Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Just4Fun on July 09, 2010, 05:26:57 PM
-
I guess I had better qualify that question. Six months ago I took up the box having opted for the B/C system but now realise that it's English I like most and have decided to accept that I made a mistake and change to D/G. So, I want to play it safe and get a good, all round, honest, no nonsense second hand D/G box with a budget of £1000. I could really do with some good advice here as if I get it wrong again I think my long suffering wife will kill me. Any suggestions about what I should be keeping my eyes open for?
-
You could do a lot worse than an elderly German-made Pokerwork, sent to Theo to have the action improved, and hang onto the rest of the dosh. You might only need to sell 1 of your B/C boxes then.
Just a thought.
John
-
Hohner Pokerwork or Erica, readily available from good folkie music shops,e.g. the Music Room (they've got some nice 2nd hand Ericas at the moment)
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/index.php/cPath/244_249_486
Or on Rees's website there is the Hohner Morgane £750, or the Dino baffetti Morris III £1000, both nice boxes.
http://www.melodeons.com/
-
Wow, good advice in a blink of an eye and notable how the same people keep coming to the rescue! Thank you gentlemen and please everyone, keep the advice coming. The Good Woman seems happier already. ; :o
-
I would say that if you are going to buy new the Morgane can't be bettered at that price. Second hand is a more sensible option and a grand will go a long way. I agree with Johnjo and go second hand and keep the excess, only selling one box to pay for it. I personally wouldn't go for a pokerwork though :P
-
I am currently cheerleading for Mike Rowbotham who supplies very well reconditioned old Hohners of which I have two which I love.
http://www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk/ (http://www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk/)
-
I'll happily second Lester's recommendation. Mike Rowbotham has recently made a lovely job of converting a C/F Hohner Liliput to D/G for me.
If you went to Mike you'd almost certainly get a cracking box, and have plenty of change from your budget.
John
-
Nope. Definitely a Bernard Loffet P'tit. I suspect that Nick Barber will agree with me. Are you out there Nick?
Guy
-
I agree wwith most of the replies that a refurbished hohner is a good bet or& the morgan is good value.
however the most important part of choosing a new (or 2ndhand) box apart from price, is to get one you like the sound off and can feel at one with. Wet or dry tuning, 2 or 3 voice to be considered . ~All this is entirely down to personal preference - otherwise there would only be a need for one type of box!. If you possibly can go to one or more of the major retailers ( hobgob, musisc room, etc and dspend some considerable time playing around with different boxes keeping in mind that whatever sound it makes you will have to live with for some considerable time. The other source of boxes to try is the bigger festivals where several traders have stalls. I am not recommending any particular retailer exept to try a good range which the smaller tetailers don't stock. Once you have decided on the box you can look around on websites etc for the best price
george
-
I agree wwith most of the replies that a refurbished hohner is a good bet or& the morgan is good value.
however the most important part of choosing a new (or 2ndhand) box apart from price, is to get one you like the sound off and can feel at one with. Wet or dry tuning, 2 or 3 voice to be considered . ~All this is entirely down to personal preference - otherwise there would only be a need for one type of box!. If you possibly can go to one or more of the major retailers ( hobgob, musisc room, etc and dspend some considerable time playing around with different boxes keeping in mind that whatever sound it makes you will have to live with for some considerable time. The other source of boxes to try is the bigger festivals where several traders have stalls. I am not recommending any particular retailer exept to try a good range which the smaller tetailers don't stock. Once you have decided on the box you can look around on websites etc for the best price
george
Completely agree with everything everyone's said here already (for once). Personally, I like old, lightweight Hohners, fettled to have action limited, and bass buttons bushed, so I'd recommend one of them!
However, it really is worth getting along to a festival stall, or one of the big folk retail shops to try as many boxes as you can out. Everyone's tastes are different and even two boxes of the same make and model can sound different depending on the tuning.
Theo, Mike and a few others can certainly do you a cracking job on an old hohner for not that much money though.
-
My only comment would be that if you can take a box player with you do so. Reason for this is that what you hear may not equate to what the listener hears (had this recently with one of my guitars which I was thinking of parting with and then I heard it played and thought "wow"). So listening to a box from a small distance may alter your selection process.
Steve
-
Nice Saltarelle Bouebe D/g just listed in Buy & Sell. Also a good starter box that you could play happily for years. If you want something more re3fined than a Hohner this would be a good model to choose.
-
Agreed, a Bouebe is my principal box and has been for years. I use it for Morris and Ceilidhs regularly.
-
The Music Room have a second hand Sandpiper that might be worth a look. I quite liked the one that I tried.
-
By way of an update: I managed to swap my blackdot for an ADG compadre thinking it would keep me going till I could sell/exchange the Excelsior and then I would get a half descent D/G. BUT I am loving the three row and so the question now is should I actually consider getting a good three row or, more to the point, what are the pros and cons of three rows when it comes to playing English?
I seem to be drawing on the experience and wisdom of you guys here but hopefully in years to come I'll be able to give something back!
-
what are the pros and cons of three rows when it comes to playing English?
The only "con" I can think of is size and weight, but it sounds like neither is an issue for you. To be honest I'm not sure why they aren't more popular.
-
Just get on and learn to play your Compadre, which would come well within my definition of half decent. Once you can play a couple of dozen tunes you will be much better placed to make your own choice of what (if any) box you need to move on to.
-
The Compadre is a great box, stick with it. It's perfect for English music and loads of other stuff too.
-
Isn't the Compadre like a Corona II inside, with a plastic casing?
-
The Compadre is a great box - more than capable of doing everything that an 'English' traditional musician could ever want (and then some). Of course - you can always go MAD (like a good number of us here on this board) - in which case whatever box you have, you'll always want another one!
;D
-
After all the kind suggestions and knowledgeable advice you people have given I thought the least I could do is add an update. Obviously I swapped the Double Ray for a Compadre and straight away started to feel that I was doing the right thing as the D/G (or ADG in this case) felt far more intuitive. After some deliberation I've now got rid of the excelsior and opted for a Castagnari Lilly, the thought process being that although it is only a single voice it will be a lot of fun to play along with the good woman on her fiddle. (Which has already proved totally right). Once the D/G system seems less alien and my confidence and tune base has grown then I'll enter full 'MAD warp ten' and invest in something more suited for session type playing like a Bouebe or numerous others... The main thing is that I feel, due to the freely given words of wisdom that you have all offered, I've been set on the right path. A huge thank you to you all and in due course I'll post a video link so you can all say in unison: "we should have told him to just quit"!
-
and invest in something more suited for session type playing like a Bouebe or numerous others...
The Compadre or Lily will be absolutely fine for session playing.
-
Thanks Theo. How do I justify the MAD though? But seriously, thanks for your help.
-
I really liked my Lilly for sessions as I could hear what I was playing through the background of the other box players
-
How do I justify the MAD though?
What - 'justify'? Nope, not MAD yet. MAD is box collection without justification surely???
:D
-
As threatened, an early massacring of an otherwise perfectly good tune. Takes a while to warm up and then goes steadily down hill but I'm loving it, so the neighbours will just have to move. >:E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6rOdpJ15vI
-
As threatened, an early massacring of an otherwise perfectly good tune. Takes a while to warm up and then goes steadily down hill but I'm loving it, so the neighbours will just have to move. >:E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6rOdpJ15vI
Crikey, that is amazingly good playing for a relative beginner.
Well done, keep it up, you'll go far.
-
Nice Black Pearl on ebay!
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/MELODEON-DINO-BAFFETTI-ITALIAN-D-G-ACCORDIAN-SQUEEZEBOX-/230501546560?cmd=ViewItem&pt=UK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL&hash=item35aaf67a40
Darnit guess I got in late on the discussion!
-
What - 'justify'? Nope, not MAD yet. MAD is box collection without justification surely???
:D
By faith or works? >:E
-
Surely MAD is justified by faith and works....for without works faith is dead!
-
Get thee behind me!
-
Surely MAD is justified by faith and works....for without works faith is dead!
Now what's really needed is Faith in Action - so in this case, know what you want - then go and get it!
;D
-
Isn't the Compadre like a Corona II inside, with a plastic casing?
The Compadre has metal grille and wood casing, no any plastic other than the usual white Hohner buttons.
IMHO the Compadre is as well built as a Pokerwork.
-
Isn't the Compadre like a Corona II inside, with a plastic casing?
The Compadre has metal grille and wood casing, no any plastic other than the usual white Hohner buttons.
IMHO the Compadre is as well built as a Pokerwork.
Couldn't agree more - and what's more my 'El Rey del Vallenato' is the three-voiced model which gives me essentially a Corona III inside with a not unleasant Compadre style casing.
Thanks again Rees - I just can't say it often enough - what a beautiful box you sold me!
AL
-
Would be great to see them come out with an Extreme in BCC# but I guess that might be a pipe dream!
-
Would be great to see them come out with an Extreme in BCC# but I guess that might be a pipe dream!
provided they put a modicum of stradella bass on it The Hohner parts bin may have a mass produced piano or continental bass end that they could fit needing only a larger airhole & air bar.
george
-
Would be great to see them come out with an Extreme in BCC# but I guess that might be a pipe dream
Yep, one thing's for sure, they [Hohner] are not listening!
-
Would be great to see them come out with an Extreme in BCC# but I guess that might be a pipe dream
Yep, one thing's for sure, they [Hohner] are not listening!
They are listening, but to different people! As the Hohner web says, these boxes are targeted to the Norteno, Vallenato or Tex Mex markets, with their preferred tunings, which does not include the one used with Irish music...
-
They are listening, but to different people! As the Hohner web says, these boxes are targeted to the Norteno, Vallenato or Tex Mex markets, with their preferred tunings, which does not include the one used with Irish music...
So why make 1/2 an accordion in the Compadre BCC# - with a more than useless bass end?
-
The Extreme models have a different reed block due to their additional treble buttons. The Compadre probably uses the same reed block as the Corona, if we tell them they are wrong they may listen!
-
As threatened, an early massacring of an otherwise perfectly good tune. Takes a while to warm up and then goes steadily down hill but I'm loving it, so the neighbours will just have to move. >:E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6rOdpJ15vI
Please, what is the name of this tune that you are not massacring anywhere near as much as I am about to!
Thanks,
;D Tim
-
Please, what is the name of this tune that you are not massacring anywhere near as much as I am about to!
Thanks,
;D Tim
It is Nancy Taylor's Reel, written by Northumbrian fiddle player Willy Taylor in honour of his wife.
Willy was one of the Northumbrian trio, The Shepherds, along with Joe Hutton on Northumbrian Smallpipes and Will Atkinson on mouth-organ. Three fine musicians and gentlemen, all now sadly departed.
Click here for dots (http://www.btinternet.com/~radical/thefolkmag/willy/willy2.gif)
-
Thank you Steve, you beat me to it. I'm most flattered that you recognised it for what it is.
-
Please, what is the name of this tune that you are not massacring anywhere near as much as I am about to!
Thanks,
;D Tim
It is Nancy Taylor's Reel, written by Northumbrian fiddle player Willy Taylor in honour of his wife.
Willy was one of the Northumbrian trio, The Shepherds, along with Joe Hutton on Northumbrian Smallpipes and Will Atkinson on mouth-organ. Three fine musicians and gentlemen, all now sadly departed.
Click here for dots (http://www.btinternet.com/~radical/thefolkmag/willy/willy2.gif)
Thank you Steve, you beat me to it. I'm most flattered that you recognised it for what it is.
Many thanks to you both, Gentlemen,
Tim
-
It's three months now since I started with a D/G having struggled with a B/C for about six months and I love the Lilly more and more. I wonder though if the single voice is leading me towards a style of playing that would not suit a two or three voice instrument that I might one day aspire to or is it just a question of picking up a different box and playing it in the same way? Maybe I'm getting ahead of myself here but having recently retired I'm now spending two or three hours a day trying to get the hang of the beast and could do with some direction. Obviously I practice on my own a bit and am very fortunate that my wife is a pretty good fiddle player so we play quite a bit together but does anyone have any suggestions as to what to aim for/aspire to? I attach a 'video nasty'. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsTNXL1wz_A
Apologies for the fluffed ending.
-
Oh dear, no replies! Even suggestions of 'give up' or 'aspire to never playing again' would be helpful!
-
OK, I'll bite:
I don't think your familiarity with the number of reeds in a Lily will affect your ability to manage a box with more reeds. A bigger instrument may be heavier, and may feel a bit cumbersome at first. But if you get one with a few stops you can approximate your single-reed sound by choosing only one set of reeds. The things that affect the quality of one's playing tend to be a bit more nebulous than the box itself. There are numerous examples of cheap, small, old, broken, out of tune, and otherwise limited instruments sounding very good in talented hands. And I've heard tell of a few cases in which very nice instruments sound a bit clunky in less expert hands. But, by all accounts, this problem diminishes with practice.