Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: GbH on June 24, 2010, 07:11:03 PM

Title: What should I learn next?
Post by: GbH on June 24, 2010, 07:11:03 PM
Hmmm.  I'm sat here with a pile of tunebooks containing all sorts of stuff.  In addition, there's also the possibility of searching for new tunes online.  There's also the never-ending option of trying to develop my technique in some way.

Usually I have a good idea as to what I want to do next.  However, at the moment, I don't know what I want to do.  Maybe the heat's making me lethargic?

So, does anyone have any suggestions for something unexpected or useful to do?
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 25, 2010, 12:37:33 AM
Hmmm.  I'm sat here with a pile of tunebooks containing all sorts of stuff.  In addition, there's also the possibility of searching for new tunes online.  There's also the never-ending option of trying to develop my technique in some way.

Usually I have a good idea as to what I want to do next.  However, at the moment, I don't know what I want to do.  Maybe the heat's making me lethargic?

So, does anyone have any suggestions for something unexpected or useful to do?

Quebecois crooked tunes! Terrific fun (:)
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: michik on June 25, 2010, 12:49:14 AM
I find this youtube user quite inspiring ... http://www.youtube.com/user/diatonik46
... or get a 'Steirische' and play some austrian accordeon music ... http://www.youtube.com/user/kasey1703
... or try a different instrument ... hurdy gurdy  for example >:E ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKdzneDosyw
... or start with expressive singing while playing melodeon: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqQRoyfW4ew
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 25, 2010, 01:53:33 PM
You may need to transpose this into a suitable key but with that extra half row you should find one that's possible. Cracking tune, quite demanding but shouldn't be played too quickly.

X:47
T: Joe Scurfield's Favourite
C: Robin Dunn
D: Syncopace
M: 4/4
L: 1/8
Q: 1/4=110
R: hornpipe
K:Gmin
D2|G^FGA Bd^cd|=cA^FD Gg^fg|=fecA GcAG|F2 (3GF=E F2EF|
GEGc AFAc|BFBg f2f^f|gecB AFGA|B2d2 B2:|
|:=B2|c=Bcd ecAF|(3BcB Ac B2=B2|c=Bcd efaf|gf=eg f2f^f|
gecB AFGA|Bdg^f =fdAB|GEGB AFAc|B2A2 B2:|
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: GbH on June 25, 2010, 05:19:39 PM
Many thanks for the interesting suggestions.  In response...


The Quebecois thing is something I've not really latched on to, beyond owning a couple of La Bottine Souriante albums (I assume that's the same sort of thing?).  I did order a tunebook once, but I got a reply back saying it was out of print and unavailable.  So, yes, following up and that is a good suggestion.

The option to buy more instruments is always going to be a tempting one for me, but I'm trying hard to fight it.  A Steirische seems like fun and I'd love to play a gurdy.  However, I know in my heart that I really need to concentrate on getting a better understanding and proficiency with what I've already got.

"....explore the modes of the the harmonic minor and discover why our push B chord plays B major" -  eek!  This sounds scary - but I guess that was the point.  Homework time.

Finally, Joe Scurfield's (  :( ) Favouite.  Playing the melody line alone, through the MIDI player, gives a somewhat unsatisfactory result.  So, I guess the trick's going to be in the chord choices and rhythm that will need to go with it.  Oh, and finding a suitable key for my box.   Transposing it down three semitones seems like a reasonable bet, but I don't have a low C, so I'd have to find a way aound that.  Also, it's not immediately obvious whether the available chords would work for that key.  Yep, this one does seem 'quite demanding'.

Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: GbH on June 26, 2010, 09:34:59 AM
...explore the modes of the the harmonic minor and discover why our push B chord plays B major ...

OK, I've just spent a little while thinking about this whilst fiddling with my melodica.  I'm not sure that I completely get the full implication of what you're getting at, but here's where I'm at...


To start with, I play a simple harmonic minor scale - say, in A.  If I then treat that scale as some sort of pseudo-Ionian mode, then using the same note set, I can derive a new set of scales (modes ?) that are the harmonic minor equivalents of the more conventionally used ones.  Is that what's meant by 'the modes of the harmonic minor'?  If so, is their any special terminology for such things? 

Once these new scales are known, then I suppose it makes sense to form chords that relate to them.  Thus, each scale can have, simplistically, it's own I, IV and V 'three-chord trick'.

On the D/G melodeon, Em is, of course, the most important minor scale used.  For the harmonic E minor, then, the dominant V chord contains the notes B-D#-F# - which is B major!  Also, for the the pseudo-harmonic-mixolydian-whatsit scale in E, the root chord also works out as B major.  Thus, perhaps, the reason why B major is useful when playing in E minor?


Overall, I think my knowledge of scales and chord theory has improved considerably since starting with the melodeon - it's not really something I ever thought about when playing other instruments.  However, questions like the one above still leave me realising how little I really know.  It's certainly never occurred to me before to consider that there could be such a thing as harmonic minor modes.  So, thanks, Chris, for the gradual enlightenment.

   
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 26, 2010, 10:15:08 AM
Finally, Joe Scurfield's (  :( ) Favouite.  Playing the melody line alone, through the MIDI player, gives a somewhat unsatisfactory result.  So, I guess the trick's going to be in the chord choices and rhythm that will need to go with it.  Oh, and finding a suitable key for my box.   Transposing it down three semitones seems like a reasonable bet, but I don't have a low C, so I'd have to find a way aound that.  Also, it's not immediately obvious whether the available chords would work for that key.  Yep, this one does seem 'quite demanding'.

Here it is in Em with chords that were generated by ABC Explorer so I would take them with a pinch of salt and regard them as a 'rough guide'. This tune was only a suggestion, I thought the quirkiness might appeal to you.

X:30
T:Joe Scurfield's Favourite (in Em with chords)
C:Robin Dunn
R:hornpipe
D:Syncopace
M:4/4
L:1/8
Q:1/4=110
K:Emin
B,2| "Em" E^DEF "Bm" GB^AB| "D" =AF^DB, "Bm" Ee^de| "D" =dcAF "D" EAFE| "Bm" D2 (3ED^C "D" D2CD|
 "A" ECEA "D" FDFA| "D" GDGe "D" d2d^d| "C" ecAG "D" FDEF| "G" G2 "Bm" B2 G2:|
|:^G2| "Bm" A^GAB "D" cAFD| "D" (3GAG FA "G" G2^G2| "Bm" A^GAB "D" cdfd| "Bm" ed^ce "D" d2d^d|
 "C" ecAG "D" FDEF| "D" GBe^d "Bm" =dBFG| "C" ECEG "D" FDFA| "G" G2 "G" F2 G2:|
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 26, 2010, 10:38:36 AM
Hi GbH. Here's a nice resumé http://www.howmusicworks.org/hmw810.html   The important modes in folk are the mode4 "dorian #4" which sounds sort of rumanian but is the one employed in 'Jump at the Sun'!  And of course mode5 "phrygian major" used in Klesmer, Arab and most famously in Flamenco.  All modes get used in jazz.

"Phrygian major" has incredibly simple chords- B7 and Cmaj7 (though you do sound a bit like a debutant guitar player if you only do those)

The fundamental to understanding harmonic minor is to notice that 1½ tone interval between (in your E example) C and D#.  The scale is no longer 'even tempered' and you are approaching the edge of folk music (which is mostly on modal diatonic scales).  That is to say that all its modes have a little 'jump' in them too.

Bizarely given the name - the Eminharm base chord of E,G,B,D# = Eminor,major7 and isn't stable to the ear. "In here be dragons"  Please note that the rest of the World turned its back on harmonic minor following Miles Davis's "Kind of Blue" album in 1959!  :|glug
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: GbH on June 26, 2010, 11:18:32 AM

Here it is in Em with chords that were generated by ABC Explorer so I would take them with a pinch of salt and regard them as a 'rough guide'. This tune was only a suggestion, I thought the quirkiness might appeal to you.


Whilst I wouldn't say that all of those chords are 100% to my taste  ;D , I think that does show the potential of the tune much better.  With the tune itself going off-piste like that, it really does seem to need something underneath to keep it grounded and in context*.  If I can get that figured out, I think it could be a really fun tune to play.  As I think you've guessed, I tend to like tunes that do unexpected things!

Thanks.

Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: GbH on June 26, 2010, 11:38:37 AM
Hi GbH. Here's a nice resumé http://www.howmusicworks.org/hmw810.html   The important modes in folk are the mode4 "dorian #4" which sounds sort of rumanian but is the one employed in 'Jump at the Sun'!  And of course mode5 "phrygian major" used in Klesmer, Arab and most famously in Flamenco.  All modes get used in jazz.

That's a very useful looking link.  Thanks.


The fundamental to understanding harmonic minor is to notice that 1½ tone interval between (in your E example) C and D#.  The scale is no longer 'even tempered' and you are approaching the edge of folk music (which is mostly on modal diatonic scales).  That is to say that all its modes have a little 'jump' in them too.

Bizarely given the name - the Eminharm base chord of E,G,B,D# = Eminor,major7 and isn't stable to the ear. "In here be dragons"  Please note that the rest of the World turned its back on harmonic minor following Miles Davis's "Kind of Blue" album in 1959!  :|glug

Oh, as you might have guessed, I'm not usually bothered about being out of date!  Nor, to a large extent, do I have any reason to think only within the boundaries of folk music.  I don't have a folk background, nor much exposure to it beyond the internet, so I'm probably not as focused on that aspect as others here seem to be.  It's true that I like to play folk tunes - well, at least some of them -  but I suspect that my approach to playing them probably borrows more from brass band playing than anything else, just because that's what I'm used to.  As such, if a chord sounds interesting to me, I'll most likely go with it regardless.
Title: Re: What should I learn next?
Post by: strad on June 26, 2010, 11:58:08 AM
GbH - The way each mode is worked out is in a previous thread under the "Teaching & Learning" heading. Have a search for "Key Trouble!!!" or search under "Phrygian"

Nigel
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal