Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Fungusface on July 13, 2010, 11:19:26 AM
-
This has a small body similar in shape to a Trichord as shown in top grille ,one of JT Forbes of Dundee ,found in a cupboard small in size like a lilliput.As you will notice the early Black Dot at bottom pics has a grill similar to Pokerworks.
and my recent find has Grille similar to Trichord and same cosmetic design.
-
I'm confused. It's about the same size as a liliput you say? But it similar to a Trichord? Does it have 3 rows then? If you have access to a Liliput size 3 row then I will buy it :P
-
That's the Hohner way alright, multiple models from the same parts and design. Quite economical.
That's a very nice looking old Trichord - I've never seen one that old in the flesh (in the wood?). I'd snap it up in a heartbeat, but it is much larger than a Liliput.
-
No I have explained wrong,, cosmetic wise in body design it has more or less same shape and brass fittings on body,as a trichord, its small and yet top grille is shaped same way as a trichord grille, usually all the old Black Dots are flat top as in pokerworks, afraid my scots being translated into english went wrong.
-
I think the original post means that the top picture Double Ray is the same size as a Liliput (very unusual) and the other two are normal size Trichord and Double Ray.
-
I think the original post means that the top picture Double Ray is the same size as a Liliput (very unusual) and the other two are normal size Trichord and Double Ray.
That's the way I understood John also. But I wonder if that top "v-grille" Double Ray is really Liliput sized. I could be wrong because I've never seen a 2-voice Double Ray v-grille. But I have two 2-voice "v-grille" Hohners, an 8-bass C/C# and a 12-bass C/F, that I think are based on the same body. These 2-voice v-grille boxes are closer in size to a typical pokerwork box. But they can look smaller from some points of view because the top and bottom of the melody-side casework are cut away, allowing for the 3-dimensional grille assembly that John has pointed out.
If John's DR v-grille box is the same size as my C/C# and C/F v-grilles, the keyboard and buttons will be normal pokerwork size, and the instrument would require a normal pokerwork-sized carrying case.
PG
-
No I have explained wrong,, cosmetic wise in body design it has more or less same shape and brass fittings on body,as a trichord, its small and yet top grille is shaped same way as a trichord grille, usually all the old Black Dots are flat top as in pokerworks, afraid my scots being translated into english went wrong.
Part of the confusion here is that the Trichord is not really a body style. The Trichord name has been used for B/C/C# boxes built on a couple of different body styles. Your Trichord is an unusual, early one. Most Trichords I've seen were made more recently, and were built on the rounded body style that Hohner used for its 1960s - present Corsos and Coronas. Your Trichord is built on what is sometimes called a "Pre-Corona" or "Pre-Corso" body style. These have a boxier shape, usually with a very sharp back edge on the bass side where they hit your left wrist, and a 3-dimensional grille with celluloid-covered wood top and bottom, and a "v-pattern" metal center panel.
So to describe your Double Ray in the top photo, I would say not that it resembles a Trichord, but that it is built on a squarish body style with the 3-dimensional "v-grille." But your Double Ray looks like a 2 voice model, so it's a smaller version of the "v-grille" body style -- smaller than the body style used for the v-grille Pre-Corsos, Pre-Coronas, and *your, unusual* Trichord.
PG
-
"Pre-Corona" or "Pre-Corso" body style. These have a boxier shape, usually with a very sharp back edge on the bass side where they hit your left wrist,
Yes, I have a GCF one of those. Man, is it ever painful to play!