Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Gandy on July 02, 2010, 01:17:32 PM
-
Hi,
I just wondered whether anyone could comment on the Hohner Club 1B which seems to be missing from the often cited table of Hohner accordions. I have one in good nick and as a layman I would have said its quite recent, although I'm not sure why I think so. Its stamped "880" under the keyboard, does that mean A440 tuning?
I was surprised to see one that looks identical offered by the Music Room for a sky-high price .. **HERE** (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_486/products_id/4610?mrSid=d3fe2ecc1826a6ace7995858f0c8c323)
Just looking at mine I would have thought it an entry-level model, for example no recessed panel for the bass buttons. Its strange that the body is so large as well for relatively few reeds.
Cheers, Tony S
-
Yes, I've got one, too. They're certainly not compact and haven't got those nice, later touches such as the recesses bass buttons - but they do have a lovely sound and the action is pretty damn good (better than a Pokerwork). I would always suggest getting one from ebay.de and having it fettled, including bringing it to A=440. Mine cost around £30 a few years back.
Rob.
-
Mine cost around £30 a few years back.
I paid quite a lot more than that (still a fraction of what the Music Room's asking). Mine doesn't really need anything doing to it, although I'd like to quieten the bass buttons if I can work out how.
-
I have one, too - from which I've removed the pearloid, plus, mine has a black plastic keyboard plate rather than a perloid one. As Rob says, nice box - got mine about 5 years ago, for certainly less than £100 on German eBay.
Diane
-
I was having another play with mine last night. I really need to do something about that bass action, it must be the loudest in history, and the buttons (on mine) disappear down their holes. Are they all like that? I was wondering whether the buttons could simply be replaced with the "mushroom" style as used on other Hohners. I'm struggling to see how else the motion could be restricted.
-
I'm struggling to see how else the motion could be restricted.
Many of the larger Hohners have the movement of the bass buttons limited by a 'buffer' at the opposite side from the buttons. It usually takes the form of a strip of wood with felt on top which limits the movement of the pivoting lever that the button rod attaches to.
-
Cheers. I'll look inside, (and I guess further discussion on those lines should be in the repair section). By the way, what's your take on the Club 1B? I'm comparing it with a Club II and to me it looks like the IB must be a much more recent model, although I'm not sure what I'm basing that on. Mine's stamped 880 (does that mean originally concert pitch?), has plastic valves and the reed plates have round headed pins between each plate as well as wax. The treble keys are more domed than the Club II and I think slightly smaller.
-
The IB is also a good deal bigger and possibly heavier than the Club II, and doesn't it have more buttons on the half row? I think it also has a separate reedblock, on which case its the descendent of the Club Victoria, and the ancestor of the Club IIB.
-
The IB is also a good deal bigger and possibly heavier than the Club II, and doesn't it have more buttons on the half row? I think it also has a separate reedblock, on which case its the descendent of the Club Victoria, and the ancestor of the Club IIB.
Its certainly bigger, and has more buttons in the 30 key Club layout shown on this site. There are three reed blocks, one for each row, and three rows of pallets. It feels light, but I'd have to weigh it to compare, it might just be light for its bulk.
-
The IB is also a good deal bigger and possibly heavier than the Club II, and doesn't it have more buttons on the half row? I think it also has a separate reedblock, on which case its the descendent of the Club Victoria, and the ancestor of the Club IIB.
The IB is almost identical to the Club Victoria as far as I can tell (except some slight cosmetic differences). I know this as I've just had a Club IB to bits for a friend and it's nearly identical to my Club Victoria on the inside!