Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Broadland Boy on July 04, 2010, 04:43:19 PM

Title: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 04, 2010, 04:43:19 PM
One for the Hohner historians....

Yup, looks like I've contracted MAD too - just won this http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=160451112155 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=160451112155) and wondered if anyone can give me an idea of age / model / calorific value as firewood if empty or reeds have reverted to rust etc.

I'm intrigued as to why two of the bass buttons have been nicely lashed up with string but thought it was worth a punt..........

The font and style of transfers make me suspect this is probably 1920 / 30 ish but I sure someone will have a better idea.

Richard  :||:
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Theo on July 04, 2010, 04:57:35 PM

The font and style of transfers make me suspect this is probably 1920 / 30 ish but I sure someone will have a better idea.

Richard  :||:

Older I think.  In "History Unfolds" (http://tp://cgi.ebay.de/Ewig-jung-trotz-vieler-Falten-History-Unfolds-Petra-/120589448413)  there are two instruments with the same metal corner bearing a portrait of M Hohner, and the same style of print, they are dated 1906 and 1907.
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: pgroff on July 04, 2010, 05:56:10 PM
Broadland Boy,

Seconding Theo's date estimate.  I didn't spot "steel reeds" labeling on this one, so it may well have brass reed tongues (common at this date).

If so, even after restoration it will be a little less responsive than a steel-reeded accordion. The brass reeds are also more prone to break. Some may already be broken.  Melodeon specialists may be able to provide replacements  (salvaged brass reeds from accordions much more wrecked than yours), or you could replace them with steel reeds.

I would keep the brass reeds (if that's what it has), if you appreciate this as a piece of history. Even if the brass reeds are replaced with steel, this accordion will never be a really speedy player. The brass reeds have a unique sweet tone quality lovely for playing around the house, songs, etc.

PG
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 04, 2010, 06:37:03 PM
Thanks both,

It certainly looks fairly elderly, as for brass reeds, I'll be happy if it has a full set in whichever metal and not too much wind escaping the bellows ;) someone has had it apart as the ends are on back to front (well at least one of 'em is) and I don't play well enough for response to be an issue.

I have both a disintegrated harmonium and accordion reed set to hand, Theo put right the damage my late father did when he fitted some of them to his D/G pokerwork as he couldn't get on with the diatonics - I eventually found and re installed the originals but a couple were beyond re use IIRC.......

While I wouldn't deliberately do anything untoward, I hope it's not such a classic that it shouldn't really be tinkered with by a rank amateur melodeon mangler - no doubt if it is someone will blow the whistle.

Will let you know the condition when it arrives, I am hopeful it is better than a total wreck and if nothing else it looks like the exterior will respond to a little TLC,

Oh the fun of the auction, the expectation of the wait, the delight at the delivery, the disappointment on opening the package !

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Owen Woods on July 06, 2010, 03:34:18 PM
Theo posted a while back that fibreglass pens were the best method of tuning brass reeds. Good luck! :P
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 06, 2010, 04:33:54 PM
Theo posted a while back that fibreglass pens were the best method of tuning brass reeds. Good luck! :P

Thanks for that, I have a few of them from my days working in stained glass.

While Kings College (Cambridge) chapel was being restored back in the '70s, 2 bays a year were worked on during the nice weather by the masons and plumbers, at the end of the nice weather four of us spent October through December (driving Norwich Cambridge daily) cleaning the Victorian and later smoke deposits off the windows using a glass fibre pen and a vast number of refills - I never did figure out what that job amounted to in acres but never since have I picked a g/f pen up without feeling the cold, damp, wind and incessant itching that the fine broken fibres caused :o

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Owen Woods on July 06, 2010, 06:20:01 PM
Theo posted a while back that fibreglass pens were the best method of tuning brass reeds. Good luck! :P

Thanks for that, I have a few of them from my days working in stained glass.

While Kings College (Cambridge) chapel was being restored back in the '70s, 2 bays a year were worked on during the nice weather by the masons and plumbers, at the end of the nice weather four of us spent October through December (driving Norwich Cambridge daily) cleaning the Victorian and later smoke deposits off the windows using a glass fibre pen and a vast number of refills - I never did figure out what that job amounted to in acres but never since have I picked a g/f pen up without feeling the cold, damp, wind and incessant itching that the fine broken fibres caused :o

Richard

I played a gig there a few weeks ago as dawn was breaking, we had a set from 0300 to 0500, playing contemporary arrangements of folk tunes with my Piano Trio (Whistle, piano, cello, me on piano). Really special experience. Also played in Trinity Great Hall as dawn was breaking, but that was for a ceilidh, so less sedate.

They've been cleaning up the stonework for years, I think that they have now done nearly all of one side.
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 08, 2010, 07:03:48 PM
Well, the beast arrived this afternoon, The decorative corner plates are lithographed tin plate - just like the old tinplate train stuff.
 
Bellows in remarkably good order given the age, weepy rather than leaky.M HOHNER  ACCORDEON in faded silver on one side Steel Bronze and something illegible on the other as far as I can make out ? ? ? ? ? ?EDAL    ??LOUIS 1904   ? ? ? ? ? AWARD, so not made before 1904 looks likely. in pencil inside on either side of the bellows, in pencil is X982 L at one end and X982 R on t'other. Ends hook on with nice shaped hooks engraved / pressed Hohner in joined up script, they all need replating.

Treble end missing pallet grille, mother of pearl buttons with steel c/s screws holding them on. In pencil on chin end 147 in neat pencil, not same scribe as the bellows. Reeds are 'steel bronze' (??) on individual zinc plates waxed and pinned with round headed bright tacks between reeds with L shaped clouts at the ends 2 voices reeds flat on endplate and again a number of missing leather valves but otherwise very clean.

Bass end fine other than a couple of broken pallet springs, the string wound round the buttons was evidently to shut them up, six individual chord plates and 4 base reeds - most needing leather valves.

Thats where the good news ends, the bad news is that 8 treble reeds 6 on one and 2 on t'other plate have been bent up through 90 degrees and one snapped off halfway down :( 

do you think I would be wasting my time trying to bend / planish them flat again ? It sounds quite mellow on the working reeds

I'd love to be able to see the worn inscription does anyone have one of these where this is legible ?

Oh and assuming 3 rd button holds good this far back it seems to be in C

Richard, both pleased and annoyed..........
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: pgroff on July 08, 2010, 07:56:39 PM
Broadland Boy,

If you want to go ahead and fix this up, you could look for another similar model (at the same great price!) and then you might have all the parts you need.

Or if you need brass reeds, M. Hohner portrait tin corners, etc., try the friendly U. K. dealers and repairmen on this site. If they don't have those vintage parts, I can probably find them for you in my stored parts.  Might have to wait until Autumn when I get up to my main storage space in the northeast (US).

I think you did great for what you paid, but as you see it will take a dedicated (and not strictly economically logical) investment of labor to restore this one.

They do sound great once the job is done (well).

Good luck!

Paul Groff
Miami, Florida, USA
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 08, 2010, 08:30:48 PM
Quote
it will take a dedicated (and not strictly economically logical) investment of labor to restore this one.

Couldn't agree more - but that's the whole point isn't it? These instruments are a labour of love - and you simply can't quantify the effort and energy, time and money that will go into them. Go for it!
AL
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 08, 2010, 10:03:31 PM
Thanks Paul and AL for your info and encouragement

The corner plates will clean and laquer, the 'shagreen' around the bellows end will probably come up nicely with some beeswax / turps, no idea on how to renovate the 'writing', the woodwork will probably polish up well enough.

As for the reeds, I'll wait for contrary opinions from melnetters but I have a drummond hand shaper in the workshop and wonder if I have the reeds off the plates and peg them to and  'stroke' them against a bit of ground steel plate with a bone burnishing tool to see what results, failing that I'll see what the accordion reeds yield size / hardness wise and in all probability even if I can them get something near it will probably need the Theo treatment before I'm satisfied....

Labour of love - yup but not what I'm used to, current steam engine project has required crankshaft main brgs metal sprayed and machined, big end bored out and new one made, new bearing brasses cast and machined, new piston and valve rods made and glands lined, I've lost count of the nuts and bolts I've made and the last big item before painting and re assembly was a pair of piston rings, made from the unconventional source of a 4 lb cast iron scale weight ;)

I'm not scared of metal working but I'm not used to this delicate springy stuff - I bought a cheap box to experiment with and hang the consequences and after a few hours in my hands have decided that it ought to be done properly !!

Oh for five minutes with the vandal that bent those reeds and my big spanner.........

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Theo on July 08, 2010, 10:09:51 PM
Richard,  there's little to be lost in trying to straighten the reed tongues, because they are no use as they are!

 Are the reeds on long plates, or separate plates with just a suck and a blow reed on each plate?  And are the tongues steel or brass?  The plates I'm assuming are zinc.  If its separate plates and steel tongues it should be possible to find some old Hohner reeds on zinc plates that will give a similar sound to the ones you already have. If its long plates you have some filing and riveting to look forward to!
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: pgroff on July 08, 2010, 10:21:02 PM
Theo,

Richard wrote that the reeds were individual, pinned between, so I assumed they were what we call "indivdual" (2 tongues to a reedplate), and mentioned the words "Steel Bronze" which to me always means tongues that we generally call brass.

But then there was the "6 reeds broken on one plate" -- was the reedblock meant?

Richard,

Don't waste too much energy cursing a vandal. Usually the tongues in old accordions get bent when loose reedplates are rattling around inside the bellows.  Either the loose reedplate can get its tongues bent in the bellows or by the reedblocks, or the loose reedplate can get caught on a mounted reed and bend *its* reedtongues.

Unless you have more evidence of actual evil intent!

Paul

Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 09, 2010, 02:11:31 PM


But then there was the "6 reeds broken on one plate" -- was the reedblock meant?


Unless you have more evidence of actual evil intent!

Paul


Theo / Paul,

Yes two bronze reeds to a zinc plate - plates stamped 'O'

My mistake in the terminology, there are two wooden reed beds for the two voices so I do not have a complete voice as some bent reeds are on both beds.

There is no way these have not been manually and individually bent up by finger or fingers unknown, as the tips of the tongues are pointing 90 degrees up from the plates - I've taken some pics but don't know yet how to attach them to a posting here.

Yes Theo, I see some rivetting in my near future  ::)  I'll let you know if I can get them flat again without breaking but I expect the work hardening will probably change their tone ? is this likely to be correctable ?

Richard

Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Theo on July 09, 2010, 02:28:08 PM
Plates stamped O is from one of the Klingenthal workshops I believe, someone here may know the makers name.

I don't know about how work hardening might affect the tone,  more likely it will just case the reed to break.

If you decide to have a go at making new tongues it's worth trying phosphor bronze rather than brass.
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 09, 2010, 02:39:30 PM
Plates stamped O is from one of the Klingenthal workshops I believe, someone here may know the makers name.

I don't know about how work hardening might affect the tone,  more likely it will just case the reed to break.

If you decide to have a go at making new tongues it's worth trying phosphor bronze rather than brass.

Thanks Theo,

The box is clearly marked Hohner (with tinplate litho'd M Hohner cornerplates) although some of the other markings are indistinct, was this a 'sub' workshop of theirs or would they have bought in parts or sub assemblies from a variety of specialists for assembly like the Black Forest clock makers did ? might explain the pencilled marks inside....

It'll be interesting to see just how much of the bend I can get out, I anticipate them breaking at the neck of the bend and I presume the material would initially have been rolled to work harden and consolidate.

I wonder why 'Steel Bronze' is mentioned, I know of no alloy, perhaps this was when steel was being introduced as the next great thing for reeds (although it had been used for musical box combs for a long time before) and it was just marketting hype - I guess we will never know.

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Lars on July 09, 2010, 03:12:31 PM
Regarding reedplates stamped 'O':

I've seen those in various boxes, from the 1920's and 1930's, and of many different names, tunings, and types - both steel on zink plates, and steel on brass plates.

I don't know about the brass on zink version, but the others are very nice reeds considering their age, and the sound is very pleasing. Not as powerful as newer (40's and beyond) reeds, but they have all had a sweet tone to them - those broad reeds just sounds very different than tapered reeds IMO.

I know that they were used in a good number of boxes from the 'International' factory - if they made the reeds or just bought them from someone else I do not know.
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: pgroff on July 09, 2010, 04:04:46 PM
Hi all,

Stephen Chambers answered my question about 1920s - 1930s zinc plate, steel tongue reeds with the "O" stamp. I will search for his answer and edit my post, but I think he suggested those reeds were made by the Bros. Dix.  I have seen some very nice sounding accordions that had reeds marked that way.

I have tried different kinds of brass and bronze to make concertina reed-tongues. I think the old recommendation is to start with a piece thicker than you need and hammer it to harden it. Anyway that's what I did and (after some experimentation to find what I liked the most) those reeds still sound and play very well, none broken yet.

PG

edited to add: here's that thread re: the Dix reeds:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2807.0.html

Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 09, 2010, 11:05:46 PM
If I've figured this out correctly there should be attached a few pics of the box for your delight and delectation, if nothing appears put it down to a day at melting point and a plague of mosquitos to spoil it now it's cooling down a bit !

I think they are self explanatory...........

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 09, 2010, 11:18:59 PM
Next pair
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 09, 2010, 11:24:08 PM
And the last two ...........

I'll try to see if I can get the light to show what remains of the writing on the outside tomorrow

Night night one and all
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 10, 2010, 02:56:05 PM
Can't get a photo but by taking a rubbing over the obscured text it appears to read

GOLD MEDAL
ST LOUIS 1904
Highest Award

Have just re glued some odd bits of bookcloth frayed round the bellows ends and found a C lightly stamped into the end of the keyboard - too hot here (32 C in shade) to even think about messing about with reeds but I may have a tinker with the bass end and fix the broken springs
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 12, 2010, 12:53:19 AM
Today being somewhat cooler I embarked on the straightening of banana shaped reeds, after gently bending the longest, thickest, least mangled, it became clear that this material is relatively ductile and the anticipated snapping off did not occur, I now have a full set of nearly flat reeds (minus the one broken off pre delivery).

Having considered the problem, instead of the mirror finish glass hard tool I had originally thought I might need, I decided on the opposite approach and so machined up a couple of bits of PTFE sheet into a sort of spatula form and just wide enough to fit in the reedplate slots. I also made up a few different shaped 'anvil stake' pieces to clamp in the vice so that with the reedplate over the top these would just reach the underside of the reed so I could use them as a fulcrum to bend the reed over while ironing out the kink from above with a PTFE 'iron'

This worked well but was leaving a distinct ripple so I reversed the process and after easing the bend down onto a bit of plastic sheet with the rivet heads off the edge put some pressure on the inside of the reed through the slot, this left a less kinky result but the reed was still bent away from the plate (part due to original bend part to the heavy burnishing from underneath).

Mulling this over an evening cider I reasoned that if the plastic sheet were replaced by something a little more yielding perhaps kinks and gentle bend might both be persuaded to depart together, so after trying a few bits of rubber sheet a bit at about 60 Shore seemed to give the right result  :D

So attached should be  a couple of pics of the 'after' - reedplates just laid on the blocks, (although missing valves have been replaced) and one of the PTFE vice 'anvil'.

I find that my 'harvested' accordion reeds are steel so have had to hunt down the box of harmonium reeds for a replacement for the broken one, that and making up some wax is a job for another day, I'm very pleased with the way the flattening has gone but what does the smart money have to say on the likelihood of acceptable tune and tone eventually ? can't get much idea by just sucking them at least they all sound freely - I need a tuning table obviously

BTW I can find no indication of iron in this so called Steel Bronze material, its non magnetic, does not spark on a grinder - I will see what I can find from the broken stump but it is most definitely not a straight brass either, Bronze, Gunmetal, Bellmetal - dunno, it does not behave in the same way my old Lachenal reeds did, now they were brittle ! anyhow, I hope the foregoing may help someone else out should they be unfortunate enough to suffer badly bent reeds - stroke not force sums up todays result.

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Owen Woods on July 12, 2010, 12:58:34 AM
Shouldn't think it is bellmetal, it can be very brittle, hence church bells cracking a fair bit and having to be recast, despite their thickness. I was always taught never to bash handbells together in case they crack.
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Theo on July 12, 2010, 08:30:05 AM
Nice work!  I expect the reeds will sound pretty much as they should once they have new valves and fresh wax.

BTW you can safely discard the pins that appear to be helping to hold the reeds in place, good wax will provide all the necessary holding power. 
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 12, 2010, 02:40:15 PM
Thanks for your encouragement Gents,

ukebert,
It may be as misleading as calling these 'Steel Bronze' but my Echo Harp mouth organ claims to have Bell Metal Reeds, know what you mean about handbells bells being brittle, however if a cast bar is hot and then cold rolled a lot of the brittleness will be converted to toughness....... BTW Have you ever tried breaking up a tower bell ? the fourth at Stratton Strawless had been badly cracked a number of years before we started ringing there regularly, having raised enough for a recast, and there being no internal trapdoor or space in the frame to lower it complete, we broke it up in the tower and chucked the bits out of the window, took a lot of hard sledgehammer work and my view of it as a cast material changed - it would have been a doddle if it had been cast iron ! (to get the new bell in we pulled it up a scaffold tower having first removed all the slate louvres and the mullion from the N tower window !)

Theo,

Whether as a result of also being pinned or just the quality of the wax, there was not a single crack visible in the wax anywhere, nor any indication that its not original - around a century old.

As for the assumed letter 'O' marking, this is neither deep nor irregular enough to have been hand stamped and it is rare for a capital O to be circular, so I'm wondering if this is actually a by-product of holding the reedplates in the flypress or nibbler when they were slotted - I presume the slots were pressed and doubt they would all have a separate tool, presumably a variety of the same reed width would be slotted to varying length.

Tuning - well we'll see, I can't believe the mangling has not affected local hardness and so tone. Tuning, as with organ pipes I think I should be able to manage up to a point but while I know the theory of voicing organ pipes I suspect there is a similar dimension to make banks of reeds speak alike and while Farmer Bills marvelous tuner will assist with identifying both aspects, where, what and how much to whittle remains a mystery ::)
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: pgroff on July 12, 2010, 02:58:11 PM
Richard,

Re: the "O" stamp on the plates, you can find Hohners contemporaneous with yours that have a mixture of zinc reedplates -- some with the "O" and some with "H" (all with brass tongues). Then you can find both "H" and "O" reeds (separately or mixed in the same istrument) but with steel tongues in other early Hohners. Some early Hohners (and at least one Wilkinson's Excelsior, which Stephen Chambers tells me was made by Hohner) have zinc plate reeds stamped with a square.  The later Hohner "H" reeds on aluminum plates, the still later "T" reeds, and reeds with other trademarks such as the Koch chamois, are also known.

And of course many reeds (early zinc with brass tongues, early zinc with steel tongues, aluminum frame, brass frame etc) have no such letter marking at all.

So it does seem reasonable to infer that the "O" marking, however created, was intentional as an identifier.

PG
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Owen Woods on July 12, 2010, 03:10:25 PM
ukebert,
It may be as misleading as calling these 'Steel Bronze' but my Echo Harp mouth organ claims to have Bell Metal Reeds, know what you mean about handbells bells being brittle, however if a cast bar is hot and then cold rolled a lot of the brittleness will be converted to toughness....... BTW Have you ever tried breaking up a tower bell ? the fourth at Stratton Strawless had been badly cracked a number of years before we started ringing there regularly, having raised enough for a recast, and there being no internal trapdoor or space in the frame to lower it complete, we broke it up in the tower and chucked the bits out of the window, took a lot of hard sledgehammer work and my view of it as a cast material changed - it would have been a doddle if it had been cast iron ! (to get the new bell in we pulled it up a scaffold tower having first removed all the slate louvres and the mullion from the N tower window !)

This is something that I really should know more about, but there is a massive difference between ductility, which is what your reeds evidently have and toughness. A material can be tough and brittle (look at martensite). I haven't tried breaking up a bell (hope I never will have to!) but I would expect it to be reasonably difficult due to the thickness, and also to the fact that it needs to sustain repeated impact loading over a long period. My point was really that although it can withstand that it doesn't mean that it is ductile, merely that it is both tough and brittle. Or something. Grief, if I'm going to do a Materials module next year I'd better start making sense to myself, let alone everyone else :P
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 12, 2010, 04:26:47 PM
"So it does seem reasonable to infer that the "O" marking, however created, was intentional as an identifier."

Fair comment - having been in such close proximity to them for an extended period it seemed that it might just be a witness mark from clamping but as it's not seen elsewhere where there is also a definite identifier you are right.

"I'd better start making sense to myself, let alone everyone else "

I've just about given up on that one ;)
I think you have said what I was saying but probably from a different staring position, cast iron breaks, size for size, far easier than bellmetal (based on the sledgehammer test !), we expect it to be brittle but if rolled etc it become much more ductile, something C/I does not to the same extent. I suspect this is due to the eutectic structure of cast Cu / Sn, which alloy is more amenable to ductility when manipulated manually.

Conversely, what would you expect a cast lead with 2% tin to sound like when struck ?  My late neighbour had to both make and repair some organ pipes in this odd alloy to match the originals, the sheets 'sang' when unrolled and rang like a bell when struck !

BTW sorry to hear about your agro with the German ebayer I nearly had a buy but thankfully checked with the vendor for acceptable payments and as I don't have ebanking decided it was too risky, glad I did now  >:(
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Owen Woods on July 12, 2010, 05:06:27 PM
I think you have said what I was saying but probably from a different staring position, cast iron breaks, size for size, far easier than bellmetal (based on the sledgehammer test !), we expect it to be brittle but if rolled etc it become much more ductile, something C/I does not to the same extent. I suspect this is due to the eutectic structure of cast Cu / Sn, which alloy is more amenable to ductility when manipulated manually.

Conversely, what would you expect a cast lead with 2% tin to sound like when struck ?  My late neighbour had to both make and repair some organ pipes in this odd alloy to match the originals, the sheets 'sang' when unrolled and rang like a bell when struck !

BTW sorry to hear about your agro with the German ebayer I nearly had a buy but thankfully checked with the vendor for acceptable payments and as I don't have ebanking decided it was too risky, glad I did now  >:(

I need to revise deformation hardening. It's already gone out of my head and I think I failed to recall the niceties of it in my exam :( You may well be right re: eutectic structures.

And yes, I've learned my lesson. Although my lesson might be to switch to a more amenable bank! There is an update as well :-\
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 12, 2010, 07:58:44 PM
"I need to revise deformation hardening. It's already gone out of my head and I think I failed to recall the niceties of it in my exam  You may well be right re: eutectic structures."

Hey, trust your memory, not mine !

Rolling to harden material for flat springs has been done for donkeys years, as has wire drawing (think piano wire) its probably one of those black arts surviving in a few places in the UK where things are still made, rather than assembled.

I've no great knowledge of metallurgy but have had some passing contact with casting Ali, Iron brass & bronzes and pipe metal (Pewter by any other name), along with carbon steel used in bandsaw blade manufacture, a little knowledge is a perilous thing so perhaps I should take a bit more care qualifying opinions or guesstimates  >:E

This afternoon a donor reed has been butchered to fit the slot vacated by the broken reed, now its time to brew up some wax.

I think I'll re wax and re assemble the box before thinking about tuning, it will give the reeds a chance to carve themselves some clearance (Nurse, another dose of sedative for Mr Gibb please) in the plates and I can run them through Bills Tuner and chart what I have got and what I may be able to do with it

You never know, it might work sufficiently for me to have a go at recording TOTM - then you can have a laugh and recommend that I'm wasting my time and to stick it back on Ebay  ;D

Richard (suffering rare delusions of adequacy)
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 17, 2010, 11:13:55 PM
ITS ALIVE!!!!!

Although tonally still on the critical list  :o

After completion and test of the 'Reedwaxers Pal'* this morning, and making up some new leather bellows end seals this afternoon (from cheapish Chamois wash leather, they don't grade them for sale but I do for purchase, much to the amusement of one of the shelf stackers). This evening with a nicely warm iron and a stick of me newly cast wax I started planting reedplates, when I saw the damage at the start, yes I had abused them before doing anything else,  by engraving each one nicely (?) with its position)

Pleased to say the wax ran nicely and temperature of iron remained stable.

After re assembly I tried a scale, a few reeds are not sounding properly (when noting 'carve some clearance' previously I was not entirely kidding as I felt there might  be some interference betwixt reeds and slots, interestingly more on the pull side including some on plates left undisturbed, the Zinc is a bit grey so I guess these will need to come out for a clean up - would you scrape or file these slots Theo ?

The Bass end has some 'failure to resonate' issues as well - hadn't done anything to the reeds this end just replaced a couple of pallet springs

Anyhow had a couple of tunes out of it, decided not to try for TOTM with it just yet otherwise the RSPCFRI might get on my case  >:E

The undisturbed top end sounds quite sweet, those badly bent reeds are not right but not cringingly out, once I can get them all speaking properly it can be pointed at the tuner to see the damage....

Richard


*(a sort of tap which stops some of the electrickery which lurks in the sockets from getting through the wire into my soldering iron)
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Theo on July 18, 2010, 12:05:58 AM
Zinc is a bit grey so I guess these will need to come out for a clean up - would you scrape or file these slots Theo ?


Scrape not file, you don't want to remove any metal.

Reed tongues may need to be centralised in their slots so they don't strike one side.
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 18, 2010, 02:27:23 PM

Scrape not file, you don't want to remove any metal.

Reed tongues may need to be centralised in their slots so they don't strike one side.

Thanks Theo, I was a little wary of trying to rotate any on their rivets, having spent so long flattening some out the first time.

Had it been an engine part my first act would have been to chemically degrease (or dewax) and then dunk in 20% citric acid solution, a brilliant cleaner for any brass / copper corrosion and gentle enough not to damage the parent metal, I've never tried it on bronze, iron rivetted to Zinc - has all the hallmarks of a primary cell !

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: pgroff on July 18, 2010, 03:10:09 PM
Richard,

I like to keep a few different gauges of thin stainless steel shim stock on hand.

The thinnest gauge can be torn like aluminum foil (but is much tougher than aluminum foil with a nice sharp edge) and a little scrap of it makes a great tool for cleaning zinc oxide from the sides of the slots.

The thicker gauges can be cut with tinsnips (or will break after folded and creased in both directions).  The corners of those pieces can also be used as a scraper (but too thick to run vertically between the side of the reedtongue and the slot), also to support or bend the reedtongue to set its spring above the plate, and can be used as a lever to rotate the reed on its rivet.  Of course, bass reeds with two rivets through the tongue can't be rotated -- with those you may have to work more on the side of the tongue or the slot.

PG
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 18, 2010, 09:14:13 PM
Richard,

I like to keep a few different gauges of thin stainless steel shim stock on hand.

PG


Aha, great minds and all that !  Thanks for the heads up but I found my way there earlier this afternoon - I had cut myself some brass, ali and steel shim, the steel from a recycled beer can, mebee not stainless but a very nice material to use and along with a little honed up TC scraper for the crusty spots and ends seems to have opened up all the bad slots.

As of now, other than the reed I made as a replacement, which is giving intermittent results, I have all the other treble end operating properly and for the most part reliably, have had a tune or two out and have just run each reed through Bills meter and was going to tabulate the results and post here so that the more  familiar with tune up jobs might offer a considered opinion prior to my piling in......

Beg to report another outbreak of MAD, to wit ebay item No 230497978804 - looked such a sad little basket case wich I could just see in satin black and gold like the JPS livery of old.............

Richard
Title: Re: Old Hohner
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 18, 2010, 10:55:22 PM
Tuning sheet attached, I have marked the damaged reeds but thought those otherwise untouched might prove interesting for any who would like a snapshot of the tuning of a near century old box - plates not removed for straightening are still in their original wax and do not appear to have been tuned since new.

Opinions on what I should or could aim for in a plain brown wrapper please  ::)

Any idea if this would have had a wooden or metal pallet cover plate (missing but 2 screw eyes still in place)

I'm off to watch Enigma
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal