Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: folkman on June 12, 2010, 07:31:58 AM
-
Dutifully practising/playing the learning tunes in George's book, I have, at times, managed the suggested finger changes quite well ie shifting all four fingers up or down a notch, displacing fingers etc. Other times I have not been so successful, especially when a low note is looming, and, as the first signs of panic creep in, my fingers start to resemble the movements of a demented crab as I attempt to keep the tune going. It is at times like these that I suddenly find myself playing the low note with my thumb and wonder whether this is a cardinal sin for melodeon players.
To me it felt quite natural but then, what do I know? Is this something I need to work on, to banish the thumb back to the role of spectator, or can it be acceptable?
Would very much appreciate your comments on this as I want to nip any bad habits, if indeed it is a bad habit, in the bud so to speak. ???
-
It's not a common practice and I have been known to threaten Sandy with the melodeon police for doing it. But if it works for you why not?
My preference is to not use the thumb as I use mine as a sort of anchor which informs my brain of where my hand is (hope that makes sense). Also when playing stood up and being a one strap player I have to adopt what is referred too as the "morris grip" thus having no thumb available.
(http://homepage.ntlworld.com/goldfrog/melodeon/melodeon_police.jpg)
-
So you would class it as an unusual habit rather than a bad habit? It may be that, as I progress, I will do it less and less but there is also the chance that I will get used to using it and, if no-one else does it, then that is worrying to me.
-
I think it all depends on whether you can keep the box in a stable position while doing this.
On the more general point of getting your fingers to follow instructions my fiddle teacher showed me a useful learning technique which involves moving the finger(s) to the position for the next note then PAUSE briefly before playing the note, then repeat this for each note. It does not sound very musical at the time, but it does work. It works because it allows your brain and fingers to learn one thing at a time, ie getting fingers moved in the correct sequence, then you can gradually shorten the pauses and eventually drop them. I think it's very important to develop good accurate fingering while playing very slowly like this. If you keep playing faster with panicky and incorrect fingering then the bad fingering habits will just become ingrained.
-
That seems a very good idea to me ie ensuring the fingers are placed correctly before playing the note. I think I will spend today's sessions trying that and it will be interesting (or worrying) to see if my thumb still wants to take part. Thanks!
-
It is "bad practice" but I've seen some pretty top players do it - if you want to play that "So What" opening chord (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/So_What_chord) it may be the only way.
Odd that the thumb is by far the most useful human digit - indeed it and the opponens (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opponens_pollicis_muscle) muscle are what make the wonderful toolmaking human hand what it is. ... yet we design melodeons to use it essentially as a strut. ???
-
I agree with all these postings that it is not usual to use the thumb on a melodeon & also that it helps to steady the keyboard and provides a stable reference point for where the hand is in relaation to the buttons. I would certainly not recommend a beginner to ;use the thumb- it could leaad to problems , particularly with playing inside row on a flat keyboard ( thumb catching button on outer row,k and also when crosss rowing on a stepped keyboard ( thumb not jumping up onto inside row swiftly enough) but there are no hard & fast 'rules' on this matter.
coming from a completely different direction on 'thumbing' it can be used to very good effect (on certain tunes anyway) when playing in the higher octave on the row as it can be used to put in low notes here & there and can give a fairground steam organ type of sou;nd eg life on the ocean wave, how much is that doggy in the window, and some waltzes. You can eithr play 'runs' of the melody with the thumb or bass accompaniment a bit like the foot pedals on a pipe organ. I am presently experimenting with this and if nothing else it adds aa completely extra dimension to the box.
again I don't recommendd it for beginners as it is very likey to interfere too much with the basic process of leaarning to play reasonable tunes as the maker intended!
george :D
-
I don't think there are any hard and fast rules but if you find it comfortable and helpful to use your thumb, then do it.
I can see it being an advantage for continental style players who tend to play in the higher octave on their G/C boxes making it a long stretch getting to the accidentals or reaching the low notes.
See here for a good example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgErzFxibsQ&playnext_from=TL&videos=mSEj_VTq54s
Martyn
-
I use it for one chord (actually just two notes) where one of the notes is an accidental at the end of the row and the stretch is too far to do with fingers. Specifically , second note of B music of John Kirkpatrick's Dummy Head, where just for fun you can play an E flat with the top C.
Elsewhere, CBA players use the thumb all the time, I think. Steirische players vary: Vojko Ukmar (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swq5BLob_3c) from Slovenia uses his; most Germans and Austrians don't.
-
My advice would be: don't do it! At least, not until you are much more experienced. The thumb helps to provide stability, which is vital to get crisp and accurate bellows action. If you move it off the end of the fingerboard, you lose that stability and have less precise control over the bellows. It can also lead to laziness in that you might start using your thumb when it would be better to move your hand position so that you can reach the note with a finger.
Later on, when you have more experience and have developed your own style, it can be useful occasionally. However, I would refrain from using your thumb until your own style is firmly ingrained in your mind and your fingers.
-
Many thanks for all the advice! I think I am now going to refrain from using the thumb even if it means losing the tune. Better to get the finger placements right first! :||:
-
It's not a common practice and I have been known to threaten Sandy with the melodeon police for doing it. But if it works for you why not?
I very rarely use the thumb now, probably on two tunes where I stretch into the higher octave and need one of the accidentals. I would say (for me) the use of thumb is for about .2 of a second and doesn't affect the stability of the box. Performed Jiggery Pokerwork with thumb in front of JK two years ago. He didn't say anything about it in my critique so that's good enough for me. (:) :Ph
I suppose my view would be 'use the thumb if you have to'
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
I use all of my thumbs.........I have ten!! ;D
-
Just a thought - I wonder whether people who are good at texting and use their thumbs for this will tend to use the thumb on the melodeon? Maybe the younger generation of players will naturally use their thumbs more than is traditional.
-
It is easier to use the thumb on the pull, as it is less necessary as a strut. Even with two straps it can be awkward using it on the push and if you have swift bellows changes then forget it. I tried using it for a Quebecois tune in G minor that some of you might have seen me attempt to record, but actually I found it easier to use my index finger in the end.