Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: boxlad on July 23, 2010, 05:34:59 PM

Title: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: boxlad on July 23, 2010, 05:34:59 PM
Lovely clip of Bobby recorded a few days ago..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xlGdv4hjuM8&feature=sub
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Theo on July 23, 2010, 05:49:22 PM
Nice, is that a C#/D box?
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: boxlad on July 23, 2010, 05:56:49 PM
D/D# I believe but correct me if I'm wrong. Great tone from that box!
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Lars on July 23, 2010, 06:31:35 PM
- and lovely playing! A real sturdy, pushy, bouncy lift to his playing!
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: pgroff on July 24, 2010, 07:57:25 AM
Boxlad,

That's what I needed this week!

PG
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: rees on July 24, 2010, 11:27:19 AM
D/D# confirmed. The man is a legend.
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Old Leaky on July 24, 2010, 05:00:41 PM
D/D# confirmed.

I'm only a slight fan of Bobby (but more of other "half step up" box players like Tony MacMahon and Mairtin O'Connor) and I recently purchased a D/D# Paolo Soprani.

While trying to get to grips with it, playing it "inside out" (as I usuallly play a C#/D), it came to me that, as a description D/D# is inaccurate and it should really be D/Eb. (Unintentionally, I'd originally written "Eb/D" - now corrected!)

D# doesn't/can't exist using the convention for notation & intervals we use in forming diatonic scales. I used up several sheets of paper trying to work it out!
???

Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: LDbosca on July 29, 2010, 11:12:23 AM
D/D# confirmed.

I'm only a slight fan of Bobby (but more of other "half step up" box players like Tony MacMahon and Mairtin O'Connor) and I recently purchased a D/D# Paolo Soprani.

While trying to get to grips with it, playing it "inside out" (as I usuallly play a C#/D), it came to me that, as a description D/D# is inaccurate and it should really be D/Eb. (Unintentionally, I'd originally written "Eb/D" - now corrected!)

D# doesn't/can't exist using the convention for notation & intervals we use in forming diatonic scales. I used up several sheets of paper trying to work it out!
???



I suppose it could exist if you wanted to be very busy with your double sharps. I think that there's a general convention of sticking to using sharps when describing button accordion layouts (although I've just remembered Bb/Eb boxes...), it has the advantage of making it easier to compare duplicate notes between rows etc. I wonder could someone with a bit more experience like Rees or Theo spread any more light on the reasons for it?
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Anahata on July 29, 2010, 11:48:00 AM
D# doesn't/can't exist using the convention for notation & intervals we use in forming diatonic scales. I used up several sheets of paper trying to work it out!

Yes, it is anomalous. D# major as a key would have 9 sharps - i.e. 5 sharps and 2 double sharps.

A box is described as Bb/Eb because those keys would use 2 and three flats respectively, whereas A# and D# would be 8 (6 + 1 double) and 9 (5 + 2 doubles)

Alkan wrote a piano piece which started in C and gradually modulated sharpwise, increasing the numbers of sharps. He didn't see why it should suddenly switch e.g. from C# (7 sharps) to Ab (4 flats) when the relationship between C# and G# was much more obvious, so by the end  it was in B sharp (12 sharps made up of 2 sharps and 5 double sharps, all written as accidentals in front of the notes), but of course actually sounding in C!

But he was mad. (no, not MAD...)
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Andrew Culwell on July 30, 2010, 05:51:01 AM
Heard Martin Quinn just two weeks ago talking about Bobby,  he spoke glowingly of Bobby as a "Boxplayer's boxplayer".
After watching that clip I have to say I wasn't a fan before but I am now!!
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Theo on July 30, 2010, 02:30:47 PM

it came to me that, as a description D/D# is inaccurate and it should really be D/Eb.

I suppose it could exist if you wanted to be very busy with your double sharps. I think that there's a general convention of sticking to using sharps when describing button accordion layouts (although I've just remembered Bb/Eb boxes...), it has the advantage of making it easier to compare duplicate notes between rows etc. I wonder could someone with a bit more experience like Rees or Theo spread any more light on the reasons for it?

Does it really matter?   I don't think so.   Everybody knows what you mean if you describe a box as either D/D# or D/Eb  and anyway the musician may well be playing by ear, or if using notation is probably reading in D and letting the box transpose.

[pedant mode]To be strictly correct we should not write Eflat as Eb but as E♭and even D# is incorrect should be D♯[/pedant mode]
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Anahata on July 30, 2010, 02:53:10 PM
E♭

How did you do that?
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Stiamh on July 30, 2010, 02:59:23 PM
I get a weird optical illusion watching that clip. I see the hanging bag as a window showing blue sky and clouds and I can't shake off the impression that Bobby is sitting in an old troop transport plane with seats along the side of the fuselage. The movement of the camera intensifies the effect. Yes I know - time for a trip to the opticians.

Are we to assume that Bobby has gone over to playing press and draw on 2-row boxes as well as on the melawjin? Nobody will be able to say he's a sorry f----- who can't play at any rate. Thanks for posting Boxlad!
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 30, 2010, 04:53:57 PM
From now on I play an F/A#/D#  ;D But it won't make any difference what I call it 'cos I'll still never have  the smallest fraction of Bobby's ability! Great post - thanks.
AL
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Andrel on July 30, 2010, 05:12:49 PM
How come it's only been viewed 197 times so far ? It's depressing. The topic ABOUT the video has been viewed more often ! ???
Title: Re: The great Bobby Gardiner
Post by: Theo on July 30, 2010, 06:16:31 PM
E♭

How did you do that?


Just insert it from the character palette,  using OS X.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal