Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: JimJ on July 24, 2010, 07:20:27 AM

Title: Club models
Post by: JimJ on July 24, 2010, 07:20:27 AM
Hi all,

Another newbie question. What is the theory behind the club keyboard layouts? I notice that when most people talk about club models on this forum, one of the first thing they usually say is that they have been "declubed" so I get the impression that the system is not too popular currently. But, there must have been a reason for them at one time. Someone must have thought they had merit. So, what are the pros and cons? Thanks ---- JimJ
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 24, 2010, 09:46:26 AM
Jim,
There has been a lot of discussion about the Club system on this forum already. To save going over old ground again, why not use the excellent search facility we have here? For starters just try typing  "club system" (without quotes) into the search box on the upper left section of the page, and click on the search button. That should come up with plenty to keep you busy for a while.  
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: ganderbox on July 24, 2010, 09:52:52 AM
Here's one I wrote while Steve was posting.....

Club models are basically 2.5 row instruments (commonly tuned to C/F), with a helper row on the inside consisting of accidentals and also some notes in opposite directions. Whereas modern 2.5 rows have 12 or more basses, clubs only have 8.

The main difference is the "gleichton". On a normal D/G, the 3rd button in the scale of G on the inside row is tuned to D on the push and E on the pull. On a club, (if it happens to be tuned to D/G of course) it plays D in both directions, and for the E you need to either cross to the outside row and play it on the pull, or use the one on the helper row on the push.  
This layout is really useful for playing smoothly across the rows, and for right hand chords. If you have learnt to play on a normal box, however, it's quite tricky to relearn, especially for English players for whom this part of the keyboard is the most familiar.
The other difference is on the bass end. The C bass, instead of playing C in both directions, plays C on the pull and F on the push, which is actually quite handy because in practice most people don't use the C on the push very often, and the F is a useful extra bass to have.

When a box is declubbed, the gleichton is retuned to play D/E instead of D/D, and the bass tuned to C/C (although some people like to keep F/C).

Clubs certainly do have merit, and if you look at some of the other threads on this forum you'll see that quite a few people are interested in them, and many of us MAD sufferers have added an undeclubbed club to our collection.  It's actually quite a clever layout, and the helper row is more of an integral part of the whole system than on a modern 2.5 row. In other words, you can play a 2.5 row on 2 rows and ignore the helper row, but you can't do that on a club.  

There are some club layouts in the information section of this forum, and lots of discussion in other threads.
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Theo on July 24, 2010, 09:58:10 AM
A lot of information on Jacques Delaguerre's website (http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/index.html)
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 24, 2010, 12:24:17 PM
Here's one I wrote while Steve was posting.....
Pauline, that's a really good summary. Thanks!
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: JimJ on July 24, 2010, 10:16:11 PM
Yes, thanks for the input all -- not sure why I didn't think of using the search, I have used it often for other questions I have had. -- thanks again -- JimJ
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: TomB-R on July 24, 2010, 10:39:08 PM
......many of us MAD sufferers have added an undeclubbed club to our collection......

LIke it!  Is that a bit like unhalfbricking only different?

(Or is it something to do with a very private and confidential organisation for members only!)
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: rees on July 24, 2010, 11:59:51 PM
Is it anything to do with pants? I want to be in the Undie Club.
Actually, I think there was a Working Mens Club in Undy, near Newport, South Wales.
Repeat to fade, Newport, Newport, Newport.

Sorry, massive thread drift. :|bl
Back on track.

I have seen the Club system several times being played by an expert.
The extra harmonies available due to the gleichton plus the half-row, set it apart from other melodeons.
I'd like to hear it accompanied by a Jeffries Duet concertina. I think they would harmonise nicely.
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: forrest on July 25, 2010, 01:14:36 AM

   I still own an un-declubbed club myself, an old Erika, and have decided at last to (dare I say it) remove it's club-ness. I am only waiting to find a good source of mylar valves with which to refurbish it so I can begin retuning. I have not, as yet, decided how to tune the four helpers.
   I Intend to try out some of Pauline's reccomendations as posted  here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3851.msg47858.html#msg47858). I am afraid that the club system did not mesh well with my rather simplistic brain function. I must admit that I have not heard anything played upon a club system box that would compel me to learn it. Of course,I live in a region that is devoid of any other  melodeon players. If I were to meet and talk with an accomplished Club player, I could be convinced otherwise, but life is passing by, and I feel like I have a toe-hold on the standard tuning system. I do admire the clubs for their build quality and potential sound. Please refer all other inquiries on un-declubbed clubs to the Department of Redundancy Department. (:)
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Ollie on August 08, 2010, 07:06:05 PM
I bought a Bb/Eb Erika from Pete Grassby at Sidmouth (as a part ex with my Liliput) and it is still in Club tuning. I'm finding the gleichton progressively more useful but have yet to find a decent use of the Db bass and chord. Seriously considering getting the left hand de-clubbed and leaving the right hand how it is, for the moment.
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 08, 2010, 07:28:47 PM
Quote
Seriously considering getting the left hand de-clubbed and leaving the right hand how it is, for the moment.
Sort of half-clubbed then?
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Ollie on August 08, 2010, 07:36:54 PM
Quote
Seriously considering getting the left hand de-clubbed and leaving the right hand how it is, for the moment.
Sort of half-clubbed then?

Yeah. I used to have a C/F Club that was declubbed on the right but not the left hand side.
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Kautilya on August 08, 2010, 08:18:02 PM
Quote
Seriously considering getting the left hand de-clubbed and leaving the right hand how it is, for the moment.
Sort of half-clubbed then?

Yeah. I used to have a C/F Club that was declubbed on the right but not the left hand side.

more grist for the club mill here?
http://www.volksmusikschule.at/engspieltechnik.htm#scale
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: OwenG on August 09, 2010, 10:14:36 AM
I bought a Bb/Eb Erika from Pete Grassby at Sidmouth (as a part ex with my Liliput)

Blimey - the Liliput didn't last long. Hope you turned a profit  ;)

I'm finding the gleichton progressively more useful but have yet to find a decent use of the Db bass and chord.

Try combining the Db Chord with the Bb bass for some Bb minor action  8)
Title: Re: Club models
Post by: Ollie on August 09, 2010, 04:15:02 PM
I bought a Bb/Eb Erika from Pete Grassby at Sidmouth (as a part ex with my Liliput)

Blimey - the Liliput didn't last long. Hope you turned a profit  ;)


I did like the Liliput, but I liked this Bb/Eb even more. In fact, if I hadn't bought the Liliput, there would've been no way I could've got the Erika.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal