Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: JimJ on June 11, 2010, 04:57:36 AM
-
Hi again,
Having a great time with the Pokerwork, but already
fantisying about the future. At some point I will probably be
looking for another box. May be a G/C box as I have seen some
tutorial material for these that look promising.
The likely goal for this box would be for quieter style music. I was
wondering if anyone had recommendations for a more "mellow"
sounding instrument than the Pokerwork. Thanks --- JimJ
-
Hi again,
recommendations for a more "mellow"
sounding instrument than the Pokerwork. Thanks --- JimJ
The cheap answer is 'Pretty much anything' >:E
On the other hand any diatonic box is a compromise, so it may be worth getting a little more playing time under your belt to work out what particular compromise might suit you best in terms of favoured style of music, number of buttons, what accidentals and where, if any, what tuning etc etc.
Graham
Graham
-
If you want "mellow" then you've picked the wrong instrument. >:E
-
Actually a Pokerwork/Erica is not a loud/obnoxious/strident box, but they are played by loud/obnoxious/strident players. You can play them in a mellow manner, you can cross row to take the bounce out, it's all a matter of practice.
-
Here's an example of how they can sound.
This is just wonderful: http://www.youtube.com/user/grivemusicienne
Graham
-
Thanks all -- and yes, I plan to take my time.
The Pokerwork has a lot to teach me - I have
always been one to think ahead.
The link didn't work at first, but now it did. You
are right you can definitely get the sound I
was thinking of out of a Pokerwork -- thanks again.
-
The Pokerwork has a lot to teach me
Quote of the Week
-
The link didn't work at first, but now it did. You
are right you can definitely get the sound I
was thinking of out of a Pokerwork -- thanks again.
That's a G/C Pokerwork in those videos, playing that high up on a D/G would have dogs scurrying about and whimpering. ;D *
*That was a party political broadcast by the G/C Is Much Better Than D/G Party
-
If you like the Hohner sound and want something a little mellower I would suggest a pre-war Erika or a Club Modell 2. They are lovely sounding boxes. If you want really mellow and the key is not important go for a Bb/Eb, they sound wonderfull.
Martyn
-
Ah, so it is not so much the manufacturer, as it is
the key that gives it that sound.
-
And the way the player plays it.
Pre-WW2 Hohners have significant differences of design and construction which also influence the sound.
The pitch of the instrument also makes a big difference, D/G is the highest in common use. Going down successively there is C/F(common in N Europe) B/E (very unusual) Bb/Eb and A/D both of which are less common, but can be found fairly easily, and G/C which is the "standard" in France and elsewhere.
-
Ah, so it is not so much the manufacturer, as it is
the key that gives it that sound.
It helps, but those older Hohners do have a mellower sound anyway.
I use a Saltarelle, often with single or LM reeds, for song accompaniments which have the same requirement for a less bright tone and the ability to control the box when played quietly. The Oakwood is useless for that.
Almost any box can be played that way as long as it is well made and in good condition. My Castagnari Max makes a terrific noise when played hard, but the reeds are so responsive that it can be played quietly with well controlled dynamics and speed.
Does anyone remember John Kirkpatrick and Sue Harris doing "The Willow Tree" (song from May Bradley) ? That was a real revelation for me, in terms of the D/G pokerwork's potential for luscious lyrical harmony.
-
And the way the player plays it.
Pre-WW2 Hohners have significant differences of design and construction which also influence the sound.
The pitch of the instrument also makes a big difference, D/G is the highest in common use. Going down successively there is C/F(common in N Europe) B/E (very unusual) Bb/Eb and A/D both of which are less common, but can be found fairly easily, and G/C which is the "standard" in France and elsewhere.
I have read that before, about the various pitches with D/G highest and G/C lowest. Not that I have any intention of moving to a new system, but I was curious as to where a B/C or C#/D box would fit into this spectrum.
-
I have read that before, about the various pitches with D/G highest and G/C lowest. Not that I have any intention of moving to a new system, but I was curious as to where a B/C or C#/D box would fit into this spectrum.
They don't fit into that spectrum, basically, because they are really one-row boxes with another row full of accidentals.
On C#/D the main row, the D row, is the same pitch as the D row on both D/G and A/D boxes. (The C# row is a semitone lower and bears no relation to either the high G row of the D/G or the low A row of the A/D.)
And on a B/C the C row is one tone lower, the same pitch as the C row of a G/C box or an ordinary C/F box.
-
If you like the Hohner sound and want something a little mellower I would suggest a pre-war Erika or a Club Modell 2. They are lovely sounding boxes. If you want really mellow and the key is not important go for a Bb/Eb, they sound wonderfull.
Martyn
I think that Anahata described my Eb/Bb as a 'mellow'deon on my TOTM recording of The Sherborne Waltz' - but it's a Hohner Club Modell 1, Martyn (perhaps you'd like to put up a little demonstration track? ;D)
Diane
-
If I ever do get a second instrument, it will more than likely be
in a different key. I have seen people say that the G/C and C/F
are more singer friendly. If I get good enough I would like to play
for things like vacation Bible school -- camp meeting type songs.
Several of you have mentioned, Bb/Eb. Other than rarity, what are
the advantages/disadvantages to this choice?
-
I think the main 'mellow' issue in the melodeon is C/G tuning. Even crappo French and itallian tunes boxes express that certain richness. Of course great lutherie, and expensive reeds have their part to play. But our instrument was never really designed for D/G. It's common experience that it makes the top end virtually unusable!
Several of you have mentioned, Bb/Eb. Other than rarity, what are the advantages/disadvantages to this choice?
Er, you can get into the Sally Army that much easier (Al will no doubt chip in).
And play a fast, fluid and facile D blues scale .. it's all there on the pull 8)
and the Good News is ... :Ph
-
B/E is the unusual tuning - Germany (eBay.de) is awash with Bb/Eb boxes. It's a very nice key, infact I have 3! It's also often listed as BEs (old way of writing it). You can usually pick one up for around €100, but it would need some work to make it playable.
-
Below G/C there's also F/Bb that Stephane Delicq used so brilliantly and I have heard of but never seen or heard an E/A box.
After several years on a D/G, G/C was a revelation. My repertoire is mostly English but having two useful octaves and playing primarily in the higher one with the ability to bring the low one in or move down to it has opened up new possibilities and the timbre is just so much nicer. I still want a D/G Hohner for that particular sound but when I can afford another posh box or get round to making one for myself it'll be an A/D, I'm done with ultrasonic high notes. ;D
-
Below G/C there's also F/Bb that Stephane Delicq used so brilliantly and I have heard of but never seen or heard an E/A box.
After several years on a D/G, G/C was a revelation. My repertoire is mostly English but having two useful octaves and playing primarily in the higher one with the ability to bring the low one in or move down to it has opened up new possibilities and the timbre is just so much nicer. I still want a D/G Hohner for that particular sound but when I can afford another posh box or get round to making one for myself it'll be an A/D, I'm done with ultrasonic high notes. ;D
You speak so highly of G/C and yet if you got a fancy box it would be A/D?????
-
I think the main 'mellow' issue in the melodeon is C/G tuning. Even crappo French and itallian tunes boxes express that certain richness. Of course great lutherie, and expensive reeds have their part to play. But our instrument was never really designed for D/G. It's common experience that it makes the top end virtually unusable!
Several of you have mentioned, Bb/Eb. Other than rarity, what are the advantages/disadvantages to this choice?
Er, you can get into the Sally Army that much easier (Al will no doubt chip in).
And play a fast, fluid and facile D blues scale .. it's all there on the pull 8)
and the Good News is ... :Ph
You joke about the Sally Army --just before I "discovered" the melodeon, I was seriously looking at a duet concertina, which apparently was another one of their tools. I could never "come to grips" with the concertina. Just too much like snake wrestling to me. I like the solid positioning of the melodeon much better.
-
You speak so highly of G/C and yet if you got a fancy box it would be A/D?????
I've already got a very good G/C, I need something for all the tunes in D I originally learned on the D/G.