Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: stevejay on June 24, 2010, 03:16:22 PM
-
I know this is discussed often but anyway..
After playing a few months, I have adapted well to placing my thumb behind the keyboard, and find it much better. It took a couple of days, but now it feels natural. I also like using the thumbstrap sometimes, and don't find it to be very limiting for most tunes. The added support also improves tone and doublestops, especially on the unmodified Hohner keyboard.
Also for push-pull phrases, it makes things snappier, just a little help from the right hand and arm.
Anyone else make this changeover one direction or the other?
-
Anyone else make this changeover one direction or the other?
Yep. Started with thumb on the side - found my elbow clicked a lot- so moved thumb to behind and now have no problems. Plus IMO the box don't feel so wobbly.
-
I do it the "wrong" way too. I have always thought that gripping the keyboard gives extra bellows control which makes playing snappier. When I had a thumbstrap, I used that 2. It is true that the received wisdom saying that a thumb resting on the edge of the keyboard gives extra mobility of the other fingers, but it is only marginal and for what you gain - you lose the extra punch that the right hand can give to the bellows control.
I've never believed in such a thing as a correct way to play instruments, only in what works for an individual. Obviously some things are quite universal, but in this case there's nothing to stop you from bringing that thumb around and shifting hand position if you need extra mobility for a section of a tune and having the best of both worlds.
Cheers
Squeezy
-
I am not the best player in the world--of any instrument--but I have many years of experience as a teacher and a parent and it is my profound belief that the best teacher does not say "this is the way to do it" but "these are the ways it can be done." Then s/he helps you to learn the way that fits for you.
But back to the thumb. For me, it is not just the mobility, it is the feel. When I have the thumb in the groove on the side I feel that hand has only one job, to find the notes and I feel like I have the freedom of a piano keyboard. I use the thumb strap on the one row and it seems to me to inhibit the feel, but I need it because without it all the push-pull starts to get really clumsy.
-
I use both, mostly thumb behind for morris/ceilidh band as it gives better attack and helps with stability when stood up as I am a one strap man. But for droney, sat down tunes that explore more of the keyboard I am thumb on the edge. Best of both worlds :-)
-
I use both as well. Behind gives, as Squeezy said, a much more punchier sound; I find that my right hand beats against the keyboard, which isn't possible when the thumb is against the side. I use the edge when I'm doing Frenchy waltzy stuff, gentle tunes, as it give more dexterity across the keyboard.
-
I'm not a big believer in the thumb behind the keyboard. Mairtin O'Connor uses it but apparently he's double jointed and I think his thumb is almost vertical behind the board as a result.
One thing I'd like to add is that if you're sittting when playing and you need to use a lot of right hand force to keep the instrument steady then you might need to reevaluate either the way you hold the instrument or how much tension is in your shoulders, legs or back. It's possible to keep the instrument steady with very minimal force from the thumb and with a single strap if you've good posture and very little tension in the shoulders and other areas. I say this not to dismiss the thumb behind the board method but just to make sure that no one's hurting themselves unnecessarily when playing. It's something I've been dealing with in the past twelve months.
Luke.
-
with two well adjusted straps the thumb should not really have any part in steadying the keyboard whereas with one or no straps it is more importantas a steadier of the box. Playing with it on the edge of the box - in the groove if provided makes it easier to use on Dg boxes to pot the accidentals near the chin. however as others have said there are no hard & fast rules & personal co;mfort is important. With my serenellini salterello I don't always take my own advice sometimes 'hanging' my thumb on the convenient hook shaped top of the keyboard!
george
-
One thing I'd like to add is that if you're sittting when playing and you need to use a lot of right hand force to keep the instrument steady then you might need to reevaluate either the way you hold the instrument or how much tension is in your shoulders, legs or back.
Thus proving that B/C system and D/G system are completely different instruments disguised under the same hardware! I apologise for not stating that I was talking about the "fifth-apart" instruments.
-
with two well adjusted straps the thumb should not really have any part in steadying the keyboard whereas with one or no straps it is more importantas a steadier of the box.
I disagree entirely. This is the kind of received wisdom I was talking about which had me angsting with neuroses in my formative years of box playing. No combination of straps, back straps and use of the crook of the knee has quite the control over the bellows for punchy English playing that a firm grip with the thumb and the lower fleshy part of the hand can give ... and believe me I've tried.
If you use the thumb on fingerboard technique and play more delicately then it is probably better to continue to do so, but those interested to try should not feel they are doing anything wrong in trying a firmer grip. Having watched a lot of players I can tell you that John Kirkpatrick, Saul Rose, Simon Care and Simon Ritchie all get excellent results this way and if they had all taken George's advice their playing would lack a lot of the punch and excitement that all these players exhibit.
-
I do it the "wrong" way too.
Cheers
Squeezy
I'm with John on this one. Have always had my thumb behind the keyboard, and, like Ollie, my hand ie the part of the palm immediately below my fingers - dorsal side of the metacarpals - beats against the keyboard. My playing has been described as 'bouncy', so, maybe that's what contributes to that. I've always found the 'thumb on the groove' position really uncomfortable: I've always had poor muscle-tone and a degree of hypermobility in my wrists so, doing this tends to put my wrist into a really awkward position, with the tendons already stretched and tending to 'click' - definitely not an anatomically functional position for the hand, whereas the 'behind the keyboard' stance retains more of that functional arch and IMO allows for greater flexibility and extention of the fingers [thinks....takes little-used goniometer from work bag and measures...yep, objectively greater hand span in latter position].. However, I have noticed that my style has changed over time - possibly through need, with playing trickier tunes - so that this position is far less of a grip, more just a position, so that my thumb can move freely in and out behind the board, towards the edge of the keyboard, as required, depending on what I need to reach or do to play a particular tune. Which is why I now find it more difficult, as a 1-strap player, to play a lot of the tunes I play in standing. Whereas alot of the more basic dance rhythms, which need a particularly powerful 'beat' such as in morris tunes, can be played adequately in standing with the thumb behind and the hand beating the keyboard. In which case, turning the argument on it's head, for this particular usage, is not the melodeon then a support for the handi rather than the other way round?
Diane
-
I use both. I started out using a thumbstrap, then progressed to thumb behind and now am using the jam more and more. Essentially though if you have two straps a lot of the force that is required by the RH thumb is gone, so there isn't that great a loss of dexterity when you grip behind, as you need to press less hard. So you get that kind of drive without being restricted in ability to manoeuvre. In practice though I end up playing thumb behind for English music and thumb on jam for Irish (broadly speaking).
EDIT: Exactly what Diane said with regards hand position rather than grip.
-
with two well adjusted straps the thumb should not really have any part in steadying the keyboard whereas with one or no straps it is more importantas a steadier of the box.
I disagree entirely. This is the kind of received wisdom I was talking about which had me angsting with neuroses in my formative years of box playing. No combination of straps, back straps and use of the crook of the knee has quite the control over the bellows for punchy English playing that a firm grip with the thumb and the lower fleshy part of the hand can give ... and believe me I've tried.
If you use the thumb on fingerboard technique and play more delicately then it is probably better to continue to do so, but those interested to try should not feel they are doing anything wrong in trying a firmer grip. Having watched a lot of players I can tell you that John Kirkpatrick, Saul Rose, Simon Care and Simon Ritchie all get excellent results this way and if they had all taken George's advice their playing would lack a lot of the punch and excitement that all these players exhibit.
When playing for morris (standing up, one strap -- see photo) I find I can really throw the box around with excellent control over it, with the right hand end braced between thumb behind keyboard/heel of hand against edge of keyboard/tension in strap.
For this to work you need quite a long strap with the box held quite low down and across to the left of your body, otherwise the right arm and hand are at an awkward angle. This also means you use stronger arm muscles on the bellows because you're extending and retracting your left arm, not moving it sideways.
The strap hangers also need to be in the right position for this to work; on many boxes they aren't (usually too close to the rear) which means that when you apply pressure to the edge of the keyboard with the heel of your hand, the box swivels forward and wobbles. When one of the new Smiffs musicians was learning he had big trouble holding the box this way until I had a go and told him to move the strap hangers forwards about 2cm, which transformed the way the box moved.
Ian
P.S. Playing for the band I brace the box against right leg (raised on an instrument case) and put my thumb on the edge of keyboard, the box is still in the same place but it's easier to play more complicated tunes because the hand is less curled and can move up and down the keyboard more easily.
-
One issue many players have is that they keep their elbow too close to their body. Try moving the elbow away and see what happens with your hand and thumb position! It also changes the dynamics of your playing.
-
The strap hangers also need to be in the right position for this to work; on many boxes they aren't (usually too close to the rear) which means that when you apply pressure to the edge of the keyboard with the heel of your hand, the box swivels forward and wobbles. When one of the new Smiffs musicians was learning he had big trouble holding the box this way until I had a go and told him to move the strap hangers forwards about 2cm, which transformed the way the box moved.
Excuse my ignorance but what are the strap hangers ? :|bl
I have changed more to a one strap style but I know it's not quite right.
cheers
Sandy (:)
-
Excuse my ignorance but what are the strap hangers ? :|bl
I have changed more to a one strap style but I know it's not quite right.
cheers
Sandy (:)
These are the brackets your straps attach to. Ian is saying that these are often/always to the very back of the box, nearest your chest/waist that is. Moving them forward slightly alters the balance of the box. My only query would be whether there is enough 'meat' in the wood to hold the screws if you move them out. The point is taken however, balance is paramount to player comfort and confidence. If the woodwork at the ideal point is not sufficient to carry the weight there are work-arounds to beef up the attachment points. This may need an accordion tech to make the alteration depending on your DIY skills.
-
Excuse my ignorance but what are the strap hangers ? :|bl
cheers
Sandy (:)
I think Ian is referring to the metal brackets - be they crescent-shaped, V-shaped, etc., - that the straps are connected through at top and bottom of the box. Just looked at mine, and they are all very firmly to the rear of the box - can't say, personally, that, as a one-strap player, I've ever had an issue with this. I agree about length of strap, though - finding my current (child-sized) one a tad on the short side. Also, agree with Quebecois about holding the elbow away from the body - which I do, and which means my hand then isn't curled over when my thumb is behind the box.
Diane
-
I agree with John and Diane - I find using the groove to be totally unhelpful. My usual position is to have the thumb resting on the back edge of the keyboard (ie the side closest to the body), where it can exert enough pressure to steady the box without cramping the fingers. It's very easy from that position to use the palm of the hand on the edge, or even slip into the full "morris grip", when I want some extra "thump", and back again when I need to play something intricate.
I've recently changed to two straps after years of playing with just one. Like John, I've never found a suitable way of adjusting the straps which steadies the box firmly enough for English-style playing, and I don't like having the box lashed tightly to my chest. After some experimentation I've started to attach the right-hand strap to the top loop of the left strap, rather than to the hanger - this puts the "hanging point" close to the chest, so there is more stability, while allowing the instrument to hang away from the body by a couple of inches, which I find more comfortable and a good compromise.
-
P.S. Playing for the band I brace the box against right leg (raised on an instrument case) and put my thumb on the edge of keyboard, the box is still in the same place but it's easier to play more complicated tunes because the hand is less curled and can move up and down the keyboard more easily.
I once played for a long processional event (Jack in the Green London City - not sure if they do it there any more) with thumb behind the KB of my pokerwork, and got agonizing hand pain from playing for several hours with fingers curled up. I can get away with simple morris tunes played like that, but I now always play with tip of thumb against edge of keyboard (the Oakwood has a concave edge making this easier) and much prefer the flexibility of hand movement.
I use a back strap when I have to stand up to play, and brace melodeon against right leg otherwise.
-
I find that I do both depending upon the instrument; generally using only one strap.
For instance, the keyboard on my Liliput is just over 30mm thick, and I don't find it very comfortable to put my thumb under it. Also, I find it a bit easier to get round the keyboard with my thumb on the edge, so that my fingertips come down as near as possible vertically on the small buttons - something I couldn't easily do "thumb under", mainly because of hand size & finger length.
On the other hand (well, it's actually the same one), the keyboard on an Erica (German, plastic keyboard version) is about 22 mm thick, so it's a case of "thumb under". Also, the slightly rounded slippery plain edge isn't that good for putting your thumb on and keeping it there.
I can't say that I've really given it much thought, and I've tended to do what feels best rather than what is considered "correct". In light of this discussion, I'll probably try some of the different methods to see if they make a difference!
-
I took up thumb on the edge early on for dexterity but have often wondered why more boxes don't have a groove at a better angle , about 45degrees edge chamfer. I have put such a groove on a few of my own fingerboards to make it more stable. But i suppose that is a bit commiting in production.
-
We all use a personal technique that works, but I never found the need to "rest" my thumb while I play! My hand goes where the fingers have to be and it makes things really simple. I really only use my thumb with the 1-rows that have a thumbstrap...
-
strange isn't it that playersof piano accordions (& continental chromatics) large & small manage perfectly well without gripping the keyboard with thumb, palm of hand or whatever! ! Neither do concert pianists attempt to push the piano accross the stage with the hand or thumb whilst playing - its all very odd but somehow they manage!
george ;)
-
strange isn't it that playersof piano accordions (& continental chromatics) large & small manage perfectly well without gripping the keyboard with thumb, palm of hand or whatever! ! Neither do concert pianists attempt to push the piano accross the stage with the hand or thumb whilst playing - its all very odd but somehow they manage!
george ;)
But accordion players don't have to pull and push the bellows all the time to get the notes out, and PAs tend to sit still while you play them (as do pianos), unlike melodeons which bounce around all over the place. :M
-
strange isn't it that playersof piano accordions (& continental chromatics) large & small manage perfectly well without gripping the keyboard with thumb, palm of hand or whatever! !
You don't have to do that with a melodeon either if you use two straps like PA players do. (and often a backstrap too). This thread only exists because the melodeon world (especially the UK department, I suspect) is is full of single-strap players.
Many PA players have a different problem though - an uncontrollable need to keep their right hands on the keyboard and at least one key pressed the whole time, as if the slightest momentary loss of contact would result in the keyboard vanishing into a black hole and never being found again.
-
Many PA players have a different problem though - an uncontrollable need to keep their right hands on the keyboard and at least one key pressed the whole time, as if the slightest momentary loss of contact would result in the keyboard vanishing into a black hole and never being found again.
;D
-
strange isn't it that playersof piano accordions (& continental chromatics) large & small manage perfectly well without gripping the keyboard with thumb, palm of hand or whatever! !
You don't have to do that with a melodeon either if you use two straps like PA players do. (and often a backstrap too). This thread only exists because the melodeon world (especially the UK department, I suspect) is is full of single-strap players.
precisely!
george :D
-
Must admit that I was a bit intimidated by the advice on this site to put your thumb on the edge. I started playing the melodeon in the way that felt the most natural for me (thumb behind the keyboard) and just carried on that way. Also since I always use the thumb strap on my excelsior, I was surprised by te criticism they get here. I tried to move my thumb and stop using the strap, but in the end I feel like squeezy that I get better punch with my thumb where it is (I play for Morris and busk mostly).
In the end I think each to their own. But I would say I don't think there is anything wrong with the thumb behind the keyboard method and thus it shouldn't be seen as the 'wrong' way. I hav even been known to curl my thumb round in the front in the thumb strap when playing without straps or on the D row and this also seems perfectly effective.
-
I don't think anyone's said "thumb behind" is wrong. It has its advantages and disadvantages, but so do other grips. Personally, I think the best way (NB not the "right" way) is to have the flexibility to move between positions which best suit whatever you are playing at the time, whether it's punchy dance music or something intricate.
The disadvantage of using the thumb strap is that it anchors the hand in a specific position. Many players, myself included, find that hampers them once they start to move around the keyboard more. On the other hand, some players like it precisely because it does give them an anchor, a reference point so they always know where they are.
As long as the way you're holding the instrument doesn't impede your playing then fine. If you find you are having difficulties playing certain things, consider whether the hand position is a factor and whether you should alter it. That doesn't mean giving up what you've been doing, just having the adaptability to adjust to different situations and requirements.
-
Each to hiers own but I definitely favour behind.
-Maneuverability not a problem (and in any case most melodeons only have 23 or so buttons which don't occupy a great vertical distance)
-Far more stability and control.
-
agreed each to their ownbut another disaadvantage to thumb under keyboard is that it ( the thumb) can't easily be used to pot the accidentals at the chin end & using the thumb for these oddly placed notes is probably the easiest way of getting at them. Thre is also scope for using the thumb as a fully paid up playing member particularly when playing in the higher octaves.
There also tends to be a difference of thumb position between 4th apart & semitone players, the latter being more likely to use the thumb groove where fitted. The thumb under technique can also for some people be very resticting when playing accross the rows on aa 3 row box of whichever denomination,.
george
-
agreed each to their ownbut another disaadvantage to thumb under keyboard is that it ( the thumb) can't easily be used to pot the accidentals at the chin end & using the thumb for these oddly placed notes is probably the easiest way of getting at them. Thre is also scope for using the thumb as a fully paid up playing member particularly when playing in the higher octaves.
There also tends to be a difference of thumb position between 4th apart & semitone players, the latter being more likely to use the thumb groove where fitted. The thumb under technique can also for some people be very resticting when playing accross the rows on aa 3 row box of whichever denomination,.
george
That is something else that works differently from person to person. When I started playing tunes with too many accidentals I tried to use the thumb, but found it too unreliable. It was better to use my fourth and fifth fingers for the tune and the second finger for the accidentals. In the same way that I find it easier to use 2 and 3 for harmony and 4 and 5 for the tune (when I can be bothered to work out harmony).
-
I took up thumb on the edge early on for dexterity but have often wondered why more boxes don't have a groove at a better angle , about 45degrees edge chamfer. I have put such a groove on a few of my own fingerboards to make it more stable. But i suppose that is a bit commiting in production.
A couple of the design changes made to my Oakwood were to tilt the fingerboard back at a bigger angle, and to chamfer the edge with a groove made to fit my thumb :-)
Ian
-
I've been a confirmed "thumb-on-edge" player, but having spent Saturday playing at the Chepstow weekend of Dance, we were teamed up for part of the afternoon with Hook Eagle (who were excellent!), and I had the chance to listen to DTN and Jimbo(I think-difficult to tell under the facepaint) playing at close quarters. It's the first time I've really "got" the whole one-strap-and-thumb-behind-the-fingerboard gives a different feel thing properly. Like others here, I've tried it occasionally for brief periods, and occasionally slip into it at ceilidhs, but have never persevered consistently or for long enough to get it to feel natural...so something else to practice and try and learn. Thanks both....I think....
Cheers,
Guy
-
Thanks both
I have the feeling that thumb-behing-the-board style is applicable only for 2- and 2.5-row melodeons (in D/G :D )
Have you seen players of 1 and 3-row melodeons using thumb-behing-the-board? It does not work on a chromatic button accordion and possibly equally not on B/C/C# neither on Steirische.
-
Thanks both
I have the feeling that thumb-behing-the-board style is applicable only for 2- and 2.5-row melodeons (in D/G :D )
Have you seen players of 1 and 3-row melodeons using thumb-behing-the-board? It does not work on a chromatic button accordion and possibly equally not on B/C/C# neither on Steirische.
Fairly common on 1 rows - prime example (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6JphSVI_Wqo)
-
I've been a confirmed "thumb-on-edge" player, but having spent Saturday playing at the Chepstow weekend of Dance, we were teamed up for part of the afternoon with Hook Eagle (who were excellent!), and I had the chance to listen to DTN and Jimbo(I think-difficult to tell under the facepaint) playing at close quarters. It's the first time I've really "got" the whole one-strap-and-thumb-behind-the-fingerboard gives a different feel thing properly. Like others here, I've tried it occasionally for brief periods, and occasionally slip into it at ceilidhs, but have never persevered consistently or for long enough to get it to feel natural...so something else to practice and try and learn. Thanks both....I think....
Cheers,
Guy
We utilised the rapid beer technique too by drinking a pint per tune set!
Was a good idea at the time .. but Chepstow seemed fuzzy on Sunday!
DTN
-
I suppose it depends how you see the melodeon. Coming from a rock background I see it as a lead guitar. So one strap and make a statement, sling it low over the hip, I know it's ergometrical wrong but you're a lead guitar. Therefore a thumb strap and an anchored thumb behind the keyboard are essential so you can strut your stuff!
Twin straps and a backstrap are so bass guitar and the only reason a rock band hass a bass player is to translate for the drummer >:E
Steve
-
Sting may disagree!
-
I suppose it depends how you see the melodeon. Coming from a rock background I see it as a lead guitar. So one strap and make a statement, sling it low over the hip, I know it's ergometrical wrong but you're a lead guitar. Therefore a thumb strap and an anchored thumb behind the keyboard are essential so you can strut your stuff!
Twin straps and a backstrap are so bass guitar and the only reason a rock band hass a bass player is to translate for the drummer >:E
Steve
;D ;D ;D ;D
-
*now has mental image of melodeon rock band*
so what staps would the melodeon equivient of a drummer use?
-
I suppose it depends how you see the melodeon. Coming from a rock background I see it as a lead guitar. So one strap and make a statement, sling it low over the hip, I know it's ergometrical wrong but you're a lead guitar. Therefore a thumb strap and an anchored thumb behind the keyboard are essential so you can strut your stuff!
Steve
.......leading to peculiar physical behavior that can only be described as "air melodeon" ;D
-
.......leading to peculiar physical behavior that can only be described as "air melodeon" ;D
I occasionally get strange looks from people as I walk down the street moving my arms about and wiggling my fingers with a distracted look on my face :P
-
not as strange as the habit many concertina players have of playing their instruments on their knees under pub tables. Some of the punters must wonder what sort of gathering they have walked into!
george ;D
-
What about "thumb behind keyboard" and "cross-rowing" .. does it work ? I tried and it didn't work very well, at least for me.
I'm a "Thumb-on-edge" and "cross-row" player.
-
What about "thumb behind keyboard" and "cross-rowing" .. does it work ? I tried and it didn't work very well, at least for me.
I'm a "Thumb-on-edge" and "cross-row" player.
Works for me (:) Although if I have a particularly difficult cross-rowing passage I will slide my thumb up to the edge or the groove.
-
Yikes! I've read through the various "thumb position" threads & I must say the issue remains as clear as mud!
I started off using the thumb strap - which was more comfortable with my older Pokerwork which has a very worn, pliable thumb strap, than my newer Pokerwork which has a very stiff strap. At that point neither of my Pokerworks were equipped with shoulder straps & I was playing with the box supported on my knees. I graduated to positioning my thumb outside the thumb strap on the back of the keyboard.
Now I am finding that I am developing fairly severe pain in my right thumb joint, presumably from the strain of clamping my thumb behind the keyboard. Playing with my thumb alongside the edge of the keyboard seems to leave me without enough control over the bellows. I have added a shoulder strap, but don't find that this makes enough of a difference.
Reading through the huge variety of responses to the question of thumb position hasn't really clarified things. :-\ Does anyone have any other suggestions that might help?
-
this ground has been well trodden! many different combinations of thumb position, one or two shoulder straps, back strap or whatever all work ok for different people. HOwever if the box is firmly attached to the person (or should it be the person to the box!) anad two shoulder straps properly adjusted is the only way to do this, then the position of the thumb becomes largely irrelevent as far as holding/supporting the box. Piano accordion players havn't got a spare thumb for such purposes as they need the only one they've got tp play the tune & they manage perfectly well thus equiped. Therefore logic dictates that the thumb can be behind or on the edge of the keyboard or if desired could even be involved in a little playing of the tune.
In other words the question of attachment of the person to the box comes before the question of where to park the thumb as the former can have a direct effect on the latter.
george
-
two shoulder straps properly adjusted is the only way to do this,
No it isn't but it is your prefered method ;)
-
No it isn't but it is your prefered method
Exactly! Clear as mud! ;)
I have seen:
using just the thumb strap in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
with the thumb behind the fingerboard in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
with the thumb alongside the fingerboard in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
with one strap with the thumb behind fingerboard in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
with one strap with the thumb alongside the fingerboard in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
with two straps with the thumb behind the fingerboard in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
with two straps with the thumb alongside the fingerboard in a sitting position - with the box on the left knee/the right knee/both knees.
standing with one strap with the thumb alongside the fingerboard.
standing with two straps with the thumb alongside the fingerboard
... and probably some other variations that haven't occurred to me just now!
All played very successfully! I should emphasize that my concern at this point isn't what style offers the optimal playing efficiency, but rather avoiding the RSI pain associated with my clamping my thumb around the back of the fingerboard
I just tried putting the second strap on & standing - it does seem to stabilize the box quite a bit more than just one strap leaving the fingers able to move more freely. Just need to re-learn everything again. :-\
I also tried my PA - the difference is, the weight of the box is greater, so it's less inclined to move around, the action of the keys & bass buttons lighter & smoother, & (especially) the motion of the bellows less frequent & less vigorous - all of which makes the playing action significantly different ...
-
All played very successfully! I should emphasize that my concern at this point isn't what style offers the optimal playing efficiency, but rather avoiding the RSI pain associated with my clamping my thumb around the back of the fingerboard
The big list of possibilities, I think, only proves that you need to try out some of them and see what works you as different people are happy with their way of holding the box and will quote it as the only possible sensible solution ;)
I for one use a single strap over my shoulder with Morris death grip when stood and single strap over the elbow with thumb on edge of keyboard when sat. I can, and do, play for hours on end with either style.
-
Now I am finding that I am developing fairly severe pain in my right thumb joint, presumably from the strain of clamping my thumb behind the keyboard.
Playing with the thumb behind the keyboard doesn't necessarily mean it has to be "clamped"; I find it sufficient to rest the thumb against the back of the fingerboard when playing this way (I swap between "behind" and "on the edge" depending on what kind of tunes I'm playing and the circumstances - though some would say my playing is often "on the edge"!). Like Lester, I play with one shoulder strap and find no problem with a 4-hour ceilidh or an all-day morris tour.
Graham
-
Your point is well taken Lester. It is natural, however, for beginners to want to learn the "right way" & a bit disconcerting when the "right way" is such a moving target!
I do wonder, in the case of "Morris death grip", if MY death grip is just too deadly, or if, alternatively, over time my thumb would strengthen. The frustrating thing is being forced to take a break when I've got the bit between my teeth ... :||:
I'm also wondering if limiting the button travel on my Pokerworks wouldn't help somewhat by making the button action quicker & more fluid.
-
I'm also wondering if limiting the button travel on my Pokerworks wouldn't help somewhat by making the button action quicker & more fluid.
Probably.
-
Your point is well taken Lester. It is natural, however, for beginners to want to learn the "right way" & a bit disconcerting when the "right way" is such a moving target!
I do wonder, in the case of "Morris death grip",
Blimey I now have visions of Mr.Spock on melodeon...
'It's music Jim, but not as we know it....."
-
My Loffet doesn't have a thumb strap as the previous owner removed it. I started off playing with my thumb on the edge of the keyboard and quickly discovered that it hurt! and it swelled! Not could as I need my hands in good shape to earn my living!
I now play it with the thumb loosely behind the keyboard and the double straps properly adjusted.
Steve
-
Your point is well taken Lester. It is natural, however, for beginners to want to learn the "right way" & a bit disconcerting when the "right way" is such a moving target!
Wisdom approaches when you realize there's no right way.
I do wonder, in the case of "Morris death grip", if MY death grip is just too deadly, or if, alternatively, over time my thumb would strengthen.
I had that problem too when I was learning....especially when I took up fiddle for a couple of years. I think sometimes we try so hard, we feel that if we aren't at full clench, then something will escape us. It requires us to practice relaxation along with getting the notes in order. Things come about more freely when you are comfortable and not tense.
I'm also wondering if limiting the button travel on my Pokerworks wouldn't help somewhat by making the button action quicker & more fluid.
At first, Pokerwork buttons seem absurdly incorrect and need to be prevented from disappearing down those dangerous holes. After you play it for many many hours, that idea goes away, and the box teaches you to have just the right touch.
-
A big help in learning to be relaxed while playing is to learn to play at quiet to medium volume while still keeping a strong rhythmic pulse to the music.
-
Do you think it matters for the discussion how much time exactly you play a day?
I think if you are playing a couple of hours a day the way you keep your body (and thumb and fingers) is much more important than if you play 2 hours a week. Not exactly for the tunes you play, but for keeping your body healthy and painless.
W
-
So I went back & attached BOTH straps to my Pokerworks box & played it standing up, & guess what ... I found it quite easy to play without my thumb applying any pressure. In fact, it also seems to make it easier to press the treble buttons without pushing them into their holes, probably because the thumb pressure is no longer acting as a counter-pressure to the fingers. The key is allowing the box to HANG so that the weight stabilizes it - previously I was using a single shoulder strap & resting the box on my thigh. This I was doing based on seeing others (apparently) use this technique.
I can see that there are any number of techniques that might work, particularly when there is enough basic skill established in bellows control, & bass & treble button control to allow for a somewhat more relaxed approach.
-
Oops - double post.
-
A big help in learning to be relaxed while playing is to learn to play at quiet to medium volume while still keeping a strong rhythmic pulse to the music.
totally agree! It is also helpful to get the hang of using the wrist rather than the whole arm for fine bellows control. The bellows are the heart of the box and are to the box plaayer what the bow is to the fiddler
george
-
Do what feels right!
I find it varies from box to box. I started with using the thumbstrap on a Pokerwork, and got the blisters to prove it, but when it tore I switched to playing with thumb behind without a strap, and I still play that box this way for most tunes - there is the odd tune, particularly in D, when thumb on the edge seems to make it easier to play fast runs.
On my Black Pearl III I took the thumbstrap off from day 1, and played with thumb behind, and still do as it feels comfiest.
However, on my new Binci thumb behind seems to restrict what my fingers can do, so I play with my thumb at right angles on the edge of the keyboard.
On my Hohner Overture IV, thumb behind makes it difficult to reach the half row, hence thumb on the keyboard edge is great, and loose thumb above the keyboard is even better as you can use it on right hand chords - note that this box is huge, and hence has double shoulder straps and a back strap, so it is very stable without having to use any thumbs.
My advice is to try every permutation on lots of different tunes, and see what works for you.
-
My advice is to try every permutation on lots of different tunes, and see what works for you.
Yep, I play with two straps almost all of the time although I've bought a Mally strap that is really quite good on its' own when you're sitting down. Mostly my thumb rest on the edge of the keyboard (but sometimes I play the odd note with it 8) ). I've tried playing with my thumb around the back of the fingerboard and although it stabilizes the box wonderfully it seems to limit my fingers too much and everything seems very awkward. Others play really well using this technique so it's obviously horses for courses. Try everything, more than once, and don't abandon anything until you are sure it's not for you, then re-visit it a year later just in case anything has changed. There are no rights or wrongs and it's all to play for.
-
I've made a tiny addition to my melodeons that might be of interest for other 'thumb-strappers'.
Reason is that I don't think modern melodeons like Castagnari etc. are constructed to suit thumb-strab players well - the sharp edges on a thin keyboard and fingertips coming all too close to buttons calls very clear for free-hand tecnique. So I've made this little tool since I want to stay a strapper:
Simply a piece of rounded stick, a bit of cutting and sanding and some velcro to fasten the stick to the edge of the keyboard. To me it gives a much more flexible finger-moving, the stick can be moved to another of my melodeons in seconds and the carving at the top-end of the stick makes it easy to change to free-hand if I should want now and then (back again needs a bit more training). In the strap behind I've just my thumbtip placed to feel precisely where my hand is, no pulling. Crossrow works ok for me.
Hope the photos illustrates how. This little piece of danish design can be seen in use at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dp9jYUTlRbQ
-
Lovely danish design!
-
The thumb strap works fine on my old Pokerwork because the strap is well-worn. I find I get good control of the box without the pain issues from grasping the back of the fingerboard. However, if the tune requires the last button at the bottom (high end) or especially the last couple of low buttons, it is quite awkward.
I have been playing 2 - 3 hours a day for the last month or so - so pretty intense for an unhardened beginner...
-
I find my hand is to big to use the thumb behind technique, which is a factor not mentioned before. If the base of my thumb is against the keyboard, I have to bend my fingers too much to be comfortable. Maybe I should fashion on of those wooden gizmos as a spacer? I do find the box a little unstable with my thumb on the side, and it sometimes slips off a inopportune moments...
David
-
Yes, relative size of hand is likely to be most influential. I have small stubby hands and usually play thumb behind, but I took the Preciosa for an outing this week and suddenly realised that I was playing with the thumb on the edge. Mind you, the box shouts so loud it stays quite stable at reasonable bellows pressures.
Rob.
-
BUMP
Putting the thumb behind the keyboard has helped me a lot as I mostly play on the inner row of a 3 row - C/C#/D in my case, a sharpened version of B/C/C#. Having my thumb on the edge seems to add some unwanted strain, not surprising since B/C/C# is meant to be played on the middle row not inner. Thumb behind might help others who play a lot on the inner row of ADG et al. I also like it because it's as solid as it gets feel wise, and also there's nobody as fast as MáirtÃn O'Connor so have no qualms about using this posture. Doesn't seem to be a problem for me, just took it easy at first and tried to not to overdo it with the practice until comfortable.
In another thread Paddy O'Brien's wood spacer below his keyboard was mentioned, here's a pic:
(https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZnOraCPM-so/hqdefault.jpg)
It's the light colored wood bar, held in place by what looks like a bit of plastic - thus extending the edge of the keyboard down a bit. Paddy holds his thumb sideways against this. Not exactly what we're discussing here but perhaps some of you of a handy inclination might want to experiment with attaching similar doohickeys to see if it helps.
-
This was an old post, I don't use a thumbstrap at all anymore, and wouldn't consider it except for a 1 row maybe.
I place my thumb behind when I need to, but not all the time. It depends, I let the tune dictate, no set rule.
-
Playing the D/G, there's playing with one strap, there's using the vice grip using the ball of the thumb. There's standing in a sword-fencing posture and looking really cool.
But then there's this:-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKtTClgT_1g
Now what was that about dynamics?
So far as I'm concerned, if playing like this means you use two straps and keep the thumb as mobile as possible, you use two straps and keep the thumb as mobile as possible.
Oh, and his main instrument is piano accordion!
Yes, let the tune (and the context of playing) decide.
-
BUMP
Putting the thumb behind the keyboard has helped me a lot as I mostly play on the inner row of a 3 row - C/C#/D in my case, a sharpened version of B/C/C#. Having my thumb on the edge seems to add some unwanted strain, not surprising since B/C/C# is meant to be played on the middle row not inner.
quote
To me the BCC# is meant to be played using all three rows with the 'main road' being the middle row for the sharp keys and the inside row the 'main road' for the flat keys. Having said that in practice all 3 rows are normally used to make fingering easier and to help to keep the bellows tight.
As to the thumb locating it in the groove provided for the purpose on the edge of the keyboard (and on the edge of the keyboard if no groove is provided) helps to locate the hand and plays no part in steadying the box. Having fairly small hands I sometimes take the thumb off the edge of the keyboard for certain bits of fingering which is in essence just the same as one would do if playing a 5 row continental.
george
-
This guy is definitely held back by the thumb behind the keyboard thing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l23JCcRVqpA
And by only using one strap
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LwCafeBmlE
;)
-
Thinking of putting a couple of straps on my Cheripashka...it's already got a thumb strap....
-
But then there's this:-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKtTClgT_1g
Now what was that about dynamics?
So far as I'm concerned, if playing like this means you use two straps and keep the thumb as mobile as possible, you use two straps and keep the thumb as mobile as possible.
Oh, and his main instrument is piano accordion!
Yes, let the tune (and the context of playing) decide.
Magic! Just magic!
-
Chris can play at a brisk clip, too: The Dublin Reel Chris Parkinson and Steve Cooper - YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nr2d7tLqTWI) Nobody's as fast as MáirtÃn though, indeed I've never listened to his records much because of the ridiculous tempi. This clip is paced nicely though: MáirtÃn O'Connor and Colm Murphy at Céilà Mór 33rd Cork Folk Festival, 07.10.2012 - YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=znEgp8p72Mk) Also Dave Munnelly: Mcgowan & Munnelly - Reels - YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHYISawoY3c)
To me the BCC# is meant to be played using all three rows with the 'main road' being the middle row for the sharp keys and the inside row the 'main road' for the flat keys. Having said that in practice all 3 rows are normally used to make fingering easier and to help to keep the bellows tight.
One reason I took to the British Chromatic was to play in flat keys but I'm pretty much alone in that regard around here, a friend who plays the PA does know tunes like President Garfield's or the Banks but always wants to play them in G...
As to the thumb locating it in the groove provided for the purpose on the edge of the keyboard (and on the edge of the keyboard if no groove is provided) helps to locate the hand and plays no part in steadying the box. Having fairly small hands I sometimes take the thumb off the edge of the keyboard for certain bits of fingering which is in essence just the same as one would do if playing a 5 row continental.
george
You said something once about how players on the B/C/C# sometimes use the thumb for lower notes - anybody in particular? Is that melody, or throwing in a lower harmony note?
I've tried playing with the thumb full time like Alex McIntyre and it's fine as long as you have a gentle touch, I've noticed, but I like to throw things around a bit here and there and concluded it wasn't for me. I've a new box on the way which has a thumb groove and maybe that will help, the Gaelic IVS I'm playing at the moment doesn't have one. But I really like the thumb under anyway, and as the players I've shown here display playing in this fashion doesn't slow you down in any way.
-
over the years I have only come across a couple of BCC# players who regularly use the thumb , can't remember who they were but think they used ot to play part of the melody.
george
-
I'm surprised this is still going, it should be clear from all the responses that there is no right answer for everyone. What works for an individual will depend on a huge number of variables, including the type of music you play and your playing style, the size and weight of the box, the size of your hands, whether you play standing or sitting, one strap or two (or none), ...
Do whatever works for you, provided it is comfortable and doesn't risk causing long-term injury.