Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on April 11, 2008, 10:22:27 PM
-
Sorry if I'm going over old ground, this has probably been discussed on the old forum which I haven't really investigated. I'm curious about the letters stamped on Hohner reed frames and what they mean.
I have an old Hohner two row three voice C/C#, I think the model is a Corso and the reeds are MMM. Before I bought this melodeon as an experimental fixer up I'd seen numerous references to the superior quality of 'H' stamped reeds vs those found in the modern Chinese made boxes. I was quite pleased to find 'H' reeds in my old box but there are also a large number of 'T' stamped reeds; what's more there's a fair mixture of leather and plastic valves. Mainly the larger reeds have leather valves and the smaller ones plastic. Is this normal in a pretty old (possibly 1930s or 1940s) box or have I bought something that's been scavenged to fix a better instrument?
I must say it doesn't look like it's been messed about with much and all of the waxing looks pretty ancient; it pretty much looks like an old box that's suffered poor storage conditions over the years but is largely untouched from a service point of view. One curious thing is a large rectangle of leather fixed to the face of the sound/pad/pallet board (help me out with terminology here!) on the bass side so that the leather faced pallet meets another layer of leather when it's in its' 'normal' closed position. This I am told is anything but normal, in fact it's pretty much unheard of. Does anyone have an old Hohner with this strange feature?
Any info would be gratefully received.
Pete.
-
Good question.I have an 30-40 year old G/C Corso that has all plastic valves,I thought they'd replaced at some point until I saw pictures of a similar vintage Corona that had the same plastic valves.
I suppose every instrument has a secret past that we'll never know about.
Chris
-
*Bump!*
Still hoping someone might know the meaning of the 'H' & 'T' stamps on Hohner reed frames.
-
My guess is H is for Hohner, and T is for Trossingen, the town where the Hohner factory is located.
-
Does anyone know a good source of the old zinc reedplates I have a few boxes with broken reeds. Or can you rivet modern reeds on from aluminium plates. Or in fact does the sound differ appreciably?
Mike
-
I've got a full set of zink reeds from an old C/F club 3v I stripped. No wax on them, as they were held in place by screws. Send me a note if you'd like them, 10 euros plus shipping for the whole set. A few broken, but as it's 3v, theres more than plenty for replacement, or a full CF 2v set.
//Lars
-
Does anyone know a good source of the old zinc reedplates I have a few boxes with broken reeds. Or can you rivet modern reeds on from aluminium plates. Or in fact does the sound differ appreciably?
Mike
Modern Hohner reed tongues are a different shape, different steel too I think, so quite a bit of work to fit a new reed tongue, but it is possible, and a good learning experience.
-
I thought I would tack this enquiry onto this thread.
I have a 1950's CF Pokerwork & a 1980's GC. The sound of the reeds, aside from the different tuning, strikes me as different: the older CF sounds softer & sweeter to me. I have listened to a variety of vintage Hohner one, two & three rows on youtube videos & I notice the sound varies a lot. Is there some consensus about the differing sound of Hohner reeds from different eras & across the various models?
-
I've just finished some work on an old 2915 C/F, probably late 40s/early 50s but possibly older. All T reeds (my 1930s Bb/Eb Club has all H reeds), and all plastic valves except for the bass fundamentals, which were leather, and all apparently original. The wax was well past its sell-by date, but rewaxed and with the tired old leather valves replaced by synthetics it now sounds a treat. I left all the original plastic valves in place as I don't see the point in doing unnecessary work. The tremelo is fairly broad, but I agree, it does sound sweeter than a modern instrument.
-
*Bump!*
Still hoping someone might know the meaning of the 'H' & 'T' stamps on Hohner reed frames.
And what about the "T dot" reeds, several of which live happily among the plain "T" reeds on my C/F....? I can't see any difference, and if there's a difference in sound or response then it's so subtle I can't hear it!
Graham
-
My guess is H is for Hohner, and T is for Trossingen, the town where the Hohner factory is located.
I think you're probably right, though I've never seen a satisfactory explanation of when or why they changed. There was a theory that "H" stood for "Handarbeit" ("handmade"), but I think that's probably rather fanciful. The logical extension of that would be that later reeds would be stamped with a letter standing for "machine made", which would be an "M" for "Maschine" or an "A" for "Apparat"........
-
and all plastic valves except for the bass fundamentals, which were leather, and all apparently original.
Yes, my 1950's CF also had all plastic valves except for a few bass leathers. As the box had been stored on its back for decades, the plastic valves were all flat on one side & all coming off on the opposite side.
-
I have a couple of one-row Hohner button accordions with "T" stamped on the reed plates and plastic valves.
Whatever "T" means, these two boxes sound much better to me than the rest of my button accordion collection.