Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on July 02, 2010, 10:00:02 AM
-
The alternative to MAD is tinkering with the boxes you've already got.....
My Loffet Pro 3 row 18 bass G/C+ is a wonderful box in every way and the layout of the accidental row is ingenious and effective: http://diato.org/pdf/3r18b-2.pdf (http://diato.org/pdf/3r18b-2.pdf). Sorry its in French!
But....
I'd dearly like a pulled Eb in two octaves so the box is chromatic on the pull in its most useful range.
I'd also like a pushed F in two octaves which would smooth out some passages in C minor and allow me to play jazzy E7b9 arpeggios against an E bass (now why would I want to do such as weird thing!)
I want to do this with as few new reeds as possible.
Possibilities for the Eb/F above middle C appear to be:
1. reverse the button 5 G/A on the middle row and replace the pulled G and pushed A on the accidental row with an Eb and F.
2. Replace the low B/E on button 1 outside row (which I dont think I've ever used) with F/Eb.
For the high pulled Eb, one of the high pulled A buttons (outer row 11 and middle row 9) could be sacrificed.
For the high pushed F, the very high Eb on button 10 of the accidental row, could be sacrificed as I've never used it.
Any thoughts, suggestions etc on the feasibility and practicality of these ideas would be gratefully received.
-
The first option of flipping the G/A button - effectively a Dutch reversal - can be quite a useful thing to do on a G/C anyway because it's really handy having that G on the pull on the middle row, (it's easier to reach there than on the accidental row). It's something I've thought about doing, but never done it because, as well as playing continental style, I also like to use G/Cs for playing in C in the lower octave, on the row, and I'd find it too confusing if the G and A were flipped. This might not be a problem for yourself, though, especially as you've played clubs in the past.
As for the top octave, I've never found the need for both those A's at the very top on the pull, although sometimes it's easier to use one rather than the other. I have a 19 button G/C with only one, and it's not a problem.
Same for those upper accidentals- when I ordered my Graet e Breizh 3 row, I had all the accidentals moved up one from his standard layout, so I lost the top ones anyway, and can't say I've missed them.
-
The first option of flipping the G/A button - effectively a Dutch reversal - can be quite a useful thing to do on a G/C anyway because it's really handy having that G on the pull on the middle row, (it's easier to reach there than on the accidental row). It's something I've thought about doing, but never done it because, as well as playing continental style, I also like to use G/Cs for playing in C in the lower octave, on the row, and I'd find it too confusing if the G and A were flipped. This might not be a problem for yourself, though, especially as you've played clubs in the past.
What exactly is Continental Style?
-
What exactly is Continental Style?
Continental (meaning European) players generally play lower-pitched instruments (most commonly G/Cs), but use mainly the upper octave of the keyboard.
The style is chord-led, and a lot of cross-fingering is used to fit the tune to the basses, which gives a much smoother feel than the bouncy English style.
There are several sites which give tablatures for tunes arranged for G/C instruments, such as
www.diatonia.net
www.diato.org
If you work through a few of them you'll get the idea. You can use a box in any key you like, using the same button numberings but transposing the basses, although they will come out a bit squeaky on a D/G.
-
Thanks for both the answer, and the links.