Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on July 05, 2010, 01:06:10 PM

Title: Any problems with re-tuning from Bb/Eb to D/G?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 05, 2010, 01:06:10 PM
I am interested in a Liliput melodeon which has been re-tuned from Bb/Eb to D/G, but am concerned whether there might be any longer term effect of all the reeds having been re-tuned down by three semi-tones. This does seem a lot of metal to scrape away and I am concerned that this could lead to weakness in some of the reeds if I were to play the instrument robustly and continuously for the next however many years.

And if a reed does go in such an old instrument, how easy is it to get a replacement? Are reed plate sizes in the Liliput the same as other melodeons?

Would I be on any safer ground to go for a Liliput that has been re-tuned up a full tone from C/F to D/G?
Title: Re: Any problems with re-tuning from Bb/Eb to D/G?
Post by: Theo on July 05, 2010, 01:53:18 PM
First let's get the pitch differences straight:

1 Bb/Eb pitch is 4 semitones below D/G
2 C/F is 2 semitones below D/G

Liliput reedplates are shorter and narrower than standard Hohner or Italian ones.

And to answer the primary question about the durability of a converted box - it all depends how well the conversion was done.

I've done several such conversions, and as far as I know they are performing well.  I've not attempted to tune all the reeds up from the old to the new pitch,  going up two semitones might be just about possible but will leave reeds with very thin tips.  Taking a whole set of reeds  4 semitones up is not on at all, except possibly for a very few low notes that have reeds with weighted tips.  If the conversion has been done like this then keep away!

I've always approached these conversions by moving the reeds about to new positions where the minimum amount of tuning is required, and almost always have gone for 4th button doh otherwise I would run out of reeds for the top notes.  Paradoxically here is actually slightly less retuning required when starting from Bb/Eb, just because of the way the notes are paired up on each button.

So ask some more questions of the seller: how was the conversion done, and who did the conversion being the most important, then contact the person who did the conversion and ask their opinion on the long term viability of the box.
Title: Re: Any problems with re-tuning from Bb/Eb to D/G?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 06, 2010, 11:09:44 AM
Many thanks for that, Theo. It all makes much more sense now, and I have ascertained the conversion was done as you describe and by a well known and very respected melodeon craftsman.
Title: Re: Any problems with re-tuning from Bb/Eb to D/G?
Post by: Alison Scott on July 06, 2010, 05:23:22 PM
I've done several such conversions, and as far as I know they are performing well. 

My Bb/Eb to D/G conversion is *loverly*.
Title: Re: Any problems with re-tuning from Bb/Eb to D/G?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 12, 2010, 01:18:21 PM
... going up two semitones might be just about possible but will leave reeds with very thin tips. 

I've always approached these conversions by moving the reeds about to new positions where the minimum amount of tuning is required ...

Would I be right in assuming that the best way to achieve an A/D Liliput would be to start with a Bb/Eb instrument and, as far as re-tuning goes, just have to tune everything down one semi-tone? Or is there some clever ways of moving the reeds around that would make it better, or no worse, converting a C/F instrument to A/D?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal