Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on July 20, 2010, 10:35:02 AM

Title: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 20, 2010, 10:35:02 AM
I have finally acquired my first Hohner Liliput and am delighted with the sound, size, weight and look. However, I am having a few problems getting my left arm and hand comfortable. If I position my hand so that my fingers can comfortably reach and play all the bass notes then the sharp back edge of the bass end digs directly into my wrist just where it joins the palm of my hand, and where the wrist strap I use with larger melodeons cannot help me. If I position my hand such that the bass edge falls on the padded part of my palm (like a concertina player) my fingers do not reliably reach all the keys. I am also finding the air button has a very strong spring, and amongst all of this it does not take much playing before my forearm begins to ache.

Have any other Liliput players found similar problems, and what solutions have they found?

Are there any good hand/wrist straps that can protect across the palm/wrist boundary? I had an archer's wrist strap many years ago which covered this area but it was not very good quality. My temporary solution is a piece of leather held in place by a (fingerless) cycling glove. I know some players say you should play such that the bass end, treble end and bellows all stay in line (like an accordion is played), and this also means the bass end does not dig into your wrist; however, I definately get the best expression out of any melodeon by having a bit of curve on the bellows (ie the bass end slightly forward of the treble end).

Would there be any problem in my easing the tension on the air button spring, or is there a mod that could be done to the air button to make it easier to operate?
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 20, 2010, 10:41:51 AM
Maggie of 'Maggie's Melodeon' fame (and also a member of this forum) advocates the use of a small chamois leather pad - you know the sort you use to clean the condensation off the inside of the car windscreen - between the thumb/palm/wrist area and the corner of the box. Though that's for a pokerwork. Don't quite know whether you'd be able to use something similar on the Lilliput? Even a folded cloth may do the trick perhaps?
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Theo on July 20, 2010, 11:10:05 AM
If you ease the tension on the air button spring then less bellows pressure will be required to cause it to leak, so if you do adjust the spring you will have to work out how far you can go in reducing the spring force before you get unacceptable leakage when you play hard.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Ollie on July 20, 2010, 03:10:23 PM
I have just aquired one too and noticed the same thing as soon as I picked it up. My solution is a Saul Rose stylee sweatband on the left wrist.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: nemethmik on July 20, 2010, 04:29:18 PM
Have any other Liliput players found similar problems, and what solutions have they found?
Yes. After a couple of weeks of playing the Liliputs my left hand started to take an optimal shape and position automatically.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: OwenG on July 20, 2010, 04:43:42 PM
I think how I overcame the problem was to rest the ball of my left thumb against the case and then cock my wrist to reach round to the buttons and brace the back of my hand against the strap. As the box is so light I don't think this is likely to knacker your wrist too much, although writing about it makes it look painful.

I'd try and have a go, but I've just sold my Liliput  :'( ;)
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Marje on July 20, 2010, 05:10:02 PM
I used to have that problem with a previous box. My solution was to take an old pair of tights (I'm sure you can source this from somewhere!) and cut off a chunk of one leg, which I then folded over and used as a wristband.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: stevejay on July 20, 2010, 05:37:00 PM
Guys are more likely to have an old pair of socks rather than tights, but you never know.

 I'd be hesitant to hack up my superhero costume however, no matter what.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: squeezy on July 20, 2010, 09:04:01 PM
I get this problem with playing my Eb/Bb liliput for more than a couple of tunes.  Not good for practising with!

I know what Sandy means about a pain in the forearm - I get cramp in my hand too, but I think that it's not due to the air button spring weight or my arm pressing against the box, at least not in my case.  I think the pain comes from having to crunch my hand up small enough to control the bass buttons and air button together, with all the movement that comes with playing the left hand I don't think it can be a healthy position to have the hand not in it's relaxed position like I can for all my other boxes.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Rob Phillips on July 20, 2010, 09:57:04 PM
This isn't a problem I have with my Liliput. Given that I'm only about 5' 6" I'm probably more in proportion to the instrument than bigger people with bigger hands (though I'm not not quite Lilliputian). I can play the box in a relaxed way  --  no problems in reaching the bass buttons or in reaching the air button, and no difficulty with the sharp edge. I have had problems recently, however, with a 1930s Erika. This really did hurt my left hand around the ball of the thumb and on the back of my hand. The original straps are fitted and are unpadded. I didn't want to lose them, so I chopped the toe end off an odd sock, fitted it double round the bass strap and taped it into place. It provides just enough "give" and has cured the problem for me.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: rees on July 20, 2010, 11:07:26 PM
Sharon Shannon uses a giant bath sponge.
Just to clarify - it's on the bass end of her melodeon.
I've no idea what she does in the bath.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: IanD on July 20, 2010, 11:31:37 PM
I have finally acquired my first Hohner Liliput and am delighted with the sound, size, weight and look. However, I am having a few problems getting my left arm and hand comfortable. If I position my hand so that my fingers can comfortably reach and play all the bass notes then the sharp back edge of the bass end digs directly into my wrist just where it joins the palm of my hand, and where the wrist strap I use with larger melodeons cannot help me. If I position my hand such that the bass edge falls on the padded part of my palm (like a concertina player) my fingers do not reliably reach all the keys. I am also finding the air button has a very strong spring, and amongst all of this it does not take much playing before my forearm begins to ache.

Have any other Liliput players found similar problems, and what solutions have they found?

Are there any good hand/wrist straps that can protect across the palm/wrist boundary? I had an archer's wrist strap many years ago which covered this area but it was not very good quality. My temporary solution is a piece of leather held in place by a (fingerless) cycling glove. I know some players say you should play such that the bass end, treble end and bellows all stay in line (like an accordion is played), and this also means the bass end does not dig into your wrist; however, I definately get the best expression out of any melodeon by having a bit of curve on the bellows (ie the bass end slightly forward of the treble end).

Would there be any problem in my easing the tension on the air button spring, or is there a mod that could be done to the air button to make it easier to operate?

I had exactly the same problem when I first got my Preciosa, so when Theo rebuilt it I got him to cut away the sharp rear corner of the bass end and insert a section of rounded celluloid over wood -- this completely solved the problem.

You could ask him how much it would cost to do the same to yours...

Ian
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: theSmoiler on July 20, 2010, 11:41:44 PM
The late Barry Callaghan had a sort of kidney-shaped gel wrist support - such as you might use when typing - on the bass end of his Castagnari.

Diane
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 21, 2010, 08:21:38 AM
I had exactly the same problem when I first got my Preciosa, so when Theo rebuilt it I got him to cut away the sharp rear corner of the bass end and insert a section of rounded celluloid over wood -- this completely solved the problem.

Ian - any chance of a photo to show us what the mod looks like? Sounds like the ultimate solution to the "cutting wrist" problem.

I think the pain comes from having to crunch my hand up small enough to control the bass buttons and air button together, with all the movement that comes with playing the left hand I don't think it can be a healthy position to have the hand not in it's relaxed position like I can for all my other boxes.

Anybody done any mod to the air button to move it up a bit to give the other fingers more room for manouevre?
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: IanD on July 21, 2010, 08:26:43 AM
I had exactly the same problem when I first got my Preciosa, so when Theo rebuilt it I got him to cut away the sharp rear corner of the bass end and insert a section of rounded celluloid over wood -- this completely solved the problem.

Ian - any chance of a photo to show us what the mod looks like? Sounds like the ultimate solution to the "cutting wrist" problem.

I think the pain comes from having to crunch my hand up small enough to control the bass buttons and air button together, with all the movement that comes with playing the left hand I don't think it can be a healthy position to have the hand not in it's relaxed position like I can for all my other boxes.

I'll take one and post it tomorrow when I have time.

You'll probably find the scrunched-up hand problem goes away with a fix like this, I did.

Ian

Anybody done any mod to the air button to move it up a bit to give the other fingers more room for manouevre?
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Marje on July 21, 2010, 09:21:49 AM
Stevejay: Tights are better than a sock because they're softer and more stretchy. Doesn't have to be your own tights, you could use someone else's, assuming you could persuade her to remove them for you! You'd have to make it clear, of course, that this would be done strictly in the service of music.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: oggiesnr on July 21, 2010, 12:26:31 PM
I have exactly the same problem with the Club that I just purchased for Sandy  (:).  I'm experimenting with hand position and overall playing position.

Steve
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Theo on July 21, 2010, 12:36:34 PM
Can't you take a bit of pain for your art!  :'(  Keep playing for a couple of years and you will develop a nice "Hohner callus" on the inside of your forearm, problem solved. :o
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: IanD on July 23, 2010, 07:42:46 PM
I had exactly the same problem when I first got my Preciosa, so when Theo rebuilt it I got him to cut away the sharp rear corner of the bass end and insert a section of rounded celluloid over wood -- this completely solved the problem.

Ian - any chance of a photo to show us what the mod looks like? Sounds like the ultimate solution to the "cutting wrist" problem.

I think the pain comes from having to crunch my hand up small enough to control the bass buttons and air button together, with all the movement that comes with playing the left hand I don't think it can be a healthy position to have the hand not in it's relaxed position like I can for all my other boxes.

Anybody done any mod to the air button to move it up a bit to give the other fingers more room for manouevre?

(http://www.dedics.co.uk/temp/preciosa_edge.JPG)

It's not as shiny as it looks, this is mainly the flash from the camera.

Ian
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 23, 2010, 10:26:06 PM
As butchery goes, doesn't our Mr Gibb have a lovely touch  :|||:

I like the 'overcentre' positioning of the strap too, similar effect to my angling the strap on the HA114

Richard
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: IanD on July 24, 2010, 10:50:11 AM
As butchery goes, doesn't our Mr Gibb have a lovely touch  :|||:

I like the 'overcentre' positioning of the strap too, similar effect to my angling the strap on the HA114

Richard

The strap needs to be that far back to stop it pressing on the back of your hand and restricting movement, this is true of any relatively shallow box.

On my Oakwood (same depth as a Pokerwork) the strap is positioned about 1cm off-centre towards the back for exactly the same reason -- doesn't sound much but it makes a big difference to playing comfort.

Ian
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 24, 2010, 09:49:58 PM
I don't know if its simply that its the box I've been most used to Ian, but there is no problem with the D/G pokerwork at this end but boy did I struggle with the HA114 until I moved the strap, and I still don't feel confident that its under total control as far as the air button is concerned - it must be to do with the airbutton being on the back rather than the end
The 'new' ancient one row feels different again but feels secure, it has an ancient thin, wide strap (rigid on arrival but several dunkings in Neatsfoot oil has brought the suppleness back, this has a flat end like the DG with similar air button position but is smaller in cross section.

Having just re read my previous posting I hope no one takes my 'butchery' comment to mean anything other than if you have to do something severe (which might offend purists) to customise a box then you couldn't have come up with a more elegant solution than Theo found for this one - no aspersions cast on our esteemed facilitator's abilities or taste...

Richard
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 26, 2010, 11:32:12 AM
Many thanks for all the responses, containing much useful advice and experience.

I experimented with a number of the ideas for a "spacer" but could not get comfortable. I also tried the "protection" idea, but rather than a stocking or sock I used an old leather glove with its fingers cut off - this did stop the sharp edge digging in, and I think helped to make me feel more relaxed playing (and it is tension which makes the muscles and tendons ache). I think I still need to explore reducing the fierce tension on the air button spring, but the more I play it the more I assume my muscles will get used to it.

After a couple of weeks of playing the Liliputs my left hand started to take an optimal shape and position automatically.
I was much encouraged by this, Miklos, not least since I had a similar comment from Mike Rowbotham regarding starting with a spacer but eventually not needing it (Mike, you may wish to post your full response to me as it was really helpful).

I think how I overcame the problem was to rest the ball of my left thumb against the case and then cock my wrist to reach round to the buttons and brace the back of my hand against the strap. As the box is so light I don't think this is likely to knacker your wrist too much, although writing about it makes it look painful.
I think this must be what I have started doing in the last couple of days and I seem to be playing a bit more smoothly and with less immediate ache. What I have decided to do is practice like this in short bursts (10 minutes or so at a time) so that my hand and arm get used to it and develop to deal with it over longer periods. The most important thing for me (and for Squeezy from what he said) is to ensure I do not play long enough to aggravate my tendons - I have written a separate post about the really serious harm I did some years ago: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4459.0.html

Ian - many thanks for the photo and info on the mod Theo did for you. I shall keep that in mind if my plan to "play it in slowly" does not work out.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Sandy Flett on October 07, 2010, 04:29:35 PM
Just thought I would report that after 10 weeks or so of gradually "playing my left hand in" on the Liliput, my forearm no longer aches and find I can play increasingly longer without my hand starting to ache. I am able to play with the wrist-end of my palm reaching the back edge of the bass end, so it does not cut in to my wrist anymore.

Two golden rules which have served me well:
(1) Try to have hands, arms, shoulders as relaxed as possible when playing
(2) At the first hint of any aches creeping in then stop for a while, ideally do some hand/arm/shoulder stretches (indeed, do some warm up stretches before starting to play if you can remember), and try to think what may be causing the tension that is causing the ache (in my case it is almost always when I am trying unfamiliar stuff, or working something out).

Hope this gives heart to other sufferers.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Broadland Boy on October 07, 2010, 07:29:50 PM
Thats good news Sandy  (:)

Having now achieved a Liliput of my own, the left hand does not feel quite as 'strange' as the one row still does but most definitely not as comfortable as the pokerwork yet, although being lighter seems to help other than I seem to bend the bellows more fore and aft than with the bigger boxes which doesn't help the left hand.

Having big paws I thought the right hand end might be a problem but the smaller buttons and absence of overtravel (fingers too big for the 'oles) make it feel more comfortable unfortunately the control my mind wants to exercise over the fingers seems to be much the same whichever box I pick up - still an unmelodeonist  ;)

Richard
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Kautilya on October 08, 2010, 03:34:13 AM

http://www.tandyleatherfactory.co.uk/home/department/Tools/Stitching-Lacing-Tools/3944-00.aspx?feature=Product_13
may be one for left hand too.
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Broadland Boy on October 08, 2010, 11:27:33 PM

http://www.tandyleatherfactory.co.uk/home/department/Tools/Stitching-Lacing-Tools/3944-00.aspx?feature=Product_13
may be one for left hand too.

Interesting thought Kautilya, I actually have one of these which I use occasionally, presumably you're thinking along the lines of a LH thumb 'ole attached to the strap for positive location - will have to think about that over a  :|glug   :D

Richard
Title: Re: Liliput left hand problems
Post by: Kautilya on October 09, 2010, 11:40:06 PM

http://www.tandyleatherfactory.co.uk/home/department/Tools/Stitching-Lacing-Tools/3944-00.aspx?feature=Product_13
may be one for left hand too.

Interesting thought Kautilya, I actually have one of these which I use occasionally, presumably you're thinking along the lines of a LH thumb 'ole attached to the strap for positive location - will have to think about that over a  :|glug   :D

Richard
Another variant would be thumb hole through leather palm pad as used by a cobbler which would not the 'wraparound'.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal