday/sunday. Now I can do 30mins of 'intense' practice and get more out of it than an hour of vague wandering.
I tend to do scales, boring stuff first and reward myself by if I do that I get to play a tune of my choice to finish.
btw. I have been known to play tunes while watching TV which according to my mum is a 'waste of electricity'. lol
Most of what's on TV is a waste of electricity in my opinion! And I'm still not going to play nursery rhymes...I hate them! :||:
-
My box sits by the front door. You would not believe the number of times it has caught my eye on the way out in the morning and I have thought " Just a quick couple of goes through.... " whatever tune I am working on at the time. Consequence, always late for work.
G
-
My original idea of practising an hour every morning from 6-7am was very daunting and something I'm not sure I was looking forward to all that much.
Educational theory (and my own experience) suggests that playing for an hour a day in one unbroken spell is far less effective than playing a few shorter spells (e.g. three sessions of 20 minutes). The little-and-often approach reinforces the learning and should help you to progress more quickly than unbroken hour-long sessions.
-
I count sessions as 'practice' as well.
-
Practice until you get tired of it, then stop and start again when you want to. Little and often is good, I concur with the whole "leaving your box around" thing.
-
I have been searching for "my instrument" for years.
I remember reading about practice on another forum.
The comment was made that sleep was a part of the
learning process. That if you practiced for a while every
day, that often you found the biggest improvement,
the next day, after your body had a chance to "absorb"
what you learned while you slept at night.
Don't have any idea if it is true or not -- just something
I read on the internet (:)
-
if you practiced for a while every day, that often you found the biggest improvement,
the next day, after your body had a chance to "absorb" what you learned while you slept at night.
True, from my own experience and I think that of many others.
-
Perhaps little and often works because every time you start, you are forced to recall what you did last time, and so it helps to train the memory.
On the other hand, it's great to just lose yourself for a couple of hours or more trying new tunes, experimenting with ways of doing things and having a go at all those tunes you can "nearly play but not quite". It may be less efficient, but it shuts out the cares and worries of everyday life (or at least passes the time on a wet Saturday afternoon!).
As for time of day - I like to play early in the morning, and find I can play well at that time, but I don't think I remember it as well as I do when I play in the evening (which isn't often except when I go out). I think I might start making an effort to play more often in the evenings, as remembering things is becoming an increasingly weak point of mine. >:(
-
To take it slightly further, I think a break of a day or two from practicing and even playing altogether every now and then can be very beneficial. More than once I've been working hard on a tune for several days with it not quite coming together, put the box down for a while and then when I've picked it up again everything seems to have fallen in to place almost as if by magic.
-
More than once I've been working hard on a tune for ages with it not quite coming together, put the box down for a while and then when I've picked it up again everything seems to have fallen in to place almost as if by magic.
As long as you understand that the hard work is necessary first, in order to make the improvement happen in the break ;)
-
Oh I don't know, I learned to play the scale of C on the trumpet 16 years ago...I'm going to town tomorrow morning to buy another trumpet and I fully expect to have jazz afficionados praising me as the new Miles Davis by lunchtime.
I think the main thrust is that with practice, as with excercise, rest is an important but often overlooked aspect.
-
A good tip associated with practice is - "Don't keep your melodeon in its case".
This is the top bit of advice for learning any instrument - in my opinion. Keep it handy.
Ray (yet to begin my melodeon journey - but pretty good at banjo and guitar).
-
Cant play yet. Hopefully I will pick up my melodeon this weekend and start my journey.
All this talk of practice got me thinking. I am a fairly competent clawhammer banjo player and have often given (free) advice and tuition. My general advice on practice as a rule of thumb is this :
- if you practice everyday for half-an-hour, after six months you will be able to play something that will impress friends and family; after twelve months you will be able to play in public and with others; after about three years you will be considered quite competent by other banjo players, and after five years you will be considered pretty good. A very general rule obviously, and people are going to vary depending on previous musical ability and knowledge, quality of teaching and teaching materials and, dare I say it, talent. Nevertheless I hope it shows that you can get far with regular (daily) commitment of not that much time.
I was wondering if the same is true of the melodeon. I mean, given some musical knowledge and exposure (keys and time signatures and such), and a regular practice routine of 30 - 60 minutes - how long for the average person to be good enough to join a session say, or play for a morris team? Anyone care to have a stab.
ray
-
I was wondering if the same is true of the melodeon. I mean, given some musical knowledge and exposure (keys and time signatures and such), and a regular practice routine of 30 - 60 minutes - how long for the average person to be good enough to join a session say, or play for a morris team? Anyone care to have a stab.
Depends on the player, but in general if you've already learned to play one instrument, learning another is easier.
-
was wondering if the same is true of the melodeon. I mean, given some musical knowledge and exposure (keys and time signatures and such), and a regular practice routine of 30 - 60 minutes - how long for the average person to be good enough to join a session say, or play for a morris team? Anyone care to have a stab.
ray
Fairly sure there is no general rule, it took me many, many months (18+) but we then had a young lad called Andy Cutting join the side and he seemed to pick it up very very quickly. So like most things in life - it depends!
-
Cant play yet. Hopefully I will pick up my melodeon this weekend and start my journey.
All this talk of practice got me thinking. I am a fairly competent clawhammer banjo player and have often given (free) advice and tuition. My general advice on practice as a rule of thumb is this :
- if you practice everyday for half-an-hour, after six months you will be able to play something that will impress friends and family; after twelve months you will be able to play in public and with others; after about three years you will be considered quite competent by other banjo players, and after five years you will be considered pretty good. A very general rule obviously, and people are going to vary depending on previous musical ability and knowledge, quality of teaching and teaching materials and, dare I say it, talent. Nevertheless I hope it shows that you can get far with regular (daily) commitment of not that much time.
I was wondering if the same is true of the melodeon. I mean, given some musical knowledge and exposure (keys and time signatures and such), and a regular practice routine of 30 - 60 minutes - how long for the average person to be good enough to join a session say, or play for a morris team? Anyone care to have a stab.
ray
It took me 6 months@1/2 hour a day to be able to "play" the bass end rythmically (it just sort of "happened") , but I was playing for Morris (just the treble end) before that. Some say I have not progressed since then (that was 1976).
-
I was wondering if the same is true of the melodeon. I mean, given some musical knowledge and exposure (keys and time signatures and such), and a regular practice routine of 30 - 60 minutes - how long for the average person to be good enough to join a session say, or play for a morris team? Anyone care to have a stab.
ray
I find setting goals helps...with only general time limits. But that's just me. Like my short term goal is to be able to go from one tune to another in a set without stopping in between. (Which is why I'm putting rusty gully and dusty miller together in a set). Long term goal is to memorise a certain number of tunes. In between those goals are playing the D row by 'reading' the music and getting waltz basses up to scratch.
Without goals my practice becomes unfocused and I loose interest.
So I say give yourself a deadline...but if you don't reach it, once you reach it move it.
-
I keep the boxes in a convenient place. They have their own table in the kitchen area and I pick one of them up whenever I can.
Hmm, not sure about the kitchen, Juker...2 things spring to mind - steam and grease - neither of which might do the boxes much good.
-
But I'm still not going to play...Polly Put The Bloody Kettle On...sorry, I just can't!
Polly put the [Bloody - can be when you mess up, as fast and driving!] Kettle On, as collected by Cecil Sharp from the Forest of Dean fiddler Charles Baldwin is an excellent - and challenging - 3-part tune as traditionally paired with the Gloucester Hornpipe by the Old Swan Band >:E
('Gamesters, Pickpockets and Harlots', 1981; 'Still Swanning', 1995)
Diane
-
Much as we all owe Cecil Sharp an enormous debt of gratitude for what he has done, I, for one, feel that he didn't get everything right and should have left Polly Put The *** Kettle On back in the Forest of Dean rather than inflict it on the rest of the country. :(
-
Folkman - try listening to the tune as collected before putting it down
-
Folkman - try listening to the tune as collected before putting it down
Fair enough, I suppose I should really! Will endeavour to track it down and listen before commenting any further.
-
Much as we all owe Cecil Sharp an enormous debt of gratitude for what he has done, I, for one, feel that he didn't get everything right and should have left Polly Put The *** Kettle On back in the Forest of Dean rather than inflict it on the rest of the country. :(
Thanks, Summerstars. Having just read the above, I was about to respond with, "Well, you're actually familiar with the version, are you?"!
Diane
-
I have given the subject of how much practise quite a bit of thought. When I was little and learning to play an instrument at home I was made to practise for a certain length of time and hated it, and unfortunately associated the ill feeling with the instrument. Consequently I have continued to play a guitar in the line of my work (primary teacher) but not for personal pleasure. Now I practise for as long as I enjoy - that is never less than about 20 minutes, and often longer. I don't want to ever stop loving playing my melodeons.
-
Thanks, Summerstars. Having just read the above, I was about to respond with, "Well, you're actually familiar with the version, are you?"!
Diane
[/quote]
I was being a bit tongue in cheek there! As you say, I can't really knock a tune if I haven't heard it. My original comment still stands though...I don't like nursery rhymes and I don't like using them to learn the melodeon. It's just a personal thing that's all.
Does the tune collected by Cecil Sharp differ much from the nursery rhyme and is the title the same? ???
-
Now I practise for as long as I enjoy -
I think this is an extremely important point! play/practice the box at every opportunity & for as long as you like - BUT if its one of those days when you seem to be making a balls of it ( & we all have th;ose days) don't persevere ,put it down, forget it, go for a pint, put the kettle on or do whatever else you do - tomorrow will be all right
george
-
I don't like nursery rhymes and I don't like using them to learn the melodeon. It's just a personal thing that's all.
They don't have to be nursery rhymes, but practicing with a tune you know well is easier than trying to learn a tune as well as learn the instrument.
-
They don't have to be nursery rhymes, but practicing with a tune you know well is easier than trying to learn a tune as well as learn the instrument.
Agreed - the thing is to work through some tunes that are really deep within you - that way you'll find they come out a lot easier and you'll know instinctively whether what you're doing is right or wrong. Hymn tunes or christmas carols or things that we learnt way back are really good for that kind of practice.
-
I don't like nursery rhymes and I don't like using them to learn the melodeon. It's just a personal thing that's all.
They don't have to be nursery rhymes, but practicing with a tune you know well is easier than trying to learn a tune as well as learn the instrument.
In view of what you have all said, I think I will now have to resist the urge to try and learn the morris tunes and concentrate instead on learning the instrument. There are a variety of tunes I know and like so I guess now's the time to put the morris on hold and get on with things. :||:
-
They don't have to be nursery rhymes, but practicing with a tune you know well is easier than trying to learn a tune as well as learn the instrument.
Agreed - the thing is to work through some tunes that are really deep within you - that way you'll find they come out a lot easier and you'll know instinctively whether what you're doing is right or wrong. Hymn tunes or christmas carols or things that we learnt way back are really good for that kind of practice.
Christmas carols and hymns are actually an excellent suggestion as many of them are still firmly ingrained, so to speak, and are very pleasant on the ear so I would enjoy learning those. Can you buy sheet music books of these do you know and, if so, any idea where might be the best place to get them? Can you get them in D/G only? ???
-
Christmas carols and hymns are actually an excellent suggestion as many of them are still firmly ingrained, so to speak, and are very pleasant on the ear so I would enjoy learning those. Can you buy sheet music books of these do you know and, if so, any idea where might be the best place to get them? Can you get them in D/G only? ???
Almost certainly, you're best off looking for ABC's of these via folktunefinder, or whatever... and then transpose the ABC via your playback tool to whatever key you want. You'll probably learn more though, with tunes you know already in your head, by trying initially to play them by ear with no written music at all. The first or second tunes may be slower to pick up - but the rest will be a *lot* quicker to learn.
(ducks)
Clive
-
Christmas carols and hymns are actually an excellent suggestion as many of them are still firmly ingrained, so to speak, and are very pleasant on the ear so I would enjoy learning those. Can you buy sheet music books of these do you know and, if so, any idea where might be the best place to get them? Can you get them in D/G only? ???
Almost certainly, you're best off looking for ABC's of these via folktunefinder, or whatever... and then transpose the ABC via your playback tool to whatever key you want. You'll probably learn more though, with tunes you know already in your head, by trying initially to play them by ear with no written music at all. The first or second tunes may be slower to pick up - but the rest will be a *lot* quicker to learn.
(ducks)
Clive
So, in your opinion, it would be a good idea to attempt to play tunes from memory as well as from books? I have been doing this with a couple of songs but wasn't really sure that it was a good idea as there was the worry that I could be missing notes out and suchlike. Or should I not worry about such things and just use it as a way of learning the instrument?
-
So, in your opinion, it would be a good idea to attempt to play tunes from memory as well as from books? I have been doing this with a couple of songs but wasn't really sure that it was a good idea as there was the worry that I could be missing notes out and suchlike. Or should I not worry about such things and just use it as a way of learning the instrument?
If you use tunes you instinctively "Know" you won't miss notes out, nor will you get the timing wrong - or if you do, you will be well aware that is what you have done, and can go back and try it again. Anything you play on your new instrument is a bonus; including playing nonsense - when I was at the very early learning stage, and struggling to play anything on the bass end, Pete Coe advised me to play nonsense on the right hand side and concentrate playing bass notes and chords along with it, you soon pick up riffs that are in your head, and some of them turn into tunes that you instinctively know - I realise that the nursery rhyme tunes idea has put you off, but they were only an example of tunes that "Everyone" knows instinctively, and most of them are simple. I still have problems with new tunes from the notes if I don't know what they are supposed to sound like - particularly getting the rhythym and timing correct.
-
If you use tunes you instinctively "Know" you won't miss notes out, nor will you get the timing wrong - or if you do, you will be well aware that is what you have done, and can go back and try it again. Anything you play on your new instrument is a bonus; including playing nonsense - when I was at the very early learning stage, and struggling to play anything on the bass end, Pete Coe advised me to play nonsense on the right hand side and concentrate playing bass notes and chords along with it, you soon pick up riffs that are in your head, and some of them turn into tunes that you instinctively know - I realise that the nursery rhyme tunes idea has put you off, but they were only an example of tunes that "Everyone" knows instinctively, and most of them are simple. I still have problems with new tunes from the notes if I don't know what they are supposed to sound like - particularly getting the rhythym and timing correct.
[/quote]
I did buy Mally's two Cotswold Morris Tunes books with the accompanying CD's in the hope that I could identify and learn at least some of them but, on reflection, it seems I am trying to run before I can walk. I'll put them aside for now I think and concentrate on tunes I know very well. Now that I know it is not vital to have the sheet music in front of me I am more than happy to start experimenting!
I confess that I haven't even considered the bass end yet as I am following George Garside's book quite closely and haven't reached that part as yet but I do occasionally use them on their own just as a way of getting used to handling them. I just can't imagine being adept enough to play a melody and the basses together but I suppose all novices feel that way to begin with. :||:
-
So, in your opinion, it would be a good idea to attempt to play tunes from memory as well as from books? I have been doing this with a couple of songs but wasn't really sure that it was a good idea as there was the worry that I could be missing notes out and suchlike. Or should I not worry about such things and just use it as a way of learning the instrument?
Yes (disclaimer - in my opinion), the melodeon is an instrument that's actually easier to play by ear than from music for beginners - mostly because many of the notes in a musical scale can be played using either of 2 keys, and musical notation doesn't tell you which to use. So I think you're better off just sitting down and having a go.
Don't be scared of trying the basses either - before too long the basses actually help you play the melody, and it's actually harder to play without the basses...
Anyway... have a go, have fun, and good luck!
Clive
-
There's absolutely no reason to seek out the written music of a tune if you know it and you can work it out by ear. As Clive says, once you can do that, you'll learn other tunes more easily. Start with any simple tunes you like - carols, hymns, and simple songs are often easier to start with than dance tunes, partly because you're more likely to have committed them to memory already. You're not going to need to be reminded of the tunes for Happy Birthday, Little Brown Jug or For He's a Jolly Good Fellow, so they're good tunes to start with.
If you play from a written score, you'll find, for one thing, that songs are usually in whatever's considered the best key for singing, which will quite probably not be G or D, so you'll have to transpose. But once you can play by ear, you can forget about the whole concept or transposing, because you only have two keys (let's keep things simple for the moment), and changing from one to the other is simply a matter of changing rows.
Many competent melodeon players can't read "the dots" at all, and some try to make a virtue out of it. (I'm quite new here but I'm sure this will have arisen before). But most good players do use written music for remembering and storing the tunes, although probably not for playing. I (like an awful lot of folk players) sometimes use a written score when I'm learning how a tune goes, but once the tune is in my head, I don't use the music any more, except for things I forget. So if you can play without "the dots", just do it!
-
I've just got home from work, picked up my box and taught myself Old Lang Syne across both rows (well I only used the D row for two notes to be honest). I know it's not earth-shattering and Rabbie Burns may not be too impressed with my rendition but I feel quite pleased with myself. So I'm going to have a pint to celebrate! :|glug
-
There you go! There'll be no stopping you now.
Next time, try it with the basses as well, and you can have a wee dram as well as your pint!
-
Better sit down when you practice ;D
-
There you go! There'll be no stopping you now.
Next time, try it with the basses as well, and you can have a wee dram as well as your pint!
With bass notes as well? I'd need a 'wee dram' before I start if you want bass notes. :|glug :|glug
-
Better sit down when you practice ;D
That's no good...I can't play sitting down! My family would say I can't play standing up either! :||:
-
I'd need a 'wee dram' before I start if you want bass notes. :|glug :|glug
No, no, bum notes are not the same as bass notes ;)
-
I'd need a 'wee dram' before I start if you want bass notes. :|glug :|glug
No, no, bum notes are not the same as bass notes ;)
Mine would be...guaranteed! :|bl
-
I have been able to read music since I was a small child but when I started the melodeon I found reading interfered more than it helped. The logic of the buttons is much moire obvious if you are playing by ear. Now that I have some facility with the instrument I can sightread but I still find I make fewer mistakes when playing by ear.
-
I find it handy to read from music if I'm learning something on anything other than D/G. Somehow seeing the note on the score helps remind that for example D is a pull and not a push or to go to the inside row for Bb.