Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: WendyG on June 14, 2010, 07:38:03 PM
-
I have a lever style air button on my Saltarelle, the problem I have is that I have arthritis of the base of the thumb and cannot lift my thumb high enough to clear it. I find that during the playing of a tune my thumb ends up resting on the lever/button and results in air loss. What systems do other makes of melodeon use for the air button and has anyone got any ideas to avoid this problem.
PS I did try to learn to play the angle concertina originally but had trouble with the air button due to arthritis in the right thumb, so I tried the melodeon as the air button in on the left, unfortunately I now have arthritis in the left thumb ::)
Wendy
-
I'm having trouble envisaging exactly what the problem is you're having. You don't need to lift your thumb clear of the air button, the neutral position for the left hand thumb is resting on the air button exerting no pressure and the only movement you make is to push your thumb inwards to operate it.
The only other type of melodeon air button that I'm aware of is the Hohner type with a small lever that the thumb pushes downards but most people seem to feel that the push-down Hohner air button is harder on the thumb than the push-in Italian type.
*Edit*
To cause air loss you need to be actually pushing it in slightly and I've just tried to make that happen on my box and the only way I could do that was to tighten the strap too much to allow my hand to rest naturally. Maybe your bass strap is just too tight?.
-
The pull-down button type is your answer and not so difficult to use and may in fact be the solution to your problem. Perhaps go to shop and try a few different types out? I have both types and I actually prefer the pull down button because, as you say, it's less prone to accidental air loss.. Maybe try anchoring your hand below the lever may help and only move the hand up to the lever to operate the lever? Failing that - have you thought about an English Concertina - which requires no air button operation? ;D
AL
-
WhatsAMelodeon?
I find that if I rest my thumb on the button it actually allows air in or out, maybe the spring mechanism is too loose? I also do have the bass strap tight otherwise I find that my hand slips and I can't reach the C bass/chord buttons-I only have small hands.
Al, I initially tried the English concertina, but I found that the weight of the concertina was painful on the thumbs, hence the anglo.
Wendy
-
Al, I initially tried the English concertina, but I found that the weight of the concertina was painful on the thumbs, hence the anglo.
Yes, I fully understand - as I did when I first started. However, Pauline de Snoo recommends a kneck strap (like you'd use on a saxophone) which really does help take the weight off the fingers and thumbs. See filmclip here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_YC_tgZYXg). However, I can fully understand what you're saying. The EC is certainly not the best ergonoically designed instrument. The melodeon isn't, for that matter either - especially since it demands a great deal of air button use and pulling out and pushing in etc. When I want a rest, literally, I switch over to a small (48 bass) piano accordion which (like a CBA too) doesn't need manipulation of any air button - and is unisonoric - so doesn't demand as much pumping back and forth.
Regards
AL
-
WhatsAMelodeon?
I find that if I rest my thumb on the button it actually allows air in or out, maybe the spring mechanism is too loose? I also do have the bass strap tight otherwise I find that my hand slips and I can't reach the C bass/chord buttons-I only have small hands.
It's extremely hard to give any advice without being able to see exactly what you're doing. I don't know in much detail how arthritis affects your thumb so I can't really say if that's a factor but unless there's something wrong with the box, and I'd be very surprised if there was, there shouldn't be a problem. There is the odd exception but in my experience the majority of problems relating to physically operating an instrument are down to incorrect or inadequate technique and the bad habits that result and not the player's physiology but it's impossible to tell without actually being able to see.
-
Hi,
I don't know if this will help or not but it might,if you form a loop with say webbing or something similar and attach it to the bottom part of your bass strap,this loops over your wrist and supports the bass end leaving more movement for your fingers,if you e,mail pm with your e mail address or if you have fax number,will send you a sketch of what I mean.
Pete
-
WhatsAMelodeon?
Arthritis at the base of the thumb involves pain when moving the thumb in any direction and especially when gripping. It is possible that the way I hold the box may be a factor as I am self taught and have not had much contact with other melodeon players. When I nest go to a festival I will have to have a good look at how others hold their boxes and see if that is the problem.
Pete
Thanks, I have just done a search and found photos that ladydetemps posted, I will drag out my sewing box and give this a go.
Wendy
-
I have mild arthritis in both thumbs.
I converted my Castagnari air-button to a Hohner push down type and find it much easier and less painful to use.
-
I understand exactly the problem and I agree with Rees and Al, the Hohner type pull down button will help. I don't have joint pain usually but I do get pain in my thumb joint when I play a box with an Italian style push down button for any length of time. I don't think that fitting a stronger spring to the air button will help. It may allow you to avoid pain from constantly raising the thumb, but its likely to give you pain from pressing down more firmly. Ironically I have a customer with a large number of Hohners who has the reverse problem - he gets pain from the Hohner type air button. Fortunately for you I have several spare Hohner air buttons that came out of his boxes. Actually it may be simpler than that - some Italian boxes have a lever under the button that can be easily modified to a pull down movement
-
I converted my Castagnari air-button to a Hohner push down type and find it much easier and less painful to use.
A bit like this?
The PO of mine did this, my initial thought was to go back to standard but it's so nice'n'easy to use I've left well alone.
Graham
-
Exactly like that, Graham.
-
Arthritis at the base of the thumb involves pain when moving the thumb in any direction and especially when gripping. It is possible that the way I hold the box may be a factor as I am self taught and have not had much contact with other melodeon players. When I nest go to a festival I will have to have a good look at how others hold their boxes and see if that is the problem.
As I said before, it's impossible to say for sure without seeing but from what you've said and my own experimentation I reckon the most likely cause of the air loss is the bass strap is too tight and is pushing your hand into the bass panel and air button when it should just be resting lightly. If you have your box converted to a Hohner type button that should cease to be a problem.
I'm mildly surprised by this thread because I've always found Hohner air buttons far more uncomfortable than Italian style ones and if I play with one for too long my thumb starts hurting a bit, albeit at the top joint rather than the base, and most complaints I've heard of "airbuttonitis" seem to have been in relation to Hohners.
-
Actually it may be simpler than that - some Italian boxes have a lever under the button that can be easily modified to a pull down movement.
I will have a look and see what mechanism is under mine.
Wendy
-
I noted on another thread that having been used to a D/G PW, the 'spoon' air release on my newly aquired 4 stop PW was awkard to get to with my great paws, as was holding the bass end in general - but has been cured by angling the strap 'back' by removing and re siting the front top and bottom strap screws outward slightly (if that makes sense !)
HTH
If you try it, don't forget to bung up the vacated screw holes, its amazing how much wind exits these under pressure
BTW a recent investment of a £1.99 (including postage) stethescope from ebay has made locating leaks very easy :)
-
Swap the air valve to the other side and use the little finger. As a left handed play I have to use the little finger on un modified boxs and on those that Ive added a second air valve for my right thumb I still find the little finger more comfortable.
If any one wants to try my corona III is ambidextrous with both valves and I'll probably be down Old Leigh for the festival on sunday.
Another comfortable solution is a wide bar ( about as wide as all the bass buttons and a bit more ) that moves back to front. easily implemented with a couple of old bass levers (one at each end) and a length of thick piano wire soldered across as a bridge. I did this to my original pokerwork after playing a very pricey Zero Sette that had one similar. It has the advantage that your hand can move up and down the basses and the air is always there.
-
Another alternative for folks who have problems with their thumb could be a small push button directly underneath the palm of the hand on the bass end. My secondhand Stierische came with an air button like this (see photos), the seller offered to alter it to an Italian type bar for the thumb but as it was my first box and I couldn't see the advantage or disadvantage so I declined. I have no problems using this type of airbutton, I also have a Hohner with a pushdown and a Saltarelle with a lever and have no problems with them either, but the button under the hand gives the thumb a nice rest.
Louise
-
some years ago I developed an extremely painful thumb joint (bass not middle of thumb) which needed severa sessions of ultrsound dtreatment by a physio to put right. She coullldn,t understand how it had occured until I suddenly realised that it was the result of trying to bend the thumb back furthur than the makeer intended i.e. beyond about 90degreees to rech air button ( airbuttonitis!)
since then I have not had any problems but make sure the thumb is not forced back beyond its natural comfartable raange of travel. If necessary I use the paalm of the hand on some aiar buttons or the lower part of the thumb (hand end).
I too like the hohner type button on small boxes & on larger ones a bar that goes down evenly rather than being hinged at one end(as there is less leverage at the hinge end). Having said that I manage perfectly well with all air buttons by just being careful about hand position& perhaps by only using the air button very deliberately when needed rather than constantly jabbing at it .
george
-
Another alternative for folks who have problems with their thumb could be a small push button directly underneath the palm of the hand on the bass end. My secondhand Stierische came with an air button like this (see photos), the seller offered to alter it to an Italian type bar for the thumb but as it was my first box and I couldn't see the advantage or disadvantage so I declined. I have no problems using this type of airbutton, I also have a Hohner with a pushdown and a Saltarelle with a lever and have no problems with them either, but the button under the hand gives the thumb a nice rest.
Louise
Does this not lead to accidental or inadvertant air-loss?
AL
-
or maybe even the accidental breaking of wind!
george ;D
-
inadvertant air-loss?
it's all a matter of self control ;D
-
or ideal accompanyment for the song 'breaking wind suddenly' which is sung to the tune 'blow the wind southerly'
george ;D
-
I'm finding the air button on my vintage Hohner awkward to use. It's a bar that runs from top to button & is activated by pressing out (away from the body). I've become used to the newer Hohner-type button activated by pulling down. Pulling down is accomplished by simply bending the last knuckle of the thumb, whereas pushing out with the thumb involves the moving the whole thumb from the joint with the rest of the hand. I find this awkward, painful (over time) & lacking in finesse.
Are the modern "Italian-style" air buttons like my old Hohner's? Should I just work on getting used to it or try & modify the action?
-
How old is this Hohner ?
This is interesting, I have three (admittedly of basic same "pokerwork" design) Hohners from 1936, 1953(ish) and 2010 and they all have the same wonderful easily slide with the thumb design. the only ones I`ve seen with what I call "regular" Air buttons (the PA-style flat pressed button on the back) or the Italian style sloped bar are non-hohners but then I`ve hardly seen the whole range.
-
Are the modern "Italian-style" air buttons like my old Hohner's? Should I just work on getting used to it or try & modify the action?
I've played a Hohner with a long bar which sounds like yours and agree it's a bit tricky. My current Hohner has the same sliding button as a pokerwork. I'm sure though that if you use the box a lot you'll find that you adapt ok. My Saltarelles and, I think, most other 'modern' Italian type boxes have a wedged shaped air button which to my mind is a bit more comfortable to use than the Hohners. On the other hand, if you want to play 'interesting' boxes like yours, I think you probably just have to accept the different types of arrangements they have. I think the flat end of a melodeon always means that the thumb button is a bit of a compromise however it's designed and that you tend to get used to whatever you play.
-
With the modern Hohner air button I'm able to nudge it down with my thumb when I need a bit or air - it doesn't really effect what I'm doing with my fingers. With the bar on the old Hohner I find I'm having to pull with my fingers against the bass buttons in order to exert leverage with my thumb against the bar - it interferes with my bass playing because I temporarily have to shift my hand position.
-
You have some really good ideas above from many experts. However, before you spend a load of money changing your instrument or having it modified what about this. My Castagnari Mory is quite heavy and if I have the strap tight enough to support the left/bass end the strap is tight enought to restrict my hand making reaching the stops to take out 3rds and bases quite difficult. Not the same as your problem I know but similar in effect. I had a small oblong foam pad covered in chammy leather that is really for wiping/drying the inside of a car windscreen in wet weather when it mists up. It cost a pound or so from Halfords. Its about 12x8x4 cms.. I put it under the strap at the chin end and it supports the left of the instrument on my hand in complete comfort and means I don't have to have the strap tight at all. It should have the same effect for you in using the air button since you ought to be able to position your hand to take any pressure off the thumb while still able to operate the air button, basses and bellows. It weighs nothing, cost almost nothing and has no effect on the instrument at all. Good luck - don't give up!
-
Here's the solution I came up with. You can see how the bar mechanism works, activating 2 levers which open the air flow in 2 different areas. I added a small wooden button, filed on one side, to the air button bar.
Having the button there allows me to catch the edge of the button with the side of my thumb in the same way that I do with a modern Hohner air button. Even though the action is in a different direction - out rather than down - it works reasonably well. The other alternative would be to replace the whole mechanism with a Pokerwork air button assembly.