Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on July 27, 2010, 03:04:58 PM
-
Hi All,
first post, hope I've got it right!
As you can tell from my name, I'm from another persuasion, but have always been interested in melodeons. Recently my teenage daughter went to an instructional and got on really well. We've borrowed a friend's box, but I have a feeling we'd probably like to share one between us to call our own, though let her be the main user. It would eventually be used for morris and sessions, and good 'ol English rumpy pumpy stuff.
Neither of us are big people, and Hohner sizes are ok, but feel big. We're learning on a cheaper hohner lookalike, great to learn on and building up those muscles!
I've also always fancied a Lilly cos they look nice in wood, I've also been aware that Dino Baffetti's are similarly small, anything else to keep an eye out for?
Any thoughts on Lilly's v's Black pearls?
any ideas and thoughts much appreciated!
cheers
Thruppeny bit
-
Well I don't know about cheap...small-wise though (me being in the 'petite' 5ft bracket) I love my castagnari tommy. Fits my hands perfectly and doesn't have the 'concertina' sound of the lilly. ;)
btw. what's a front row prop?
-
I would certainly agree about the Tommy for size, and usual excellent Castagnari quality. But even smaller is my current favourite melodeon, the Hohner Liliput, with that lovely Hohner sound which has more depth (and a touch of reverb) and which I prefer to the more clinically clean (?) sound of the Castagnaris. Although the Liliputs were made in the mid-1930s, it is possible to get restored instruments which have been converted to D/G (and for a lot less than a second hand Tommy).
Lots of info on Liliputs (and the even smaller Preciosa) on melnet - just type "Liliput" in the Search box.
-
I'd also go for the Tommy, as although I'm reasonably tall, I stand up to play for Morris and ceilidhs, and also tend to leap about in an embarrassing "dad-dancing" kind of way, so I prefer something smaller and lighter. Also, as a previous reply has said, I think they're really good quality instruments.
I've had a Hohner Liliput too, and they're also nice and light to play. The drawback though for you may be that as they're older instruments they aren't so easy to come by, and unless they've already been through the hands of someone who knows what they're doing, you will probably need to have it re-tuned. This isn't difficult to have done, but the costs and the waiting time would be something you have to take into account. Your best bet would be to try some-if you can, to go to a couple of the bigger folk festivals where there will be several stands where you can get your hands on some for comparison....
Hope this helps,
Guy
-
ladydetemps :
A front row prop is one of the 'gurt big' blokes that can walk through walls unaided.....
unlike me ::)
Ahh... yes i remember seeing tommy's, I reember the inlays - nice bit of woodwork there too....shame about the price :o
I suppose being from concertina-land, the Lilly sounds good to me and not too harsh.
Not sure about the older Hohners, perhaps I've never seen one so will keep an eye out.
I suppose being of an age when seemingly *everything* was a Pokerwork, which always looked like it was somewhat hastily thrown together, it's nice to see craftsmen producing stuff out of wood, looking like it was carefully put together with love.
Realistically I think a Tommy's a bit too much, hence my original focus on Black pearls and Lilly's as possibly top of my list, hence me mentioning them.
TB
-
You could always try a one row..they are pretty light. ;)
-
Yep, true, but my daughter's started on a G/D, and I've friends that can help on a D/G so I think it'd be good to stick on that.
We're not complete hobbits, so in reality anything pokerwork size is manageable, and something a touch smaller would be even better.
Maybe my general love of wood etc. is drawing me that way?
-
(...)
As you can tell from my name, I'm from another persuasion...
I'm guessing you're not familiar with Cockney rhyming slang... :-X :|bl
pokerworks and Ericas might 'feel' a little large but it's all relative. Having played my (Walnut! bootiful wood) Serenellini B/C (3stops on the treble + 2 on the bass) my Erica felt quite light by comparison.
Guess which one I use for Morris stuff.... the other (a product of M A D ) is for me ... played indoors mostly
-
Hohner Morgane or Galaad, get it retuned a little dry, get a treble keyboard fix, nice instrument, classic look, nice sound, maybe 100 pounds more than stock price.
-
Hohner Morgane or Galaad, get it retuned a little dry, get a treble keyboard fix, nice instrument, classic look, nice sound, maybe 100 pounds more than stock price.
Aren't these both heavier than a pokerwork though???
-
xgx: ahhh....!
no sorry, other end of the country.
Hmm never occurred to me...... that's got me worried. :-[
-
Well, I have several small boxes because I'm short and not very good at lifting things.
The Liliput has the best combination of size, price and flexibility; I can play all sorts of things on mine and it's the box I reach for if I'm playing something weird.
For solid D/G tunes my Dino Baffetti Binci is small and punchy and bouncy. The Oakwood even more so! But I don't yet have it insured so I tend not to take it out of the house. And both of those are much more spendy than a Morgane or one of the regular Dinos without go-faster stripes.
I've never seen a Sandpiper in the flesh but I bet that's a small box -- can someone confirm?
-
yep, saw one at Chippenham this year, from memory it's half way between a Lilly and Pokerwork in size.....
I think.... ish!
-
Listen to some of Anahata's YouTubes and fall in love with the Oakwood/Music Room Dino/binci. Sell your car.
-
Listen to some of Anahata's YouTubes and fall in love with the Oakwood/Music Room Dino/binci. Sell your car.
Thought Anahata played an actual Oakwood rather than the Binci? I love my Binci (and its 2 LH stops which my Oakwood doesn't have) but the Oakwood's treble is heart-stoppingly brilliant, and of course is very very hard-to-get-hold of. Though my Oakwood cost me less than the current new price of the Binci, and my Binci cost *so much less* than the current new price of the Binci that I give thanks to the currency gods every day.
On the bright side, running costs are much lower than a car.
-
good 'ol English rumpy pumpy stuff.
...erm, not even I can think of a practical way to incorporate a melodeon into that... :o
I'm not a fan of single reed boxes but if I had to get one I'd buy a Loffet Touptit rather than a Lilly.
How much were you looking to spend?, a Tommy would probably fit the bill for you if you can afford it and you'll appreciate having the 3rd voice more and more as you progress.
The Baffetti Binci is an amazing box and if you're able to try one I'll bet you anything that you'll start thinking of ways to afford one. There's a 3 voice version under development that'll probably make a lot of potential Tommy buyers think twice once it hits the shelves, especially if they can get a left hand stop in there, so far there's only been one in G/C with no bass stop but it's superb.
That is an original Oakwood that Anahata's playing in his Youtube videos but he now has the 3 voice Baffetti Binci that he bought from me....any chance of a video of that one in action, Anahata?. ;D
-
The 'Excelsior Mini' that I've seen for sale Hobgoblin would seem to be another option.
-
Dino Bafetti Black pearl 11 or 111 perfect for your needs , the playability and sound out weigh the wood finish, they are great little boxes.
-
Thought Anahata played an actual Oakwood rather than the Binci?
Correct!
I did recently acquire a G/C Baffetti Binci, but my old-style real Oakwood is the one on those U-tube videos.
I've also tried playing a D/G Baffetti/Oakwood Binci and it's the nearest thing in speed, feel and sound to my Oakwood.
-
Well, plenty of things coming out of the woodwork, I'm looking them up on sites as we go along.
A friend has previously extolled the virtue of Oakwoods/ Dino's but I think i need my car to earn some pay!
....and I can't go 18miles to work on a melodeon....
Maybe a pointer for the future if I get that good.
Huw - how would you compare a black pearl to a lilly?, pro's con's etc ( finish aside )
right...off to look up Excelsiors!
TB
-
Well, plenty of things coming out of the woodwork, I'm looking them up on sites as we go along.
A friend has previously extolled the virtue of Oakwoods/ Dino's but I think i need my car to earn some pay!
....and I can't go 18miles to work on a melodeon....
Maybe a pointer for the future if I get that good.
Huw - how would you compare a black pearl to a lilly?, pro's con's etc ( finish aside )
right...off to look up Excelsiors!
TB
I've played a Dino Baffettti Black Pearl II for about 15 years (oh 'eck :-\ ) and I've never regretted buying it. It's a light, tough little box, great action, good reeds, punchy sound etc. etc.
One thing to be aware of is that it has 19 buttons, rather than the 21 of the Lilly. This means that it has one fewer button on each row at the high end, though I've rarely missed them. With 19 buttons, I find the Baffetti playable, but the Lilly with 21 over basically the same span is too cramped for me.
The best advice I can thi8nk of right now is, if you can keep borrowing it, keep learning on the Hohner for a while. They're fine boxes and as you play more you'll magically find it easier to handle. Familiarity (and hopefully a more relaxed style) and strengthening of certain muscles and all that.
Looking at other boxes is fun, take the opportunity to try different models and play tunes that you've learnt on them. Picking up a box and playing on it can often be a love-hate thing, and everybody seems to have their own preferences, some of them explicable, but others not.
EDIT: /s/less/fewer/
-
You could always try a one row..they are pretty light. ;)
Sometimes lighter, but sometimes not. My Zero Sette one row is bigger and heavier than my Baffetti.
It also has 4 reeds playing on each note, and the low stop features some BIG reeds.
-
I have a Lilly which I bought to replace a borrowed Hohner Erica. I play left-handed, so I wanted something with a readily-accessible air button.
I tried the Lilly against the Excelsior and it was only the better deal I could get on the Castagnari which swung it. I've since played a single-voice Saltarelle which has a lovely tone and would certainly have bought that if I could have.
Since getting the Lilly, I've tried both a Tommy (similar size, three voices) and a Benny (same but three-row) and while both are lovely boxes and very compact, they do weigh a fair bit more.
I've also played a Dino Black Pearl two-voice which doesn' feel heavy at all; the tone is a bit more harmonica-like somehow than the Castagnaris and while it would be a perfect morris box, I'm not sure it would suit everything I play. :M
I'm hoping to get a chance to try one of these Oakwood Dinos some time, they sound wonderful! :||:
-
Huw Lester - how would you compare a black pearl to a lilly?, pro's con's etc ( finish aside )
For proper English rumpy pumpy IMO you need two reeds so the Black Pearl wins hands down, but for build quality etc the Lilly wins. But if you look at the number of morris musicians, either solo or leading a band, they will almost entirely be playing two voice/reed boxes.
My 2d worth which leaves 1d change from a Thrupenny Bit ;D
ps the correct spelling of thrupenny bit has only one "e", I now I'm a pedantic old git but Her Majesty needs someone to look after her language
-
(quick off the subject drift)
Does "rumpy pumpy" not refer to the, ahem, sex act?
This is not in my Schur's, which says rumpy=manx cat. I had always thought rumpy pumpy was not for polite company.
(back to subject)
On the original request, what would be the perfect instrument for the gentlement, regardless of cost, the Dino/Binci?
-
I play a Black Pearl regularly in a ceilidh band ,light enough to play all night, great fast action and a sound that really cuts through.
I also play in an American Old Tymey trio which quite often we play acoustically, the Dino is really controlable to balance with fiddle guitar and vocals not always possible with many boxes, all in all a very versatile box. Build quality I find very good but not as good as a Castagnari.
The Lilly its a Castagnari build quality tops. But in my opinion the sound of these boxes is too limiting for many situations, could this be why there seem to be so many for sale second hand and often go unsold on eBay ?
These are only my opinions and I'm sure many will disagree, but you pays your money and makes your choice.
Good luck Huw.
-
rumpty tumpty.
:||:
-
The Lilly its a Castagnari build quality tops. But in my opinion the sound of these boxes is too limiting for many situations, could this be why there seem to be so many for sale second hand and often go unsold on eBay ?
I believe that it is because they are "second boxes" for many -- often in keys that are repeats of a player's other boxes. I also think that they are good boxes for learning because they force the player to be very precise.
-
rumpty tumpty.
:||:
My spelling mistake. Rumpty Tumpty not in Schurr's either. Is is an onomatopaeia?
Please disregard the drifting post.
-
I'd go for a BP II but I'm biased because I play one (:)
In all seriousness when I bought mine I could have bought an Oakwood or a Casta. What swayed it for me was the basses. I love the big bass sound and punch of the BP, to me, and for what I wanted to play, the others sound a bit thin.
Steve
-
I'd go for a BP II but I'm biased because I play one (:)
In all seriousness when I bought mine I could have bought an Oakwood or a Casta. What swayed it for me was the basses. I love the big bass sound and punch of the BP, to me, and for what I wanted to play, the others sound a bit thin.
Steve
Oh, yeah ... I forgot about that. That was one of the things that I didn't like about the BP II, so I fixed it.
-
If lightness is important then stick to two voice boxes such as:
Hohner pokerwork or Erica
Dino Bafetti Black Pearl II
Saltarelle Bouebe
Castagnari Studio
B Loffet 2 voice
to get Significantly lighter you would need to re-consider a single voice box
-
Right.
Let's get this straight. I have to translate from native devonian into foreign 'English' stuff.
Therefore I admit to putting the odd extra 'e' in some places. Just think of it as a bonus!!!!
As to rumpy pumpy.....I know what I mean :|bl
Ahem..... Right. I've now got things slightly sorted, and now understand that a BP is 2 voiced and a lilly single... so that makes sense.
P'raps I need to look around a bit more, keep an eye on the Classifieds here, and I'll be at Sidmouth next week, day tripping cos it's close to me, so will take a look around the stalls. I expect Hobgoblin and music Room to be there, amongst others.
I'm also involved in :M so have a lot of friends around, and also will meet others from all over at sidders, so now armed with the informaton in this thread, I can start to keep an ear to the ground if there's a box for sale, and have some idea of what's what.
Thanks for all this.... and any more info kindly recieved!
cheers
TB
-
ps.... thank you Mr. Wigglesworth,
speeling now corrected into this foreign stuff ;)
( yawn)
night all,
TB
-
That is an original Oakwood that Anahata's playing in his Youtube videos but he now has the 3 voice Baffetti Binci that he bought from me....any chance of a video of that one in action, Anahata?. ;D
Only just spotted your post there - I'm still recovering from a weekend of invasion by the French that included having Jean Blanchard as a house guest for 4 days. It was only gradually as the weekend progressed we realised how famous he is. Anyway the G/C box has had a good workout playing along with Jean's G pipes and he's just emailed me the dots for a gorgeous Waltz "Crue D'Amour" by Philippe Prieur which he played last night.
So yes, that may be just the tune for the job, if I can get time before shooting off to Sidmouth...
-
Ahem..... Right. I've now got things slightly sorted, and now understand that a BP is 2 voiced and a lilly single... so that makes sense.
P'raps I need to look around a bit more, keep an eye on the Classifieds here, and I'll be at Sidmouth next week, day tripping cos it's close to me, so will take a look around the stalls. I expect Hobgoblin and music Room to be there, amongst others.
Sidmouth! Well that should be perfect; go round and play all the small boxes on all the stalls. You'll soon work out what you like. And then you can either buy, or given that you have a box to play in the meantime, wait for your favourite to come up second-hand. Just one thing to remember is that all the two-reed boxes can be tuned dry or wet as you like -- and that's a big part of the sound.
Someone mentioned 19 vs 21 button trebles. I don't miss the top two buttons; they're too high for normal use and I like the lighter box. But some people do.
-
Yes after sleeping on it, going round the stalls at Sidders seems favourite.
As mentioned, I've got something to tide me over, so rather than do something rash, it might be a case of hanging on to the pennies for that box that feels right.
On another note:
Oakwood/ Dino's seem to have an amazing reputation on here.
How does the young upstarts Sandpipers fare on here?
....it seems to be from the same stable..
TB
-
[the dots for a gorgeous Waltz "Crue D'Amour" by Philippe Prieur which he played last night.
any chance of sharing the gorgeous waltz with us?
-
rumpty tumpty.
:||:
To the tune of Rufty Tufty ?? ;D ;D
-
How does the young upstarts Sandpipers fare on here?
....it seems to be from the same stable..
TB
I can't claim to be a young upstart, but in my opinion Sandpiper's are nice boxes. In terms of size they are about the same size as a Pokerwork but are certainly a bit heavier. I had the pleasure of hearing young Ollie of this parish playing mine last week and from the other side it certainly sounds good. If I remember correctly, Ollie compared it to a Bouebe.
Mine is provisionally sold . . .
-
On another note:
Oakwood/ Dino's seem to have an amazing reputation on here.
How does the young upstarts Sandpipers fare on here?
....it seems to be from the same stable..
TB
OK. They're two different attempts by the Music Room and Martyn Banks to solve the same problem. Now-unobtainable Oakwood boxes were essentially handmade to order, and Oakwood concluded that the amount of work was too great for the profit involved. But people thought them particularly nice for rumpty-tumpty (or even rumpy-pumpy*) English music. So. The Dino box is a stock box that then has massive Oakwood-y modifications; they have high-quality reeds, a new grille, and are each hand-fettled. The much cheaper Sandpiper is an Oakwood-designed box that is constructed in China to save money -- and again has a 'handmade'-type reed option, but no hand-finishing.
Obviously a £769 box is not going to be as nice as a £1900 box. But I have heard only good things about the Sandpiper as a starter/improvers instrument.
*the festivale at the Trowbridge Village Pump Festival this weekend was called Rumpy Pumpy, which led to lots of innocent amusement of the 'ooh, I fancy a bit of rumpy-pumpy' and 'gosh, I've overdone it a bit on the rumpy-pumpy front' type.
-
any chance of sharing the gorgeous waltz with us?
Working on it now...
-
any chance of sharing the gorgeous waltz with us?
Working on it now...
Here you go: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4607.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4607.0.html)
(Crue D'amour on the new G/C Baffetti Binci)
-
Right.
Let's get this straight. I have to translate from native devonian into foreign 'English' stuff.
Therefore I admit to putting the odd extra 'e' in some places. Just think of it as a bonus!!!!
As to rumpy pumpy.....I know what I mean :|bl
Ahem..... Right. I've now got things slightly sorted, and now understand that a BP is 2 voiced and a lilly single... so that makes sense.
P'raps I need to look around a bit more, keep an eye on the Classifieds here, and I'll be at Sidmouth next week, day tripping cos it's close to me, so will take a look around the stalls. I expect Hobgoblin and music Room to be there, amongst others.
I'm also involved in :M so have a lot of friends around, and also will meet others from all over at sidders, so now armed with the informaton in this thread, I can start to keep an ear to the ground if there's a box for sale, and have some idea of what's what.
Thanks for all this.... and any more info kindly recieved!
cheers
TB
I'll be at Sidmouth with both an Oakwood and a Preciosa, if you run into me you're welcome to have a go on whichever one I've got with me at the time -- and one of Smiffs other musicians has got an "Oakwood" Binci, but I don't know if he'll have it with him when we're dancing out.
Ian
-
Here you go: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4607.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4607.0.html)
(Crue D'amour on the new G/C Baffetti Binci)
Thank you, any chance of the dots or an abc?
Steve
-
Clicked on the linky - nice waltz!
Ian - thanks for the kind offer. Yes you will bump into me but you might not realise it yet!!!
( har har....that'll get you thinking! )
I have to be careful though, I've not yet 'come out' as a melodeon beginner.
My name's more my normal box!
cheers
TB
-
Thank you, any chance of the dots or an abc?
On The Other Thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4607.0.html) in "Tunes" section
-
[the dots for a gorgeous Waltz "Crue D'Amour" by Philippe Prieur which he played last night.
any chance of sharing the gorgeous waltz with us?
Yes please ..
On the original topic, how about a restored and converted Preciosa?
-
Well, just re-read al lthe thread and it has helped enormously, thanks to all.
I've compiled a list of boxes to look at and twiddle with so long as no one's looking!
Just chatting to my daughter in the car, and she just said " Dad, I really don't like those really small ones...."
by which I think she means Lilly's, so maybe someting a touch larger is more realistic and also allowing a greater slecetion and opportunity to pick something up.
cheers
TB
-
Well, plenty of things coming out of the woodwork, I'm looking them up on sites as we go along.
A friend has previously extolled the virtue of Oakwoods/ Dino's but I think i need my car to earn some pay!
....and I can't go 18miles to work on a melodeon....
Maybe a pointer for the future if I get that good.
Huw - how would you compare a black pearl to a lilly?, pro's con's etc ( finish aside )
right...off to look up Excelsiors!...
Unfortunately, you probably do need to keep the car.
However should you win the lottery, you might consider an Yvus MaxiMini http://yvusaccordeons.free.fr/anglais/models-yvus-accordions.html#maximini (http://yvusaccordeons.free.fr/anglais/models-yvus-accordions.html#maximini). Available in any tuning you choose. Perhaps the cutest, most desirable small melodeon available new. There is a waiting list though.
-
Flanna:
They look beautiful. That is a work of beauty, if they sound as good as they look..... !
best not ask about prices!
TB
-
Flanna:
They look beautiful. That is a work of beauty, if they sound as good as they look..... !
best not ask about prices!
TB
Not sure, but I think they cost €1650. How much do you want for your car? >:E
The great thing is that they have a 4 key extra 1/2 row, just like a Lilliput.
-
Flana: Errmmmm that seems pretty good, unless my conversion's off ( but have just got back from a blowy beach!)
May be one day....!
TB
-
You could try one of these, I can play it in D and G ::)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2XfXA1bzM8 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2XfXA1bzM8)
-
TB - If you fancy a Lilly, I've sent you a PM
-
Thanks Steve,
Have read and digested - Will see what pans out, but message noted.
have a good holiday!
TB
-
Update:
Just to follow up on advice recieved, I had a good old dig around today at the Sidmouth festival, looking at Hobgoblin, Music Room and others.
The light has dawned!
I picked up a Lilly, it felt quite good, but my daughter ( who will be joint owner) thinks they're too small!!!
So.... I tried a Hohner Megane, it felt a stretch on the bass side.
Sandpipers felt unsresponsive, sort of mushy!
The Black Pearl felt ok but a touch unresponsive, it was obviously new and stiff.
Then we discovered the Tommy. It just felt soooo good to both of us, really nice - except the price!!!!
A second hand one there was even better ( the older ones had better reeds they said?)
I was offered a Saltarelle Swift, but again, it felt so wrong in the hand I'm not sure i even played many notes. It simply didn't feel right.
They had a second hand red Black Pearl, and that was fine too, obviously played in and responsive.
We both came away waxing lyrical about a Tommy, with a BP coming in second place.
Do you see many Tommy's second hand?
Any guesses at a 'ball park' figure for one? ( just to compare with the one seen )
Anyway, thanks to you and the forum, i now realise how different they can be.....and why do I always go for the expensive ones?
I have a horrible feeling we might go back armed with a card.......
cheers
TB
-
I have been watching second hand Tommy activity over the past year and have seen/heard of 5 or 6 being sold with prices ranging from £1200 to around £2000.
There does not seem to have been one on eBay for the past couple of months.
They are wonderful, compact melodeons, brilliant action/response.
-
Thanks Sandy,
funnily enough, one went for auction on ebay yesterday!
....but knowing my luck, I'd better leave it there. If we're talking this amount of money, I'd like some comeback.
cheers
TB
-
...and I've also learnt from trying different ones:
It's not the absolute size of the thing that makes it feel right for me, it's the ability to easily get to the bass buttons that i was finding hard on my borrowed cheapy box. I now realise it's my very small hands - *that* was my problem!
cheers
TB
-
Then we discovered the Tommy. It just felt soooo good to both of us, really nice - except the price!!!!
...
We both came away waxing lyrical about a Tommy, with a BP coming in second place.
Do you see many Tommy's second hand?
Any guesses at a 'ball park' figure for one? ( just to compare with the one seen )
Anyway, thanks to you and the forum, i now realise how different they can be.....and why do I always go for the expensive ones?
I have a horrible feeling we might go back armed with a card.......
cheers
TB
Tommys are superb compact instruments, with very few detractors (there's always someone who will complain about them, but they are few and far between). Review from the early days of this forum here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,93.msg410.html#msg410
-
Thanks Steve..... good stuff!
TB
-
with very few detractors
I prefer the sound quality you get from a box with a larger casing, so if I was looking for a 2 row 3 voice Castagnari my choice would be a Hascy. Small format boxes like the Tommy just don't excite my ears, especially the bass end which can sound a bit thin. Some of the early Tommys had a reduced number of bass and chord reeds, though I think newer ones have a more 'normal' bass end reed setup.
-
Tommy enthusiast though I am, I have to agree with Theo about the sound of the Tommy - the two MM reeds do sound a bit thin and even getting my dry-tuned Tommy tuned to +5 cents has not improved the thin-ness that much. However, when you include the L reed it is just incredible that you can get such a rich sound from so small a box.
The bass reeds are also thin on mine because there are no thirds, but I have actually got used to that and it allows some nice combinations of buttons to get different chords.
-
It just goes to show what a personal choice this is - its the sound of the Tommy with the L reed in play that I like the least, I find it a very wooly undefined sort of sound, but then I'm a confirmed two voice player.
-
Well I tuned my Tommy out to a Hohner-like tremolo (20 cent offset at A above muddle C) and I reckon the right-hand end now sounds wonderful. ;D
Next job, when I get around to it, (and bearing in mind that I've owned it for over 10 years; can't rush these things), is to take the G bass notes (and probably the A and B too) down an octave. I did this to my (now sold) Benny and it gave a much more meaty bass. (Apologies to any vegetarians reading!)
There will no doubt be some who wonder at the wisdom of giving my Tommy some Hohner-like traits. Well frankly, I have never played any Hohner with an action and reed response as quick as the Tommy, nor any other 3 reed box that is so light in weight.
As a Hohner fan of longstanding, if only....
No, it will never happen. Sob. :(
The Tommy will, I'm sure, remain my favoured front line melodeon.
Go for it, 3d. 8)
-
.... I did this to my (now sold) Benny and it gave a much more meaty bass. (Apologies to any vegetarians reading!)...
Perhaps that should be more "morrowy" or more "pumpkiny" :P
-
Theo/Sandy:
Thanks for the comments about bass ends, will listen and enquire before eventually deciding.
I think the fact that I had to litterally prise it out my daughters' hand might be a deciding point!
( ...... only cos I wanted another go!!! )
I think this might have said it all.
cheers
TB
-
Well I tuned my Tommy out to a Hohner-like tremolo (20 cent offset at A above muddle C) and I reckon the right-hand end now sounds wonderful. ;D
Next job, when I get around to it, (and bearing in mind that I've owned it for over 10 years; can't rush these things), is to take the G bass notes (and probably the A and B too) down an octave. I did this to my (now sold) Benny and it gave a much more meaty bass. (Apologies to any vegetarians reading!)
Malcolm,
Now you've got me thinking! 20 cents offset sounds like an awful lot; I was thinking about 10. Any chance of a sound sample of your Tommy?
Also, how did you manage to squeeze the bigger bass reed into your Benny (which I assume will be the same in the Tommy), and if you could do it, I wonder why Castagnari did not in the first place?
And do you mind if I ask what made you settle for the Tommy as opposed to the Benny which is a similar size but has the extra versatility of the 3-row?
-
Malcolm,
Now you've got me thinking! 20 cents offset sounds like an awful lot; I was thinking about 10. Any chance of a sound sample of your Tommy?
Also, how did you manage to squeeze the bigger bass reed into your Benny (which I assume will be the same in the Tommy), and if you could do it, I wonder why Castagnari did not in the first place?
And do you mind if I ask what made you settle for the Tommy as opposed to the Benny which is a similar size but has the extra versatility of the 3-row?
Sandy, not real sure where to post a sound clip; sorry, but will look into it ....
20 cents is a lot, but not awful imo :P :o ;D
The bass and baritone reeds of the Tommy and Benny are an octave higher than those on the Hohner Erica and pokerwork models.To lower the pitch of bass reeds, you don't necessarily need longer reeds, but to increase the mass at the tip.
Neither the D or the G in my Tommy (or my ex-Benny) is weighted, so I weight the D down to a lower G and the G down to D and reverse the plates. So each reed is dropped by a few tones rather than by a whole octave. Similarly with the D/A and B/E reeds. That then puts them in the same octave as used by Hohner on their Erica and pokerwork models. The hard part is then adjusting the height of the reed to allow the optimum response speed; too low and the reed will jam; too high and the reed won't start.
I have found that soldering a piece of brass to the reed tip gives a cleaner sound than using just lead solder on its own; not sure why.
Why Castagnari doesn't use reeds that go below C I don't know. Maybe some one should ask them.... Some makers (and repairers) are not keen on weighted reeds, and with the limited space in the Tommy body, that's the only way to go lower. True, the response time might be a tad slower, but with a bit of care in setting the reed height, that can be neglegible.
Why I prefer the Tommy rather than the Benny? Well, I'm more of a 2 row player than a 3 row player; too many opportunities when cross rowing over 3 rows to get lost :'(
Also I like the low octave reed set on the D/G to give some strength to the melody, especially in the top octave of G. Not so necessary on lower pitched boxes imho.
-
Update:
Thanks for all advice.
Now owner of a nice Tommy. My very good friend has checked it out and declaired it a nice box and very responsive.
Has anyone got amelodeon shaped crowbar?
....can't seem to rise it out of daughter's hands!!!!!!!!
..which is a good sign.
Thanks all
TB
-
Update:
Thanks for all advice.
Now owner of a nice Tommy. My very good friend has checked it out and declaired it a nice box and very responsive.
Has anyone got amelodeon shaped crowbar?
Dear Twelve-sided One,
Congratulations on your new acquisition. May you both have much joy from it for many years to come! (:)
....can't seem to prise it out of daughter's hands!!!!!!!!
Perhaps you should get one each (MAD strikes already!) >:E
-
Update:
Thanks for all advice.
Now owner of a nice Tommy. My very good friend has checked it out and declaired it a nice box and very responsive.
Has anyone got amelodeon shaped crowbar?
....can't seem to rise it out of daughter's hands!!!!!!!!
..which is a good sign.
Thanks all
TB
They are nice boxes. I like my one.
-
Steve & Lady:
thanks for good wishes....
Erm.... ( cough ) not sure we can *both* buy one, am still wondering what's hit me!!!!!
Yes MAD has struck, snuck up behind us and surprised us both!
Right, off to have another go.
(:)
TB
-
Steve & Lady:
thanks for good wishes....
Erm.... ( cough ) not sure we can *both* buy one, am still wondering what's hit me!!!!!
Yes MAD has struck, snuck up behind us and surprised us both!
Right, off to have another go.
(:)
TB
I'll have a guess at your real name:
Edu y Ffôn, by any chance?
-
Has anyone got a melodeon shaped crowbar?
I would go for a daughter shaped crowbar less likely to damage the melodeon ;D
-
Steve:
Nope sorry not me!
I am now sweating profusely, of the nervously induced sort........
My good lady has just sat down and after browsing Mally's book picked up the Tommy and started to smile.
You know that 'Ahhh.....so that's it..' type smile.
....heaven forbid she's thinking about starting.....
:o
off to sit down in a darkened room to calm down, ( with box of course!)
cheers
TB
-
I am now sweating profusely, of the nervously induced sort........
My good lady has just sat down and after browsing Mally's book picked up the Tommy and started to smile.
You know that 'Ahhh.....so that's it..' type smile.
....heaven forbid she's thinking about starting.....
:o
off to sit down in a darkened room to calm down, ( with box of course!)
cheers
TB
I'd be most shocked if anyone in my family decided to take up playing the box...you should be pleased....means your M.A.D. will be tolerated as well as all that noise practice. ;)
-
Well, I think she's feeling left out.
I normally play English Concertina, and my eldest daughter has taken that up, sufficiently well to play out for the morris, and play good 'un solid too.
P'raps Mrs. TB is wondering what all the fuss is about!
cheers
TB