Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: John C on July 03, 2010, 03:57:29 PM
-
I just bought the Bal Folk tune book from Mally and am enjoying the D and G tunes on my ADG.
I play ADG and don't want to relearn fingering patterns, layouts etc but I would like to play C tunes on a GC Pokerwork and it seems like a good idea to transpose the C tunes to D or G and use the same fingering (more or less) as I do on my ADG.
I'd be interested to hear what your thoughts are about this, do you suggest putting everything into tablature or buy some sort of transposing software?
Thanks
John
-
I've been using ABCMus V2 which I downloaded from a url in the abc software thread recently, simple enough for me to use for transposing tunes into G and D although I have been using ABC Navigator for listening and organising as I find it easier.
ABCMus says it will not let you copy the transposed ABC (as it is a demo rather than full version) but it responds fine to the old DOS Ctrl+C for copy and Ctrl+V for pasting into the navigator as a new file.....
HTH
Richard
-
It seems a long way round to transpose into another key so as to play in the original key.
It's probably quicker to learn to read the C/F music directly to your C/F melodeon safe in the knowledge that you can transfer the fingering onwards to other boxes if you want to. It may seem a chore but it's surprising how quickly you get the hang of it.
Steve
-
surely its just a question of learning the scaless both on & accross rows - you can then either
dot read directly onto the CF box
play from memory on the gc box
I presume from your question you are playing everything accross the rows on the ADG, the simplest way to play in C on a GC is ,at least to start off with, to play in C on the row & then if you wnat to to get better bass harmony experiment with an element of cross rowing where it helps.
george
-
It seems a long way round to transpose into another key so as to play in the original key.
It's probably quicker to learn to read the C/F music directly to your C/F melodeon
I agree it's a long way round, but nevertheless it's the sort of thing that I do.
I find it quite difficult to read music straight onto boxes in different keys. I know the notes on the lower area of the keyboard in D/G, and most of the ones on the upper end in G/C (but not so well), and that's about all I can cope with.
For transposing fairly simple tunes, I find I can do most of it in my head as I go along (slowly!). It helps if you get used to reading note intervals rather than each individual note, as you can then recognise patterns of notes without needing to read every single one.
Another method I use is to play the actual notes on my 2.5 row D/G to learn the tune, then pick up the box in the right key and play it on that one, changing the fingering and putting in the basses. Sometimes the tune works perfectly well on the D/G anyway.
If the tune is a bit more complicated, I resort to transposing note by note and writing each one in pencil above the stave! Not a very high-tec solution, but when you are dealing with printed music it's probably just as quick as using a computer.
-
It helps if you get used to reading note intervals rather than each individual note, as you can then recognise patterns of notes without needing to read every single one.
This gets easier if you play more than one instrument, or if you can sing at sight and also play tunes by ear. In that case you tend to learn to read music by 'hearing' it in your head when you read the dots, and then playing what you hear.
Works for me, anyway.
If you're actually transposing to a different pitch from what's written, it also helps if you don't have perfect pitch.
-
or don't worry about keys! just read the ups & downs on the dots eg if the dots are for a tune in G & you want to play it in say, A & assuming the first note in the G version is G then deem it to be A & get on wth it on the basis of - one up- two down - one down- one up etc etc. Dot readers can still read the value of each note if they must! The French call this something like solmonisation! but whatevr its called it works provided you know & have the manual dexterity to pay the scale you are switching to
Non readers can use exactly the same process but without the complication of staring at rows of dots. It is however vital to be able to play the 'new' scale without having to ponder about it
george
-
Thanks goodness for those last two replies (Anahata and George)! I couldn't decide whether I had some faculty that others lacked, or whether I was missing a skill that everyone else was using. I'm still not sure ...
I can read music, but when it comes to melodeon I use the dots mainly to get the tune into my head, after which I can start to work out how to play it. If the tunes is written in the "wrong" key it doesn't really matter - in fact only yesterday I printed out a tune written in D minor and played it in E minor. I wasn't doing anything as clever as "transposing" - I just used the written score to remind me how the tune went, so that I could then begin to play it. The rhythm, the intervals and the shape of the tune are the same no matter which key you're in.
If there's any sort of analogy with the written word, I'd say that playing (for me) is like seeing a sentence, reading it silently, so I know what it says, and then saying it aloud, rather than sounding it out by the letter or the word.
-
- in fact only yesterday I printed out a tune written in D minor and played it in E minor. I wasn't doing anything as clever as "transposing" -
You underestimate yourself. You were transposing, just not on paper.
-
Indeed - some classicly trained bods surround 'transposing' with a whole load of unnecesary complication & even crap!. Perhaps the easiest waay to visualise how to do it is to think in terms of a piano keyboard with black & white keys. The white keys are the 'main road' (as is the C row on a 2 or 3 row semitone box)
you can start anywhere on the keyboard and proceed do re me fa etc on white notes until a note sounds wrong at which point you try the nearest black key instead (or if on a blck one try the white one of the same naame.
DG boxes (& similar) without part row of accidentals are obviously limited in availoable keys but the principle still applies).
when teaching piano or continental or BCC# I ask students to choose a tune they are VERY familier with and to try to play it in all 12 major keys. Obviously some sound better than others (keys not students) but the mystique around 'transposing instantly (more or less!!) disapears.
george
-
- in fact only yesterday I printed out a tune written in D minor and played it in E minor. I wasn't doing anything as clever as "transposing" -
You underestimate yourself. You were transposing, just not on paper.
Yes, when I say "transposing in my head" that is exactly what I mean...just looking at the dots in one key and then playing it in another by looking at the shape of the tune rather than the names of the notes.
Nothing complicated.
-
I just bought the Bal Folk tune book from Mally and am enjoying the D and G tunes on my ADG.
I play ADG and don't want to relearn fingering patterns, layouts etc but I would like to play C tunes on a GC Pokerwork and it seems like a good idea to transpose the C tunes to D or G and use the same fingering (more or less) as I do on my ADG.
I'd be interested to hear what your thoughts are about this, do you suggest putting everything into tablature or buy some sort of transposing software?
Thanks
John
I use "THE AMAZING SLOWDOWNER" software http://www.ronimusic.com/ (http://www.ronimusic.com/) mostly so i can learn good tunes i hear in different keys easily... and if they are really hard .. slow them down a bit too!.... assuming you can play by ear of course.
-
The melodeon is one of the easiest transposing instruments, in that if you can play a tune in, say, "C" on a C instrument, with exactly the same fingering on a "G" box you will have transposed (= "change key") the tune to "G". If you can read any tune on the "C", just swap your box to another and play it as if it were in "C" - transposition! :||:
PS: The horn is a b*gger to transpose on! :Ph
-
I knew there was a use for tonic sol fa!
-
Aha! Again I'm reassured that I'm normal! I often think in terms of tonic sol-fa, which to me is a very natural way of making sense of a melodeon.
-
I often think in terms of tonic sol-fa, which to me is a very natural way of making sense of
a melodeon music.
-
If you're actually transposing to a different pitch from what's written, it also helps if you don't have perfect pitch.
Tell me about it :-\ It's taken me a while to get the hang of it, but the thing that I really can't do is transpose Bb Clarinet music to concert pitch. It does my head in to be fingering a different key to that which everyone is playing. If I concentrate on the written music then I'm OK.
-
Tell me about it :-\ It's taken me a while to get the hang of it, but the thing that I really can't do is transpose Bb Clarinet music to concert pitch. It does my head in to be fingering a different key to that which everyone is playing. If I concentrate on the written music then I'm OK.
It's worth persevering with this transposition, i.e. up a tone, Bb clarinet parts into C. I don't know whether you do any orchestral playing, but a lot of clarinet parts in the classical (senzu strictu) repertoire were written for C clarinet, which was much more common in the late 18th and 19th century than it is now. Most orchestral players transpose C clarinet parts at sight on to a Bb clarinet. Just keep on practicing and it will come. Sometimes people write out the parts transposed for Bb clarinet, but often there isn't the time to do this, especially in a full length work like a symphony.
You could invest in a C clarinet (they are still available), but the sound quality is quite different from a Bb instrument - much brighter - and tends not to fit in with current orchestral fashion. And it is one more instrument to lug around. I find it is quite enough keeping a Bb and and A clarinet on the go, never mind a C gobstick.
The other advantage of being able to transpose Bb to C at sight is that you can then play flute/oboe/violin parts if needed, say in a special arrangement, or play from the myriad tunebooks along with other people on fiddle, whistle, concertina, even melodeon.
-
Tell me about it :-\ It's taken me a while to get the hang of it, but the thing that I really can't do is transpose Bb Clarinet music to concert pitch. It does my head in to be fingering a different key to that which everyone is playing. If I concentrate on the written music then I'm OK.
My son is learning Eb alto sax. His little tunes have accompanying parts, and I struggle, even with these pre-Grade1 pieces, to transpose them on sight onto the recorder. Plus the recorder is much quieter than the sax. Melodeon's much better. But of course, most of them aren't playable on a 21/8 D/G melodeon. And besides, J professes to hate the sound of the melodeon.
Current solution: I use the Streb, set it up as F/Bb, then play the music as written. Obviously it tends to be in slightly harder keys (not a lot in D or G, even for beginners), so it's good practice for me in learning to play a D/G melodeon in keys like F, Bb, Dmin (note that those aren't the same F/Bb as the box is in; I could tune the box to play in D, G or Em but then I'd have to transpose on the fly again). Moreover, to avoid the dreaded melodeon sound, I've been exploring the weirder bits of the midi sample set. My son's current favourite is FX7; I'm pretty glad at this point that the Streb doesn't have the helicopter patch.
If we ever get our little duets to the point where they sound actively good, I'll put them on YouTube under 'Music You Didn't Expect to Hear on a Melodeon'.
-
It's worth persevering with this transposition, i.e. up a tone, Bb clarinet parts into C. I don't know whether you do any orchestral playing, but a lot of clarinet parts in the classical (senzu strictu) repertoire were written for C clarinet, which was much more common in the late 18th and 19th century than it is now. Most orchestral players transpose C clarinet parts at sight on to a Bb clarinet. Just keep on practicing and it will come. Sometimes people write out the parts transposed for Bb clarinet, but often there isn't the time to do this, especially in a full length work like a symphony.
You could invest in a C clarinet (they are still available), but the sound quality is quite different from a Bb instrument - much brighter - and tends not to fit in with current orchestral fashion. And it is one more instrument to lug around. I find it is quite enough keeping a Bb and and A clarinet on the go, never mind a C gobstick.
The other advantage of being able to transpose Bb to C at sight is that you can then play flute/oboe/violin parts if needed, say in a special arrangement, or play from the myriad tunebooks along with other people on fiddle, whistle, concertina, even melodeon.
I can transpose Bb parts into C if I am playing a C instrument, just about. That isn't a problem, assuming that they aren't too complicated. If I know a tune or a part then I can play it in any key that you could name. The problem comes when I am playing a Bb instrument but have to transpose C music. See because I have perfect pitch I can hear everyone playing in G (say), but find myself fingering in A. My brain doesn't like this and tells my fingers to start playing in G again. Not nice, gives me a headache. Even with a Bb score if I allow my mind to concentrate too much on the music it will want to switch again. I do have a C Clarinet, a forte C from Dr Henderson in the US. Unfortunately the intonation isn't that great. I don't really play clarinet enough any more to justify the expense of fixing it, which is a real shame. I also have a 1920's C Melody which has the same issue; I really must play that a bit this vac, I haven't played it in ages.
-
I often think in terms of tonic sol-fa, which to me is a very natural way of making sense of a melodeon music.
Tonic sol-fa is the easiest and most natural way to go, not only when playing melodeons but also building them.
Italian accordion builders have been using it for more than 100 years so it must have something going for it.
-
So, has your question been answered, John? ;)
Tonic sol-fa is the easiest and most natural way to go, not only when playing melodeons but also building them. Italian accordion builders have been using it for more than 100 years so it must have something going for it.
What we Anglo-Saxons call tonic sol-fa means using the doh-re-mi etc note names in a relative sense. Your tonic is doh whatever key you're in. Certainly the French and AFAIK the Italians do not do this. Doh (or rather "do") is always the note C. My sister was recently on an international training course for music teachers exploring new pedagogical techniques (in Finland), in which tonic sol-fa was used, and she said the French participants were flummoxed because they couldn't dissociate the note names from their absolute values.
-
I am struggling to see the advantage of tonic sol-fa over the "normal" system :-\
-
I am struggling to see the advantage of tonic sol-fa over the "normal" system :-\
It has the supposed advantage of allowing musicians, especially singers, to be able to judge and pitch intervals easily at sight, relative to any 'doh' which is established at the beginning of the piece. Ideally you have to be immersed in it and use it regularly to be fluent in it. Like learning a foreign language, I suspect tonic sol-fa is best learnt at a young age. I find it doesn't particularly work for me, although I can use it to a certain extent. As an instrumental player rather than a singer, it is largely superfluous.
-
I am struggling to see the advantage of tonic sol-fa over the "normal" system :-\
It has the supposed advantage of allowing musicians, especially singers, to be able to judge and pitch intervals easily at sight, relative to any 'doh' which is established at the beginning of the piece. Ideally you have to be immersed in it and use it regularly to be fluent in it. Like learning a foreign language, I suspect tonic sol-fa is best learnt at a young age. I find it doesn't particularly work for me, although I can use it to a certain extent. As an instrumental player rather than a singer, it is largely superfluous.
Ah, I see. Yes, completely superfluous for any instrumentalist :P
-
Humff, I disagree. I learn tunes in my head in tonic sol fa using doh as the root note be it D,G, C or whatever. Then, I don't have to remember the names of the notes to play the tune in any key, just the tonic sol fa pattern. Simples.
-
Humff, I disagree. I learn tunes in my head in tonic sol fa using doh as the root note be it D,G, C or whatever. Then, I don't have to remember the names of the notes to play the tune in any key, just the tonic sol fa pattern. Simples.
But I don't rememner the names of the notes to play the tune in any key... I just remember the tune ???
-
You could invest in a C clarinet (they are still available), but the sound quality is quite different from a Bb instrument - much brighter - and tends not to fit in with current orchestral fashion. And it is one more instrument to lug around. I find it is quite enough keeping a Bb and and A clarinet on the go, never mind a C gobstick
Steve
Have you (any other Melnet-er) played a Bb clarinet whilst out with a Morris side and how does it fit in as an accompanying instrument. Just wondered as I also play the clarinet.
DaveD
-
Humff, I disagree. I learn tunes in my head in tonic sol fa using doh as the root note be it D,G, C or whatever. Then, I don't have to remember the names of the notes to play the tune in any key, just the tonic sol fa pattern. Simples.
I agree with Rees, thinking in terms of do re me instead of cde of whatever provides you with a scale in your autopilot that is the same irrespective of musical key, You can as a result start on any note & play a major scale (provided your instrument has appropriate accidentals) & provided you have sufficient manuel dexterity you can then play any tune you know.
The problem is that some people coming/suffering from a classical disposition have , for the purposes of playing traditional/folk music, had an overdose of musical theory that is inhibiting rather than liberating as it can result in too much contemplation of the navel trying to work out if what you are doing fits the theory rathr than keeping it simple & just getting on with it!. A bit like the story about profesor Heinkel a notable aerodynamicist & aeronautical designer who apparently said that " according to the laws of aerodynamics it is impossible for the bumblebee to fly - but nobody has told this to the bumblebee.
george
-
[ Steve
Have you (any other Melnet-er) played a Bb clarinet whilst out with a Morris side and how does it fit in as an accompanying instrument. Just wondered as I also play the clarinet.
DaveD
[/quote]
I have haad a Bflat clarinet in a ceilidh band & there was no problem. Box & fiddle in G clarinet in A, b&F in D, clarinet inE etc etc. Would be same with morris side.
george
-
I agree with Rees, thinking in terms of do re me instead of cde of whatever provides you with a scale in your autopilot that is the same irrespective of musical key, You can as a result start on any note & play a major scale (provided your instrument has appropriate accidentals) & provided you have sufficient manuel dexterity you can then play any tune you know.
The problem is that some people coming/suffering from a classical disposition have , for the purposes of playing traditional/folk music, had an overdose of musical theory that is inhibiting rather than liberating as it can result in too much contemplation of the navel trying to work out if what you are doing fits the theory rathr than keeping it simple & just getting on with it!. A bit like the story about profesor Heinkel a notable aerodynamicist & aeronautical designer who apparently said that " according to the laws of aerodynamics it is impossible for the bumblebee to fly - but nobody has told this to the bumblebee.
george
I disagree entirely. A good knowledge of music theory improves both your playing and your appreciation of what you are playing. With your example, Prof Heinkel's statement is not something to be deplored or ridiculed, it is something to be welcomed (even though the thing about bumblebees is an urban myth). If it were true it would highlight a gap in our understanding that rather than be ignored or brushed aside should be examined and filled, to the improvement of everything. Having said that, music theory knowledge is not for everyone, but to imply that it is inhibiting rather than liberating for traditional music is to work yourself into a backwater. I always like to know the theory behind anything, so that I know exactly what it is that I am doing "wrong".
-
Have you (any other Melnet-er) played a Bb clarinet whilst out with a Morris side and how does it fit in as an accompanying instrument. Just wondered as I also play the clarinet.
Hello Dave,
Yes, I used to play for a womens' step dancing side (The Step Sisters, now sadly defunct) and used a D/G Tommy and a Bb clarinet (not at the same time ;) ). Some of the music we used was traditional English, which went on the Tommy, but a lot of our stuff was taken from the music hall and jazz band repertoire, and I used my clarinet for those - tunes like Scott Joplin's 'Entertainer', Lily of Laguna, Silvery Moon, On the Sunny Side of the Street, etc. It worked very well indeed, and our side often got a lot of interest from the crowd, mostly from the rather glamorous appearance of the girls, but also I hope from the more unusual style of the music.
At first I thought that the clarinet, being a melody only instrument, would not give the fullness of sound needed in the way a melodeon does, but we soon found that in fact the clarinet sound complemented the percussion sound from the dancers' tap shoes, so much so that it was often easy and quite effective to leave 'holes' in the music and just allow the tap shoes to sound.
Photo attached of us at Rye in Kent, in our heyday in 1996. You can just see me behind the dancers playing my clarinet. Ah - happy days!
-
A bit like the story about profesor Heinkel a notable aerodynamicist & aeronautical designer who apparently said that " according to the laws of aerodynamics it is impossible for the bumblebee to fly - but nobody has told this to the bumblebee./quote]
That's a myth though, isn't it?
-
apparently based on knowledge of aerodynamic theory of 1918/1919 & something to do with the size & shape of the bees body in relation to its wingspan & power output !. Obviously aerodynamic theory has moved on considerably since then!
george
-
Down the Rhone the French seem to map SolFa 1:1 onto the C scale so your Si bemol is Bb whtever your base key. I guess it´s a usage thing.
Same in Italy, look in any Italian made D/G box and you are likely to see Re/Sol marked on the reedblocks.