Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on June 11, 2010, 02:11:15 PM

Title: The need for speed...
Post by: ladydetemps on June 11, 2010, 02:11:15 PM
I'd like to know what the obsession with speed and playing a tune as fast as possible is all about?   :P
What makes someone want to take a tune that sounds nice played steadily and speed it up so you can't tell what tune it is?
Why is it so hard in sessions to play at a steady pace?
Do people play fast when they practice at home?

No particular reason...its just something I wanted to ask for a while.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Lester on June 11, 2010, 02:16:29 PM
From my viewpoint it seems to have started in the Irish session community where, as far as I can tell, fast is better than any thing else. Unfortunately it is leaking into English sessions. Mind you if I start a tune and it gallops away I am inclined to just stop everyone and start again  (:).
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: ladydetemps on June 11, 2010, 02:19:45 PM
From my viewpoint it seems to have started in the Irish session community where, as far as I can tell, fast is better than any thing else. Unfortunately it is leaking into English sessions. Mind you if I start a tune and it gallops away I am inclined to just stop everyone and start again  (:).
In my head logically wouldn't you be able to play it more than three times through if you played it slower as you wouldn't be tired so quickly? ;)
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 11, 2010, 02:35:30 PM
I am someone who tends to play too fast when they are nervous... so I am probably partly to blame. I do dislike it when nice tunes are played too fast.

I annoy the Irish aficionados by saying that only really musical tunes can stand being played slowly, which is why Irish music is played so fast and English music is played at a more sedate pace. Otherwise people would realise that there are only 5 or 6 Irish tunes and millions of variations ;)

[/tongue in cheek]
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Gandy on June 11, 2010, 02:38:39 PM
Impromptu groups of musicians seem to speed up, I think its something to do with hearing yourself clearer if you're very fractionally ahead of the others, so it turns into a race.   Also nerves or distractions make me speed up.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 11, 2010, 02:38:54 PM
If you play really fast that means you're really good, even if you don't keep a steady tempo and completely remove the feel and groove of a tune...I thought everyone knew that. ???

I don't think it's a problem specific to folk, speed freaks ruin every genre on every instrument. I was turned off Gypsy Jazz in my teens by people who think it's all about playing as many blazing chromatic runs as possible and "racing" other guitarists and seemed totally oblivious to the need for playing with a nice swing and good sense of melody.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Lester on June 11, 2010, 02:39:05 PM
From my viewpoint it seems to have started in the Irish session community where, as far as I can tell, fast is better than any thing else. Unfortunately it is leaking into English sessions. Mind you if I start a tune and it gallops away I am inclined to just stop everyone and start again  (:).
In my head logically wouldn't you be able to play it more than three times through if you played it slower as you wouldn't be tired so quickly? ;)


Playing slow is far harder than playing fast because there is far more time to make mistakes so it requires higher concentation. So in my view playimng slower is more tiring not less.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 11, 2010, 02:44:16 PM
Agreed, it is significantly more difficult to play slowly than fast imo.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 11, 2010, 02:51:10 PM
it's just become a daft fashion in some quarters to the degree that anybody playing a atune at its natural speed  has little choice but to speed up to keep up with the clever sods who are murduring the tune!

I also think that if somebody not particularly experienced at session playing plucks up the courage to start a tune albeit a bit shaky the rest should follow he or she who started the tune & keep to the starters pace as a matter of courtesy.

as others have said it is more difficult to play a tune at a steady pace & with half decent phrasing & dynamics - it is however very satisfying when a tune is played in this way by a collection of musicians.

george ( keep it simple & keep it steady!) ;D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: LDbosca on June 11, 2010, 02:59:33 PM
From my viewpoint it seems to have started in the Irish session community where, as far as I can tell, fast is better than any thing else. Unfortunately it is leaking into English sessions. Mind you if I start a tune and it gallops away I am inclined to just stop everyone and start again  (:).

While I am completely opposed to excessive speed and speed gained at the expense of rhythm, feel, etc, and indeed there's a good few hundred-miles-an-hour merchants about, that statement is definitely not true of Irish musicians in general and does Irish music a bit of disservice.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Lester on June 11, 2010, 03:05:31 PM
From my viewpoint it seems to have started in the Irish session community where, as far as I can tell, fast is better than any thing else. Unfortunately it is leaking into English sessions. Mind you if I start a tune and it gallops away I am inclined to just stop everyone and start again  (:).

While I am completely opposed to excessive speed and speed gained at the expense of rhythm, feel, etc, and indeed there's a good few hundred-miles-an-hour merchants about, that statement is definitely not true of Irish musicians in general and does Irish music a bit of disservice.

I did say it was from my viewpoint, and it is what I have seen at the Irish sessions I have been too. Mind you they have all be in England and may well not be representative of the traditional players in Ireland.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 11, 2010, 03:08:50 PM
My experience over many years has been that this is a habit of Irish style musicians on British mainland.  I did not see it in Irish sessions on the West Coast of Ireland, in eg France or New Zealand. I have only seen it rarely in non Irish music - and then usually in conjunction with tradition for a specific tune - eg pas d'été

I personally simply stop playing
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Theo on June 11, 2010, 03:28:41 PM
I personally simply stop playing

Me too, and glare at the culprit if I can identify them, unfortunately they usually have their head down and are not paying attention to anyone else, which is part of the problem.

The other way to avoid playing too fast is to play for dancing,  you won't get many gigs if word gets around that you play too fast (or too slow) all the time.

If you are playing a good steady tempo and you become aware that someone is pushing the tempo, then listen carefully and you can often spot a particular phrase where the speed increases,   often it is a passage of fast notes, or a run up a scale.  Sometimes you can get back to a steady tempo if you really sit on the rhythm at that point in the tune and play very deliberately.  If the others are listening you may get the train back on the rails.

It all comes down to using the ear - the most under-used part of the musicians equipment.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: LDbosca on June 11, 2010, 04:28:46 PM

If you are playing a good steady tempo and you become aware that someone is pushing the tempo, then listen carefully and you can often spot a particular phrase where the speed increases,   often it is a passage of fast notes, or a run up a scale.  Sometimes you can get back to a steady tempo if you really sit on the rhythm at that point in the tune and play very deliberately.  If the others are listening you may get the train back on the rails.

Just thinking, does anyone find this happens the other way round as well? There's a guitarist I occasionally play with for one gig and at the change from the end of the tune back to the start he often drags the tempo and bogs the whole thing down.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Bill the Farmer on June 11, 2010, 04:30:19 PM
There's a chap who plays in sessions in the Lewes area who has a small illuminated sign he clips to his lapel which he has set to read:
SLOW DOWN
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 11, 2010, 04:31:37 PM
My experience over many years has been that this is a habit of Irish style musicians on British mainland.  I did not see it in Irish sessions on the West Coast of Ireland,

Yes, it definitely happens in "Irish", (inverted commas heavily emphasised), sessions by people who've picked up on one aspect of the style, usually from a distorted perception, and grossly overemphasised it to the detriment of all the others.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 11, 2010, 04:40:19 PM
I personally simply stop playing

 

It all comes down to using the ear - the most under-used part of the musicians equipment.



and watching each others feet which should all be tapping at exactly the same rate !


geeorge
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: folkman on June 11, 2010, 04:54:20 PM
As a beginner, I have absolutely no interest in playing fast (even if I could). I love the sound of the melodeon when it is played in the 'jaunty' way for the morris, it is the perfect music. When I hear it played at breakneck speed it loses all it's inherent charm and appeal.
 I must admit though that I feel that way about most instruments...it's as if the musician is just showing off and has no regard for the natural sound of their instrument.  >:(
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: ganderbox on June 11, 2010, 04:56:51 PM
On the other hand.....
Playing tunes too slow makes it all rather dull and ploddy. Dance tunes need to rattle along at a fairly lively pace. Irish polkas, for example, go at quite a  lick for set dancing.
At some sessions (and I don't mean beginners sessions), everything gets played like it's a North West morris tune.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Quebecois on June 11, 2010, 05:02:01 PM
When we listen at many recordings we can hear that tunes very often got faster as we reach the end. And this is not only with traditional music. When editing recordings with computer software we can easily "see" that the pace is often 15% to 20% faster at the end compared to the beginning! This makes dubbing and mixing complicated sometimes.

This is where a metronome or a click track are useful when practicing and recording, so at least we do not take the habit of speeding up our tunes.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: LDbosca on June 11, 2010, 05:14:43 PM

Yes, it definitely happens in "Irish", (inverted commas heavily emphasised), sessions by people who've picked up on one aspect of the style, usually from a distorted perception, and grossly overemphasised it to the detriment of all the others.

Succinctly put.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: nfldbox on June 11, 2010, 05:15:16 PM
Dancing is a good control but it is a fact of life--explainable somehow, I presume--that most musicians speed up. If you spend much time in orchestras you will find the conductor says 100 "slow down"s for every one "you're dragging." The latter tends to happen only when the tempo is very fast. Otherwise, everyone speeds up. Perhaps it is just feeling the drive, perhaps once the fingers fall into place they fall faster or whatever. No question the accusation is primarily directed in trad circles at Irish but it is much more general. And back to the opening word, Irish musicians who play for dancers don't speed up.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: waltzman on June 11, 2010, 06:13:56 PM
I personally simply stop playing
If you are playing a good steady tempo and you become aware that someone is pushing the tempo, then listen carefully and you can often spot a particular phrase where the speed increases,   often it is a passage of fast notes, or a run up a scale.  Sometimes you can get back to a steady tempo if you really sit on the rhythm at that point in the tune and play very deliberately. 

At the risk of drawing fire again over the metronome issue, I would like to say that this is where working with a metronome is most useful.  It will make you aware of those bits of a tune where you either speed up or slow down.  These bits are sometimes quite hard to pick up in your own playing but the metronome will ferret them out every time!
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 11, 2010, 07:37:53 PM
this seems to apply particularly to those who don't 'keep time' with foot or even feet!. It also seems to be easier for experienced dance musicians ( who may well also play many other non dance tunes) to keep steady time as they are ab le to visualise/audiologise  the subtle difference in tempo between eg reel, rant,  , polka,strathspey, hornpipe, schottische, march, slow march etc - and thats only the 4/4's!  - i.e. they are able to 'aim'  the same tune at a veriety of functions. The same goes for balld accompanyment or just playing singy tunes on their own - its much eassier if you can at least sing it in the privacy of your own head ( vital if youv'e got a non singing voice like mine!)
george
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: GbH on June 12, 2010, 12:40:24 AM
Hmmmph!  Pshaw!  I don't really understand where all this anti-going-fast stuff is coming from.  In life generally, speed is associated with excitement and drama - think galloping horses, powerboats and rollercoasters.  Indeed, when we get excited, doesn't our heart beat faster?

In music, tempo and tempo change are additional weapons at our disposal, that we can use to make things more interesting.  You only have to hear something like Kalinka to understand the effect that tempo alone can achieve.  Bearing this in mind, surely it's obvious why people like to play fast, at least some of the time.

I don't agree with this 'it's harder to play slow' stuff, either.  To me, they're both as challenging as you wish to make them.  Playing fast most likely requires a degree of dexterity that takes a lot work to achieve and maintain - plus, even when you've achieved that, you've still got to squeeze the phrasing, articulation and musicality in there too.  If you consider that to be too easy, surely you're not being ambitious enough?

One thing that I learned when performing juggling routines was that the effects of speed are very much relative.  When I wanted to make something appear fast and complicated, I'd do something slow just before, just to get an obvious contrast.  This achieved a far greater response than simply trying to make the fast tricks faster still.  I think this is something that can work just as well with music, too (not just with tempo...) - i.e. it's not so much the actual BPM's that are key, but the relative effect it has on the listener. 

Of course, if people try and play music that's too fast for their own abilities (yep, frequently guilty as charged...) then obviously problems start to occur.  But, is that the fault of the tempo, or of the player? 
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: theSmoiler on June 12, 2010, 01:29:55 AM
this seems to apply particularly to those who don't 'keep time' with foot or even feet!.
george

George, it has become glaringly obvious to me over the years that there are many people who think they are 'keeping time' with their foot or feet - and, often, insist on inflicting 'their' time on everybody else in the vicinity - who are blatantly not in time (or, at least not in time with the style required for the particular type of music! such as when a bodhran player insists on beating 'flat' rhythms for English tunes - grrrr) ie either before or after the beat, or tapping irregularly or, not with the 'swing'. It is one of my absolute 'bete noirs' to be near such a person in a session as it is extremely difficult to keep time yourself when in view or ear-shot of such a foot! (had one such occasion recently from a banjo player at a festival Session at Holmfirth - not only did he tap not-in-synch, but he was sat at the front with large feet in almost luminous green shoes! also, he continued such tapping through someone playing a solo slow air...I had to say something  ::) ) in such cases, unless people are sure their timing is pretty accurate, they should keep their foot-tapping discrete/ discreet....

Diane
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Eric Barker on June 12, 2010, 05:30:27 AM
I have also witnessed the 'need for speed' at sessions.  At one time I blamed bluegrass and what I deemed to be its influence on Irish folk bands.  It does seem like music has sped up quite a bit since the late '70s.  I think that many tunes have a pace where they sound musical.  Of course some tunes sound good at any speed but we should be aware of those that have their special pace.  Finally, I was talking to a session musician in NYC about 10 years ago and he commented that he also had noticed a trend towards fast playing and stated that "when a singer sings a song he does not try to sing it as fast as possible.' 'So why do the instrumental players try to play as fast as they can?"  The problem with playing fast all the time is that it makes each piece sound the same.  I have had great luck finding a great variety in pace by musicians from England, Scotland, and regions such as county Clare in Ireland. Perhaps if more people tried JK's idea of playing one tune for 1/2 hour it would slow things down a bit...but once again I am rambling.  Thank you, Eric B.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 12, 2010, 08:12:38 AM
I have to admit that my foot seems to have a mind of it's own, it tends to tap on a beat or on the offbeat, but not necessarily consistently. Since it doesn't seem to affect how I play it isn't much of a problem and I don't think that it is noticeable. Also I often jig my knee up and down rather than tap. Oh and sometimes I do Quebecois stepping :P
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 12, 2010, 09:35:16 AM
I have to admit that my foot seems to have a mind of it's own, it tends to tap on a beat or on the offbeat, but not necessarily consistently.

Same problem here. Drives the French in particular mad - though I think also some English too who are too reserved to shout "Chris, tu tappes le pied comme vache invalide" across the room.  Defo a fault, my boy.  You are still young - do a bit of playing in fornt of a mirror until you've got it tamed. Yep, Québécois would be good.  :|glug
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Marje on June 12, 2010, 08:54:47 PM
Maybe the real skill is in keeping the speed constant, so you end up playing at the same speed that you started with. Of course, if you're playing with others, the tune may speed up despite you (it's always someone else's fault, isn't it? ).
 
I have the impression that jigs tend to speed up more than reels. There may, as has been suggested, be a particular point in the tune when it tends to speed up. I think it's often the gaps that are the problem - some people can't cope with long notes or rests, and tend to rush on to the next moving note.

I have no idea what you can do about this. It's easy for one person to speed up a tune in a group of players, but very difficult indeed for anyone to slow it down again, even if they want to.

And why does it matter? Well, obviously it matters for dancing. And even in a session, the speed can actually make the music heavier and less interesting. After a certain point, beats and notes get missed out altogether, so an Irish jig ends up sounding like a messy hornpipe, and a reel like a rather ploddy march, because alternate notes are simply being skipped by many of the players. The tune can then begin to lose its identity, as well as losing drive and energy.

Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 12, 2010, 09:38:07 PM
I was sat at a session recently where everything was played at breakneck pace.  After about half an hour the non-player next me turned round and said "why are they just playing the same tune?"  They hadn't been but I saw their point, it did all sound the same!

As a teenager I had a few lessons with an Irish fiddler, Pat Neely (denizens of Cleetorpes Folk Festivals in the seventies may remember him).  Smahing guy who played for the dance.  The one thing he drummed into me was that these were dance tunes, they had dances with them, play them so the dancers can dance.  I still play reels and hornpipes slower than most and my set dances are very slow compared to modern session taste.  Personally I have a repertoire of slow airs and I tend to throw these into sessions just to vary the tempo.

On a sadder note I took Peter (son) to a session when he was about fifteen, he played EC.  So he started a reel at a reasonable speed and the fiddler next to us took it over and speeded it up to a stupid extent so Peter stopped playing.  At the end of tune said fiddler looked at him and said "never mind, you'll get there someday!"  Peter bit his tongue.

A bit later Peter (ex-chorister with a ferocious gift for music) was playing a harmony to a tune.  D***head said "stop that rubbish, we only play tunes here".  Peter put away his concertina, I packed up and we left.  As we left Peter looked at fiddle player and said "Never mind, one day you'll be able to play in tune!"

Sad thing is Peter has never been to another session and hasn't touched his concertina in five years.  He now plays in a ukelele group and keyboards in a prog-rock group.

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2010, 01:00:16 AM
I have to admit that my foot seems to have a mind of it's own, it tends to tap on a beat or on the offbeat, but not necessarily consistently.

Same problem here. Drives the French in particular mad - though I think also some English too who are too reserved to shout "Chris, tu tappes le pied comme vache invalide" across the room.  Defo a fault, my boy.  You are still young - do a bit of playing in fornt of a mirror until you've got it tamed. Yep, Québécois would be good.  :|glug

I tap properly when I stand up, it's only when I sit down that it goes a bit haywire. It's not something that concerns me too much, but it is on my rather large list of "things to fix".
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 13, 2010, 12:47:42 PM
amajor problem with over fast session playing is that in reality the tune can finish up as a 'sturmey archer' job i.e. 3 speed!  At speed it is much harder to keep togeth;e;r , particularly when in a sesssion with inevitable differences in competence.  Far better to take t;he top edge off th;e speed so everybody can enjoy joining in at a reasonable pace.  It is for the same reason (keeping together at speed) that many rapper mu;sicians, myself included, mu;ch prefer to  play solo so that things dodn't get muddied.

george
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: nemethmik on June 14, 2010, 03:13:20 PM
After about half an hour the non-player next me turned round and said "why are they just playing the same tune?"
Maybe that's why an instructor told me that it's completely meaningless to learn more than two Irish dance tunes: one reel and one jig are perfectly enough.
 :D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: ganderbox on June 14, 2010, 04:06:06 PM
After about half an hour the non-player next me turned round and said "why are they just playing the same tune?"
Maybe that's why an instructor told me that it's completely meaningless to learn more than two Irish dance tunes: one reel and one jig are perfectly enough.
 :D

Same sort of thing once happened at a session I was at, when a woman complained to the musicians that  they'd been playing the same tune all night, and could they play something different.
Thing was, although there was quite a lot of Irish played at this session, it wasn't all Irish by any means, and it included a fair smattering of slow English. So, it seems that all traditional music, not just Irish, sounds the same to some people.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Quebecois on June 14, 2010, 04:40:48 PM
Maybe that's why an instructor told me that it's completely meaningless to learn more than two Irish dance tunes: one reel and one jig are perfectly enough.
That's funny!

I recently bought an Irish session album made of over 100 tunes on iTunes for only $9.99. Trouble is, all tunes are played in unison by all audible instruments (concertina, fiddle, tin whistle) and all tunes of the same kind (i.e. jigs, reels) sound really similar! Apart from a handful typical tunes we can recognize in the lot...
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Andrew Culwell on June 14, 2010, 05:25:29 PM
I do believe that in the Irish session community here in the states that there is a tendency to emphasize BPM (Beats Per Minute) and to that end learners and some midlevel and advanced players tend to think everything should be played at 125 BPM or more.  This varies wildly I went to a session in Asheville a couple weeks ago and they played every tune at a blistering rate.  As a learner I was discouraged and lost.  My local session is quite varied depending on the tune.  I also feel much is lost when we emphasize pace to the exclusion of all else. Whatever happened to individuality and interpetation?
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: MadDogMurdock on June 14, 2010, 05:58:44 PM
I am just starting out learning Irish style B/C and find that recording myself is one of the most useful tools for regulating tempo, and making tunes interesting.  While playing, although I tend to tap my toes and heels, I rarely notice changes in my tempo.  Recordings are not at all forgiving.  When listening back to what I've done I am often surprised to hear myself speeding up passages that I had thought I was playing in time.  I can then focus on regulating those areas and work to keep the tune steady. 

Recordings also make me realize how boring some of my playing can be.  I suspect I will always be improving on this.  I have a notion that if more players, of all styles, critically listened to their playing, tempos would slow, variation would blossom and the "it all sounds the same" symptoms (which I find nearly every style of music can be guilty of) would be lessened.   '

On the bright side...I am also often surprised by just how nicely I've pulled off a tune  :||:
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Howard Jones on June 14, 2010, 07:23:32 PM
Hmmmph!  Pshaw!  I don't really understand where all this anti-going-fast stuff is coming from....  Playing fast most likely requires a degree of dexterity that takes a lot work to achieve and maintain - plus, even when you've achieved that, you've still got to squeeze the phrasing, articulation and musicality in there too.  If you consider that to be too easy, surely you're not being ambitious enough?

The problem is that most people who play fast in sessions haven't achieved the required degree of dexterity, nor are they able to bring in the musicality.  Even if they could, the majority of other people in the session definitely can't, so it degenerates into showing-off rather than sharing the music, which is what a session should be about.

Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Theo on June 14, 2010, 11:23:51 PM
Hmmmph!  Pshaw!  I don't really understand where all this anti-going-fast stuff is coming from....  Playing fast most likely requires a degree of dexterity that takes a lot work to achieve and maintain - plus, even when you've achieved that, you've still got to squeeze the phrasing, articulation and musicality in there too.  If you consider that to be too easy, surely you're not being ambitious enough?

The problem is that most people who play fast in sessions haven't achieved the required degree of dexterity, nor are they able to bring in the musicality.  Even if they could, the majority of other people in the session definitely can't, so it degenerates into showing-off rather than sharing the music, which is what a session should be about.



I think GbH had his tongue firmly in his cheek when he said that, but unfortunately the handlebar makes it hard to be sure.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 14, 2010, 11:39:44 PM
Play a reel or a hornpipe at two thirds speed and listen to what you're actually playing, are those dotted quavers precise, the crotchets of equal length, the emphasis on the beat?  Playing slower means you have to be precise.  It's much, much harder.

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Theo on June 14, 2010, 11:48:19 PM
And,  whatever speed you play at in public there should be some headroom. If you play at no more than three quarters of the the maximum speed you are capable of then your playing will be relaxed and effortless. 
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: waltzman on June 15, 2010, 01:25:04 AM
Play a reel or a hornpipe at two thirds speed and listen to what you're actually playing, are those dotted quavers precise, the crotchets of equal length, the emphasis on the beat?  Playing slower means you have to be precise.  It's much, much harder.

Steve

I don't quite get this.  It's not harder to play slower.  If that were the case then all beginners would start out a break neck speed and then gradually slow down as they got better.  What is difficult is the precision that gives the lift.  It's difficult at any speed, to my mind, but to learn the precison you have to start out at slower tempos before you can bring it up to dance tempo.  What often happens is giving up precision for speed and in that case I think fast and sloppy may be easier than slow and precise.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Stiamh on June 15, 2010, 04:09:55 AM
Play a reel or a hornpipe at two thirds speed and listen to what you're actually playing, are those dotted quavers precise, the crotchets of equal length, the emphasis on the beat?  Playing slower means you have to be precise.  It's much, much harder.

Steve

I don't quite get this.  It's not harder to play slower.  If that were the case then all beginners would start out a break neck speed and then gradually slow down as they got better.  What is difficult is the precision that gives the lift.  It's difficult at any speed, to my mind, but to learn the precison you have to start out at slower tempos before you can bring it up to dance tempo.  What often happens is giving up precision for speed and in that case I think fast and sloppy may be easier than slow and precise.

Nicely put, Waltzman. I do think it's a good idea for anybody who has made a certain amount of progress - that is, after you think you can play at reasonable tempi - to slow things down and reassess your playing. At slow speeds any uncertainty about the rhythm and flow of a tune is glaringly obvious. It's not harder to play more slowly, but to be able to play a dance tune slowly and make it sound satisfying and convincing to listen to at that tempo is IMO an essential accomplishment, or at least something to strive for. (And I don't mean turning a dance tune into a cure for insomnia, looking for hidden depths that aren't there!)
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: LJC on June 15, 2010, 12:44:38 PM
The slower you play, the more notes you can fit in. It might sound a bit of a crazy statement, but in my opinion, the key to playing slowly is to have enough going on in the tune to keep it interesting (for yourself and the audience). Busy but unhurried is how a friend described it.

I think its a different matter for beginners where playing slow is necessary to build up coordination and dexterity.

@waltzman - many beginners I teach do play too fast. The most common thing is playing the easy bits really quickly and then stumbling slowly over the hard bits. It's then a process of having them slow everything down to the same speed so that the tempo and rhythm is even and consistent.

Playing too fast gets messy and dull, playing too slowly drags and is dull. There is a range of happy speeds for all tunes.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 15, 2010, 02:34:05 PM
I wasn't advocating always playing at slow speeds.  What I meant was that every so often it pays to slow a tune down down (whilst practising) and listen to what you're playing, is the precision actually there or are you masking a lack of precision with speed.  I still think it is harder to play precisely more slowly because you cannot mask any faults in a blur of notes (my bad habit when playing tin whistle).

Mind you I saw Martin Hayes last year and he redefines playing slowly and guess what? it didn't matter because it was probably the best two hours I've ever spent listening to Irish music.  There was more life, bounce and vitality in one of his "slow" reels than in the whole of most sessions.

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 15, 2010, 02:46:33 PM
And,  whatever speed you play at in public there should be some headroom. If you play at no more than three quarters of the the maximum speed you are capable of then your playing will be relaxed and effortless. 


to which I would add - never play faster than you can!

george
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 15, 2010, 05:15:21 PM
To which I would add - and continue at your own pace letting the speed junkies surge ahead. They might even learn from the experience  ;)

Indeed!

george :D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: cboody on June 19, 2010, 08:37:46 AM
Speed, once you leave the issue of dancing behind, is often a matter of comfortable technical proficiency.  Really super players can often play very fast but still include all sorts of wonderfully musical things in what they are doing.  Seems to me the rest of us should try to do the musical things at tempos that are reasonable for the type of tune and not worry too much about flying along.  Of course if you play like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_Va0ojp-Dk

You can do anything you darn well please....
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 19, 2010, 03:53:03 PM
Except speed it up it would seem ???  Watched it twice - rock steady and dancable  :|glug

As is this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0mV6fcvkv8&feature=channel (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0mV6fcvkv8&feature=channel).

Great stuff

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Peter G on June 19, 2010, 11:24:14 PM
Re John Whelan: 'Champion'! So how young do you have to be to be a junior?  ;D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Stiamh on June 19, 2010, 11:41:46 PM
You can do anything you darn well please....

Are you saying that's a fast tempo? Because to me, it's a very nice, relaxed pace. About 112 bpm, I'd guess.  Lovely tempo, lovely playing.

And I wish I could smile half as convincingly when playing.  :D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: cboody on June 20, 2010, 04:19:58 AM
You can do anything you darn well please....

Are you saying that's a fast tempo? Because to me, it's a very nice, relaxed pace. About 112 bpm, I'd guess.  Lovely tempo, lovely playing.

And I wish I could smile half as convincingly when playing.  :D

No, I didn't think it was fast, but rather that if you can play with that sort of rhythmic precision and musical content you can probably do what you wish because you have total control of your instrument (and probably of the musical styles you choose to play)
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 20, 2010, 07:49:27 AM
Ireland can be - well, Irish ???  The renouned flute player James Galway was "All Ireland Flute Champion" at junior, intermediate and open levels all at the same time, but that's another story. Yup, another rock steady dancable set just as I remember it from my 2 trips to the Wet West Coast. Isn't there beauty in that?

This awful racing thing seems to be peculiar to 'English' Irish music. (Though I hear the Paddies still do it in the Curragh of Kildare)  ;D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 20, 2010, 01:16:18 PM
Lovely laid back recordings.  I thought the speed was great and just allowed the ornamentation to work - so he ain't gonna try to go faster!

I use a few ornaments in my regular playing for a NW side which allow me to assess the speed for the dance.  If I'm struggling with the ornaments, some of the dancers will be struggling with the speed.  The same tune in a session and I drop the ornamentation or it gets bent out of shape.

Rob.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 20, 2010, 02:56:37 PM
It seems to me that there are many dimensions to playing tunes, and speed is merely one of them.  Talking about speed alone can miss the point, and I would suggest that the problem with all-out speed is where a player can't get the emphasis right any more.  If you want to play music for dancing, as many of us do, then the trick is to play in a way that catches and emphasises the movement of dancers' legs and feet in an infectious way, and understanding how that is done is probably an art more than a science.  Listening to the excellent vid of John Whelan and Felix Dolan, it's interesting how John is clearly very influenced by Felix's playing (and he often nods in his direction with a smile!), although Felix's style is actually very quiet and pretty laid back.  I would guess that the recording has deliberately downplayed the volume of the keyboard, but that John could hear it more clearly while he was playing.

Despite what disco music appears to assume, dancing does not involve hard-as-nails attack immediately on the beat, it's actually much more subtle. The box matches that, and that's IMO why it works so well (although funnily enough Irish playing tends to be smoother and less 'attacky' than English).   I also think that's why pianos complement dance music so well, and violins, flutes, and bass guitars are much the same.  (And maybe also the tuba, GbH?)  Drums, mandolins, or acoustic guitars, which have more immediate attack, don't quite give the same effect. (A well-strummed acoustic guitar can approach it, but IMO it still gives a slightly messier feel to the sound.)
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: GbH on June 20, 2010, 08:19:10 PM
(And maybe also the tuba, GbH?) 

I guess so.  Other than the odd try, I've never attempted to play one seriously, nor have I ever been involved in dancing in any form.  So, I'm not really the best person to ask.

My own brass playing has mostly been limited to the much smaller baritone horn.  It uses the same fingering as a tuba, but has a very different mouthpiece and serves a completely different role within an ensemble.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 20, 2010, 10:28:50 PM
If you can find a copy may I reccomend John Doonan "Flute for the Feis" (sadly a "Bulmerised" Trailer LP) as an LP to listen to.  It is what it says on the cover, music for competitive dancing.

I saw Pat Nealy (my mentor) play for the dance (as I have JD). He played five tunes all day (about six hours playing) and at the end his time was as rock steady as when he started.  He saw his role as providing music for the dance and the lassie who danced last had to have as good a chance as the one who danced first and it was his job to make sure that she had the same music.

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Stiamh on June 21, 2010, 02:32:50 AM
From an Irish player's point of view it's a bit odd to think about the ability to "put in" ornamentation being dependent on tempo. For most players what tends to called "ornamentation" isn't an optional extra that you can fit it if the tune is slow enough and can't manage if the tune gets fast. All the various graces are just part of the way you choose to shape the melody and they are not going to get dropped at fast tempi. The ability to execute them has to be a reflex anyway and I'd say that they are not what makes playing at insane speeds difficult.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Anahata on June 21, 2010, 08:20:09 AM
If you can find a copy may I recommend John Doonan "Flute for the Feis"

Seconded!
A fabulous album, which unfortunately I don't have any more, but I'm sure I still haven't escaped its influence.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 21, 2010, 10:07:33 AM
GbH, as an example of tuba in a dance band have you heard Roger Watson's playing in the New Victory Band's fabulous old LP 'One More Dance and Then...'?   The overall sound of the band is a bit like extremely nimble elephants hugely enjoying themselves at a party!  I think he got the effect by matching the weight of the note with the beat perfectly, without any drag at all, and the band was virtually impossible to avoid dancing to.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Peter G on June 21, 2010, 05:04:25 PM
Quote
Are you saying that's a fast tempo? Because to me, it's a very nice, relaxed pace. About 112 bpm, I'd guess.  Lovely tempo, lovely playing.

What is the right tempo for morris? I've listened to morris musicians but by the time I get home I've lost it! The ABC player has a bpm facilty so maybe I could use that? (:)
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 21, 2010, 05:30:04 PM
I used to 'accompany' morris. Different dancers - different tempo. Also I think one reason why the 'massed morris' experience .. can sometimes be less than the sum of its parts  :|glug
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Ollie on June 21, 2010, 05:34:39 PM
Quote
Are you saying that's a fast tempo? Because to me, it's a very nice, relaxed pace. About 112 bpm, I'd guess.  Lovely tempo, lovely playing.

What is the right tempo for morris? I've listened to morris musicians but by the time I get home I've lost it! The ABC player has a bpm facilty so maybe I could use that? (:)


As Chris said, it really depends on a number of things. It varies between sides, between traditions, between dances, even between dancers. It also depends on the weather in some cases.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 21, 2010, 06:07:56 PM
As Chris said, it really depends on a number of things. It varies between sides, between traditions, between dances, even between dancers. It also depends on the weather in some cases.

I still have the occassional shudder about the time I was dancing Bacca Pipes and the musician had just got a copy of "Morris On".  Only time I ever stepped on the pipes.

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: folkman on June 21, 2010, 06:45:41 PM
As Chris said, it really depends on a number of things. It varies between sides, between traditions, between dances, even between dancers. It also depends on the weather in some cases.

I still have the occassional shudder about the time I was dancing Bacca Pipes and the musician had just got a copy of "Morris On".  Only time I ever stepped on the pipes.

Steve
I thought all morris dance music was like 'Morris On' until I went to see the Chingford morris men and realised it wasn't quite so frenetic after all!  :Ph
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 21, 2010, 08:46:32 PM

I thought all morris dance music was like 'Morris On' until I went to see the Chingford morris men and realised it wasn't quite so frenetic after all!  :Ph

...and it doesn't have a horrible pub band rhythm section ruining and instantly dating it. >:E


Thread drift aside, speaking strictly as an observer, the tempo seems to vary for the reasons stated above but it's "right" when it's the same one as the dancers, I saw a godawful rapper side outside the Anchor at Sidmouth last year and it was like the musician was playing for a different set of dancers entirely. This begs the question for any of our Morrising members, there must be some degree of interdependence but generally speaking, do the dancers try to match the tempo of the musicians or is it the other way round?.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Wicked Lady on June 21, 2010, 09:19:23 PM
Well, as a NW dancer I would say the musicians should play for the dancing.
Some of them do get a bit carried away at times though.................:)
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: oggiesnr on June 21, 2010, 10:26:56 PM

Well, as a NW dancer I would say the musicians should play for the dancing.


Spot on.  Without the dancers you wouldn't need to have musicians there!

Steve
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: GbH on June 21, 2010, 11:17:34 PM
GbH, as an example of tuba in a dance band have you heard Roger Watson's playing in the New Victory Band's fabulous old LP 'One More Dance and Then...'?   The overall sound of the band is a bit like extremely nimble elephants hugely enjoying themselves at a party!  I think he got the effect by matching the weight of the note with the beat perfectly, without any drag at all, and the band was virtually impossible to avoid dancing to.

I'm not familiar with that band (my knowledge of folk artists isn't great), but just did a search and have something playing now.  Yes, the tuba is doing a very good job at underpinning the tunes.  It would probably be a good source of inspiration for playing melodeon basses, too.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Ellie on June 22, 2010, 11:12:44 AM
Quote from: WhatsAMelodeon?
do the dancers try to match the tempo of the musicians or is it the other way round?.

Other way round in our side - the musicians watch whoever is dancing as n1 fore tempo. Some of us prefer dancing with different number ones, depending on how energetic we're feeling  :D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: xgx on June 22, 2010, 01:47:55 PM
... generally speaking, do the dancers try to match the tempo of the musicians or is it the other way round?.

It's simple really... the musicians watch the dancer(s) who dance to the musician(s) who watch the dancer(s) who dance to ...
...
...
or graphically:
 :|||: :M :|||: :||: :M :|||: :||: :M :|||: ad nauseam


Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Theo on June 22, 2010, 02:16:08 PM
In other words the dancers are musicians too,  making music with their hands and feet.
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: george garside on June 22, 2010, 02:31:11 PM
Quote from: WhatsAMelodeon?
do the dancers try to match the tempo of the musicians or is it the other way round?.

Other way round in our side - the musicians watch whoever is dancing as n1 fore tempo. Some of us prefer dancing with different number ones, depending on how energetic we're feeling  :D

I just play to the feet of the best danceer in the morris side  or in a ceilidh to the feet of the best dancer I can  get a clear view of on the floor.

george
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Wicked Lady on June 22, 2010, 03:56:10 PM
That sounds like my sort of musician!

And as for these "rolling start" ceilidhs - don't get me started on that!
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Alison Scott on June 22, 2010, 06:11:27 PM
I thought all morris dance music was like 'Morris On' until I went to see the Chingford morris men and realised it wasn't quite so frenetic after all!  :Ph

When did you see Chingford? I think the tunes the way Adrian plays them are just fantastic but freely admit my bias.  ;D
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: folkman on June 22, 2010, 07:23:47 PM
I thought all morris dance music was like 'Morris On' until I went to see the Chingford morris men and realised it wasn't quite so frenetic after all!  :Ph

When did you see Chingford? I think the tunes the way Adrian plays them are just fantastic but freely admit my bias.  ;D
I first saw them way back in the 70's and the last time was outside The Traveller's Friend a few weeks ago. Much as I enjoyed the Morris On album at the time, I much prefer morris music done in the 'traditional' way as the Chingford side and others do it. Were you there that night by any chance? :||:
Title: Re: The need for speed...
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 24, 2010, 11:00:15 AM
Two other issues with NW dances are the space available - faster in a smaller space as they have less distance to cover - and the surface.  Whenever our side dance on a wooden stage, they get carried away with the racket they're making and I have trouble keeping up with them!

Rob.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal