I don't know if this is a worthwhile idea or not - what do you think?
Are you volunteering to make and distribute these?
I don't know if this is a worthwhile idea or not - what do you think?I think it's a great idea! If someone is willing to take on the somewhat thankless task of organising the manufacture/sale, it could raise a little money for the website and provide all of us with the chance to say hello to a fellow member when we are at a folk festival, function or whatever.
If there's any / enough interest then I'd be happy to organise ... unless that's stepping on toes.
Have you thought about teeshirts/mugs/keyfobs....
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows? I would do a design, but I'm rubbish at drawing on the computer.If you do it by hand and scan it in...I'll 'redraw' it electronically Ollie.
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows? I would do a design, but I'm rubbish at drawing on the computer.That sounds quite good! Re the vote, does a simple majority win the day or does it have to be something like 80% for the Yays to triumph?
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows? I would do a design, but I'm rubbish at drawing on the computer.That sounds quite good!
Re the vote, does a simple majority win the day or does it have to be something like 80% for the Yays to triumph?
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows? I would do a design, but I'm rubbish at drawing on the computer.
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows? I would do a design, but I'm rubbish at drawing on the computer.
How about just a simple enamel melodeon? Then all we'd have to agree on is what type...
....that should be worth about another three years of discussion of the relative merits of different makes/models to symbolise "melodeon"....
How about just a simple enamel melodeon? Then all we'd have to agree on is what type...
....that should be worth about another three years of discussion of the relative merits of different makes/models to symbolise "melodeon"....
Yes, a big metal badge with nice sharp edges to really hack the back of your bellows to bits and scratch lumps out of the celluloid/varnish! >:ETrouble is, not everyone takes their box with them wherever they go (or do they?) so perhaps we could have both a badge and a sticker
I'd far prefer a case sticker, maybe incorporating the forum url so that it might advertise this place to non-believers. The International Concertina Association did one some years ago, and I know that mine has received a fair bit of attention from players who see my cases. Not sure whether it had any effect in raising the ICA profile in terms of membership enquiries though....
(Tried to take a photo for attachment, but it's too dark here right now (1am) and the flash bounces badly off the shiny surface; may try again tomorrow...)
MC (cheap and nasty camera owner)
or maybe a way to signal your a forum member.
I know on other forums there are things like, having a yellow hankerchief, or a tiara or a fez is the way to spot a member of those forums.
So maybe a coloured [or melodeon logo-ed] handkerchief tied somewhere to bag box or on your person would be a good identifier?
or maybe a way to signal your a forum member.Bit tricky if you're chatting away to a stranger about melodeons just because he happens to have a handkerchief of the same colour about his person...and it turns out he is a banjo player or something. :|bl
I know on other forums there are things like, having a yellow hankerchief, or a tiara or a fez is the way to spot a member of those forums.
So maybe a coloured [or melodeon logo-ed] handkerchief tied somewhere to bag box or on your person would be a good identifier?
What about a T-shirt with a motto: "Melodeon players do it at both ends simultaneously". :o
Given I am across the pond, the mailing of a pin might be a bit ridiculous. How about sending it pinned onto a suitable tshirt? If not "I heart melodeon" how about "I am not Reg Wilson" with a suitable representation of a Wesson melodeon?
or maybe a way to signal your a forum member.
I know on other forums there are things like, having a yellow hankerchief, or a tiara or a fez is the way to spot a member of those forums.
So maybe a coloured [or melodeon logo-ed] handkerchief tied somewhere to bag box or on your person would be a good identifier?
Yes, a big metal badge with nice sharp edges to really hack the back of your bellows to bits and scratch lumps out of the celluloid/varnish! >:E
How about something simple that can't be mistaken for anything else?
I'd suggest black face make up, top hat, tabard, bells, and a tankard strapped to the belt. Beards optional. Then we can't be confused with anyone else at a folk gathering.
This lot (http://www.cafepress.co.uk/) will produce customised stuff. Anyone fancy a melodeon.net thong? :o
And I said "coat", not goat!
The hairs are growing on my chin Malcolm, not my chest!!!
It needs to be very distinctive and colourful and easily identifiable from a distance.
The hairs are growing on my chin Malcolm, not my chest!!!
I was at the Squeezing Shropshire workshop in early July. One of the tutors was a fine old gentleman, steeped in Cajun tradition. His beard was so long he had to throw it over his shoulder when putting on the melodeon (and it got in the way a fair bit when playing the fiddle too!)
:D
How about a special melodeon.net beard?
Gomm badges here:
http://www.shawmunstergroup.co.uk/home.php?page=gomm_badges (http://www.shawmunstergroup.co.uk/home.php?page=gomm_badges)
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows? I would do a design, but I'm rubbish at drawing on the computer.If you do it by hand and scan it in...I'll 'redraw' it electronically Ollie.
wot about including a stubbie holder also?
now there's an idea............ :|glug :|glug :|glug
Um...looks great except the keyboard and basses need flipping?
Um...looks great except the keyboard and basses need flipping?
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4552.0;attach=3604;image)I think this is an excellent design but would agree that a subtle colour change might be in order. This would be so easy to spot on someone which is the basic idea of the whole thing. Put me down for two (one spare)! :||:
Um...looks great except the keyboard and basses need flipping?
I thought the suggestion was for enamelled.
I'd also like part of my £5 whatever to subsidise an 'unwaged' arrangement in this. Chris
I thought the suggestion was for enamelled.
Hmmmm "I personally favour leather" :Ph But entirely happy to go with the flow on this. I am however unlikely to wear a cheapo tinplate version. I'm very cool about price, provided a fair portion goes to the person managing it, and any excess to forum funds. I'd also like part of my £5 whatever to subsidise an 'unwaged' arrangement in this. Chris
I think before anyone gets carried away costings should be done and enquiries made....coz take a look at how many members there are, how many are active etc. you may find you'll have to sell quite a few to break even.
Preference - Leather or enamel please
I think before anyone gets carried away costings should be done and enquiries made....coz take a look at how many members there are, how many are active etc. you may find you'll have to sell quite a few to break even.
If someone could get some costings and then build some profit in for the forum and let us know? Then we'll have a better idea what we're talking about. Perhaps this task should be given lock, stock and barrel, to someone? Rather than us all chipping in with our (v.important 2p's). I propose whoever started the thread ;D
BTW I prefer either leather or enamel - with enamel as my fave!
AL
Preference - Leather or enamel please
I may be having a senior moment, but what do you mean by "leather badge"?
(oh, don't say "a badge made of leather"! - I get that bit, I'm just drawing a blank on how it would be used - pinned on? sewn on? etc)
Al - see my reply #71.
Leather pin on badges as provided and worn by numerous british morris dance teams
I've been watching 'The Apprentice' and 'High street dreams' and 'mary queen of shops' and they main problem is always lack of market research and costing. Who says tv doesn't teach you anything? ;)QuoteI think before anyone gets carried away costings should be done and enquiries made....coz take a look at how many members there are, how many are active etc. you may find you'll have to sell quite a few to break even.
Ah...the voice of commonsense (:)
I'm probably going to want a few - if someone could get some costings and then build some profit in for the forum and let us know? Then we'll have a better idea what we're talking about. Perhaps this task should be given lock, stock and barrel, to someone? Rather than us all chipping in with our (v.important 2p's). I propose whoever started the thread ;D
Preference - Leather or enamel please
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4552.0;attach=3604;image)
Um...looks great except the keyboard and basses need flipping?
This lot (http://www.cafepress.co.uk/) will produce customised stuff. Anyone fancy a melodeon.net thong? :o
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4552.0;attach=3604;image)
Um...looks great except the keyboard and basses need flipping?
no they don't!!
I don't know what a leather badge is either.Leather badges are nice. Here's one I have from the Scarborough Fayre Morris festival last year. This one is oval, but they can be circular (or other shapes, I guess)
Never seen badges like that before....quite big aren't they?I don't know what a leather badge is either.Leather badges are nice. Here's one I have from the Scarborough Fayre Morris festival last year. This one is oval, but they can be circular (or other shapes, I guess)
You can also see us wearing them ;)
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows?
Prehaps a melodeon, but with MAD for the bellows?
Would the badge be a DG or BC box? ;)
Graeme
"something completely different" that only those who were a member would recognise.
... the piece of cod that passeth all understanding...
Quote... the piece of cod that passeth all understanding...
beat me too it!
;D
... the piece of cod that passeth all understanding...
beat me too it!
Grin
What do you mean, you fed me the line!
How about a Melnet Merkin (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkin)
except for very close friends.
Imagine the sight of a group of players at a festival in loincloths with MAD emblazoned on them!
Imagine the sight of a group of players at a festival in loincloths with MAD emblazoned on them!Could possibly put a new twist to the phrase 'going commando' ;)
It would seem Al hasn't encountered Whitby's daytrippers from the Ayre valley ;DOh dear, I have indeed read the Miller's tale but had forgotten about it. Thanks for reminding me :|bl :|bl
And that Juker may not have read the Miller's tale ;)
Where's the soap? :|bl
Nobody so far has mentioned the process for the obligatory public removal of regalia (Badge, pin, leather thing, merkin etc) in the event of its wearer bringing melnet into disrepute by crossing those boundaries of decency which are seldom spoken of amongst decent folk, such as playing things with 4 1/2 strings, black and white rectangular keys, hexagonal ends or anything ending with 'lli'.
hexagonal ends
hexagonal ends
You'll be treading on quite a few toes there! Not mine though as my Wheatstone Æola has octagonal ends. :M
... crossing those boundaries of decency which are seldom spoken of amongst decent folk, such as ..... anything ending with 'lli'.And just what, precisely, is wrong with Llanelli?
... crossing those boundaries of decency which are seldom spoken of amongst decent folk, such as ..... anything ending with 'lli'.And just what, precisely, is wrong with Llanelli?
(where I learnt to play the melodeon, I'll have you know....)
how about a pin (maybe a cloisonne?) with one of the emoticons on it?
I think this one: :||:
Excellent idea - but we'd need LDT's ok as I believe she was responsible for the design of our little squeezing buddies?Say 'please' and I might just do you a hi res version big enough to use....and you do know its a one row the little person is playing. hmmmm....what's its name?
:||:
Please :||:Is that a general consensus then I'll get it done some time this week.
;D
Sorry to get back on topic, but how about a pin (maybe a cloisonne?) with one of the emoticons on it?
I think this one: :||:
I had to google it.Sorry to get back on topic, but how about a pin (maybe a cloisonne?) with one of the emoticons on it?
I think this one: :||:
Sorry to be ignorant - wossa cloisonne??
Also, how are you planning on animating said badge?? :-\ :-\ :-\ ;)
Please :||:Is that a general consensus then I'll get it done some time this week.
;D
I know what about 'Mel Net'
Thanks LdT - I'll see if I can get that hi-res into cafepress (or similar), or I'll see what prices for a job lot.
We could also use that for stickers, which were also a popular idea for cases etc.
Cheers
Chris
this is just a rough draftPlease :||:Is that a general consensus then I'll get it done some time this week.
;D
I know what about 'Mel Net'
Thanks LdT - I'll see if I can get that hi-res into cafepress (or similar), or I'll see what prices for a job lot.
We could also use that for stickers, which were also a popular idea for cases etc.
Cheers
Chris
this is just a rough draft
<snip>
In leather - we could do a version on a slightly taller piece - slit top and bottom - thread it on your shoulder strap?
Or even this.... (sorry, LdT)you can always get a marker pen and draw one on the badge/sticker ;)
PS GbH ... naughty boy! Stop fiddling with others' graphics! ;)
PS GbH ... naughty boy! Stop fiddling with others' graphics! ;)
Awwww! But it's fun! For instance, you could have a more representative version, such as this...
<snip>
I keep reading this but I still don't get it! ???Where's the soap? :|bl
that's wot one (1st) sailor said to another (2nd) sailor, who was swabbing the deck.
the 2nd sailor replied, "yes it does, doesn't it!"
I keep reading this but I still don't get it! ???Where's the soap? :|bl
that's wot one (1st) sailor said to another (2nd) sailor, who was swabbing the deck.
the 2nd sailor replied, "yes it does, doesn't it!"
Where's the soap? Yes it does, doesn't it! ??? Are you sure I'm not missing a line somewhere? Either that or I'm a bit thick! :|blI keep reading this but I still don't get it! ???Where's the soap? :|bl
that's wot one (1st) sailor said to another (2nd) sailor, who was swabbing the deck.
the 2nd sailor replied, "yes it does, doesn't it!"
Don't "read" it - "say" it. Forget the apostrophe and the spelling.
In this (clean) version, they're swabbing the deck ... which leads sailor 1 to ask ... "W....... soap?"
Any clearer? >:E
What's the latest on the badge situation? I seem to have lost track of where it's all at ;D
Oh....I was wondering about that comment, but was too polite to point out that it didn't seem to make any sense in the context. Still don't get it really!!Apparently, for 'where's the soap' you should read 'wears the soap' as in it wears the soap out scrubbing the deck :-\ quite where the nuns come into it I have no idea and have decided, in the words of the late, great Tony Hancock, not to pursue that line of enquiry.... :|bl
What's the latest on the badge situation? I seem to have lost track of where it's all at ;D
Sorry to introduce a jarring note, but the static emoticon doesn't convey the image of a melodeon. It's more like a yellow chap reading a crumpled newspaper. It's the movement that makes the emoticon work - it's then recognisable as a squeezebox. For a badge, you'd be better with something more . . . melodeon-like.
There are two melodeon emoticons - one with hair. :||: :|||:gender-specific implications such as we have in the online emoticons.Better eyesight than mine.
I was recently invited to fill in a form with three options - male, female or transgender. ???
Regarding the emoticon as opposed to the straight melodeon image, I rather favour the original concept by Ollie
I had to go back to find what he did, and offer this rather cleaned up version, half an hour's work with the GIMP
(Could be used with or without the melodeon.net lettering at the bottom which I added as an afterthought)
.... MAD does not make sense. ...
I like Anahata's work but would take out the "MAD" and put "MELNET" there. MAD does not make sense. Many but not every member has it.
I like Anahata's work but would take out the "MAD" and put "MELNET" there. MAD does not make sense. Many but not every member has it.
I think we all know what it means even if we don't have it, but....
I'll leave it to someone else to decide, and to decide how we decide...
To be proper they might perhaps indicate that only members likely to actually buy the damn thing should vote? And while "PR" is the Spirit of the Age here in Blighty, the SMF facility allows dynamic vote change in mid election - so there's no risk of Gordon Brown being relected in this ;) OK then - hustings! I'd like to nominate Anyone else off to Anglesey today? :|glug | (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=4552.0;attach=3680;image) |
I suppose the messy business of a plebiscite is inevitableNah! Too messy. I just think our mods should pick a design, make it available and let the plebs do the buying???
Thinking outside the box ........
Anahata's simple design (the MAD one) less the melnet bit at the bottom has everything... its meaning is not obvious to anyone outside melnet ... and may very well prompt an enquiry (waass that then Mate?) at which point the wearer can bore the pants off the enquirer
If that design gets chosen I'll buy one ... and I'm not one of the51;)
Sorry Steve (but photo's for logo's is the bane of my life, can't stand them).Hey - no apologies needed.
Regarding the emoticon as opposed to the straight melodeon image, I rather favour the original concept by Ollie
I had to go back to find what he did, and offer this rather cleaned up version, half an hour's work with the GIMP
(Could be used with or without the melodeon.net lettering at the bottom which I added as an afterthought)
Anahata's simple design (the MAD one) less the melnet bit at the bottom has everything... its meaning is not obvious to anyone outside melnet
...
To be clear, this is really Ollie's design: the MAD, the simple cartoon style, the colours. All I did was make a neater version to replace Ollie's hand-and-mouse-drawn sketch. And turn it the right way round.
Nice one Sarah!thanks
I agree, Clive. It should definitely have www.melodeon.net on it.
I've one comment, and it's just a comment from me as a member of the site, not as a moderator, which is that personally I'd favour a design having the words either melodeon.net or www.melodeon.net visible somewhere on it, especially if there are versions of the design blown up to t-shirt size.
My thinking's simple; I'm just interested in other players who you might meet on your travels that won't necessarily talk to you, notice the design, think what's that, see the website address/name, and think 'didn't know there was such a thing - must look that up when I get home'.
Cheers,
Clive
That would make a splendid header or footer for letterhead or a web site, with the red horizontal line extended across the width of its environment.that's what I thought.
"melodeon.net" and "www.melodeon.net" are both valid Web addresses
www.melodeon.net. 479 IN CNAME melodeon.net."melodeon.net" and "www.melodeon.net" are both valid Web addresses
What that means is that, as with many web sites, www.melodeon.net is defined as an alias for melodeon.net. It's common practice, but not guaranteed for all domains.
I don't have the skills to produce an image so maybe someone could do the necessary from the following words ::)
A circle of leather about 50mm diameter with melodeon.net at the top (following the curvature) and at the bottom The Box Place (following the curvature) and in the centre the mad melodeon but taller with less bellows stretch so that the MAD is a little more high frequency ..think sine waves, think bellows folds...
Anyway ... I think we should at least have a final design agreed by Monday.
Anyway ... I think we should at least have a final design agreed by Monday.
Really? You haven't been here very long have you?
The Box Place is my trading name as used on my website (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/) so would be entirely inappropriate here.
Off to Anglesey soon. I will wear my new 'mockup' badge and report back ...
I'm adapting steve's design....but won't get it done till monday first thing.Thanks, Sarah!
Have to disagree, I have no problem (quite the contrary) with a mention of the box place since its owner is largely responsible for the fact that we can debate this and other matters here!!
Have to disagree, I have no problem (quite the contrary) with a mention of the box place since its owner is largely responsible for the fact that we can debate this and other matters here!!
I think the important thing here is that the owner of The Box Place feels uncomfortable with the idea and we should respect that without question. Theo could plaster the whole forum with adverts for The Box Place but obviously sees his business interests, his playing for dances, and administration of this forum as different compartments in his life.
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?) just how does one put up an image please?
The Box Place is my trading name as used on my website (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/) so would be entirely inappropriate here.
Have to disagree, I have no problem (quite the contrary) with a mention of the box place since its owner is largely responsible for the fact that we can debate this and other matters here!!
respect that without question[/i] as a concept.
Here's a version which LDT and myself have worked on jointly. Thanks Sarah!
The attachment here is low resolution. Hi-res version available.
Yes - I did wonder myself about the capitalisation. I tried it with a lower case 'm' and that looked wrong to me! I was originally going for a touch of class anyway, so 'M' is how it turned out. But it's no big deal. It can easily be changed.
I like it but might I suggest it be melodeon.net rather than Melodeon.net, just looks wrong to me.
Good Lord... is it Monday already :DNope - we're a day early. See, you get good service from us (:)
It's fine as a thumbnail but the white of the melodeon is a bit much full size...Don't forget that no-one knows what 'full size' (i.e. badge size) is going to be yet. I was anticipating nothing larger than about 2 inches across the maximum ellipse diameter, in which case the white would probably not be too much. But I also agree that black on a pale leather background would look quite good. Something like the attachment perhaps? The brown colour would vary according to the type of leather used. Also made the text size slightly larger as per Bill's suggestion.
Maybe it would look good as a black outline on leather?
How soon? ???
Fuse lit, asbestos undies on, tin hat handy, running............
Please, no "MAD". Not the essence of the reason for the pin, which is:
Firstly: Identify fellow melnetters
Secondly: Identify fellow melnetters
If someone asks "what is melnet", well fine. Good. Spread the gospel.
Don't forget that no-one knows what 'full size' (i.e. badge size) is going to be yet. I was anticipating nothing larger than about 2 inches across the maximum ellipse diameter, in which case the white would probably not be too much. But I also agree that black on a pale leather background would look quite good. Something like the attachment perhaps? The brown colour would vary according to the type of leather used. Also made the text size slightly larger as per Bill's suggestion.
It's all just an idea by way of an illustrative example. Any final version would be refined further and have the linework improved, but I'm not prepared to put in a lot more extra work unless we are going to run with this idea.
Fuse lit, asbestos undies on, tin hat handy, running............
Take those asbestos undies off immediately - they're just not safe you know! ;)
Chris
How about making some stickers that we can put on cases, etc?
Could the text be made to match the curve of the inner perimeter?Tried it and rejected it. It doesn't look so good because of the extreme curve of the text. And the way I have it now, the curve of the text complements the shape of the melodeon.
Alternatively, use the elliptical badge shape as before... would that throw up production difficulties?Haven't gone into production or quotes yet, but I envisage it being easier and cheaper to use a circular shape rather than elliptical. Also, a circular shape has more visual impact than an ellipse; plus I prefer it too!
... Also, a circular shape has more visual impact than an ellipse; plus I prefer it too!
Yes, I know. I have one from last year:... Also, a circular shape has more visual impact than an ellipse; plus I prefer it too!
Dunno about that, the Scarborough Morris fest one that I have from '91 looks smart enough ;)
Not wishing to take sides, but xgx is right and Steve is wrong ;DI've been checking out prices and suppliers. I can't find any that do elliptical badges. But circular badges are readily available and relatively cheap. It depends on total numbers ordered but I think that I could offer 45 mm or 55 mm dia. circular badges for about £1.00 each, hopefully including carriage and VAT.
The curvature of the text looks odd against the circular badge, it would look better on an elliptical badge
If you want me to produce the badges, I will, but I haven't got a lot of time to do much more messing about. So make your minds up.
Version 4 or 4.1 ?
With MAD or without ?
Whoops!If you want me to produce the badges, I will, but I haven't got a lot of time to do much more messing about. So make your minds up.
Version 4 or 4.1 ?
With MAD or without ?
Steve, I think you are taking things too fast here. Originally Zubz sad he was willing to arrange the making of badges, so he should at least have some input at this stage, I've also had off-list contact with him and agreed that any design should be referred to myself and Clive before going to production. In my mind we also have at least two runners still in the game. Yours and the red MAD badge or a version of it. There have been posts in favour and against both. Rather than a decision being taken by PM's to you I suggest that we have a time limited poll on the contenders.
Theo
Whoops!
OK - fair enough and apologies to all for rushing things and especially to Zubz! I hadn't taken in his previous offer.
Happy to go with your suggestion of a limited time poll. Will someone set it up?
I've been checking out prices and suppliers. I can't find any that do elliptical badges. But circular badges are readily available and relatively cheap. It depends on total numbers ordered but I think that I could offer 45 mm or 55 mm dia. circular badges for about £1.00 each, hopefully including carriage and VAT.
. . . I suggest that we have a time limited poll on the contenders.Please include a "none of these" category in the poll.
Theo
Please include a "none of these" category in the poll.I don't mind if people don't like my design, but I do wish they would read the chuffing text. I said that the colours can be changed, the one shown was just an illustration.
Steve, sorry, but I don't think that any of your designs based on a picture of a real melodeon are any good. The colours of the latest ones, especially, are more MUD than MAD. A symbolic melodeon, like some of the earlier designs, is the way to go.
What is a leather badge? I've never seen such a thing, or heard of it until mentioned in this thread. Is it something peculiar to Morris? If so, wouldn't that rather limit the market (which from the current poll isn't all that big anyway)?For the second time today, here is a link to a photo of a leather badge which I posted on this thread a few days ago.
I think a poll makes abundant sense...let the majority rule!
Even though I'm very new to mel.net, I'd be quite proud to wear the badge. (:)
[These things change over time ;) As I intimated above - my field test put me off MAD and I share Lester's view (that's 3x now!) that elliptical is better, even if it's eg 50p more expensive. I don't feankly mind whether melodeon.net is above or below - whatever looks better - but I think it should be there.
Here's an elliptical version of Steve's old melodeon. May I offer it as v3 please. As elaborated before - the melnet voting system is even more sophisiticated than the apocryphal Labour Party! Chris
A 12mm badge would be miniscule and almost unreadable from a distance.It doesn't need to be readable, it needs to be recognizable. If you need to read words on it, the design isn't working as a logo.
I'm with Chris with this version, elliptical shaped with the .net underneath
Seems we cannot satisfy the fisherman and butterfly catchers at the same time. Here's the alternative - though I'd emphasise this is just a mockup to express the principle.Yes - I quite like the balance on that one, Chris. In fact it's very close to version 3 here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4552.msg58712.html#msg58712).
Personally I might prefer text underneath too - but with Steve's rather nicer font. Can I get back to launching the hospital audit poster competition now please? :|glug
A 12mm badge would be miniscule and almost unreadable from a distance.It doesn't need to be readable, it needs to be recognizable. If you need to read words on it, the design isn't working as a logo
No good if you want to raise awareness of this website and forum. (Which I rather thought was the point, given the in-depth discussion from quite a few people about which wording we want where on the badge)It doesn't need to be readable, it needs to be recognizable. If you need to read words on it, the design isn't working as a logoI agree Bill. Graphics only. Like free reed.
And those wot lose don't have to wear the thing. :|glug
I'm with you on this one Steve! Wearing a badge such as your design is quite self-explanatory and would encourage people with an interest in music, and specifically the melodeon, to enquire about what is behind such a badge.No good if you want to raise awareness of this website and forum. (Which I rather thought was the point, given the in-depth discussion from quite a few people about which wording we want where on the badge)It doesn't need to be readable, it needs to be recognizable. If you need to read words on it, the design isn't working as a logoI agree Bill. Graphics only. Like free reed.
On the other hand, the "nailing jello to the wall" aspect of the group is certainly entertaining.lol! you just summed it up in a phrase
This thread looks like a United Nations session...
My understanding, my hope, is the melodeon.net is NOT a democracy, and that one of our enlightened leaders will make a decision, call the shot and we can move on.
On the other hand, the "nailing jello to the wall" aspect of the group is certainly entertaining.
Well, I think it comes down to a question of the purpose or purposes of having a badge which is entirely unclear. There are to be two reasons that I can think of:I'll just add a 3rd reason - to give us a sense of group identity which is immediately obvious to others, e.g. at festivals, workshop events, etc. The unspoken, subliminal message would be hopefully be something like 'ah - that person is a melodeon.net member. I've heard of them, they seem to have a good time and get a lot of help from each other'.
1 Recruiting new members
2 Enabling existing members to spot each other in real life.
My feeling is that (1) is less likely to happen through a badge, and much more likely to happen by being seen playing a melodeon and then to get into conversation. And, anyone who has internet access and a melodeon is highly likely to find us through search engines or links from other sites, so I question the value of a badge for that purpose. We have 1144 members and are recruiting 15 to 20 new members per week, so I don't think there is a particular problem of prospective new members being unable to find us.
(2) seems to me to be a much more useful reason for wearing a badge. Many of us become acquainted here online and may well attend festivals and workshops and may not be able to match up online personas with real people with whom we rub shoulders.
So if we can decide on the main reason for having a badge then we are better placed to make a decision on the design. If its to recruit members then clearly the domain name should feature, if its to recognise each other then it only needs to be recognisable to all of us here.
Whatever it ends up as I'll not be wearing it, and did vote against the idea.Funnily enough, I voted against it too!
I voted for the idea and still think it's a good way to bump into fellow forum members. If you spot a melodeon player and wonder if s/he is a forum member there's probably a 99% or greater chance that they aren't, the badge tips you the wink in rather a nice way so you can amble over and say hello, or not as the mood takes you.
If you spot a melodeon player and wonder if s/he is a forum member there's probably a 99% or greater chance that they aren't, the badge tips you the wink in rather a nice way so you can amble over and say hello, or not as the mood takes you.
Any chance of having them in time for Whitby (pretty please with sugar on) ?
the presence of a melodeon on the musician's lap has pretty high predictive value wrt melodeon.net membershipCan't argue with the theory - however was browsing round Hay-on-Wye during the festival and came across a nice gent busking with a Castagnari of some sort. I approached and asked if he was a member of melnet - to which came his response: "God no...they're just a bunch of #@!^%~!" [insert expletive of your own choice] - although I was somewhat taken aback by his opinion of me and my fellow melnetters, we went on to have a good chat anyway. I just didn't mention this place again ;D
Are we to go evermore in fear of our lives through wearing the melnet badge? If so, I would suggest a melnet knuckleduster be made available to members as well. :PhQuotethe presence of a melodeon on the musician's lap has pretty high predictive value wrt melodeon.net membershipCan't argue with the theory - however was browsing round Hay-on-Wye during the festival and came across a nice gent busking with a Castagnari of some sort. I approached and asked if he was a member of melnet - to which came his response: "God no...they're just a bunch of #@!^%~!" [insert expletive of your own choice] - although I was somewhat taken aback by his opinion of me and my fellow melnetters, we went on to have a good chat anyway. I just didn't mention this place again ;D
AL
I approached and asked if he was a member of melnet - to which came his response: "God no...they're just a bunch of #@!^%~!" [insert expletive of your own choice]
in the confession business and fair game even if off duty
Or may have mistaken it for one of the other, less 'refined' fora we have heard of in recent posts about Mustard
Are you sure you said melodeon.net clearly...coz it can sound like another 'forum' if you mumble melnet? ;)I approached and asked if he was a member of melnet - to which came his response: "God no...they're just a bunch of #@!^%~!" [insert expletive of your own choice]
??? Is that a commonly held view?
It seems surprising to me that this might have occurred - but I'm usually the last person to pick up on this sort of thing.
Or may have mistaken it for one of the other, less 'refined' fora we have heard of in recent posts about Mustard etc.
Or may have mistaken it for one of the other, less 'refined' fora we have heard of in recent posts about Mustard etc.
[pedant warning] forums not fora, this is an English language discussion [/pedant warning]
What's the latest on the badge front? Has a design been agreed yet?Not as far as I know. As I recall, Theo's suggestion was to put the various designs to a poll.
What's the latest on the badge front? Has a design been agreed yet?Not as far as I know. As I recall, Theo's suggestion was to put the various designs to a poll.
A monacled man, riding a bycycle, while carrying a melodeon, with a large reptile wrapped about his solar topeed head ??
Thats just the sort of person I generally go to great lengths to avoid upsetting or saying anything controversial to.
Now a cleric - well they are in the confession business and fair game even if off duty - what say Al ?
;D ;D ;D
Richard