Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: folkman on June 10, 2010, 12:33:23 PM
-
Having really struggled with Dave Mallinson's Beginners Tutor Book, I have just received my copy of George Garside's 'Crash Course for Beginners' and I am, once again, raring to go. What a difference a book can make!
George's one is in a language and format I can understand. There are no complicated (in my eyes) music notations to learn, it is just full of easy to grasp instructions and it's simple message is "follow this book and you will play the melodeon". At least that's what it says to me!
Mally's book certainly has it's own virtues and will no doubt suit many people as it is quite comprehensive but I found it heavy going. Just a personal thing I guess! Whereas, with George's book, I can sit and read it quite happily even without my melodeon at hand as it is a very interesting read. The big bonus is that I don't have to read music. As long as I understand the basic scales of D and G then, according to George, I should be able to play a tune. And I believe him! He really does give you confidence!
The icing on the cake for me is that there are no nursery rhymes to learn! And what is even better, there are three songs from the North East to do much of the learning on, The Blaydon Races, The Keel Row and The Waters of Tyne. As these are three songs I am very well acquainted with, it will make my learning process that much more enjoyable. I'm a happy man today...and I have no excuse not to progress now. :|glug :|glug
-
I started with using georges book (was reading it before I got my first box...in the hope I'd be able to play something when trying melodeons on stalls my first attempt recorded from the book (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAyzpNp1_Cc)) before I bought the mally one and the John Kirkpatrick dvd and John Spiers DVD....and well anything else that had 'melodeon' in the title. I've found a 'buffet' approach to the learning material on offer the best.
-
Interesting review. Does George Garside's book not use musical notation at all, to the extent that it could be used for example for someone learning on C/F instead of D/G?
-
I started with using georges book (was reading it before I got my first box...in the hope I'd be able to play something when trying melodeons on stalls my first attempt recorded from the book (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAyzpNp1_Cc)) before I bought the mally one and the John Kirkpatrick dvd and John Spiers DVD....and well anything else that had 'melodeon' in the title. I've found a 'buffet' approach to the learning material on offer the best.
Was that your very first attempt at 'What can the matter Be'....or did you have a few goes beforehand? That was really impressive...I'm now under pressure! :Ph
-
I started with using georges book (was reading it before I got my first box...in the hope I'd be able to play something when trying melodeons on stalls my first attempt recorded from the book (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAyzpNp1_Cc)) before I bought the mally one and the John Kirkpatrick dvd and John Spiers DVD....and well anything else that had 'melodeon' in the title. I've found a 'buffet' approach to the learning material on offer the best.
Was that your very first attempt at 'What can the matter Be'....or did you have a few goes beforehand? That was really impressive...I'm now under pressure! :Ph
That was after two days of constant practice. Much to my siblings chargrin.
-
I have a benchmark to go by now! Good thing I can't have a video done though...just in case I fail miserably. :||:
-
Interesting review. Does George Garside's book not use musical notation at all, to the extent that it could be used for example for someone learning on C/F instead of D/G?
I think it's only for D/G melodeon but you might want to ask someone who knows a bit more than me...shouldn't be hard to find someone. :D
-
Interesting review. Does George Garside's book not use musical notation at all, to the extent that it could be used for example for someone learning on C/F instead of D/G?
I think it's only for D/G melodeon but you might want to ask someone who knows a bit more than me...shouldn't be hard to find someone. :D
If it just talks button numbers, as long as your box starts the octave on the third button, it will work just as well for any key.
-
I started with using georges book (was reading it before I got my first box...in the hope I'd be able to play something when trying melodeons on stalls my first attempt recorded from the book (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAyzpNp1_Cc)) before I bought the mally one and the John Kirkpatrick dvd and John Spiers DVD....and well anything else that had 'melodeon' in the title. I've found a 'buffet' approach to the learning material on offer the best.
Did you get Maggie's Melodeon book as well? I'm looking to order that as I've been told it is quite good.
-
I have a benchmark to go by now! Good thing I can't have a video done though...just in case I fail miserably. :||:
I have to say think you to those on this forum who helped me when I first started in particular Steve who even now puts up with my ranting emails every time I get stuck with a tune/technique etc.
@folkman I did have the slight dis/advantage of having been learning concertina for a couple of months beforehand so the push and pull thing wasn't completely alien.
-
I found Dave Mallinson's book really helpful. Can't recommend it highly enough, but then I didn't try any of the competitors so I can't really make a fair comparison. Did George Garside's beginner workshops at Whitby one year though, and I date that as the start of my playing career. (Thanks George.)
Guy
-
Interesting review. Does George Garside's book not use musical notation at all, to the extent that it could be used for example for someone learning on C/F instead of D/G?
I think it's only for D/G melodeon but you might want to ask someone who knows a bit more than me...shouldn't be hard to find someone. :D
Whilst it is aimed specifically at would be DGists it will work for any 21 or 23 button box ( including BC played ON THE ROW ONLY) or indeed for any one row. That is provided the student ignores the dots( they are included for those who prefer to use them) and instead follows my notation in the temporary belief that they are playing a DG box. i.e. on a CF box you can deem the inside row to be in the key of G - follow the notation and the tune will pop out in F!. The French have a word for such deeming & I think it is solmonising or something like that. I prefer to sell it simply as a DG tutor as this avoids any possible confusion.
george
-
Where can I get a copy of this book? I did a web search
and got several hit of people telling how great it is,
but no retailers selling it.
-
Its available from EFDSS ( English Folk song & dance Society) either in person from their shop at cecil sharp house, london or by mail order or direct from me via ebay. Its always on Ebay as a buy now item with full description & feedback - just put in melodeon tutor & it should come up.
thanks
george
-
Thanks -- off to ebay (:)
done
-
The only thing in the make-up of the book that I struggle with is differentiating between the push and the draw as the symbols are so similar. I know one is upside down to the other but they are still too much of a similar ilk for my personal liking.
Probably no-one else ever has this sort of problem but, to overcome it, I take a photocopy of each of the tunes, tippex out the key symbols, recopy, and then just write in the key numbers in black for the push and in red for the draw. I find this helps me enormously and I have just had a thoroughly enjoyable half hour session with the Blaydon Races and The Keel Row.
The other alternative is to write the push keys as a number and the draw keys as a number in a circle...but since I can never draw a decent looking circle I stick to my black/red combination.
As I say, this problem may be peculiar only to me (my wife is always saying I'm peculiar) but it is easily surmountable and the book really is a blessing to a beginner like myself. Thanks George!
And I like the quote at the end of the book: "Don't practice the thing - play it at every opportunity". :||:
-
I have Georges book and have just received a copy of Maggie's melodeon. They are both good books but I find Maggie's a bit easyer. ( I am a B/C player trying to get a grip of the D/G and 'English' tunes)