Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: tedrick on June 24, 2010, 04:31:40 AM
-
just for fun:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVbKdHuKBts
same tune
two different boxes - a Castagnari Dinn III and an upgraded Paolo flower grille. The Castagnari is set to MMM - with the M tremelo stop pulled, my Paolo is set at MMM
interesting to hear the differences between the boxes --
-
My box is famous! ;D
-
To be honest (and it may be down to the camera mic or the fact that we were given lots of free beer tonight :|glug) I couldn't hear much of a difference.
-
Maybe it was the beer Ollie ;D I can hear some difference, the Castagnari is brighter, harder more open, the Paolo more rounded, smoother sound. But its not a big difference.
-
Ah but one box is played in the bathroom (while sitting on the can!) and the other is in a regular room.. Reeds are you biased and wanting to give that Castagnari a better sound in the tiled room?? ;) ;D ;)
-
Ah but one box is played in the bathroom (while sitting on the can!) and the other is in a regular room.. Reeds are you biased and wanting to give that Castagnari a better sound in the tiled room?? ;) ;D ;)
Ah I hadn't noticed that! Mind you better is subjective, I preferred the sound of the Paolo :o
-
yeah, I should have done both recordings in the bathroom - In my hearing the Casta has a more rich, woody, softer tone - while the Paolo is brighter, slightly nasal, somewhat metallic tone -
It's fun to hear them and play them side by side -
-
For Theo: I thought the toilet paper over the shoulder would have given it away
-
Listening again, I have to say the Paolo has a more... rounder sound, if that makes any sense.
-
Well, I was there the day the two recordings were made and had a chance to play the two instruments too. The Paolo is tuned a bit wetter than the Casti and tends to sound smoother or rounder or whatever in that category. That said though, I have to admit that neither recording seems to me to be a really good representation of either instrument. The Casti is mine, and I have at least one audio recording of it that is much different (less edgy and brittle) from the sound on this video. I suspect too that the bathroom was not kind to the recorded sound...or at least resulted in a different recorded sound than the sound in the living room. I suppose if we hadn't been playing in the living room a better comparison could have been made.
I guess it just means that Reed and I will need to get together again!!
-
IMHO, both boxes sound good, as stated before, the Paolo a bit wetter sounding and the Dinn III a bit more refined sound. It also appeared that it took alittle more effort to play the Paolo, but that wasn't the question.
I admit to prefering the Castagnari as I play a Dinn II.